Opinion

Commonwealth v. Brown

  • 2 Mass. App. Ct. 883
  • 318 N.E.2d 486
  • 1974 Mass. App. LEXIS 826
Court
Massachusetts Appeals Court
Filed
Nov 4, 1974
Status
Published
Cited by
12 cases
Authority
More cited than 77.9%

fmding sufficient force where defendant “snatched the purse out of [the victim’s] hand, touching neither her hand nor her body”

How later courts described this case

  • fmding sufficient force where defendant “snatched the purse out of [the victim’s] hand, touching neither her hand nor her body”
  • pulling purse from victim’s hand constitutes sufficient “force and violence”

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

This case is here on the defendant’s exceptions to the denial of his motion for a directed verdict with respect to so much of an indictment as charged unarmed robbery, to portions of the court’s charge, and to the court’s failure to give his requested instructions. The facts of the case were as follows: The defendant and another youth approached the victim from behind while she was walking on the street. The victim was holding a small purse in her left hand, and one of the youths snatched the purse out of her hand, touching neither her hand nor her body. The two youths fled. The victim testified she was not really aware of their presence until her purse had been snatched. The issue presented by each of the exceptions is whether the bare act of snatching a purse from the hand of a victim, in the absence of any prior awareness by the victim of the impending act, is sufficient to constitute the element of force required for unarmed robbery. We answer this question in the affirmative. By its use of the word “rob” the indictment effectively charged a “taking and carrying away of personal property of another from his person and against his will, by force and violence, or by assault and putting in fear, with intent to steal.” G. L. c. 277, § 39 (emphasis supplied). The trial judge correctly instructed the jury that while there was no evidence that the purse was taken by placing the victim in fear, the pulling of a purse *884 from a victim’s hand constituted sufficient force to satisfy the “by force and violence” alternative of the statutory definition. The defendant’s requested instruction which asserted that the defendant could be found guilty of unarmed robbery only if the victim was placed in fear at the time of taking the property was properly denied. The Supreme Judicial Court has explicitly stated, although by way of dictum, that Massachusetts will follow the minority or Kentucky rule on purse snatching. “ [SJnatching, without more, involves the requisite element of force to permit a jury verdict on a charge of robbery.” Commonwealth v. Jones, 362 Mass. 83, 88 (1972). See Jones v. Commonwealth, 112 Ky. 689, 692-695 (1902).

David Skeels for the defendant.

Sandra Lee Hamlin, Assistant District Attorney, for the Commonwealth.

Exceptions overruled.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.