Opinion

Benick v. Dept. of Agriculture

  • 2019 Ohio 5469
Court
Ohio Court of Claims
Filed
Dec 30, 2019
Status
Published
On the bench
McGrath
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 10.8%

The opinion

[Cite as Benick v. Dept. of Agriculture, 2019-Ohio-5469.]

BRIAN L. BENICK Case No. 2018-01543JD

Plaintiff Judge Patrick M. McGrath

Magistrate Robert Van Schoyck

v.

ENTRY GRANTING DEFENDANT’S

DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE

PLEADINGS

Defendant

{¶1} On November 20, 2019, defendant filed a motion for judgment on the

pleadings pursuant to Civ.R. 12(C). Plaintiff did not file a response.

{¶2} “Civ.R. 12(C) may be employed by a defendant as a vehicle for raising the

several defenses contained in Civ.R. 12(B) after the close of the pleadings. * * *

Pursuant to Civ.R. 12(C), the pleadings must be construed liberally and in a light most

favorable to the party against whom the motion is made along with the reasonable

inferences drawn therefrom. * * * A Civ.R. 12(C) motion presents only questions of law,

and it may be granted only when no material factual issues exist, and the movant is

entitled to a judgment as a matter of law.” Burnside v. Leimbach, 71 Ohio App.3d 399,

402-403, 594 N.E.2d 60 (10th Dist.1991).

{¶3} Defendant’s motion raises the defenses contained in Civ.R. 12(B)(1) and

(6). “The standard of review for a dismissal pursuant to Civ.R. 12(B)(1) is whether any

cause of action cognizable by the forum has been raised in the complaint.” State ex rel.

Bush v. Spurlock, 42 Ohio St.3d 77, 80, 537 N.E.2d 641 (1989). “In order for a court to

dismiss a complaint for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted

(Civ.R. 12(B)(6)), it must appear beyond doubt from the complaint that the plaintiff can

prove no set of facts entitling him to recovery.” O’Brien v. Univ. Community Tenants

Union, Inc., 42 Ohio St.2d 242, 327 N.E.2d 753 (1975), syllabus.

{¶4} According to the complaint and documents attached thereto, plaintiff was

formerly employed with the Morrow County Health Department as Director of

Environmental Health. Plaintiff seeks $50,000,000 in damages arising from allegations

Case No. 2018-01543JD -2- ENTRY

that defendant’s “Food Safety Division forces local health departments to violate state

laws and state rules.” (Complaint, ¶ 12, 14.) The complaint provides that such

violations have “occurred for years” throughout the state and “specifically in Morrow Co.

since 7/28/16”. (Id., ¶ 10-11.) On that date, July 28, 2016, defendant notified the

Morrow County Health Department that its Retail Food Establishment Licensing and

Inspection Program would be classified as “provisional” due to several deficiencies that

defendant found while conducting a survey of the program pursuant to R.C. 3717.11

and Ohio Adm.Code 901:3-4-17, according to an attachment to the complaint.

{¶5} Plaintiff, who disagreed with the results of that survey, claims that

defendant “forces [local health districts] to require food-related businesses to install

equipment not specified in rules” and “forced [the Morrow County Health Department] to

close Amish businesses, violating the Ohio Supreme Court deliberately.” (Id., ¶ 12.)

According to plaintiff:

[defendant] regularly exceeds their authority, forcing [local health districts]

to document huge numbers of violations, when it is the local health

departments’ authority to determine what constitutes a violation.

[Defendant] deliberately ignores the lawful definitions of “food service

operation” and “retail food establishment” to force [local health districts] to

provide money to [defendant] that lawfully is required to go to [the Ohio

Department of Health].

(Id.) Plaintiff asserts that he has “taken every possible action to avoid being forced to

violate state laws + rules. My supervisor, my subordinate, MCHD board of health,

[defendant] and local health departments have all interferred [sic] with my efforts, forced

me to violate state laws + rules, and resulting in my termination.” (Id., ¶ 13.)

{¶6} As defendant notes in its motion for judgment on the pleadings, the

complaint does not identify any specific cause of action. The gravamen of the complaint

aims to challenge what plaintiff claims are violations of defendant’s statutory

Case No. 2018-01543JD -3- ENTRY

responsibilities to survey retail food establishment programs administered by boards of

health throughout the state. Basically, plaintiff contends that defendant has exceeded

its authority in performing these surveys or otherwise exercising its regulatory or

supervisory duties and has misapplied applicable laws and regulations. Defendant

argues, however, that such allegations do not support a claim upon which relief can be

granted in this court. The court agrees.

{¶7} “The Court of Claims Act, effective January 1, 1975, waived the state’s

sovereign immunity and established the Court of Claims * * *.” Keller v. Dailey, 124

Ohio App.3d 298, 302, 706 N.E.2d 28 (10th Dist.1997). “The court of claims has

exclusive, original jurisdiction over civil actions against the state for money damages

that sound in law.” Young v. Ohio State Univ. Hosps., 2017-Ohio-2673, 90 N.E.3d 234,

¶ 13 (10th Dist.), citing R.C. 2743.03(A)(1). “While the state waived its sovereign

immunity in R.C. 2743.02, the state also limited its amenability to suit.” Cardi v. Dept. of

Commerce, 10th Dist. Franklin No. 12AP-15, 2012-Ohio-6157, ¶ 13. “R.C. 2743.02

limits actions brought in the Court of Claims to those which could be brought between

private parties.” Peters v. Ohio Dept. of Rehab. & Corr., 10th Dist. Franklin No. 03AP-

350, 2003-Ohio-5895, ¶ 13; see also Henneke v. Ohio Dept. of Ins., 10th Dist. Franklin

No. 11AP-254, 2011-Ohio-5366, ¶ 8. “Thus, suits against the state are inherently

limited by the type of action asserted against it; if the cause of action is not cognizable

as between private parties, then there can likewise be no state liability. For instance,

actions * * * that do not sound in tort but seek recovery purely for a statutory violation

will not necessarily lie against the state—particularly if the statute in question provides

no private right of action.” Wallace v. Ohio Dept. of Commerce, 96 Ohio St.3d 266,

2002-Ohio-4210, 773 N.E.2d 1018, ¶ 37.

{¶8} Plaintiff seeks to recover damages based on defendant’s alleged failure to

abide by its statutory and regulatory responsibilities with regard to surveying retail food

establishment programs administered by boards of health. Plaintiff has not

Case No. 2018-01543JD -4- ENTRY

demonstrated, however, that the applicable statutes or regulations create a private right

of action. In the absence of a statutory basis for this lawsuit, plaintiff does not have a

viable claim for money damages against the state. See Vos v. Ohio Environmental

Protection Agency, 10th Dist. Franklin No. 17AP-749, 2018-Ohio-2956, ¶ 11.

{¶9} Defendant also argues that even if plaintiff’s complaint could be

interpreted to state a cognizable claim for relief, defendant is immune from liability since

any such claim would involve defendant’s performance or nonperformance of a “public

duty.” “Generally, the state is ‘immune from liability in any civil action or proceeding

involving the performance or nonperformance of a public duty.’” Lawrence v. Meridian

Senior Living, L.L.C., 2016-Ohio-8500, 79 N.E.3d 1158, ¶ 8 (10th Dist.), quoting

R.C. 2743.02(A)(3)(a). As defined in R.C. 2743.01(E)(1), “‘[p]ublic duty’ includes, but is

not limited to, any statutory, regulatory, or assumed duty concerning any action or

omission of the state involving any of the following: (a) Permitting, certifying, licensing,

inspecting, investigating, supervising, regulating, auditing, monitoring, law enforcement,

or emergency response activity * * *.”

{¶10} Pursuant to R.C. 3717.11, defendant has a duty to conduct surveys of

boards of health “for the purpose of determining whether the board is qualified and has

the capacity to administer and enforce this chapter and the rules adopted under it and to

abide by the Ohio uniform food safety code.” As a matter of law, this supervisory duty

on the part of defendant is owed to the general public rather than any particular

individual and defendant is therefore immune from liability in any civil action involving

the performance or nonperformance of such duty, pursuant to the public duty rule set

out in R.C. 2743.02(A)(3)(a). See Benick v. Dept. of Health, Ct. of Cl. No. 2018-

01165JD, 2019-Ohio-3693, ¶ 13 (involving duty to survey health districts under

R.C. 3718.07). Moreover, the complaint does not put forth factual allegations sufficient

to establish the “special relationship” exception to the public duty rule under

Case No. 2018-01543JD -5- ENTRY

R.C. 2743.02(A)(3)(b). See Estate of Tokes v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr., 10th Dist.

Franklin No. 18AP-723, 2019-Ohio-1794, ¶ 36-37.

{¶11} Finally, to the extent that the complaint may be construed as a collateral

attack upon defendant’s administrative determination under R.C. 3717.11 and Ohio

Adm.Code 901:3-4-17, the court of claims “generally lacks appellate jurisdiction over

administrative decisions.” Hulbert v. Ohio Bur. of Workers’ Comp., 10th Dist. Franklin

No. 14AP-374, 2014-Ohio-3937, ¶ 7. And, with respect to plaintiff’s claim that

defendant violated the rights of the Amish, ordinarily a non-attorney pro se litigant may

only represent his or her own legal interests. See Hamilton v. Ohio Dept. of Health,

2015-Ohio-4041, 42 N.E.3d 1261, ¶ 29 (10th Dist.); State ex rel. Manning v. Adult

Parole Auth., 10th Dist. Franklin No. 15AP-1050, 2016-Ohio-7946, ¶ 15.

{¶12} Based upon the foregoing, defendant’s motion for judgment on the

pleadings is GRANTED and judgment is rendered in favor of defendant. All previously

scheduled events are VACATED. Court costs are assessed against plaintiff. The clerk

shall serve upon all parties notice of this judgment and its date of entry upon the journal.

PATRICK M. MCGRATH

Judge

Filed December 30, 2019

Sent to S.C. Reporter 1/24/20

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.