Opinion

BALBIN

  • 14 I. & N. Dec. 165
Court
Board of Immigration Appeals
Filed
Jul 1, 1972
Status
Published
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Interim Decision #2156

MATTER OF BALBIN

In Section 245 Proceedings

A-19725973

Decided by Regional Commissioner June 22, 1972

Since applicant has established only a temporary need for his services as a

minister by a religious denomination in the United States, he is ineligible for

classification as a "special immigrant" under section 101(a)(27)(DX0 of the

Immigration and Nationality Act and, accordingly, has failed to establish visa

availability as required for adjustment of status under section 245 of the Act.

Consequently, his application for adjustment of status is denied without

prejudice to reconsideration if he can establish that his services as a minister

are needed within the meaning of section 101(aX27)(D)(i) of the Act.

ON BEHALF OF APPLICANT: Richard W. Lowery, Esquire

77 W. Washington Street

Chicago, Illinois 60602

The District Director on May 23, 1972 certified this case to me

for review and decision.

A careful review of the record of proceedings discloses that the

applicant is eligible pursuant to section 245 of the Immigration

and Nationality Act, as amended, for adjustment of status to that

of a lawful permanent resident of the United States if "an

immigrant visa is immediately available to him. at the time his

application is approved."

The District Director has denied this application on the ground

the applicant does not qualify for "special immigrant" status as

contemplated by section 101(a)(2'7)(D)(i) of the Act. His decision

states that the applicant has not furnished "sufficient evidence

that your services are needed in the United States. The letter on

your behalf submitted by Cardinal Cody indicates your appoint-

ment to Our Lady of Lourdes Rectory is only temporary in

nature."

The determination that the applicant's services were of a tempo-

rary nature is based upon a letter dated June 29, 1971 from the

Archdiocese of Chicago reading in part as follows:

...faculties of the Archdiocese of Chicago, in accordance with Canon Law and

the regulations of this Archdiocese, are hereby granted you during your

165

Interim Decision #2156

residence at Our Lady of Lourdes Rectory, under the direction of the

Reverend Thomas J. Goldrick, Pastor, until June 30, 1972." (Emphasis supplied.)

Section 101(a)(27)(DA) of the Act classifies the following as a

"special immigrant":

an immigrant who continuously for at least two years immediately preceding

the time of his application for admission to the United States has been, and who

seeks to enter the United States solely for the purpose of carrying on the

vocation of a minister of a religious denomination, and whose services are

needed by such religious denomination having a bona fide organization in the

United States ...

The applicant received his Bachelor of Theology during May of

1965 and was ordained a priest on the 9th of that month. From the

time of his ordination until he departed for the United States in

1970 he served as a minister of religion in the Philippines. Since

his arrival in this country he has continued his religious educa-

tion, and has served as an assistant pastor at Our Lady of Lourdes

Church. He clearly meets the requirement of the statute regarding

carrying on the vocation of a minister for the requisite period

immediately prior to his admission; and there is every indication

that the applicant intends to carry on that vocation in the United

States for his religious denomination.

The remaining question is whether his "services are needed by

such religious denomination having a bona fide organization in

the United States", as specified in section 101(a)(27)(D)(i) of the

Act. Counsel for the applicant points out that this section does not

require that the minister's services be urgently needed, but merely

that they be needed by the religious denomination. This the

Service concedes. Counsel goes on to state that there is a shortage

of priests in the United States and that, therefore, the statutory

requirement regarding "need" has been met. We disagree with

that contention. The statute clearly indicates that in order to

qualify for "special immigrant" classification as a minister, the

alien must be "an immigrant who" .possesses certain specified

qualifications "and whose services are needed" by the religious

denomination. Thus the statute is geared to the qualifications and

the need for the services of an individual. Even if it were conceded

that a general shortage of priests exists, this does not establish

the need for the applicant's services as a priest.

Counsel also points to a letter issued by the pastor of Our Lady

of Lourdes Church describing the ministerial assistance which the

applicant has been rendering to him and that church, and express-

ing the pastor's desire that the applicant's effort to become a

permanent resident be facilitated. Counsel states that this also

establishes that the applicant's services are "needed", and charges

that the District Director's request that the applicant present a

166

Interim Decision #2156

letter from the Archdiocese concerning the need for his services is

improper under the circumstances. He alleges that this would not

be done with respect to other religious denominations which do not

have a "church structure" similar to the Catholic Church.

The need for the applicant's services must be established by the

appropriate religious authority. As indicated above, the Arch-

diocese has informed this Service that its "faculties" have been

granted to the applicant only until June 20, 1972. The fact that the

Catholic Church has a hierarchy cannot be ignored. Faced with a

statement from the ecclesiastical superiors of the pastor to the

effect that the applicant is authorized to perform his ministerial

functions within the Archdiocese only until June 30, 1972, it is our

view that the District Director's request for a statement from the

Archdiocese concerning the continuing need for the applicant's

services is not an unreasonable one, for, if the applicant's author-

ized services are to be finished by June 30, 1972, it is concluded

that the requisite need for his services has not been established

within the meaning and intent of the statute. Furthermore, it may

be noted, in passing, that the Immigration and Nationality Act

contains a provision whereby an organization seeking the tempo-

rary services of certain qualified aliens, including a bona fide

religious organization seeking the temporary services of a quali-

fied minister, may petition under section 214(c) of that Act for his

importation as a nonimmigrant under section 101(a)(15)(H)(i) of the

Act.

It is concluded that the applicant is ineligible for classification as

a "special immigrant" within the meaning of section 101(aX27)(D)(i) of

the Act. He has not established that an immigrant visa is im-

mediately available to him as a preference or nonpreference immi-

grant, or otherwise. Accordingly, he is statutorily ineligible for the

adjustment of status which he seeks. His application will be denied,

without prejudice to reconsideration in the event he is able to estab-

lish satisfactorily that his services as a minister are needed by his

religious denomination within the United States.

It is ordered that the decision of the District Director denying

the application for status as a permanent resident be and the

same is hereby affirmed.

167

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.