Opinion

Equal Emp't Opportunity Comm'n v. Costco Wholesale Corp.

  • 903 F.3d 618
Court
Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
Filed
Sep 10, 2018
Status
Published
Author
Barrett
On the bench
Sykes, Barrett, Griesbach
Nature of suit
civil
Cited by
98 cases
Authority
More cited than 90.0%

discussing the holding of Baskerville v. Culligan International Co., 50 F.3d 428, 430 (7th Cir. 1995), and noting that a supervisor “making masturbation gestures while conversing with [the plaintiff], grunting suggestively as she turned to leave his office, referring to her as a ‘pretty girl,’ and commenting that his office did not get ‘hot’ until she walked in” wasn’t enough to create a hostile work environment

How later courts described this case

  • discussing the holding of Baskerville v. Culligan International Co., 50 F.3d 428, 430 (7th Cir. 1995), and noting that a supervisor “making masturbation gestures while conversing with [the plaintiff], grunting suggestively as she turned to leave his office, referring to her as a ‘pretty girl,’ and commenting that his office did not get ‘hot’ until she walked in” wasn’t enough to create a hostile work environment
  • observing that “[a]ctionable discrimination can [consist of] demeaning, ostracizing, or even terrorizing the victim,” and noting that the court “must decide whether a reasonable juror could find [the employer’s] conduct objectively intimidating or frightening”
  • recognizing that an employer can create a hostile work environment by “demeaning, ostracizing, or even terrorizing the victim because of her sex”
  • discussing the holding of Baskerville v. Culligan International Co., 50 F.3d 428, 430 (7th Cir. 1995

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

In the

United States Court of Appeals

For the Seventh Circuit

____________________

Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454

EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION,

Plaintiff-Appellee/

Cross-Appellant

v.

COSTCO WHOLESALE CORPORATION,

Defendant-Appellant/

Cross-Appellee.

____________________

Appeals from the United States District Court for the

Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division.

No. 1:14-cv-06553 — Ruben Castillo, Chief Judge.

____________________

ARGUED FEBRUARY 13, 2018 — DECIDED SEPTEMBER 10, 2018

____________________

Before SYKES and BARRETT, Circuit Judges, and GRIESBACH,

Chief District Judge. *

BARRETT, Circuit Judge. Dawn Suppo, an employee of

Costco Wholesale Corporation, was stalked by Thad Thomp-

son, a customer of Costco, for over a year. Things got so bad

* Of the Eastern District of Wisconsin, sitting by designation.

2 Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454

at the end that Suppo secured a plenary no-contact order from

an Illinois state court. Traumatized by the experience, she also

took an unpaid medical leave, and when she didn’t come

back, Costco terminated her employment.

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission

(EEOC) sued Costco on Suppo’s behalf, alleging that Costco

had subjected her to a hostile work environment by tolerating

Thompson’s harassment. After the jury rendered a verdict in

the EEOC’s favor, Costco moved for judgment as a matter of

law and the EEOC moved for backpay. The district court de-

nied both motions, and both parties appeal.

We conclude that the district court was right to deny

Costco’s motion for judgment as a matter of law, because a

reasonable jury could conclude that Thompson’s conduct was

severe or pervasive enough to render Suppo’s work environ-

ment hostile. The district court was only half right, however,

with respect to the EEOC’s motion for backpay. We agree

with the district court that Suppo cannot recover backpay for

the period of time after Costco fired her. But it should have

considered whether Suppo was entitled to backpay for some

or all of her time on unpaid medical leave.

I.

The evidence frequently conflicted during the trial, but be-

cause the EEOC won a verdict on Suppo’s behalf, we recount

the facts in the light most favorable to her. We look at the rec-

ord as a whole, give her the benefit of every inference, and

refrain from making credibility determinations. Reeves v.

Sanderson Plumbing Prods., Inc., 530 U.S. 133, 150–51 (2000); see

also Walker v. Bd. of Regents of Univ. of Wis. Sys., 410 F.3d 387,

393 (7th Cir. 2005). Our task is to determine whether a juror

Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454 3

inclined to believe Suppo’s side of the story could reasonably

conclude that Costco subjected her to a hostile work environ-

ment.

A.

Costco is a warehouse club open to members who pay an

annual fee. It offers a wide range of goods—everything from

groceries to furniture—at its many locations around the coun-

try. In 2009, Suppo began working at Costco’s store in Glen-

view, Illinois as a seasonal, part-time employee; in May of

2010, she transitioned to regular, part-time status. Her duties

included doing “go-backs”—re-shelving items that members

decided not to purchase. Go-backs required Suppo to circu-

late around the large warehouse with a shopping cart, return-

ing items to the sections where they belonged. Most, if not all,

of her encounters with Thompson occurred while she was do-

ing go-backs.

Suppo encountered Thompson for the first time in May or

June of 2010. Thompson referred to Suppo by her first name,

which he read from her employee nametag. He noted that he

had seen her “speaking to one of the guys up front” and asked

what Suppo describes as “a few personal questions,” such as

where she lived. Suppo replied that it was nice to meet him,

but she had to return to work. A few days later, they had a

similar encounter: Thompson approached her, asked ques-

tions that Suppo considered personal, and Suppo replied that

she had to go back to work. Suppo did not immediately report

these interactions to Costco management. But they had un-

nerved her, and two months later, she related them to Don

Currier, her direct manager. She told Currier that she was

scared, and he instructed her to notify him if she saw Thomp-

son again.

4 Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454

Shortly after her conversation with Currier, Suppo did see

Thompson again. This time, he was wearing “sunglasses and

a hat” while “watching [her] in different aisles and hiding be-

hind the clothes.” When Thompson realized that she had seen

him, he told Suppo that she “looked scared” and left. Suppo

notified Currier, and Currier, Greg West (Assistant General

Manager), and Daniro Hernandez (a loss-prevention officer)

brought Thompson into the warehouse office, where they told

him to “avoid [Suppo] and … not talk to her.” Thompson was

defensive and angry; he loudly stated that it is a “free coun-

try” and invoked his “freedom of speech.” He nonetheless

agreed to stay away from Suppo. Currier told Suppo about

the meeting and instructed her to follow up with him if she

had future concerns about Thompson.

Suppo remained frightened by this third interaction with

Thompson and decided to contact the police. She filed a re-

port stating that Thompson had been asking personal ques-

tions and “hiding behind clothes watching her.” Later that

day, the police called Suppo about her report while she was

in the warehouse office with Currier and West. After she hung

up, West yelled at her and told her to “be friendly to” Thomp-

son. The police interviewed Thompson, but they did not ar-

rest or charge him. Instead, they filed a half-page report relat-

ing Suppo’s claims that “Thompson was stalking her while

she was at Costco,” that she could “feel him looking at her,”

and that “when she looks at him he looks down.” The report

also noted that Thompson had apologized and said that he

would avoid Suppo in Costco.

But Thompson did not avoid Suppo. The two encountered

one another multiple times over the next 13 months, although

Costco and the EEOC disagree about how many. Costco

Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454 5

insists before us (as it did before the jury) that Thompson and

Suppo could not have seen one another more than 20 times

during this 13-month period, because Thompson’s purchase

record reflects that he was in the warehouse during only 20 of

Suppo’s 308 scheduled shifts. As the EEOC pointed out at

trial, however, Costco only records when members purchase

items, not when they enter the warehouse, and Suppo testi-

fied that Thompson’s cart was sometimes empty when she

saw him. Thus, Thompson could have been in the warehouse

much more often than his purchase record reflects. Suppo

also testified that Thompson “constantly” tried to talk to her

and “constantly” tried to give her his phone number. Based

on the EEOC’s evidence, the jury could infer both that

Thompson approached Suppo very frequently and that he

sometimes came to the warehouse to see her rather than to

shop. It was not required to credit Costco’s claim that the two

saw one another no more than 20 times.

Suppo described her interactions with Thompson as fol-

lows. On two occasions, she saw him “coming around the

aisle just watching [her],” which made her “uncomfortable.”

On other occasions, he talked to her. Suppo testified that

Thompson expressed some (though not all) of his questions

“in a sexual way.” He asked (often repeatedly) where she was

from, what her nationality was, where else she worked, where

else she went, where she lived, what else she did, if she had a

boyfriend, which male employees she spoke to, and the iden-

tity of a man she shopped with. Suppo described each of these

questions as “intimate” because each made her feel “uncom-

fortable.” On various occasions, he told her she was “pretty,”

“beautiful,” and “exotic.” He asked how old she was. Two or

three times Suppo told him she would not answer, and

Thompson mused that “he couldn’t tell if [she] was 17 or 27.”

6 Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454

(Suppo was in her 40s at the time.) Thompson told her that

she “look[ed] scared” and asked several times whether “he

freak[ed her] out.” He tried to give her his business card on

one occasion (pushing it into her hand “two, three, and four

times”), asked her out on dates approximately six times, and

“constantly” tried to give her his phone number. He also

closely observed her appearance: For example, on a day that

he saw her twice, he “noticed that she had obviously pow-

dered her face” between the first and second times that he saw

her. On another occasion, he noticed that her eye makeup had

been applied unevenly.

There was also some physical contact. Thompson used his

shopping cart to bump into Suppo or her cart four times. He

touched her twice: On one occasion, Thompson touched her

face under her eye, noting some darkness. On another, he

touched her wrist, commenting on her veins and a sore on her

hand that was healing slowly. Thompson also attempted un-

successfully to hug Suppo twice.

Currier was present for two of these encounters: once

when Thompson pulled his cart up next to Suppo before go-

ing to the restroom, and once when Thompson asked Suppo

a few questions on the warehouse floor before she walked

away from him and toward Currier. After the first instance,

Currier told Suppo he was watching Thompson. After the sec-

ond, Currier talked to Thompson. Suppo asked if she could

park closer to the store’s entrance to avoid being in the park-

ing lot alone. When Costco denied her request, her father be-

gan picking her up from work.

On September 1, 2011, Suppo was returning items

throughout the warehouse as part of her “go-back” duties.

While she was in the fish aisle, Thompson walked up to her

Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454 7

and asked if they could talk. Suppo said no, and Thompson,

red-faced, “whipped” his cart around and left. Shortly after-

ward, Suppo was in the candy aisle near the registers when

she saw Thompson with his phone over his head, videotaping

her “from afar.” She said, “I told you to leave me alone.”

Thompson retorted, “Okay, I’ll leave you alone, mysterious

Dawn.” Suppo returned to work. In the meantime, Thompson

saw Currier on the warehouse floor and claimed that while he

had just encountered Suppo, she had initiated the contact.

Things moved quickly after that. On September 8th,

Suppo secured a Stalking No Contact Order against Thomp-

son from the county circuit court; the order forbade Thomp-

son from approaching Suppo at her residence or place of em-

ployment for 21 days. On September 11th, Suppo went on a

medical leave of absence from Costco. And on September

19th, the General Manager of the Glenview Costco told

Thompson not to shop at the Glenview location anymore; he

suggested that Thompson shop at Costco’s Mettawa location,

which was a comparable distance from Thompson’s home.

Thompson agreed. When the emergency no contact order ex-

pired at the end of the month, Suppo secured a plenary No

Contact Order against Thompson for a full year.

Costco continued its investigation after Suppo went on

medical leave. On October 4th, the Assistant Vice President of

the Midwest Region sent a letter to Thompson notifying him

that Costco was aware of Suppo’s complaints to both manage-

ment and the Glenview police. The letter formally directed

Thompson to shop at the Mettawa warehouse instead of the

one in Glenview. On November 23rd, the General Manager of

the Glenview store sent an investigation closure letter to

Suppo, informing her that although the company could not

8 Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454

confirm a violation of its harassment policy, it had instructed

Thompson not to shop at the Glenview warehouse.

Unfortunately, the closure letter did not mark the end of

Suppo’s interactions with Thompson. A few months later, she

saw him while she was shopping with her father at Costco’s

Mettawa warehouse, where Thompson had been told to shop.

Thompson screamed profanity at them. This happened on a

Friday; Costco revoked Thompson’s membership the follow-

ing Monday. It forbade Thompson to enter any Costco ware-

house without direct permission from the warehouse General

Manager or the Assistant Vice President of the Midwest Re-

gion.

In November of 2012, per company policy, Costco termi-

nated Suppo because her unpaid medical leave of absence

had extended beyond twelve months.

B.

The EEOC filed suit on Suppo’s behalf. Its complaint al-

leged that Costco had discriminated against her because of

her sex “by creating and tolerating a sexually hostile work en-

vironment of offensive comments of a sexual nature, unwel-

come touching, unwelcome advances, and stalking by a cus-

tomer.” It also accused Costco of constructively discharging

Suppo. The district court granted Costco summary judgment

on the constructive discharge claim, but it allowed the hostile

work environment claim to go to trial. At the close of the

EEOC’s case, Costco moved for judgment as a matter of law,

and the district court denied the motion. After the jury

awarded Suppo $250,000 in compensatory damages, Costco

renewed its motion for judgment as a matter of law and asked

in the alternative for a new trial. The EEOC moved for

Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454 9

backpay and various forms of injunctive relief. The district

court denied all post-trial motions. Costco appeals the denial

of its motion for judgment as a matter of law, and the EEOC

cross-appeals the denial of backpay.

II.

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits an em-

ployer from discriminating against an employee on the basis

of sex. 42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2(a)(1). An employer violates this

provision when “discrimination based on sex … create[s] a

hostile or abusive work environment.” Meritor Sav. Bank, FSB

v. Vinson, 477 U.S. 57, 66 (1986). This case is unusual because

it involves alleged sexual harassment by a customer rather

than by a supervisor or coworker. That does not get Costco

off the hook, however, because an employer can be liable for

a hostile work environment that results from the acts of non-

employees, including customers. Dunn v. Washington Cty.

Hosp., 429 F.3d 689, 691 (7th Cir. 2005); see also Lockard v. Pizza

Hut, Inc., 162 F.3d 1062, 1074 (10th Cir. 1998) (“[T]he same

standard of liability applies to both co-worker and customer

harassment.”).

To establish a hostile work environment claim, a plaintiff

must show that she was “(1) subjected to unwelcome sexual

conduct, advances, or requests; (2) because of her sex; (3) that

were severe or pervasive enough to create a hostile work en-

vironment; and (4) that there is a basis for employer liability.”

Lapka v. Chertoff, 517 F.3d 974, 982 (7th Cir. 2008). The third

factor—the only one that Costco contests—requires the un-

welcome conduct to be severe or pervasive from both a sub-

jective and an objective point of view. Faragher v. City of Boca

Raton, 524 U.S. 775, 787 (1998). This case turns on the objective

prong: Costco concedes that Suppo subjectively perceived

10 Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454

Thompson’s conduct to be severe or pervasive, but it argues

that no reasonable person would have experienced it that

way.

To be severe or pervasive enough to create a hostile work

environment, conduct must be “extreme.” Id. at 788. Deter-

mining whether behavior crosses that threshold is not subject

to “a mathematically precise test.” Harris v. Forklift Sys., Inc.,

510 U.S. 17, 22 (1993). Rather, it depends on “all the circum-

stances,” including “the frequency of the discriminatory con-

duct; its severity; whether it is physically threatening or hu-

miliating, or a mere offensive utterance; and whether it un-

reasonably interferes with an employee’s work performance.”

Id. at 23. With that standard in mind, we evaluate Costco’s

appeal.

A.

Costco grounds its attack on the jury’s verdict in the con-

tent of Thompson’s comments to Suppo and the nature of his

physical contact with her. As for Thompson’s comments,

Costco insists that they were “tepid” compared to those that

we have held insufficiently severe or pervasive to create a

hostile work environment. On the scale of vulgarity, Costco is

right—unsuccessful Title VII plaintiffs have endured far

worse. Baskerville v. Culligan International Co. is a good exam-

ple. There, we held that an employer was entitled to judgment

in a case in which the behavior of the plaintiff’s supervisor

included making masturbation gestures while conversing

with her, grunting suggestively as she turned to leave his of-

fice, referring to her as a “pretty girl,” and commenting that

his office did not get “hot” until she walked in. 50 F.3d 428,

430 (7th Cir. 1995). Thompson’s attempts to solicit

Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454 11

biographical information from Suppo, compliments on her

appearance, and requests for dates were nowhere near this

lewd.

The same is true of the occasions on which Thompson

touched Suppo. Costco correctly observes that we have held

conduct that is more amorous and similarly pervasive to be

insufficiently hostile to sustain a claim under Title VII. For ex-

ample, in McPherson v. City of Waukegan, we held that a super-

visor did not severely or pervasively harass plaintiff by ask-

ing what color bra she was wearing, pulling back the shoulder

strap of her tank top to see for himself, and suggesting that he

“make a house call” when she called in sick. 379 F.3d 430, 438–

39 (7th Cir. 2004). In Adusumilli v. City of Chicago, we held that

a coworker did not severely or pervasively harass the plaintiff

by making sexual comments and touching her arm, fingers,

or buttocks, on four occasions. 164 F.3d 353, 361–62 (7th Cir.

1998). Thompson’s physical contact with Suppo—touches on

the wrist and cheek, bumps with a shopping cart, and at-

tempted hugs—was less sexually suggestive than conduct

that we have already described as falling below the bar. Be-

cause Thompson’s come-ons were so mild, Costco says, the

district court should have granted it judgment as a matter of

law.

Yet Costco’s argument implies a position inconsistent

with our case law: that harassment must be overtly sexual to

be actionable under Title VII. To be sure, the alleged harass-

ment must occur because of the plaintiff’s sex. 1 Smith v. Rose-

bud Farm, Inc., 898 F.3d 747, 750 (7th Cir. 2018). But it need not

1Costco does not dispute that Thompson focused his attention on

Suppo because she is female.

12 Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454

consist of pressure for sex, intimate touching, or a barrage of

deeply offensive sexual comments. Passananti v. Cook Cty., 689

F.3d 655, 664 (7th Cir. 2012). Actionable discrimination can

take other forms, such as demeaning, ostracizing, or even ter-

rorizing the victim because of her sex. See, e.g., id. at 663–64

(supervisor created a hostile work environment by “demean-

ing, degrading and demoralizing” the plaintiff); Hall v. City of

Chicago, 713 F.3d 325, 331 (7th Cir. 2013) (supervisor isolated

the plaintiff from her coworkers); Frazier v. Delco Elecs. Corp.,

263 F.3d 663, 664–65, 667 (7th Cir. 2001) (coworker terrorized

the plaintiff). Here, we must decide whether a reasonable ju-

ror could find Thompson’s conduct objectively intimidating

or frightening.

In making this assessment, we do not—as Costco would

have it—consider only what Thompson said and where he

touched her. As we have emphasized before, “[c]ourts should

not carve up the incidents of harassment and then separately

analyze each incident, by itself, to see if each rises to the level

of being severe or pervasive.” Hall, 713 F.3d at 331 (quoting

Mason v. S. Ill. Univ. at Carbondale, 233 F.3d 1036, 1045 (7th Cir.

2000)). We determine whether a workplace was hostile based

on “all the circumstances” of the case. Harris, 510 U.S. at 23;

see also Hall, 713 F.3d at 331 (severity and pervasiveness must

be judged by “the totality of the circumstances”). And in the

circumstances of this case, Thompson’s talking and touching

took place in the context of his stalking.

Suppo testified that Thompson’s presence at the Glenview

Costco was “constant.” He followed Suppo around the store,

watching her from around corners. He stared at her from be-

hind clothes racks, disguised in sunglasses and a hat. He mon-

itored her movements and asked her to account for her

Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454 13

conversations with men. He made trips to the warehouse to

see Suppo rather than to shop. He “constantly” asked her out

and “constantly” tried to give her his phone number. And

Thompson continued this dogged pursuit of Suppo even after

Don Currier told him to stay away from her, even after he

knew that Suppo had gone to the police, even after he had

assured both the police and Currier that he would avoid her,

and even though he knew that his attention scared her. His

behavior culminated in the bizarre, objectively frightening act

of filming Suppo, whom he called “mysterious Dawn.” A rea-

sonable juror could conclude that being hounded for over a

year by a customer despite intervention by management, in-

volvement of the police, and knowledge that he was scaring

her would be pervasively intimidating or frightening to a per-

son “of average steadfastness.” Frazier, 263 F.3d at 668.

Thompson’s outburst in the Mettawa warehouse supports

this conclusion. When Thompson saw Suppo and her father

there, he screamed expletives. This outburst did not contrib-

ute to the hostility of Suppo’s workplace because it occurred

after Thompson had been banned from the Glenview store. It

is relevant, however, to the jury’s evaluation of Thompson’s

behavior during the 13-month period in which he interacted

with Suppo at Glenview. Costco depicted Thompson as

friendly but overeager; the EEOC portrayed him as unstable

and obsessive. A reasonable juror aware of both the filming at

Glenview and the outburst at Mettawa could view Thomp-

son’s behavior between May of 2010 and September of 2011

through the lens of the EEOC’s portrayal.

14 Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454

Last but certainly not least is the plenary “no contact” or-

der issued by the state court.2 According to Costco, the evi-

dence construed in the light most favorable to the EEOC per-

mits only one conclusion: that Suppo is an eggshell plaintiff

whom Thompson pestered rather than harassed. That posi-

tion is exceedingly difficult to maintain in light of the state

court’s conclusion that Thompson violated the Illinois Stalk-

ing No Contact Order Act. The then-effective version of that

Act provided that “‘[s]talking’ means engaging in a course of

conduct directed at a specific person” when the stalker

“knows or should know that this course of conduct would

cause a reasonable person to fear for his or her safety … or

suffer emotional distress.” 740 ILCS 21/10 § 10 (2010). 3 It de-

fined a “course of conduct” as “2 or more acts, including but

not limited to acts in which a respondent directly [or] indi-

rectly … follows, monitors, observes, surveils, threatens, or

communicates to or about, a person, [or] engages in other con-

tact ….” Id. And it described “emotional distress” as “signifi-

cant mental suffering, anxiety or alarm.” Id. After an adver-

sarial hearing, the state court concluded that Thompson had

violated this statute and issued a no-contact order prohibiting

him from (among other things) coming within 200 feet of

Suppo’s place of employment for a year. Given the state

court’s judgment that Thompson engaged in a course of con-

duct that would “cause a reasonable person to fear for his or

her safety … or suffer emotional distress,” it would be quite

2The state court initially issued an emergency, 21-day no-contact or-

der based on evidence submitted by Suppo. See 740 ILCS 21/95. It issued

the plenary no-contact order after an adversarial process.

3

The Illinois legislature recently made minor amendments to § 10.

Public Act 100-1000 (2018).

Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454 15

something for us to say that a jury acted unreasonably by

reaching the same conclusion.

B.

It bears emphasis that an employer is not vicariously liable

for the sexual harassment of its employee by a customer.

There must be “a basis for employer liability,” Lapka, 517 F.3d

at 982, and an employer is responsible for its own negligence

if it is “reckless in permitting, or failing to prevent, negligent

or other tortious conduct by persons, whether or not his serv-

ants or agents, upon premises … under his control.” Dunn,

429 F.3d at 691 (quoting the Restatement (2d) of Agency

§ 213(d)); see also Lapka, 517 F.3d at 985 (“Title VII requires

only that the employer take steps reasonably likely to stop the

harassment.”); Frazier, 263 F.3d at 666 (“[A] violation of Title

VII that is based on a claim of harassment by a coworker

doesn’t occur until the employer has failed to take reasonable

steps to bring the harassment to an end.”). Costco’s liability

therefore depends not only on what Thompson did, but also

on how Costco responded. And while Costco did respond to

Suppo’s complaints about Thompson, it does not challenge

the jury’s decision that its response was unreasonably weak.

Because Costco doesn’t press that point, we don’t address it.

Costco’s only challenge is to the jury’s conclusion that

Thompson severely or pervasively harassed Suppo, and as

we have explained, that is a losing argument.

III.

On cross-appeal, the EEOC argues that the district court

erred in denying its motion for backpay covering the period

during which emotional distress rendered Suppo unable to

16 Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454

work—a period that the EEOC defines as running from Sep-

tember of 2011, when Suppo went on unpaid medical leave,

to December of 2014, a little more than two years after Costco

terminated her. The district court’s decision was driven by its

view that backpay is available only to remedy discriminatory

discharge. Suppo could not recover backpay for the time be-

tween September 11, 2011 and November 19, 2012 because she

remained employed by Costco while she was on medical

leave. And she was not constructively discharged on Novem-

ber 19, 2012 because she did not quit: Costco fired her because

she had exhausted the 12-month leave of absence available

under her Employee Agreement, and it could not reasonably

accommodate her request for indefinite leave. 4 Because

Suppo could not show that she was constructively discharged

either when she left for medical leave or when she was termi-

nated, the district court reasoned, she was not entitled to

backpay.

The district court got it right with respect to the EEOC’s

claim for backpay after Costco terminated Suppo. We have

said that “[w]e can make it no plainer than to reiterate that

constructive discharge ‘refers to a situation in which the em-

ployee is not fired but quits.’” Jordan v. City of Gary, 396 F.3d

825, 837 (7th Cir. 2005) (quoting McPherson, 379 F.3d at 440).

4 Costco contacted Suppo on September 20th, notifying her that her

leave of absence had expired and requesting a time to discuss her return

to work. On October 4th, Suppo submitted a form from a physician indi-

cating that she would be unable to work for 1–2 years. On October 10th,

Costco informed Suppo that it interpreted her need for leave as “indefi-

nite,” and that it would proceed with the termination process unless she

provided additional information by October 25th. Suppo did not respond,

and Costco sent her a termination letter on November 19th, explaining

that it could not accommodate indefinite leave.

Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454 17

Suppo did not quit; she was fired because she did not comply

with Costco’s requirement that she return to work. That was

the equivalent of walking off the job, and an employee who

fails to return to work rather than resigning cannot bring a

constructive discharge claim. Id.

The district court misinterpreted our precedent, however,

when it stated that backpay is unavailable to remedy wages

lost during an unpaid leave. The district court reached that

conclusion based on Hertzberg v. SRAM Corp., which holds

that “[a] victim of discrimination [who] leaves his or her em-

ployment as a result of the discrimination must show either

an actual or constructive discharge in order to receive the eq-

uitable remedy of [backpay].” 261 F.3d 651, 659 (7th Cir. 2001).

The district court understood this to mean that any victim of

discrimination must show actual or constructive discharge to

recover backpay. But Hertzberg only addresses what a plaintiff

who “leaves his or her employment” must show—such a plaintiff

must show that her employer made her working conditions

so intolerable that she was forced to quit. Id. at 658. Hertzberg

does not address whether a plaintiff can recover backpay if

she does not leave her employment.

Townsend v. Indiana University answers that question. 995

F.2d 691, 693 (7th Cir. 1993). There, the plaintiff took unpaid

leave after being sexually assaulted at work. Her employer in-

sisted that the she was not entitled to backpay because she

remained an employee. We rejected the proposition that “in-

voluntary termination, whether in the form of outright dis-

charge or of constructive discharge (where the employer

makes life so unbearable for the employee that the latter quits)

is a sine qua non to prevailing under Title VII.” Id. at 693. We

held that the plaintiff could seek backpay for the wages she

18 Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454

lost while on an unpaid leave that sexual harassment had

forced her to take. Id.

The district court treated Hertzberg as superseding Town-

send, because we decided Hertzberg after a 1991 amendment

to Title VII authorized the recovery of compensatory and pu-

nitive damages. See 42 U.S.C. § 1981a(1) (providing that a

plaintiff can recover compensatory and punitive damages in

addition to equitable relief). But Hertzberg emphasizes that the

new remedies provisions “left undisturbed” the previously

available equitable remedies like backpay. Id. at 659. In so do-

ing, it expressly embraces rather than impliedly overrules our

preexisting case law on backpay. 5 Id. (“There is nothing in the

1991 Amendments to suggest that the case law applying those

prior [equitable] remedies is abrogated.” (quoting Mallinson-

Montague v. Pocrnick, 224 F.3d 1224, 1237 (10th Cir. 2000)).

Townsend remains good law.

Thus, the EEOC can recover backpay on Suppo’s behalf if

it can show that Suppo’s work environment was so hostile

that she was “forced to take unpaid leave.” Townsend, 995 F.2d

693. As with constructive discharge, a mere causal link be-

tween the discrimination and the change in employment sta-

tus is insufficient. The victim of the harassment must establish

that her working conditions were so objectively intolerable

that they forced a change in employment status—here, from

regular employment to unpaid leave. If a reasonable person

in Suppo’s shoes would have felt forced by unbearable work-

ing conditions to take an unpaid medical leave in September

5 It

is also worth noting that even though Townsend arose before the

statute was amended, it was decided afterward. Townsend, 995 F.2d at 694.

Yet the opinion contains no suggestion that backpay for unpaid leave was

a one-trip ticket.

Nos. 17-2432 & 17-2454 19

of 2011, then Suppo is entitled to recover backpay for some

period of time following the involuntary leave. 6 That period,

however, cannot extend beyond the date that Costco termi-

nated her employment.

***

The district court properly denied Costco’s motion for

judgment as a matter of law. But because it did not address

whether the sexual harassment that Suppo suffered while at

Costco forced her to take unpaid medical leave, we REMAND

to the district court so that it can decide that question in the

first instance.

Backpay “is a reasonable estimate of the harm suffered as a result of

6

[the adverse employment action],” determined by (1) “measuring the dif-

ference between actual earnings for the period and those which she would

have earned absent the discrimination by [the] defendant” and (2) reduc-

ing that amount if the defendant can show “failure to take reasonable ef-

forts to mitigate her damages.” Horn v. Duke Homes, 755 F.2d 599, 606–08

(7th Cir. 1985).

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.