Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1939
Status
Published
On the bench
Gerald Mann
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS

AUSTIN

HcmornbleGsci.E. Sheppsrd

Dear 91x1

PC8rrcaivad your let

opinion ea to ahethar Xouso Bi

“In all oases wbars ring on the tax

rolls, whothor ourrent or dalin-

t a valuation groator

n ruoh 1aoaUty of

IIaggragats,rueha8eunt

tnble or oonrhortar~,

to the Cosadr4lon4rsCourt that suah aswWta6nts weI-6

diaorimlnatory,or out of proportion te the taxable value.

or the property, or that by reason or the 46preaiatienof

value of pame, or that the aniemed QollsotIoaof tb act-

0umkt4a dslirquent tsxeis,panaltie8, intarert,anb

-.

Bon. Gee. Ii.Sheppard, Page E

oosts would be inequitable..rcnnflso4tory, the Co6mzIs8ioners

Court may, undet it# poiers PB a i@rd of'Squalizatlon,

aake such adJus.tnsnta .asto aesesaed values of auoh pro-

perty B it z.eydetemins to be equitable and just. had

4ny prerlous rixing or values of 6uoh pmpsrty r0r the years

involved shall not be *res ndjudioata'es to the partloulnr

oaw.*

1% aewm sore eoomoniant for u4 to firet disouss the

son8titntIona$Ityof the pmvislons of thi6 bill rhloh would perrsIt

ooou3IesIoners courts to raau04 assessed values 0r propertlsr od

which tarea hare becom delinc,uent when It is found that "by reason

of the aepFeeiatlonin the value of such property an adjustment

of assessed ralue would be equitable and expe41entn and when It

appears that "by reason of lonrzdelinquenoy,the aooumulataddelin-

quent tame, with penaltlen, interest, an6 coat-baggregate suoh

amount a6 to snaketheir oolleotioninaqultableand oontlroato~.~

kTt.10143, &JCtiOll55, Constitution of iexnr; aa adopt4d

in liJli, reada as SollorPa~

Vho Leglolatureehdll have no power to releare or

extingulah,or to authorlec.thsreleasing or extinguishing,

In whole or In part, the indabtedneas, 1IibllIt.yor obll-

gatlon or any corporation or In6Ividuel,~tothis ftata

or to any aaunty or defined subdfrlaion thereof, or ether,

oiunlalpalcrorporation thsroia, exoept delinquent taxes

which baroabeen duo for a Perldl of at least ten y6tar8.w

fbodersooring ours)

Prior to lQS3, 44Id ?mhtIoa 65 of Art1010 S did not oontaln

the part which we here above underaonrad. After quoting euoh seo-

tion of the Conatltution as It ~ex%stad prior to the 1QZW karcndPe?nt,

the Cormnission of Appeals in State vs. Plonsar 011 4 El4finlngCo.,

893 5. a. 869, opinion by Judge Slqhals, said:

WC do not atop to consider whether a delinquent

tax lo an *in4ebted3css~ or *sblIgatlon,*within the

meaning of the language quote6, tcr that it Is a

*liability*oannot be doubted. olllrer v. City of

x0utwi, 93 ~4s. 006, 64 8. i\. 940, 94s) city 0r

Itenrlrtta

t. PuetI8, 89 Tex. 14, 86 6. ti..

019."

.

BOO. ho. .x- Sheppard, Page 3

That the above conetitutlonalprovielon iabiblts the

L&elature troz releaeing or sxtlngtiiehing, or authorizingthe

extlnguiehiagof any taxes due the ttate,,or any county or defined

~Ubdivlslon thereof. or other muniolpal corporationtherein,

exeept those ‘*hIohbars been due for at least tsn yeare, Is too

p&in to ednlt of argument. PUShormore the Constitutionmake8

ne mxoeptlon In favor of those who uould stand to profit by the

a0t In Question. :,trlppIng the part of the Gtetute whioh we are

&Ieeuseing d-n 'torhet~,It actually in, it la eimply an atteupt

to plnoe In the band8 of the various oo~.Iealonsre~court8 the

~euthorltyto releaso end extinguishdalinquantStata and oouty

axe4 . It would.bs just that and nothing more, to pemlt a oomule-

eionerst Qourt to reduoe an aeeee6x4ntzade zany years before, the

'fairneeeand legality of which 18 not questioned,on the ground

that ths owner has allowed his tazen t.cgo delinquent for eo long

thet they equal or nearly equal its value, or that the proparty'

had depreciated in value elnce the taxea beoaze-due and ought to

have been paid.

Seotlon 18 of Art~lole8, Constitutionof Texas, roquIre8

the Legislature to "provide for equalizing,as near as may be, the

valuation of all property eubjsot to or rendered for taxation,

(the oounty 00mmisston4r~t oourt to oonetltutea board of-equalize-

tlon); and may also pmvlbe for.the ola88ifIoatIonof eU lend6

with refsrttnoeto their value in the eeverel oountiee.W

Art1010 8, hotloo 10, of the State Coaetltutlon,ray8 that

*The Lcgialaturee,ballhats no power to releaec tho lahabttante

or, or pmperty In, any oounty, city or towns from ths peymeet'oi

texts levied for Etete or county purpose*, unlace finoaee of great

publld oalnsIty In any such oounty, city or town, uhen such releaee

nay be made by a vote of two-third8 Of each House of the Le&ieleture.w

It he8 beon haltlthat the'present industrialdeprhelon

14 not a "great public oalemlty" within the nteanlngof auuh pm-

t1.410n. Jones ve. taillieme,46 S. k. (24) 1.30.

Theee oonetitutlonalprorlelonsw,eremeant to enoourage

the tlncly payusnt of taxes. By Artlole 3, Saotlon 35, an8 Article

8, 24otion 10, a man Se told that jU6t as oertaln,ae the &mtitU-

tlon stands he mast pay his taxee. Be is told T&at hts neighbor'

will not gain anythlna:over hintby 1ettIng hIe tax48 go dollnquent.

Ea Ia told by Article 8, %otIon 18, quoted above, and by Article 8,

beation 1, which say8 that*t+xatIon shall be equal anb uniroza,W

that he and his fellow man are to be treated alike In matter8 oi

BtXl.Gee. I!.Sheppard; Page 6

taxdtion, that neither is entitled to any advantage over the other,

and certainly that none should be eoqulreclby delinquency.

Furthermar?,to reduae an a8mmtment, Khich was legally

and fairly made, giving suah reduotlon of essesamct a retro-

aotive eiisot., rtmlting in a tram*8eesosment being 10cRer~

end the

tax*8 paid by hln thereford proportionatelyloss Mmn.otRe& about

him, and who had ptafdthslr'tareewhen the indebtednearboame due,

wuld be in rlolence to Gotion 5 or krtiole 1, of the Texas Con-

8tltutlon,providing that 'all free mm,--Kh.entl;syion:*a soolel

ocmpaot, have equal rights, and no EU&, or set ot mn, le entitled

to lxolusire separate publio emoluments,~orprivileges,but In b

ooasidorationof publio aervioes." '

T&t part of the statute proriding for mch reduotlon .

of resessaentKhere it 8ppeare that enforoed oolleatlon ot aooruulated

delinquenttaxee, penaltisa, intereat and ooets, Kould be inoqultable

and,oonfleoatory,Is inapplicableto ourront tasea. so far aa thit

part of the statute I8 oonoermd whlah provides that an asseamnt

mey be zeducad where the value of the roperty hao depreciated in '.

~0 ior aI OIWrmnt taXe8 are 00nObNsd Pand this Would be oquelt

applioableto delinquenttmxea), we noed hardly say more than quoto

I-- the oplnlon cf Judge Crltn, In iroranDrfUfng Co. V. Sheppard,

-. ::. (ad) 706, a8 fOlloK8l

When Ke read the rarlous tax pmavlsionsof our

Constitution814@y, and .iathe light of maoh other, re

are oqmfnoed that by aecremary implioation,lf not by

dISeot language, it prohibit8 more than one valuation of

property tar ad ralorom tax purpose8 ?or the same tax

par. In this eo~eotlon~re call attention to the iaot

that the various tar.provialons of our Constitutionuao

the.Kord *valuetlon~in the singular. Also p holding

that more than onr?valuation onn be provided~bylaw for

the bane tax year would bring about Impossiblesituationa

in regard to meny tax mmtters. In this aonneotionko oall

attention to the fact that motion 58 of artlole b, of our

Constltutlbnporaite bonca to bo fsaued by.any county, any

political aubdlrlslonof a oqunty, any number or’adjofn-

lng oountiea, or any polltloal subdltiislon of the state,

or eny definad district now or hereafter to be do8erlbed

and defined aithin the atat? of Toxaa, et%., for oar aia

purpoatee in any axant not to oxoeed one-fourth of t1o

maaeseed valuation of the real property In rruohdie&riot

or territory. it ie clear to ULIthet thie provision

of the Conetitutlcc demnatratea d direot aonatitutio~al

lrzezttnot to alloK mre than one valuation. It undoubt-

edly 4e;olonstrates a oonatltutionallmpllaatio~not to do

800. Coo. Ii.Shoppardr.Pege6

Thie 18 evident for the reason that ii four Value-

::&, are provided bi lew, we are loft w$&out, a ccn-

etltutIoxie1 BAda to,detmzine whloh veluetion should

bs teim Sor bonding purpo8w under thl6 gr0~181~ Ot

our ConetitutIon.*

The provleioneor nouse Bill No. (56, ior a rsduation

ol esseeemata where ft appears that by reeeon‘of depreciationla. v

the value of the property or ths eotoroed oolleotion ot the looumzlnte

dolioquoat texas, pc~ltlee, Interost end aoatS would be lmqultnble

or ocnri6oatory,aro oleerly unconetItuf$onelend void.,

We oome now to the other &oundr protided In the bill for

the reduotlon OS asse8altente.It la provided that 'Where property

. .‘. eppeere to liarsbeen e8edeeed at a valuation greater than that

p&00& upon other property in euoh locality of elmilar value . . .

the amulsslonere~ oourt . . . (upon lpplloetlon)ehall hare power

to reopen and reoeneldertte orIgInal aeeeeementer* It ie then

provided that ii "it shall appear thet such eeaoeement8were dle-

orlainatory . , . the oommlseIonere*oourt my, under its powers,ae

a bwrd OS equellzetlon,mukr, euoh adju8tmentsse to asssseed valuae

of such property as it my deternine to bo equitable end juet.":

without ltteaipting'toeaunolate rules *a tc'uhet property,

the nature end looetlon thereof, lu to be ueod for oo8perIaonIn

doteming whetbar a givompleoe ol proporty'heeboea over-a88eesodj

~0 think the leegue60 above &sod een be ralrly aonetrued to mean

that l oomal8aionera~ court my review a prior eeeee8aent’ ad. reduos

th e 8u ia w& ir e it is Eo u nd that l p a r tio u ler pisoe' o r ’p r o p er ty b a a

been ler etid8d

80 mch higher then.tbe other $ropertleewith uhioh

it should here been kept in line ae to% dlecrriainatory and

threateningto bring about the oolleotlon of en unequal end unoon-

Btltutbnal tax agalnut the 8ae.e.

Zhe bill alLsoprorides tar a mooneIderetlon and adjusts

mont of a prior eseossmentwhen It appear8 that property mr assewed

"out of proportion to the texeble reluo of euah property." ArtIole

8, Geotion 1, of our Con6titutlonrequlreu tihet*all property In this

State, whether owned by neturhl persons or eorporatlonr, other then

munloipel, shell be taxed In proportion to it8 value, whloh ehell be

oeoertained a8 mey be provided by law.*

ArtIoAe 8, Aotion ED, of the Ztete Constitution,adopted

In'l937, provIdo8 that %g,property oi eny kind In thle State shell.

: ever be asseeaed for ad valorem taxes at a greater value then its

frlr caeh market value nor ehell any.board of oquallsetIonof eny

‘i.;1.

e*, .

mm

BOD. Ceo. El.Shappard. Page 6

governmentalor politica) auiidlv~eionOr taxing alstriot rlthln

thla Ltate fix the value at any property for tax purpo8ea at m3re

than it% fair canh %arket.~-vaLue.w Z~en b&ore the aQoptlon of

6Sid Scotlon 80, t3fXrtialo 9, the word "va1ue* as used ln Article

8, Leotlon.1, rneantaash market va+e, *hare property had a market

value. PhiUlpr Petmleun Co. vs. ~OwnS8R6, a, red. (Ed) s!os;

4. k P. Fly.co. Pa. B Paal3,85 s. -. (2d) 245, ~upraaw court. be

construe the term mtaxable value,” as used 10 Senate Bill 456,~to

mean iair each nark,et value. The statute, in quention Xhamfora

would authorize an adjuatientof the aaoe%%%entwhere lt was out oi

proportion to the ossh mrkat valua of the prope~y, that is, where

the aa%eased talus exceeded the market value themof.

Briefly, the bill prepma% to authorize aoml%%loner%*

oourt8 to reviewand adjust (1) previous dlsorimlnetoryover488ese-

wuts, and, (Z) pruvlous aaaesementsin exaeem of eaah eimrketvalue.

Ilt6crlmlmtoryover-a8se66mentana aeseeement in exceee OS value

are both torbidden by the Conatltutlon. The problem6 presented by.

this Act in respot tL:authorizingadju6tmemteor preerlou~Qlaarfm-

hatory assesmanta and asssssatent~

in 0x0088 0r value are eo muah

the oaxw that we will OOBsidOr them to&ether.

&m the opinion 0r Judge Sharp, ln.@tate~'8.Mallet twl

.a& Cattld‘co.,88 %. 5. (24) 471, weq&n aa~iT'oll.cwai

Thq rule hns been repaatediy announcsd that,‘ln

the absanae of fraud or ll.legallty, the aatlon of e

hoard of eguallzatlonupon a partloufar esaessnent lm

final; azul,turthe~more,that such valuation will.not

be eat SOtde memu upon a &!EoWLngt&at the 8am 18 in

reat exaeesire. it the board fairly and honestly a~-

deavors to fix a fair and ju%t vaiuatlon for tax&w

purposes, a nlmtake on its part, under such olroum-

-aL~noaa,is not~subjactto review by,tbs aourta.

Texea & Paolrla By. Co. 'v.City ol 3.1Pee10 (Ter.SUp.)

85 ii.%.(2d) 24s; flowlandv. City of Tyler tTox.,Cox.

rpp.) g s. x. (2d) 786; Druosdow v. Baker (Tax. Cork.

A$;! eE9. a. :*. 4525; Duok v. Peeler, 01 TUX. 268,

fi.llll; Ctaus vxhlaago, R. I. & O.,Ry. Co;'

(Tax. Corn. App.) 265 s. ?I.249; Sundey Lake Iron C3.

v. iiaketlelt., 247 0. 3. SW, s8 s.ct. 495, 62 l.Td.

1154. &mover, the rule hsa been deolared that if a

board of oqu&llzationadopt8 a ziethodthat is iu8ga1,

arbitrary, or fundsmentallywron&, the daolalon of the

board %ay tw attacked and eet aaide.*

mna '30. E. Sheppard, pa@ I

nther cases use the lane.uc@ethct "a% a &ymerci rule*

the deofclon of a board of equcliaatlon upon a pcrtloular acaocc&ent,

.icthe ebaanoe of fraud-or irregularity,is oonoluclve.* Port

Arthur Ind. Ahl. Diet. ~6. Eaumer, 64 S. 8. (Zd) 412; Nederlan&Ind.

S&i Diet. v%. Carter, 9s S. $8.(kd) OS& Xhen 80 used the wor&a

*final" and "oocolucIva~nxvn the cama thing. The relue of the

property as fired by the board o? equallcatlon la ret adjudlaatc,

aubjeot only to bein set acids for fraud or t.he.adoptlonor a

~ndacmntally wrong &hod o? aceeament.

kultc olearly, therefore, all e8ae8amaasnta

heretofore

-de, and whloh cre not aubjeot to being aet aside for trcud or

lrrsguhrlty, are final (md aonoluaIYe. fn all suoh Inatanooa It

has been detcrmlned that the a8aeccmcntewere aelthar dlcarlmInatory

nor exosssl+e,and cucb 6eternlnctlonc'areri836iana oonolu8~+s.

The right of the state to the,amotmt oi its tcxaa.aa baaeQ Upon

iwoh vcluatIons has vestad.

Article 1,'Scotlon 16, of tho Terse Conrrtltutlan,guarantees

us that "no . . . retroaatlve law . . . ehaU be emUa.* This pro-

vision la aonetruab to forbid the enactment of a law, cv),na remedial

one, whloh blcturbs or IrnpcLrc~rected rights. 39 fox. J\rr. 65;

9 Tez. Jurc--527, 8SSi. It la aur opInIon that the above aonetltutlona

prorlclon,as well as Article 8, Section 55, would-prohibita aoa-

cIaaIoner8*oourt, uador the authorltl of said S. B. 466, from shter-

talnlngappllcatloncto reduce ccaessmenta whloh had bean coda atid

beocmerlnal before the eiieatlve data of the Act.

A&Itc the power or the Lsglalature to authorhe oocmlc-

iloners*‘courts In t&e future to review an& a djwtlaaeaamontacm&e

after the etfeotlve date of the kot, different quoattona am pro-

rented. Se cannot remrd the OorrOOtiOn Gf cn l8848SSmQt, 80 a8 t0

mlievs a X&B of a burdeq plaaed apo~ bia contrary to the Conatitu-

'tlou,8% beine a Coccna accecmcent, cwh as Judge Crltr ~8 talking

about fn kowan Drllllcg Co. va. Sheppard, cupra. AC8e88mEnt8 CoMOt

be reduded tc;such e mcthe~etloaloertelnty that one-fourth of the

Esaee8ed valuetlon c&n be irrevocably oelculatsb to the penny* Dlctrl

Oourte,pultefrequently entertain suits which have the etteot of -due

ing exoncaivcvaluetlonc. 40 ‘Per. Jur. l.ST-17E. AC already notti, th

oourta are made boards of equcllutlon by tie

OasnalsaIonere*~

Constitution. Nothlm would prevent the Leglalaturb~c Inventing

cuch boards Of equalleation with powor to review their am flndlngc,

if cuoh power of review lc kept wlthln due bounds. The bill in

questionprovlde8 that *s previous ilxlng of values of snob

Proparty ror the para involved shall not be *ret adjudleata* as to

the parCiau3.mease." Cur conclderatlonwill.now be dlreoted to

the erfect of talc prorlclon, whlah would deprlve the vcluatIona

lade by the boards of equallzatlonor any finality whatsoever.

ear..Leo. Ii.Lhappard.Pare 8

Artlcie 8, .footicn13, of th e Constitution,a.8it existed

before 193&?,comcnced "provisionaheii be made by the first Legis-

letire ror the speedy 018 of a muftIClemtportion of all iand

.a& izhar property for the taxes due theraon, and 4~417 year thare-

after ior the sale of nll land6 and other property, upon rhloh the

tares have not beau paid." Aa,edopted in 1939, eeid krtlole 8,

&cation 13, says *~rcvIslonsheii be mada by the rlret Le@el+trcl

sor ttc speedy cola, vIthout the ni,aesaltyof a suit in aourt, of a

6u:ricI4zt portion 0r all iond8 and other property r0r tts tax68

6~4 ttareori,end 4~4 year therearterSor the sale In iIka manner

of ali ianda end +0 er property upon which the taxes bsv4 not been

paid."

AS already touched upon, r;rtlala3, Saatlon a!r provide8

that "any county (etc.) . . . my issue bonds or otherwise lend lta

aradlt in any amount not to sxoeed one-fourth of the asaeeaed valua-

tion 0: the real property of eucn district or territory,axoepwt

thstot.61 . . . shall never excaed . . .*

Artloie 8, Laotlon 16, of tba ConetitutIon,sayr thatl

“the 6~~1uaiassesarseot made upon iamled property shell be a apealal

llan QZiGA?

_ Se. have already

. observed

. _- that Artlola

-. . . 8, Sctlon 18, make8

the- aojP1ssronera~ coum a noarg.or equaiiaatioa:

X4 think it clear from the abova quoted provlslon8ot our

Constitution that it was aontamplatadthat thera should ba an aaseas-

ment ublch abouid become of such daflnlte aharaater end flnallty

8OWtimZ during the year am would swtein an eotlon to aOl.leCt t8xea

baaed theraoni It thi4 prOTi8iOA should be ralld, +!nrmr, an 68646S-

wnt aould ncvar be final, values for taxing purpoesr could nstar be

quieted. .Therela co ilmlt to tte tlma wltbln whlob a?pilO8tlonS.

Sor adjustments P;aybe filed, nor is there any limit to the number

of tIim8 the board of aquaiiaatlono@uid be called upon to pa86 upon

th&value to be fixed upon a plea4 of land. A county attorney fll-

Ing suit for t6x46 baeed on a peirtiOui6r eaaesemont might find on

trial day that it had been eet ‘asideSnd rs*i8ed, or be might meat

a plea in abatement on the ground that an appiiaatlon to reduce the

Vaiuation Is pending before tha oomudseIon8r8~ Court. To-ail

intents arid9urpo8e8~, we nould have no board of equaiization. A '

board of equellzetlonoen no nora be a board of equalizationwith

it8 fln6Ings having no flnaiity and being rem ad&dloata of nothlng,

than could a.court be a court end i-tsjudgment.8 dstsrmlne nothing.

Zhe prorielon bP the statute l&at "auy previous iWIng

Of vaiuas of much proparty ror t:,s y46rs ir~~olvcul shall not be r88

adJw$icata 4s to tt* particular ~ea4~ contravenesthe above 64a-

*ione ot.Our Constitutionand 1s void. Furthertore, it Is Lo

~ntarwOTeA xith Other peti4 of the atstute a8 ti be IAefirIoabi4.

%ako out the void part8 of thlo statut4 and nothin@ workable re-

main*. It rOlhW5 thet.thQ i-at 86 6 WhCif$ IS ~OOngtitutiOnai pnd

void.

Yours very truly

BY L&c

Glsnn E. Lade

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.