Opinion

GONZALEZ

  • 17 I. & N. Dec. 236
Court
Board of Immigration Appeals
Filed
Jul 1, 1980
Status
Published
Cited by
1 cases
Authority
More cited than 56.3%

The opinion

Interim Decision #2754

MATTER OF GONZALEZ

In Visa Petition Proceedings

A-12727931

Decided by Board January 17, 1980

(1) In order to support a claimed sibling relationship under section 203(a)(5) of the

Immigration and Nationality Act, S U.S.C. 1153(a)(5), the petitioner must establish

that she and the beneficiary once qualified as the "children" of a common "parent" as

those terms are defined by section 101(b)(1) and (2) of the Act, S U.S.C. 1101(b)(1) and

(2).

(2) The mere fact of a marriage that technically creates a steprelationship is insufficient

to establish the existence of that steprelationship for immigration purposes; however,

such relationship may be established upon the additional showing that the stepparent,

prior to the stepchild's eighteenth birthday, evinced an active parental interest in the

child's support, instruction, and general welfare. Matter of Moreira, Interim Decision

2720 (BIA 1979).

(3) In determining whether a stepparent-stepchild relationship exists under section

101(b)(1)(B) of the Act, the fact that the beneficiary is an adulterine child born after

the marriage which created the steprela.tionship, rather than prior to that marriage,

is irrelevant. Matter of Stoltz, 15 I&N Dec. 362 (BIA 1974,1975; A.G. 1975).

(4) Where evidence establishes that the petitioner's natural mother took the benefici-

ary, the illegitimate offspring of her husband and another woman, into her home and

raised him as her own son, the beneficiary in fact once qualified as her child within the

meaning of section 101(b)(1)(B) of the Act, inasmuch as the petitioner qualifies as her

child by reason of section 101(b)(1)(A) of the Ad, the petitioner and the beneficiary

have a common parent and accordingly may be regarded as sister and brother under

section 203(a)(5) of the Act.

ON BEHALF OF PETITIONER: Benjamin Globman, Esquire

915 Asylum Avenue

Hartford, Connecticut 06105

BY: Milhollan, Chairman; Maniatis, Appleman, Maguire, and Farb, Board Members

This case is before us on appeal from the decision of the District

Director dated January 30, 1979, which denied the visa petition filed by

the United States citizen petitioner to accord the beneficiary prefer-

ence status as her brother pursuant to section 202(a)(5) of the Im-

migration and Nationality Act, 8 1J.S.C. 1153(a)(5). The appeal will be

sustained and the visa petition will be approved.

236

Interim Decision 112754

The petitioner was born in the Dominican Republic on August 12,

1926, the legitimate daughter of Francisco Ramirez and Rosalinda

Soriano. The beneficiary, a native and citizen of the Dominican Repub-

lic, was born of a relationship between Francisco Ramirez and

Enadina Gonzalez Ruiz on July 1, 1946, while Francisco Ramirez was

married to Rosalinda Soriano. In affidavits executed in support of the

visa petition, the petitioner and her husband declared that the benefi-

ciary was brought into the home of the petitioner's family and was

raised by Rosalinda Soriano as her own son until her death when the

beneficiary was 13 years of age. The beneficiary continued living with

Francisco Ramirez until his death and thereafter resided with other

close relatives of the petitioner.

In order to support a claimed sibling relationship under section

203(a)(5) of the Act, the petitioner must establish that she and the

beneficiary once qualified as the "children" of a common "parent" as

those terms are defined by section 101(b)(1) and (2) of the Act, 8 U.S.C.

1101(b)(1) and (2). See Matter'of Bourne,16 I&N Dec. 367 (BIA 1977);

Matter of Garner, 16 I&N Dec. 367 (BIA 1975).

The District Director denied the visa petition as a matter of law,

concluding that the beneficiary cannot qualify as a "child" of the

petitioner's parents within the purview of the definition set forth in

section 101(b)(1)(A) through (F) of the Act. The District Director's

legal conclusion is erroneous.

Where the claimed common parent is the natural father of the

petitioner and the beneficiary, each must establish that he or she was

legitimate at birth pursuant to section 101(b)(1)(A), legitimated prior

to reaching 18 years of age in accordance with section 101(b)(1)(C), or

adopted before his or her fourteenth birthday as provided in section

101(b)(1)(E) of the Act. The petitioner, as the legitimate offspring of

Francisco Ramirez, clearly qualifies as his "child" within the meaning

of the Act. However, since the beneficiary was born out of wedlock and

was never adopted by Francisco Ramirez, it must be shown that the

beneficiary was legitimated by him prior to reaching 18 years of age if

the beneficiary is to qualify for immigration benefits by virtue of his

relationship to his natural father. That showing cannot be made in the

instant case since under the law of the Dominican Republic, the

applicable law in the case, legitimation can only be accomplished by

the acknowledgment of the illegitimate offspring and the subsequent

marriage of the child's natural parents. Matter of Reyes, 16 I&N Dee.

475 (BIA. 1978). It has not been alleged that the beneficiary's natural

parents ever married.

We nevertheless conclude that the beneficiary qualifies as the

brother of the petitioner through the operation of section 101(b)(1)(B)

of the Act, 8 U.S.C. 1101(B)(1)(B), which includes within the definition

237

Interim Decision #2754

of the term "child":

(B) a stepchild, whether or not born out of wedlock, provided the child had not

reached the age of eighteen years at the time the marriage creating the status of

stepchild occurred; or...

In a recent precedent decision, Matter of Moreira, Interim Decision

2720 (BIA. 1979), we construed the foregoing section of the Act and

formulated a definition of the term "stepchild" for purposes of the

immigration laws. After reviewing the legislative history of the

stepchild provision and the case law, both from the Board and the

courts, we held that the mere fact of a marriage that technically

creates a steprelationship is insufficient to establish the existence of

that steprelationship for immigration purposes; however, such rela-

tionship may be established upon the additional showing that the

stepparent, prior to the stepchild's eighteenth birthday, evinced an

active parental interest in the child's support, instruction, and general

welfare.

We are satisfied that the petitioner has made the requisite showing

that the beneficiary in fact once qualified as the child of Rosalinda

Soriano within the meaning of section 101(b)(1)(B) of the Act as

construed in Matter of Moreira, supra.' The petitioner, legitimate at

birth, qualifies as the child of Rosalinda Soriano by reason of section

101(b)(1)(A) of the Act. Inasmuch as the petitioner and the beneficiary

have a common parent within the context of the Immigration and

Nationality Act, namely, Rosalinda Soriano, the petitioner's natural

mother and the beneficiary's stepmother, they may be considered as

"sister" and "brother" under section 203(a)(5). The appeal will accord-

ingly be sustained.

ORDERS The apnealis sustained and the visa petition is approved.

' The fact that the beneficiary is an adulterine child born after the marriage which

created the steprelationship, rather than prior to that marriage, is irrelevant. Matter of

Stuitz, 15 I&N Dec. 362 (BIA 1974,1975; A.G. 1975).

238

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.