Opinion

ASCHER

  • 14 I. & N. Dec. 271
Court
Board of Immigration Appeals
Filed
Jul 1, 1972
Status
Published
Cited by
4 cases
Authority
More cited than 74.5%

The opinion

Interim Decision #2182

MATTER OF ASCHER

In Visa Petition Proceedings

A-11081509

Decided by Board April 19, 1972 and January 23, 1973

Despite birth in an independent country of the Western Hemisphere, an alien

within the purview of section 202(bX2) of the Immigration and Nationality Act

may be alternately charged to the foreign state of his accompanying spouse

and within such alternate chargeability may be accorded preference classifica-

tion under section 203(aX5) of the Act subject to simultaneous applications by

him and his accompanying spouse for visas and for admission to the United

States.

ON BEHALF OF PETITIONER: ON BEHALF OF SERVICE:

James J. Orlow, Esquire Irving A. Appleman

824 Bankers Securities Bldg. ' Appellate Trial Attorney

Philadelphia, Pa. 19107 Charles Gordon

General Counsel

BEFORE THE BOARD

(April 19, 1972)

The United States citizen petitioner applied for preference

status for the beneficiary as his brother under section 203(aX5) of

the Immigration and Nationality Act. The District Director, in his

order dated November 4, 1971, denied the petition on the ground

that the beneficiary was not eligible for alternate chargeability

under section 202(bX2) of the Act to the foreign state of birth of his

spouse. From that order the petitioner appeals. His appeal will be

dismissed.

The father of both the petitioner and the beneficiary is Mauricio

Ascher. He was born in Poland, as was, presumably, their mother.

In 1932, Mauricio Ascher left Poland, sensing that the rise of Nazi

Germany meant that Poland would no longer be a safe place for

271

Interim Decision #2182

his family, since he was Jewish. He visited Ecuador in 1933 and

China in 1934 and 1935. The petitioner was born in Ecuador in

November of 1935, when his parents returned there from China.

He has since become a United States citizen. His brother Isaac

Ascher, the beneficiary, was born in Ecuador in 1940. The family

remained in Ecuador until either 1946 or 1917. The beneficiary,

Isaac Ascher, married a native of Great Britain in approximately

1962. Two children were born to them in England in 1964 and 1967.

The beneficiary, his wife and their children are presentlY in the

United States as nonimmigrants. The record indicates that the

beneficiary arrived in the United States on July 3, 1969 as a

visitor. Mauricio Ascher, the father of both the petitioner and the

beneficiary, has been admitted to the United States for lawful

permanent residence.

The issue presented by this case is whether the beneficiary, a

special immigrant by virtue of his birth in an independent country

of the Western Hemisphere, may be charged in the alternate to

the country of birth of either (1) his father, or (2) his spouse. Stated

in technical language, the question is whether the beneficiary

qualifies for an exception under section 202(b)(4) or section

202(b)(2) from the general rule that an alien is chargeable to the

foreign state of his birth. If he qualifies, then he may properly be

accorded a preference status under section 203(a) of the Act.

Our•prior precedent decision in Matter of Tiszai, 12 I. & N. Dec.

425 (8 IA, 1967) formerly served to bar access to the alternate

chargeability provisions contained in section 202(b) of the Act to

natives of the Western Hemisphere on the ground that they were

special immigrants. That decision was held by us to be no longer

applicable due to substantial changes in law and regulations since

it was decided, Matter of Chatterton, A-19942340, Interim Decision

No. 2133 (B IA, March 21, 1972). Thus, a native of the Western

Hemisphere may take advantage of the alternate chargeability

provisions if he otherwise qualifies.

Section 202(b) of the Immigration and Nationality Act contains

the provisions relating to alternate chargeability to the country of

birth of a parent or spouse. It reads, in relevant part, as follows:

... For the purposes of this Act the foreign state to which an immigrant is

chargeable shall be determined by birth within such foreign state except that (1)

an alien child, when accompanied by his alien parent or parents, may be charged

to the same foreign state as the accompanying parent or of either accompanying

parent if such parent has received or would be qualified for an immigrant visa, if

necessary to prevent the separation of the child from the accompanying parent

or parents, and if the foreign state to which such parent has been or would be

chargeable has not exceeded the numerical limitation cot forth in the proviso to

subsection (a) of this section for that fiscal year; (2) if an alien is chargeable to a

different foreign state from that of his accompanying spouse, the foreign state to

272

Interim Decision #2182

which such alien is chargeable may, if necessary to prevent the separation of

husband and wife, be determined by the foreign state of the accompanying

spouse, if such spouse has received or would be qualified for an immigrant visa

and if the foreign state to which such spouse would be chargeable has not

exceeded the numerical limitation set forth in the proviso to subsection (a) of

this section for that fiscal year; (3) ... (4) an alien born within any foreign state

in which neither of his parents was born and in which neither of his parents had

a residence at the time of such alien's birth may be charged to the foreign state

of either parent.

For the sake of simplicity, we shall refer to the exception from

the general rule for chargeability contained in section 202(bX1) as

the "first exception"; that contained in section 202(bX2) as the

"second exception"; and so on.

The term "foreign state" is defined in 22 CFR 42.1, which reads

as follows:

For the purpose of according alternate chargeability pursuant to section 202(b)

of the Act, the term "foreign state" is not restricted to those areas to which the

numerical limitation prescribed by section 202(a) of the Act applies but includes

dependent areas, as defined in this section, and independent countries of the

Western Hemisphere and the Canal Zone.

The term "accompanying" is not defined in the Immigration and

Nationality Act but is defined in 22 CFR 42.1 as follows:

"Accompanying" or "accompanied by" means, in addition to an alien in the

physical company of a principal alien, an alien who is issued an immigrant visa

within 4 months of the date of issuance of a visa to the principal alien, within 4

months of the adjustment of status in the United States of the principal alien, or

within 4 months from the date of the departure of the principal alien from the

country in which his dependents are applying for visas if he has traveled abroad

to confer his foreign state chargeability upon them. An "accompanying" relative

may not precede the principal alien to the United States.

The beneficiary does not qualify for an exception under section

202(bX4) because the fourth exception is only available to an alien

born in a foreign state in which neither of his parents was born

and in which neither of his parents had a residence at the time of

his birth. Although his parents were both apparently natives of

Poland, it seems to us that their stay in Ecuador from 1935 until

1940 constitutes sufficient residence in Ecuador to make section

202(bX4) inapplicable to the present case. The Ecuadorian authori-

ties apparently took the same stance, for the beneficiary's birth

certificate states that his parents were both of Ecuadorian nation-

ality.

It is essential to bear in mind that the spouse of Isaac Ascher is

not petitioning for preference status on her husband's behalf.

Isaac Ascher is the beneficiary of a petition filed by his United

States citizen brother, Charles Ascher. As we have seen above, the

fourth exception, found in section 202(b)(4), is inapplicable. The

273

Interim Decision #2182

first exception, found in section 202(b)(1), clearly is limited to an

alien child accompanied by a parent. The record indicates that the

beneficiary is 32 years of age. Therefore, he does not qualify as a

"child" under the immigration laws. The first exception, then, is

not available to him. The third exception, relating to aliens born

within the United States, is clearly inapplicable. There remains to

be considered only the possibility of the second exception which is

found in section 202(b)(2).

The beneficiary, whose brother is the petitioner, may not be

charged to the foreign state of birth of his wife. For qualification

for the second exception under section 202(bX2), it must be estab-

lished (1) that the beneficiary is an alien spouse, (2) that he will be

"accompanied by" his spouse within that term's definition found in

22 CFR 42.1, (3) the accompanying spouse must have been born in

a "foreign state" as defined in 22 CFR 42.1, (4) the accompanying

spouse must have "received or would be qualified for an immi-

grant visa", and (5) the foreign state to which such spouse would

be chargeable has not exceeded the applicable numerical limita-

tion for the fiscal year.

At oral argument petitioner's attorney spoke of the possibility

that the beneficiary's spouse might apply to have her status

adjusted to that of a lawful permanent resident. Section 202(bX2)

is silent about the case of a principal alien who has her status

adjusted. Would adjustment of status bring her within the cate-

gory of a spouse who "has received or would be qualified for an

immigrant visa?" We believe it would, since adjustment of status is

tantamount to the receipt of an immigrant visa in that it too

confers immigrant status.

The case of a principal alien who receives adjustment of status

instead of an immigrant visa is specifically mentioned in 22 CFR

42.1, which contains the definition of the term "accompanied by."

According to that section, an alien qualifies as an accompanied

alien if he is issued an immigrant visa "within 4 months of the

adjustment of status in the United States of the principal alien."

In our opinion the words "would be qualified for an immigrant

visa", which appear in section 202(b)(2), were not intended to

include a case in which there is a mere theoretical possibility that

the accompanying spouse might be qualified for an immigrant visa

or for adjustment of status. In any given case the appropriate

application must have been filed and there must be a strong

likelihood of approval. Of course, an exception granted under

section 202(b)(2) on the basis that an accompanying spouse "would

be qualified for an immigrant visa" must be withdrawn in the

event the application of the accompanying spouse is not approved.

In the present case the District Director found that the benefi-

274

Interim Decision #2182

ciary's spouse (1) had not received an immigrant visa and (2) that

there was nothing in the record to indicate that she would be

eligible for one. He applied the test set forth in section 202(bX2)

and concluded that it had not been established that the benefi-

ciary qualified for an exception under that section. The benefici-

ary, then, is not entitled to alternate chargeability to the birth-

place of his spouse, and without such alternate chargeability he is

not eligible for an immigrant visa. The District Director accord-

ingly denied the petitioner's application for preference status. We

affirm his denial and the following order shall be entered.

ORDER: The appeal is dismissed.

BEFORE THE BOARD

(January 23, 1973)

In an order dated April 19, 1972, we dismissed an appeal from a

decision of the District Director denying the petitioner's applica-

tion for preference status for the beneficiary. The Service moves

for reconsideration, and counsel for the petitioner joins in that

request. The motion for reconsideration will be granted and the

case will be remanded to the District Director for further proceed-

ings.

The United States citizen petitioner applied for preference

status for the beneficiary as his brother under section 203(aX5) of

the Immigration and Nationality Act. The beneficiary was born in

Ecuador, of parents who were born in Poland, and his wife is a

native of Great Britain. At the present time he is not eligible for

an immigrant visa unless he can receive alternate chargeability to

the foreign state of his wife's birth pursuant to section 202(bX2) of

the Act.

In our decision of April 19, 1972, we found the beneficiary not

entitled to alternate chargeability. We reached that conclusion

because section 202(b)(2), dealing with alternate chargeability to

the foreign state of an alien's spouse, requires, inter edict, that the

spouse have "received or would be qualified for" an immigrant

visa. We agreed with the District Director's finding that (1) the

beneficiary's spouse had not received • an immigrant visa, and (2)

that there was nothing in the record to indicate that she would be

eligible for one. On the basis of new facts presented by the Service

and the petitioner's counsel, we now find that there may be a

possibility that the beneficiary's wife can become eligible for an

immigrant visa.

The Service takes the position that our ruling of April 19, 1972

was unduly restrictive and in conflict with a long-standing policy

of the Department of State. The Service refers to Note 6 to 22 CFR

275

Interim Decision #2182

42.1 appearing in the Visa Volume of the Foreign Service Manual'

The Service contends in its motion that "[I]t is not necessary that

the spouse whose foreign state chargeability was to be conferred

on the other spouse, be independently qualified for an immigrant

visa or already be a recipient of an immigrant visa." We do not

agree with this position.

We have examined the language of Note 6 carefully and con-

clude that the Service's construction is overly broad. The very

language of Note 6 limits its application to the case of an alien who

wishes to derive more favorable foreign state chargeability from

his accompanying alien spouse under section 202(b)(2), when the

spouse wishes to derive preference status from him at the same

time. The Note advises simultaneous issuance of visas and applica-

tion for admission into the United States.

Inasmuch as the beneficiary was born in a foreign country of

the Western Hemisphere, he could not be granted adjustment of

his status under section 245 of the Immigration and Nationality

Act. Therefore, the spouses will have to proceed abroad for the

purpose of filing simultaneous applications for visas. Counsel

obviously contemplates that course of action.

We are satisfied that simultaneous application for visas abroad

by the beneficiary and his wife, followed by simultaneous applica-

tion for admission, would comply with both our order of April 19,

1972 and Note 6. We disagree with the Service's motion for

reconsideration only to the extent that the Service seeks a rever-

sal of our earlier order, which we deem unnecessary. The question

now is a factual one: whether the petitioner can establish, in

1 The full text of Note 6 is as follows:

Principal and derivative aliens. An alien may derive more favorable foreign

state chargeability from his accompanying alien spouse under the provisions of

section 202(b)(2) of the Act and the spouse may, at the same time, derive

preference status from him. Thus, the beneficiary of a fifth preference petition

born in Italy who is accompanying his Austrian-born spouse to the United

States may be issued a fifth preference Austrian visa if Austrian fifth prefer-

ence numbers are available. His wife in turn derives fifth preference status

under her own foreign state from her husband if a visa is not otherwise

immediately available to her. In such cases there are two principal aliens; the

husband is the principal alien for the purpose of conferring preference status

and the wife is the principal alien for the purpose of conferring a more favorable

foreign state chargeability. The same principles would apply in a case in which

one spouse must benefit from the provisions of section 212(g) of the Act, while

the other spouse may derive the benefits of a more favorable foreign state

chargeability, or of special immigrant or a preference immigrant status, from

the afflicted alien. In this type of case visas should be issued to the husband and

wife simultaneously and they should be cautioned to apply for admission into

the United States simultaneously, neither preceding the other_ (See Note 4 to 22

CFR 42.37.)

276

Interim Decision #2182

advance, that the' beneficiary and his spouse will go abroad as

indicated.

We hold that the District Director may, if he is satisified that it

is the appropriate procedure in a given case, issue a conditional

grant of approval, subject to a later simultaneous application for

visas and admission. The present case is one in which counsel has

suggested the possibility that there may be such simultaneous

application. Unfortunately, there is nothing before us as to the

intentions of the beneficiary and his spouse except, the bare

assertion of counsel. Consequently, we must remand the case to

the District Director so that he may make further inquiry.

The motion for reconsideration is granted and the case will be

remanded to the District Director.

ORDER: The motion for reconsideration is granted, our order

dated April 19, 1972 is vacated, and the case is remanded to the

District Director for further proceedings consistent with the fore-

going opinion.

277

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.