Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1939
Status
Published
On the bench
Gerald Mann
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

State Board of Control

Austin, Texas

Gentlemen:

Opinion No. O-1033

Re: Authority of State Board of Control

to award contracts for various types

of printing or binding to Texas Prison

System.

By your letter of June 23, 1939, you advise that the Board of

Control in accordance with the provisions of Section 21, Article 16, of

our Constitution, and of Article 608 et seq. of the Revised Civil Statutes

of 1925, advertised for bids for printing, binding, and stationery supplies;

that among the bids received was one from the Texas Prison System, the

bid being signed “Texas Prison System by 0. JS. Ellingson. General Man-

ager,- and the bid being accompanied by a bond made by the Texas Prison

System, by O.J.S. Ellingson, General Manager. as Principal, with two

sureties certified to be good and sufficient, etc., by the County Clerk of

Walker County.

You asked the opinion of this Department upon the question

whether, under these circumstances, the State Board of Control can le-

gally award a contract for various types of printing or binding to the Texas

Prison System on its low bid under the provisions of Section 21. Article 16

of the Constitution, and under the laws of the State of Texas.

Section 21 of Article 16 of the Constitution reads as follows:

“All stationery, and printing, except proclamations

and such printing as may be done at the Deaf and Dumb Asy-

lum, paper, and fuel used in the Legislative and other depart-

ments of the government, except the Judicial Department,

shall be furnished and the printing and binding of the laws,

journals, and department reports, and all other printing and

binding and the repairing and furnishing the halls and rooms

used for the meetings of the Legislature and its committees,

shall be performed under contract, to be given to the lowest

responsible bidder, below such maximum price, and under such

State Board of Control, page 2

regulations, as shall be prescribed by law. No member

or officer of any department of the government shall be

in any way interested in such contracts; and all such con-

tracts shall be subject to the approval of the Governor,

Secretary of State and Comptroller.”

Article 608, Revised Civil Statutes, 1925, reads in part as

follows:

“The Board shall contract for a term of not exceed-

ing two years with responsible persons, firms, corpora-

tions, or associations of persons, who shall be residents

of Texas, for supplying to the state all printing . . . ”

Article 613, R.C.S. 1925, provides that all bids or propo-

s.als shall be accompanied by a bond or certified check; and by the pro-

visions of Article 614 it is required that when any bid shall have been

accepted, the Board shall require of the successful bidder a bond payable

to the State of Texas, conditioned for the faithful performance of the con-

tract.

The only exception from the constitutional provision requir~ing

competitive bidding on stationery. printing, and binding, is contained in

that portion of Section 21 of Article $6 which reads:

Y.,. l except proclamations and such printing as

may be done at the Deaf and Dumb Asylum, . . . *

By virtue of the provisions of the Constitution and of the laws

of the State of Texas, contracts for all stationery and printing, except

such printing as may be done at the Deaf and Dumb Asylum, must be let

to the lowest responsible bidder after having been submitted to competi-

tive bidding. The same is true of contracts for binding.

.We find no constitutional or statutory authorization to the

State Prison-System to bid on contracts for printing and binding to he let

by the State Board of Control for the use and benefit of the State. More es-

pecially do we note the entire absence of authority, express or implied, to

give on behalf of the Texas Prison System the character of bond tendered

in this case and required by the provisions of the Article regarding public

printing above referred to.

It follows that, since the Texas Prison System if without authori-

* State Board of Control, page 3.

ty. express or implied, to execute such a bond as is required by the stat-

ute, the Board of Control is without authority under existing laws to award

a contract for various types of printing or binding to said Prison System on

its low bid.

It must be noted in passing that the constitutional provision above

referred to requires the contract to be let to “the lowest responsible bidder.”

This, of course, implies and requires competitive bidding; but, more than

that, it requires that such bidding be by ‘responsible* bidders. We take the

term ‘responsible bidder” to mean such a bidder as the State might hold re-

sponsible in damages in event of such bidder’s failure to fulfill his contract

according to its terms. If a contract should be entered into with the Texas

Prison System, and the Texas Prison System should fail to comply with the

terms thereof, causing the State to suffer damages, we would be confronted

with the peculiar and anomalous situation of the State seeking to recover

damages of itself for a failure to perform a contract made and entered into

with itself.

An opinion * similar in most respects to this one was rendered

,on March 24, 1931, by the Honorable James V. Allred. Attorney General of

Texas, to the Honorable Claude D. Teer, Chairman of the Board of Control,

Austin, Texas, and a copy of such opinion is attached hereto for your infor-

mation.

Yours very truly,

ATTORNEYGENERALOF TEXAS

BY s/ R. W. Fairchild

R. W. Fairchild

Assistant

R WF:PBP:da

Enc. Approved Jul 5, 1939 APPROVED OPINION COMMITTEE

BY R. W.F.

/s/ W. F. Moore Chairman

FIRST ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL

* V. 319, P. 918

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.