Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1940
Status
Published
On the bench
Gerald Mann
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS

AUSTIN

Honorable George 3. Sheppml

iIokpttoll6r of Publio Aooounts

AUElt.LrI,

Texas

Dear Sii:

Ill YOW 16tt6r 40, you advim thqt in

1934 a oertain taxpayer r perty at .lts actual

market value, which rend1 duoed by the Board of

Equallzatimi. Eovwrer, as el-',iesIn the county

for the am year es w6xx-1lntantlon3Uy

tixqd at only for alue by the atard of

Equalization. Y s to whether or not

tho Cocmission mcy now deolare such

aFJsesomalt voi to ba mossessod for

the year in qu

lsad Civil Statutss, in ren-

Yalu.3tion Lbercto ," etc.

Khl.lo it is untioubtodly ooniezplsted that property

shall be ofxossed and taxed u.gon its fail cash mar&t value

ht. 8, see. 20, and Art, 8, Sec. 1, State Const., at-a!

Art.

7164, ii.C.3.)‘ iS aust bo borne in tinti that Artiole 6, Section

Eionorable George Ii. Sheppard, Page 2

the Constitiction of Texas, also requires that Taxation

;L”L be equal and UniforsP, and provides that nisl..l.

property

. . l

&all be taxed fp groportion to its value".

Xn Lively vs. N. K. and T. ~?ai.luayCoznw, 120 S.S.

222, by the Supreme Court, ths intang5.bl.oassets of a railroad

wera assassed at full value, vheruas 'tie property or individ~uels

was assessed at only two thirds of its real value, in accordance

vith a deliberately adopted policy. In answer to certified

questions, the Supren3 Court held that the trial court had cor-

rectly granted an injunction against the collection of taxes

on nor% than two thiz-ds of the value of such intangible assets.

After observing _that v;hile other property was deliberately

assessed at oaly 66 2/3 per cent of itsreal Value, the lntangi-

ble assets of ths appellee were assessed at 100 per cent, the

court said:

*. . . It Is evident that this was a deliberate

soheme 69 the part or the officersor Eallas oounty by

nirich the assessmnt was tide at the pro?ortioh of

its value stated, end there is nothins An ths case to

IJdtiuate that there was any tietake on the part or

the offioers. It was the delibera:elp adopted policy

to so discrizlnate betwee the 6ifferaEt olasses of

property in the as6essc;ent for taxation. It is not

necessary that the officers fin so disorimlnating

should have intendeds~ecificslly to injure the ap-

pellee or Ether railroad co4~mi8s. It is sufficient

that by their action they Ce::iad the appellee the

equal proteotion of the Constitution and lam of the

state. The intention vith vhich the acts were done

is of no oax3eq2ep3e. Suoh,deliberate action on the

part of officers charged vith the ezforcezent of the

la-amst be Bald. to ba the aot of the state, and she C

appellcc me. aztitledto relief a:;sinst t:ie.eaforce-

ment of the exce3sive assensmnt, , .

*Counsel for the ap~:ellants objeot ~to the re-

&Jction of th6 vslus of app311ee13 gropcrty as

assessed by tbc stsse board beca~oe t&at. ,a3sessznt

was mdo in cmfmzzity to the Gm3tituticg -gmC !.av3

of the stat6 2inti ms tkrefore valid. I< is clairied

that it is not pertissiblo to overturn this valid

assess~mt anti to bc.ne the juQ,mnt of the court up-

on that v:;S:ch~3 &ado contrary to the 1~:~s and Con-

stitution. Thst is it p1nusibl.a >m?osition, and

w~3uld ba u2plicablc if the object of t.lis prooai?ding

721

Boaarable i38orge H. Shsppsrd, Page 3

were to enroroe the ri.zhts or the appqlee to a rair

valuation of its property. But, aa statted bePore in

this opinion, the wow +Ai.iohwas'inflicte% upon the

appellee was noi,in re.qtiring it tcr pay.twe5 upon

t&e fullvalue 0r its proparty, but in denying to it

the equality oi taxaticn se~u.ied,by the Constitution,

which e+ality of s+-tioa necessarily depmds'upon

uniforzity 0r asssssmnt. . .=

Ordinarily the action of a board of equallzaticn upon

a particular piece of'propertp is final, and a valilation will

not b8 Set at3iES l?i8ZCu U?OE ShOVJinath.tlt it iS~8XO8SSiv8.

BOWeaW , eilch eO8S not ho16 trU8 uhan such exoessi~e valuatitiaa

is shown to result fron fraud on the part- of the board of equal-

izatic?n,.or iron ah arbitrary or fuadamntolly wohg n&hod of,

SSS8SSU8nt. Liv.alg vs. Fly, supra; Stats vs. Mallet Iand am5

Cattlc Co., .SD 3,i;;i(2) 4711 aowland vs. Cfty of~Tyler, 5 S.::.

(2) 756; T. d; Fe By. CO. vii, xi hS0, a5 se%; (2) 245; &?8d8C

(&) e.7;. X!r;eaC~w

land Ind. School Dist. vs. Carter, 93 S~.k'..

VS. i%8r, is29 %%i, 493.

'Zn the ease d&h &I.% sub&i t3 us, the taxpayer ?cas

oonplying with the statute in rendering his 3rogerty. Ee sha;lld

not be discouraged Crmi dshg t!mi. In &dVbg the totuFtlVitLU8

andzaking oath to it he sas oniy swasriag to the truth. ii8

should not be penalized for that. 1Z8 WnS 8ntitlGd to b31ieV8

that all. property would be assesseti at its, true valua, or ir

otLer progmty vias to be daliberately swsssed at only a frao-

tional part of’ its value tht his asssssma@i wml.~ bG reduced

as p,rcvvidGdih titicle 72l.2. Xhothsr the iailuro to ditiinish

tha valuation on his progorty ras intcntfonti or accidental, the

8ri'&Ct i3 th8 9338. Proportionally he is paying EO:D than tiiioe

tha tax piti by thoso about bin. This violates Section 1 of hr-

tic18 G of t&8 Sate Constitution requir9.n~;that tcration be

epuai emi uniform. In oil,” opinion tho aotior? oz? the Eoard of

Quallwtion was void as to this uan's aseassmnt. ti I;rusnCow

vs. &&er, supra, the Suprema Court said:

The decisions of the (State) Tax &arc! in

thG imttcr of valuations are c_uasi judicial iu

their nature. This notion (to enjoti collecti

of tax ,is th8Tefore & collateral attack u>oa the

jucgmnt or a ;ua~si judicial ixibunaf. Such an

attack cmatt bc Jus;tificd in the nbsenoc of fraud,

f Eonorable George B. Sheppard, Page 4

or something equfvalent thereto; lack of jurisdfo-

tioo; ah obvious violation of the law, or the ado?;.

tion of a funmentally wrong principle or nethod,

the application of uhich substactially injures cost-',

p1abult.=

The comnissioners* court sitting as a board of equal-

ization is acting in a slm.Uar casoity to that or the state

Tax Board, end if the decision of the one is quasi judicial in

nature 50 is that of the other. See C. C. &S. F. 83. Co. vs.

atate, 9 5. 3. (2), 1051, at p. 1052, so indicating. Our

courts ,have frequently granted lnjunctioas to prevent the ool-

lection of axoessive taxes,where such exoessivesess is a

result of the adoption of a fundmentally wrong nethod of

assessmnt or of fraud or other arbitrary action on tha part

&the board of equalization. This oan only Eean that assess-

ments whioh are excessive by reason of such situations are.

VOld.

fn our opi.nion, the 1954 aesessmmt described above

vzasvoid end reassessment xzay be had as provided in Chapter 11,

Title 122, Revised Civil Statutes.

Bearlag an the question we %ould also cite the cases

of State vs. Houser, L37 S.‘J;.(2) 800, French Independent

School Dist, vs Bowth, 134 9.3. (2):1036, and C&I& S.F. By.

Co. vs. state, 9 S.U. (2) 1051. ~'.

B3b4L:

Glen B, Lewis

Assistant

/ATTORNEY GEIUSRAL OF 'i-s?.\:::

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.