Opinion

Lee v. Offshore Logistical & Transport, L.L.C.

  • 859 F.3d 353
  • 2017 WL 2507740
Court
Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Filed
Jun 9, 2017
Status
Published
Author
Haynes
On the bench
Costa, Haynes, Reavley
Nature of suit
Private Civil Diversity
Cited by
218 cases
Authority
More cited than 95.0%

holding that the district court erred in dismissing a “report solely because it was not sworn [and] without considering [the appellant’s] argument that” the report’s author “would testify to those opinions at trial”

How later courts described this case

  • holding that the district court erred in dismissing a “report solely because it was not sworn [and] without considering [the appellant’s] argument that” the report’s author “would testify to those opinions at trial”
  • vacating and remanding the district court’s entry of summary judgment because “[t]he district court dismissed [a witness’s] report solely because it was not sworn without considering [the plaintiff’s] argument that [the witness] would testify to those opinions at trial and without determining whether such opinions, as testified to at trial, would be admissible”
  • explaining that Rule 56 “expressly contemplates that affidavits are only one way to support a fact; documents . . . declarations, [and] other materials are also supportive of facts.”
  • holding that a court may consider evidence at the summary judgment stage as long as the substance of the evidence will be admissible at trial—even if its form is currently incorrect

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

Case: 16-31049 Document: 00514027367 Page: 1 Date Filed: 06/09/2017

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

United States Court of Appeals

Fif h Circuit

No. 16-31049 FILED

June 9, 2017

Lyle W. Cayce

ELWOOD LEE, Clerk

Plaintiff – Appellant

v.

OFFSHORE LOGISTICAL AND TRANSPORT, L.L.C.,

Defendant – Appellee

Appeal from the United States District Court

for the Eastern District of Louisiana

Before REAVLEY, HAYNES, and COSTA, Circuit Judges.

HAYNES, Circuit Judge:

Elwood Lee (“Lee”) appeals the summary judgment entered against him

in favor of Offshore Logistical & Transports LLC (“Offshore”) on his Jones Act

and maritime claims for negligence and unseaworthiness arising out of an

alleged injury Lee suffered. As explained below, we VACATE and REMAND

for reconsideration in light of the current Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56.

We give only a brief discussion of the facts, because this appeal turns on

the procedural ruling of the district court. Lee claims that he was employed

by Offshore on its vessel, the M/V BALTY. He states that he fell while walking

on the decks of the vessel. Offshore filed a motion for summary judgment

challenging various aspects of Lee’s proof. Ultimately, the district court

concluded that Lee failed to bring forward evidence that would support a

Case: 16-31049 Document: 00514027367 Page: 2 Date Filed: 06/09/2017

No. 16-31049

finding of causation between Offshore’s acts or omissions and Lee’s injuries.

In so doing, the district court discounted as inadmissible the signed but

unsworn report of Captain James P. Jamison which Lee filed in the record.

The district court did not make a finding that the report could not be placed in

admissible form.

In discounting Captain Jamison’s opinions, the district court relied on a

prior version of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56 and cases thereunder,

specifically old Rule 56(e) regarding affidavits. In 2010, Rule 56 was amended

to clarify and streamline the procedures regarding summary judgment motions

and to make clear the process for supporting assertions of fact and objecting

thereto. See FED. R. CIV. P. 56, advisory committee’s note to 2010 amendment

(“Subdivision (c) is new. It establishes a common procedure for several aspects

of summary-judgment motions . . . .”). Rule 56(c)(1) was amended to state as

follows:

(1) Supporting Factual Positions. A party

asserting that a fact cannot be or is genuinely disputed

must support the assertion by:

(A) citing to particular parts of materials

in the record, including depositions,

documents, electronically stored

information, affidavits or declarations,

stipulations (including those made for

purposes of the motion only), admissions,

interrogatory answers, or other materials

....

FED. R. CIV. P. 56(c)(1)(A).

“Although the substance or content of the evidence submitted to support

or dispute a fact on summary judgment must be admissible . . . , the material

may be presented in a form that would not, in itself, be admissible at trial.” 11

MOORE’S FEDERAL PRACTICE - CIVIL ¶ 56.91 (2017); see also Fraternal Order of

Police, Lodge 1 v. City of Camden, 842 F.3d 231, 238 (3d Cir. 2016) (holding

2

Case: 16-31049 Document: 00514027367 Page: 3 Date Filed: 06/09/2017

No. 16-31049

that a “proponent need only ‘explain the admissible form that is anticipated’”

(quoting FED. R. CIV. P. 56, advisory committee’s note to 2010 amendment));

Humphreys & Partners Architects, L.P. v. Lessard Design, Inc., 790 F.3d 532,

538 (4th Cir. 2015) (recognizing that a “court may consider . . . the content or

substance of otherwise inadmissible materials where the ‘the party submitting

the evidence show[s] that it will be possible to put the information . . . into an

admissible form.’” (alteration in original) (quoting 11 JAMES WM. MOORE ET AL,

MOORE’S FEDERAL PRACTICE – CIVIL ¶ 56.91[2] (3d ed. 2015))); Jones v. UPS

Ground Freight, 683 F.3d 1283, 1293–94 (11th Cir. 2012) (determining that a

district court may consider a statement “if the statement could be reduced to

admissible evidence at trial or reduced to admissible form.” (citation omitted)).

Thus, the rule expressly contemplates that affidavits are only one way

to “support” a fact; “documents . . . declarations, [and] other materials” are also

supportive of facts. FED. R. CIV. P. 56(c)(1)(A). To avoid the use of materials

that lack authenticity or violate other evidentiary rules, the new rule allows a

party to object “that the material cited to support or dispute a fact cannot be

presented in a form that would be admissible as evidence.” FED. R. CIV. P.

56(c)(2); see also advisory committee’s note to 2010 amendment (“The objection

functions much as an objection at trial, adjusted for the pretrial setting. The

burden is on the proponent to show that the material is admissible as

presented or to explain the admissible form that is anticipated.”). The district

court dismissed Captain Jamison’s report solely because it was not sworn

without considering Lee’s argument that Captain Jamison would testify to

those opinions at trial and without determining whether such opinions, as

testified to at trial, would be admissible.

Before the district court, Offshore made other arguments and

contentions about Captain Jamison’s report that were not addressed by that

court. However, no alternate ground for affirmance was briefed before our

3

Case: 16-31049 Document: 00514027367 Page: 4 Date Filed: 06/09/2017

No. 16-31049

court, and, on this record, we decline to rule upon these points in the first

instance. Cf. Hernandez v. Velasquez, 522 F.3d 556, 560 (5th Cir. 2008)

(holding that a court of appeals “may affirm a grant of summary judgment on

any grounds supported by the record and presented to the court below”

(emphasis added)); see also Burleson v. Tex. Dep’t of Criminal Justice, 393 F.3d

577, 583–84 (5th Cir. 2004) (indicating that we court cannot make a certain

evidentiary evaluation for the first time on appeal). We VACATE and

REMAND for consideration of the summary judgment evidence under current

Rule 56 including whether the particular material to which objection is lodged

can or cannot “be presented in a form that would be admissible at trial.”

VACATED and REMANDED.

4

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.