Opinion

PETERSON

  • 10 I. & N. Dec. 663
Court
Board of Immigration Appeals
Filed
Jul 1, 1963
Status
Published
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Interim Decision -#137a

MATTER OF PETERSON

In VISA PETITION Proceedings

A-8952166

Derided by Regional Conymiasioner December 19, 1963

Beneficiary, who is employed on a cattle ranch engaged in raising purebred

herefords for sale and show purposes, and who is responsible for the feeding

of young calves up to the age of about 15 months and of the bulls kept on

range for breeding purposes, who assists in the vaccination and immunization

of the stock, treats minor ailments, measures and mixes the feed grains ac-

cording to prepared formulas, grooms and cares for animals being prepared

for exhibition purposes, assists with haying and in the irrigation and culti-

vation of the farm land is ineligible for first preference classification under

section 203(a) (1), Immigration and Nationality Act, as amended, since the

duties performed are duties ordinarily performed by a good ranch hand or

herdsman and do not require the high education, technical training, specialized

experience or excepticeial ability contemplated by the statute.

This cam comas -before the Regional Commissioner on appeal from

the decision of the District Director, San Francisco, who denied the

petition on the grounds that the duties of the position for which

petitioned do not require the high education, technical training, spe-

cialized experience or exceptional ability to the degree contemplated

by the statute for first preference classification.

Petitioner is owner and manager of the cattle ranch "Ruby Moun-

tain Herefords" near Elko, Nevada. This ranching business was

established in 1930. Petitioner has approximately 2,000 head of cattle

ranging on 15,000 acres of fee-simple land and employs from eight to

seventeen persons. The ranch is valued at about $100,000 with an

annual income of $75,000 to $90,000. Purebred herefords are raised

for sale and show purposes.

Beneficiary is a 56-year-old married male, a native and citizen of

Spain who was admitted into the United States as a. crewman at

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, on May 15, 1953, for a period not to exceed

29 days. He deserted his ship, went west and has been employed by

the petitioner in Nevada since June of 1953. Following his appre-

hension, he was served with an order to show cause and at a hearing

663

Interim Decision #1373

accorded0.by a. Special Inquiry Officer on March 26, 1956, was found to

be deportable and granted voluntary departure with an alternate order

of deportation. Various private bills introduced periodically in his

behalf since 1953 have failed of passage. On April 10, 1963, the visa

petition for first preference classification was filed in his behalf.

The petitioner states that beneficiary is responsible for the feeding

of the young calves up to the age of about fifteen months, that bene-

ficiary assists in the vaccination and immunization of the stock and

treats minor ailment . He measures and mixes the feeed grains accord-

ing to prepared formulas and grooms and cares for the animals that

are being prepared for exhibition purposes. He is also responsible

for the feeding of bulls that are kept on the range for breeding pur-

poses. During the Spring and Summer months, he assists in the ir-

rigation and cultivation of the farm land and assists with the haying.

The clearance order issued by the Bureau of Employment Security

titles the position to be filled as "cattle breeder" and describes the duties

as "Takes care of the health, welfare, feeding, halter breaking and ex-

hibition of from 40 to 50 head of registered hereford cattle both while

at the home ranch and while on the road exhibiting. Compounds

feed formulas as directed. Observes daily health of stock by frequent

inspection. Tests cattle and inoculates or treats with salves when

necessary." The clearance order further shows that a minimum of

five years' experience in the care and exhibition of purebred beef cattle

is required and that the position requires a man who is gentle and

tolerant with stock.

The Dictionary of Occupational Titles, 'Volume I, defines a "cattle

breeder" as one who "Breeds and raises purebred beef or dairy cattle

for sale to Dairymen II, Cattle Ranchers; and other growers. Seeps

pedigree records. Grooms cattle and exhibits them at fairs, conven-

tions, and other gatherings."

Petitioner is in reality the "cattle breeder." While it is true the

beneficiary grooms the cattle, he is not the exhibitor. The petitioner,

Ruby Mountain Herefords, is the exhibitor. The petitioner breeds

and raises the purebred stock and keeps the pedigree records. The

petitioner, himself, and others who have presented letters attesting to

the beneficiary's ability to perform the tasks of the position refer to the

beneficiary as "herdsman" which is a more descriptive title of his

duties.

We agree with counsel that beneficiary is qualified to perform the

duties as set forth by the petitioner and that petitioner needs the serv-

ices of an employee to perform these duties. However, we must agree

with the District Director that the tasks performed do not require

the high education, technical training, specialized experience or special

ability as contemplated by the statute for first preference classification.

664

Interim Decision *1378

Counsel has argued that if the "requirements are met in any degree,

the petition should be granted." We do not agree. The tasks to be

performed must be of a degree of complexity or difficulty that only a

person with a high education, technical training, exceptional ability

or specialized experience could, because of these qualifications, pro-

ficiently perform the duties. The duties performed by the beneficiary

are duties ordinarily performed by good ranch hands or herdsmen

and do not meet first preference standards. The appeal must be dis-

missed and the decision of the District Director to deny the application

be affirmed.

ORDER: It is ordered that the appeal be dismissed and the decision

of the District Director to deny the application be affirmed.

605

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.