Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1939
Status
Published
On the bench
Gerald Mann
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS

AUSTIN

Honorable L. h. Woods

State SuperintenCtent

Dcpartaent of Education

Austi& Texas

Dear Mr. i?oods~

te whether

or not

e 6F-a fherclbf

eeary to put3 8mB.IfO.

I¶&

eenotmfriol@Mil7#Tex-

dltbelmemledlneueha

5. 8. 60. 117, as stated ln the b&l& ie o mnendment

of Article 2866 of the Revised Citil Statutes of Pexae. The

first paragraph thereof;Seidentiml to Article 2665. The

seoond paragaph~reade'hs follors~

SIn arriving at the f5ount to be ap-

portioned, the Mate Board of RduGstiOn

Hon. L. B. ~p-il

\SC~O(LS, 14, ma90 Page 2

shall &eterdze the cost of operating schools

far a six (6) months period, taking into wn-

sideration the estir;late

of current costs, in-

cluding the cast of general control, instruct-

ion, operation, ncrintenance,fixed charges,

auxiliary agencies, and interest on short term

loans; all itoms to be calculated on a minimum

p~gram of education set up by the State Board.

When such ~portioment per pupil has been fix-

a same &all be certified by the secretary of

the fioard and filed with the Equalization Tax

Board to be used by the Tax Board in fixing the

rate of State ad valorem taxee for eohool pnr-

posesthatrillpreride slliiialent.Sunda to

asintsin the public oehool8 eS %x80 for 8 per-

ked or mot less than sir (6)ronths~

TherboMp~agrephdlWG&sthe StateBaardof Bdnoa-

tion to determine anmall the per aaplta apportlomemt OS

thearallsble sohoolfundrltJmutllmlktiena~ to mouat.

Artidle 1045 Rwked CWil Ststates, llpB6,& smeuded

b7 l@3&

Acts 426 Le@alature, 'Mound oOrle(lSertioo,page 22,

Chspter8% provlde6iinpartr

loie& eaUmlatlng the rate te be ool-

leafed for publio ?ree who01 purpoaee~ maib

Boanl shal1toke into eoneiderotlenthema-

her oi childmu in the state with&a the aohelae~

tlo age, to be deterrained .fremthe m8Bt Pemnt

offlaW aohool eeumq aud rdmllflxa rote

thatr3ll7leldaadprodaoefor smhiisoal

7- sweutef3uaudoue-half (~70ao)Bo~lU~

per eaplk for all the ehlldron tith%n the

oah@laotloage, 68 shorn br 8al.ds8hol8atlo

aemmm protided, therrte soSiredfOr~ea7

7-a Ll lnwer emeed the rate ?$xedb71u,m

Atterney Oenerol Wlllma BoGraw, in a letter OpiniolL

addroswd t&the Iionorahl6 Ben 0. Tlmlnger, President of the

State Board of Jfducatioq,under date Of Ua7 1% 392% bon-

etrued this part ot'Artlole 91.349so ae not to pmhiblt the

State Bosrd of Bduoation from maMng 8 suppleakentd 8ppropria-

tion.rhich would bring the total per mplta apportiollneatfir

the year in exceos of $17.60, *if In the seuud dleeretlon09

the Board the bslance on hand ia the Avalhble Behool2'und

justifies such act3#mm

Without passing upon the construction of the $17.60

prcjvisiouof Article 7043 in this opinion, wc believe that

it Is not repealed by S. li.NO. 117. As ftatod by Judge

Phillips in Cole

-- vs. State, 1m S.\i'.lO30:

gH&pesls by inplication are never favored.

Laws arc enacted with a view to their peman-

i?ncc,and it is to be slrpposedthat a purpose

on the part of the law-mal;ingbody to abrogate

thm nilL bc given uucqulvocal expression.

finotdOedg0

of an existing law relating to the

~a.m subject is likewise attributed to the

Legislature iu the enactment of a subsequent

statute; and when the later act Is 8ileut a8

to the older Xaw, the prennptlon 18 that lt8.

contluuedoporatlonrs8 intended, auleec they

present a eontraaiotlon a0 poeltive that f&e

purpooe to repeal 18 maultest. To arold a

state of. oonfllot an lmplled repeal result8

rhetiethe tro act8 are in 8uch opposition.But

the antagoElisrquat be abcolate * oo p~Waoanoed

that bath asuut -otslt&*

The am10 rdle of 8tatutory oonstm~tion 18 la&d down

In the followlug quotation from the oplnlon 0.fthe Taae ma- -

prePleCourt by Gaines, C. JO la Wddls ~8. Terre& AlO &Ws

*The repefdllng 8imtion of the *ot~l~et

olted la as rolloro$ 'All law ondpartooi

law8 irrUMUllOt with the p~~l8iou8 Of t&l8

Ac3tweherebyr6pdaeaBg. Lawa l906p'lUB

aa IO& It 28 ale* that there $8 us explW0

repeal8 that Is, the prorl8ton lo question 18

not direoIl pointed out-as expre8sly repsited.

But SiNme the &feet Of II, geUerti pmWi8%8n re-

p8d~g'00~llot~ lam ednao8 that the Loglo-

lature hadlnmlndooaothlng that was fobere-

pealed, the ~courts rlll be less inclined

againetreaognircingrepu.gUancy luappljtng

such stfbtutee, rpile, In dealing rlth those ot

the other class, they will, as prlnoiple 8ad

authority requires,be astute to find 8omo

reasonablemode of reoonalling tha with prlS@:’

statutes so as to avoid a repeal by l@loatlon*.

SutherlandBtatr Canst. p.SfW. But wen with

such a provl8ion repe'ialing all confilctlnglate,

flon. L. A. Woods, 4ril 14, lo30, Page 4

the courts uust find a repugnancy between the

old prcvisicn and the new before they can find

that the latter repeals the farmer.* ,

It la our opinion that such repugnancy does not exist

between Article 7043 and Se B. No. 117 which would, under

'the above cited rule of statutory construction, lea& tc the

conclusion that the latter bill repeals by implication the

$17.50 provision of Article 1043. Nor would the +dition

of the clause *All lavs and parts of laws in conflict rith

the provisions of the dot are hereby repealed* to S. B. 117

haVe Buch an effect under the nils amounoed by tbe Tsxas

mpreme-Court In Osddie YE* Terrell, spra. 8.-B*,x0. 317

would h8re to reier specitla8llyto the prwieion intended

Co be repealed in order to effeotuate such a purpoee.

we adt, ~~V~YSP~ th8t 6tmt.0~ alrrfty totadbe

better eemed U, instead of repealing the $17.60 pmrislon

In Artlale 704Rbyasaneof aproVision lnan awmdmsnt t0

Article 26g6 (i.e. S.3.Uo.117) It be.dnne by a dire& amend-

ment of Article 7043 (as by &R~Lla.llS). 8rB.Xoa.417and

Il.8are most properly 00nui4ered as companion birlq deeigrr-

ed together to attain 8 oingle purpoee.

We vodLd like ta mggest 8 Correotfon fat81 Ba 1171

rhatiulsne 31 tbersof, Wqu8llztbtlonTasBowl~be changed

t,aread *AutomafiaTax IWOrrtt*

Ne hope.thot the dote OpiniOn rlll help to elar%fy

the questlone sulmltted in your letter of AprU l%tb.

Yours very truly

ATTORXBX,GpJIEsdt

OF TESA8

UFlN-BR .

APPROVED:

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.