Opinion

Untitled California Attorney General Opinion

Court
California Attorney General Reports
Filed
Apr 1, 2022
Status
Published
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 8.1%

referring to Act’s ballot arguments as interpretative aid

How later courts described this case

  • referring to Act’s ballot arguments as interpretative aid

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

State of California

ROB BONTA

Attorney General

_________________________

:

OPINION : No. 19-1001

:

of : April 1, 2022

:

ROB BONTA :

Attorney General :

:

CATHERINE BIDART :

Deputy Attorney General :

THE HONORABLE GALENA WEST, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE

FAIR POLITICAL PRACTICES COMMISSION, has requested an opinion relating to

campaign contributions by Commissioners.

QUESTION PRESENTED AND CONCLUSION

Does Government Code section 83105, which bans campaign contributions by

members of the Fair Political Practices Commission, apply to election campaigns for

President and Congress?

Yes, the statutory ban applies to elections held in California, which includes

elections for President and for seats in the United States Senate and House of

Representatives.

1

19-1001

BACKGROUND

The Fair Political Practices Commission administers and implements the Political

Reform Act of 1974, which contains Government Code section 83105. 1 The Act,

adopted as a voter initiative measure in the wake of the Watergate scandal, seeks to

prevent political corruption by regulating lobbying, conflicts of interest, and campaign

disclosures, among other things. 2 These concepts were not new in 1974, but voters

determined that state and local authorities had inadequately enforced prior laws. 3 So the

voters established an independent government body to oversee implementation and

enforcement of the Act: the Fair Political Practices Commission.

The Commission comprises five appointees; the method of their appointment is

designed to limit partisan influence by spreading appointments across political parties. 4

Voters entrusted the Commission with “primary responsibility for the impartial, effective

administration and implementation” of the Act, to ensure that the Act would be

“vigorously enforced.” 5

To that end, the Commission has extensive oversight powers. For example, the

Commission may investigate possible violations, hold hearings, order penalties, and

compel disclosures. 6 The Commission may also make rules and regulations, prescribe

1

Gov. Code, § 81000 et seq. All statutory references in the text are to the Government

Code unless otherwise noted.

2

Ibid.; see generally Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians v. Superior Court (2006) 40

Cal.4th 239, 244; People v. Snyder (2000) 22 Cal.4th 304, 307.

3

Gov. Code, § 81001, subd. (h); see Warden v. Brown (1960) 185 Cal.App.2d 626, 627–

628 (discussing long history of “election purity laws” requiring disclosures of

contributions).

4

See Gov. Code, §§ 83100, 83101, 83102. For example, no more than three of the five

Commissioners may be of the same political party. (Gov. Code, § 83100.) The Governor

appoints the Chair and one Commissioner, who may not be of same party. (Gov. Code,

§ 83101.) The Attorney General, the Secretary of State, and the Controller each appoints

a Commissioner; if these appointing officers are of the same party, then the Controller

appoints from a list (if provided) by other parties. (Gov. Code, § 83102.)

5

Gov. Code, §§ 81002, subd. (f), 83111; see Gov. Code, §§ 82012, 91001, subd. (b).

6

Gov. Code, §§ 83115, 83116, 90009, subd. (a).

2

19-1001

forms and publish manuals to facilitate compliance and enforcement, and issue opinions

on which a requesting party may rely as a safe harbor. 7

The provision we consider here, Government Code section 83105, fosters

impartiality by prohibiting Commissioners from engaging in certain political activities

during their tenure. Commissioners may not serve as an officer of a political party or

partisan organization, work as a lobbyist, or hold or seek another public office.8 Nor may

Commissioners “participate in or contribute to an election campaign.” 9 This brings us to

the issue at hand: whether this statutory ban on contributing to an election campaign

applies to one for President or Congress. 10

The Commission’s own manual provides that it does. 11 But at its September 2019

meeting, the Commission decided to suspend its own rule against donations to federal

candidates, reevaluate related manual provisions governing Commissioner conduct, and

seek this Attorney General opinion. 12 At its December 2019 meeting, the Commission

7

Gov. Code, §§ 83112, 83113, 83114.

8

Gov. Code, § 83105. The latter prohibition also applies during their term of

appointment. (Ibid.)

9

Gov. Code, § 83105.

10

We have been asked only to interpret the statute, not to resolve any potential free-

speech issue that might arise under the state or federal Constitution.

11

Fair Political Practices Commission, Commissioner Code of Conduct (Oct. 2020),

pp. 3–4 (hereafter “Manual”). Prior editions provided the same. (See, e.g., Fair Political

Practices Commission, 2019 Commissioner Manual (June 2019), pp. 14–15.)

12

See, e.g., Fair Political Practices Commission Minutes of Hearing, Sept. 19, 2019, p. 3,

available at https://fppc.ca.gov/content/dam/fppc/NS-

Documents/AgendaDocuments/Minutes/2019/Approved/sept%202019.pdf (as of Mar. 7,

2022); Commissioner Cárdenas, mem. on Commissioner Manual Revision, Dec. 19,

2019, pp. 1–2, on file; McGreevy, L.A. Times, California Campaign Watchdog Suspends

Donation Rules after a Member Gives to Sanders, Dec. 4, 2019, available at

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-12-04/california-campaign-watchdogs-

want-to-make-their-own-political-donations (as of Mar. 7, 2022).

3

19-1001

decided to return to its rule embodied in its manual. 13 The Commission’s request for an

Attorney General opinion on this topic remains open.

ANALYSIS

To interpret the scope of the statutory ban on FPPC Commissioner contributions to

election campaigns, we look to the usual principles governing questions of statutory

interpretation, which apply equally to a voter-enacted initiative such as the Act. 14 As we

explain below, the language, history, and purpose of Government Code section 83105 all

compel the conclusion that the ban extends to all federal elections held in California.

Statutory Language

Government Code section 83105 provides in relevant part:

A member of the commission, during the member’s tenure, shall not hold

any other public office, serve as an officer of any political party or partisan

organization, participate in or contribute to an election campaign, or

employ or be employed as a lobbyist nor, during the member’s term of

appointment, seek election to any other public office. 15

Does this reference to “an election campaign” include one for President or

Congress? Based on the definition of “election” provided in the Act, we believe it does.

While silent on the meaning of “campaign” and “election campaign,” Government Code

section 82022 defines “election” to mean “any primary, general, special or recall election

held in this state.” 16 A “general election” held in California includes federal elections for

President, Vice President, and seats in the United States Senate and House of

13

Fair Political Practices Commission Minutes of Hearing, Dec. 19, 2019, p. 3, available

at https://fppc.ca.gov/content/dam/fppc/NS-

Documents/AgendaDocuments/Minutes/2019/Approved/dec%202019.pdf (as of Mar. 7,

2022); McGreevy, L.A. Times, California’s Campaign Watchdog Reverses Course,

Won’t Allow Its Leaders To Donate to Politicians, Dec. 19, 2019, available at

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-12-19/california-fair-political-practices-

commission-political-donations (as of Mar. 7, 2022).

14

Day v. City of Fontana (2001) 25 Cal.4th 268, 272.

Gov. Code, § 83105, italics added; see Gov. Code, § 82012 (“Commission” is Fair

15

Political Practices Commission).

16

Gov. Code, § 82022, italics added.

4

19-1001

Representatives. 17 Those federal elections therefore fall squarely within the Act’s

definition of an “election.”

The Act states that its definitions govern the interpretation of the Act, “[u]nless the

contrary is stated or clearly appears from the context.” 18 And nothing in the Act suggests

an intent to alter the definition of “election” for section 83105. In contrast, other parts of

the Act do provide customized definitions limited to particular sections. For example,

one section of the Act limits gifts to Commissioners, and defines “gift” uniquely for

purposes of that section, ousting the definition that would otherwise apply. 19

The Act’s drafters demonstrated that they knew how to exclude federal elections

when that was their intent. For instance, the Act separately defines “statewide election”

to exclude elections for federal office. 20 It also defines “candidate,” “elective office,”

“elective state office,” “state candidate,” and “statewide elective office” in terms that

exclude federal offices or federal candidates. 21 But the Act does not use any of these

other terms in section 83105. Instead, it uses the term “election,” which is defined to

encompass federal elections held in this State.

17

See U.S. Const., art. I, § 4, cl. 1 (state legislatures to provide times, places, and manner

of congressional elections); Elec. Code, §§ 324, subd. (b) (each general election to

include congressional candidates), 6901 (Secretary of State to place presidential and vice-

presidential candidates on general election ballot).

18

Gov. Code, § 82000. This echoes the general rule that “if the Legislature, or the

electorate in the case of an initiative measure, has provided an express definition of a

term, that definition ordinarily is binding on the courts.” (People v. Zeigler (2012) 211

Cal.App.4th 638, 650, quoting People v. Canty (2004) 32 Cal.4th 1266, 1277, internal

quotation marks omitted.)

19

Compare Gov. Code, § 83117.5 (prohibiting gift of $10 or more per month to

Commissioners, and defining “gift” for these purposes only) with Gov. Code, § 82028

(defining “gift” for rest of Act).

20

Gov. Code, § 82052.5.

21

See, e.g., Gov. Code, §§ 82007, subd. (c) (“candidate” excludes federal), 82023

(“elective office” excludes federal), 82024 (“elective state office” excludes federal),

82050 (“state candidate” excludes federal), 82053 (“statewide elective office” excludes

federal).

5

19-1001

The definition provided in the Act is clear. We will not “interpret away clear

language in favor of an ambiguity that does not exist.” 22 We therefore interpret the

statute using the defined term for “election” in the Act, and conclude that section 83105

bars Commissioners from contributing to federal elections held within the State.

As noted above, the Commission’s manual agrees with this conclusion. It

provides that the statutory ban applies to “any primary, general, special or recall election

held in this state,” which echoes the Act’s governing definition of election. 23 It

continues: “The Commission interprets this to include contributions to the campaign of

any candidate for President and contributions to the campaign of any other candidate for

federal office when the election is held in California.” 24

Our interpretation of the text is also consistent with the history of amendments to

the Act. The Act has been amended over 200 times. 25 None of these amendments altered

the language of the ban on contributions in Government Code section 83105. 26 But the

larger context of one amendment is arguably relevant to our analysis. When first

adopted, the Act required certain campaign disclosures by federal candidates. 27

Specifically, section 84208 stated that every person required by a provision of federal law

(section 309(a) of Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971) to file any statement or report

with the California Secretary of State, must file two copies and must also file two copies

Lennane v. Franchise Tax Bd. (1994) 9 Cal.4th 263, 268, quoting Hartford Fire Ins.

22

Co. v. Macri (1992) 4 Cal.4th 318, 326.

23

Manual, supra, at p. 3; Gov. Code, §§ 82000, 82022 (“‘Election’ means any primary,

general, special or recall election held in this state”).

24

Manual, supra, at p. 3.

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn. v. Newsom (2019) 39 Cal.App.5th 158, 163, citing

25

People v. Kelly (2010) 47 Cal.4th 1008, 1042, fn. 59.

26

The statute containing the ban, section 83105, has been amended twice, but neither

amendment had any effect on the scope of the ban. (Stats. 2021, ch. 50, § 152

[modernizing gender-neutral language]; Stats., 1986, ch. 620, § 1 [decapitalizing

“Commission” and extending prohibition on seeking election to other public office to

appointment term].)

27

See former Gov. Code, § 84208 (added by Initiative Measure approved by the electors

June 4, 1974); see also Pub. L. No. 92-225, (Feb. 7, 1972) 86 Stat. 3, § 403(a) (providing

nothing in the federal law “shall be deemed to invalidate or make inapplicable” state law,

unless complying with it would result in federal law violation).

6

19-1001

with certain county clerks. 28 Candidates for President, Vice President, and United States

Senate had to file their additional copies with the county clerks of Los Angeles and San

Francisco; candidates for the United States House of Representatives had to file theirs

with the clerk for each county in their congressional district. 29

As we have noted, the voters created the Commission to impartially administer

and implement the Act, including the provision just described. The inclusion of federal

candidates in that provision suggests that the voters intended Commissioners to remain

impartial with respect to federal candidates—including by not contributing to the

campaigns of federal candidates.

Federal law preempted the disclosure requirements for federal candidates shortly

after voters adopted the Act. 30 Now, the Act directs that, when federal law requires

federal candidates to furnish disclosures to California’s Secretary of State, the onus is on

the Secretary of State (rather than the candidates) to furnish copies to the county clerks. 31

We have considered a possible argument that this change impliedly amended

section 83105, such that its contributions ban would no longer apply to campaigns for

federal elections held in this State. Under this view, when the Legislature amended the

Act to remove the requirement that federal candidates submit campaign disclosures to

state officials, it also impliedly removed federal elections from the ban on Commissioner

contributions. This implied amendment supposedly occurred because one obvious reason

for the ban—to maintain Commissioner impartiality in its oversight of federal candidate

disclosures—no longer existed. We reject this notion for two reasons.

28

Former Gov. Code, § 84208 (as added by Initiative Measure approved by the electors

June 4, 1974).

29

Ibid.

30

52 U.S.C. § 30143 (current preemption provision); Pub. L. No. 93–443 (Oct. 15, 1974)

88 Stat 1263, § 301 (original preemption provision); 2 FPPC Op. 61, In the Matter of:

Opinion requested by Jeffrey A. Dennis-Strathmeyer (1976) (concluding that federal law

preempts section 84208, so Congressman and campaign committee treasurer “are

required to file copies of campaign statements only with those persons specified by

federal law”).

Gov. Code, § 84217; see also Stats. 1977, ch. 1095, p. 3509, § 3 (similarly providing as

31

much in amendments to former section 84208).

7

19-1001

First, implied amendments are generally disfavored. 32 Second, the Act contains

strict limits on amending it, which apply to implied amendments. 33 The limits here

would mean that the implied amendment to the statutory ban would have to further the

Act’s purposes. 34 But amending the statute on Commissioner contributions, so that the

ban no longer applies to federal elections held in this State, would not further the Act’s

purposes. Instead, as explained below, the ban on those contributions still furthers the

purposes of the Act.

The Statutory Purpose

The Act directs that it “should be liberally construed to accomplish its purposes.” 35

A central purpose of the Act was to create a commission that would vigorously enforce

its provisions. 36 In addition to what the Act itself expresses about its goals, the ballot

arguments in favor of the measure further reveal the Act’s purposes. 37 The ballot

arguments state that a “yes” vote will “[e]nforce the law by establishing a tough,

nonpolitical commission.” 38 They further state: “Rather than leading to unfounded

charges or selective enforcement, [the Act] will at last bring full, fair and independent

enforcement of the law.” 39

The goal of a “tough, nonpolitical” Commission is furthered by construing section

83105 to ban Commissioners from contributing to campaigns for federal elections held in

Environmental Protection Information Center v. California Dept. of Forestry and Fire

32

Protection (2008) 44 Cal.4th 459, 514; Lesher Communications, Inc. v. City of Walnut

Creek (1990) 52 Cal.3d 531, 540–541.

33

Gov. Code, § 81012 (providing that amendments to Act may be made by voters or by a

2/3 vote in the Legislature; if the latter, the amendment must further the Act’s purposes);

Huening v. Eu (1991) 231 Cal.App.3d 766, 777, 779 (Act’s limit on amendments in

section 81012 applies to implied amendments).

34

See Gov. Code, § 81012; Stats. 1977, ch. 1095, p. 3509, § 3 (legislative removal of

preempted material from former section 84208).

35

Gov. Code, § 81003.

36

Gov. Code, §§ 81001, subd. (h), 81002, subd. (f), 83111.

37

See People v. Snyder, supra, 22 Cal.4th at p. 309, fn. 5 (referring to Act’s ballot

arguments as interpretative aid).

Ballot Pamp., Primary Elec. (June 4, 1974), argument in favor of Prop. 9, p. 36, bold

38

omitted.

39

Ballot Pamp., Primary Elec. (June 4, 1974), rebuttal to argument against Prop. 9, p. 37.

8

19-1001

this State. Because the way the Commission interprets, applies, and enforces the Act

may affect those candidates, a ban on Commissioner contributions to them promotes the

impartial administration and implementation of the Act. Several concrete examples

illustrate this.

To begin with, individuals who remain under the Commission’s purview by virtue

of a current or past office or candidacy may become federal candidates. In general, the

Commission has at least four years to enforce compliance with the Act. 40 Applying the

contributions ban to federal elections preserves this statutory safeguard of impartiality

toward covered officials and candidates, who may then become federal candidates in

California. Otherwise, Commissioners could be enforcing the Act against those

candidates while also contributing to their campaigns.

Additionally, at least two provisions of the Act independently illustrate the

ongoing relevance of the ban to federal elections held in this State. Government Code

section 89519 allows state and local candidates to use their “surplus campaign funds” to

support or oppose a federal candidate. 41 The Commission might well be called on to

consider whether funds were actually “surplus campaign funds,” properly used for that

purpose, or properly disclosed. 42 In that scenario, preserving Commissioner

impartiality—by prohibiting Commissioners from contributing to federal candidates—

would help promote full, fair, and independent enforcement of section 89519.

Similarly, Government Code section 84308 prohibits an officer of certain state and

local agencies from directing contributions exceeding $250 to federal candidates from

anyone who is a party to a proceeding pending at the agency involving a license, permit,

or other entitlement. 43 In overseeing this prohibition, the Commission may find itself

40

See Gov. Code, §§ 91000.5 (five-year statute of limitations, unless tolled, on

administrative action), 91011 (generally setting forth four-year statute of limitations on

civil action, but limitations period for violations of filing reports and statements is either

four years after audit could begin or one year after Franchise Tax Board sends

Commission report of audit of alleged violator, whichever is less); see also Gov. Code,

§ 91013.7 (Commission has four years to seek court judgment to collect unpaid civil

monetary penalty).

41

Gov. Code, § 89519, subds. (a) & (b)(5); see Gov. Code, § 82023.

42

See Gov. Code, § 89519, subd. (a) (requiring disclosure of surplus campaign funds

pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with section 84100)).

43

Gov. Code, § 84308, subds. (a)–(b). The same prohibition exists for agents and

“participants”—someone who is not a party to, but who has a financial interest in and

actively supports or opposes a particular decision in the proceeding. (Ibid.)

9

19-1001

directly involved in a matter implicating federal candidates. The goal of impartiality is

served by a Commission whose members have not contributed to such candidates.

Another example pertains to the state ballot pamphlet, which the Act intends to be

useful to voters. 44 The Act authorizes a candidate for United States Senate to buy

pamphlet space for a 250-word statement, but prohibits mentioning opponents. 45 If a

question arose relating to this aspect of the pamphlet, the Commission could again find

itself involved in a matter involving federal candidates.

As these examples illustrate, applying the ban on Commissioner contributions to

federal candidates promotes impartiality and the full, fair, and independent enforcement

of the Act by the Commission. The objects sought to be achieved by the Act, like its

history, reinforce that the words of the Act mean what they say: the statutory ban on

Commissioner contributions applies to candidates in federal elections held in this State.

44

Gov. Code, § 81002, subd. (d).

45

Gov. Code, § 88001, subd. (i); see also Elec. Code, § 9084, subd. (i) (containing same

language).

10

19-1001

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.