Opinion

Hoxie v. Chamberlain

  • 228 Pa. 31
  • 76 A. 423
  • 1910 Pa. LEXIS 425
Court
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Filed
Apr 18, 1910
Status
Published
Author
Potter
On the bench
Elkin, Mestrezat, Moschzisker, Potter, Stewart
Cited by
1 cases
Authority
More cited than 48.6%

The opinion

Opinion by

Mr. Justice Potter,

The question here presented for consideration is as to the extent of the estate vested in the plaintiff by the will of Otis J. Chubbuck. In the third paragraph of his will-the testator gave to the plaintiff the same .estate whicli she would have taken as his only child and heir at law. It is clear that he intended to give her what amounted to an estate of inheritance. He went on to express a further intent by saying, *33 “ Should the said Mary have no legal issxxe or heir of her own body at her death, the personal or real property she may die seized of by virtue of this bequest shall revert to and belong to my estate.” It is necessarily implied by these words that the devisee had power to dispose of the property given to her, for the limitation over to the estate of the testator was only to apply to so much of it as “she may die seized of.” There was no limit placed upon her right to dispose of the property at hex-own discretion, and therefore the devise amounted to an unqualified gift. A devise with power to give a fee, passes a fee: Brown’s Est., 38 Pa. 289 ; Chxirch v. Disbrow, 52 Pa. 219 ; Witmer v. Delone, 225 Pa. 450 .

In so far as any subsequent limitation over was inconsistent with the absolute gift already made, it would be void. We agree with the court below that under the will in question the estate devised to the plaintiff in the property described, is a fee simple, and that the deed of herself and husband for the same will convey a good and marketable title thereto.

The specifications of error are overrxiled, and the judgment is affirmed.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.