Opinion

Excellent Holding Corp. v. Richman

  • 155 Misc. 257
  • 279 N.Y.S. 587
  • 1935 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 1161
Court
City of New York Municipal Court
Filed
Apr 23, 1935
Status
Published
Author
Lewisdavid
On the bench
David, Lewis
Cited by
2 cases
Authority
More cited than 59.5%

The opinion

Lewis (David C.), J.

The landlord disposseses for non-payment. The tenant counterclaims for damage to property and injuries to person caused by the landlord’s neglect. The lease contains an immunity clause similar to that passed upon by our Court of Appeals (Kirshenbaum v. General Outdoor Adv. Co., 258 N. Y. 489 ).

It is noted that the Kirshenbaum case involved premises in a business building. In the case before the court the premises are in a multiple dwelling. One is plainly without the pale; the other clearly within the province of the expressed and enlightened policy of our State —■ a policy established by statute and indorsed by precedent. (Multiple Dwelling Law, § 2.) (See, also, Altz v. Leiberson, 233 N. Y. 16 .)

The court is loathe to hold that the negative covenant of a private lease should be permitted to override the positive mandate of a public policy and the public law.

*258 Stripped of the assumed immunity, the landlord must meet the facts.

It was not a mere ordinary leak that disturbed this tenant’s quite enjoyment. It was a most unusual invasion; the water from the roof finding its way through various portions of the entire ceiling down into his bed and upon bis person, in the early hours of a cold winter’s morning.

This was not a sound and safe roof. The history of events presents symptoms of its defects. Evidence of their cure is lacking. The assurances of correction by the landlord lulled the tenant into false security. It remained for the mishap to open his eyes to the truth. The liability of the landlord has been established. (Marks v. Nambill Realty Co., Inc., 245 N. Y. 256 .)

The question of damages remains. As to the personal property, it is only a matter of assessment. As to the physical injury, it is a matter of approximate cause. Upon his awakening, the tenant suffered a chill. He did not immediately take to bed. He went to business for a few days, notwithstanding his physical feelings or condition, and continued to work until his temperature compelled medical attention. It is not beyond the realm of probability that such an experience should be followed by an attack of grippe. The mere fact that the tenant refused to surrender to the first stages of his illness may have delayed the cure but cannot deny the cause.

I am of the opinion that the testimony is sufficient in fact and law to warrant the conclusion that the experience of that night was the approximate cause of the illness complained of. (See Goldkopf v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co., 149 Misc. 663 .)

It remains to assess the damage. From the proof presented, the court fixes the damages at $75 for property damages and $110 for personal injuries.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.