Opinion

Yates v. Tiffiny

  • 126 Me. 128
  • 136 A. 668
  • 1927 Me. LEXIS 22
Court
Supreme Judicial Court of Maine
Filed
Mar 17, 1927
Status
Published
Author
Sturgis
On the bench
Barnes, Deasy, Dunn, Philbrook, Sturgis, Wilson
Cited by
4 cases
Authority
More cited than 62.8%

The opinion

Sturgis, J.

Action on the case to recover damages for obstructing a public highway. General demurrer filed and overruled. Exception reserved.

The declaration sets out that the defendant erected a fence and budding upon a certain public highway in Camden known as Cottage Street over which the plaintiffs had a right to travel.

*129 An obstruction placed within the limits of a public way is a nuisance at common law and by statute. R. S., Chap. 23, Sec. 5. Smith v. Preston, 104 Me., 156; Corthell v. Holmes, 88 Me., 376. One who has sustained special damage from a common nuisance may recover therefor in an action on the case. R. S., Chap. 23, Sec. 16; Smith v. Preston, supra; Staples v. Dickson, 88 Me, 362; Brown v. Watson, 47 Me., 161.

It sufficiently appears in the plaintiffs’ declaration that they were entitled to use the obstructed portion of the way for egress and ingress to their premises and in a special manner not common to the public. To reach Mill Street, a public way in the village, from the Cottage Street side of their premises, they were obliged to pass over the obstructed section of the way. The fence and building not only obstructed the plaintiff’s right in common with others to pass up and down the street, but cut off their right of access to their private property. This constitutes special injury differing in kind and degree from that suffered by the community at large. Smart v. Lumber Co., 103 Me., 37; Cobe v. Banton, 106 Me., 418.

The declaration states a legal cause of action and is sufficient on general demurrer.

Exception overruled.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.