Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1940
Status
Published
On the bench
Gerald Mann
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Y

OFFICE OFTHE ATTORNEY GENERAL OFTEXAS

AUSTIN

Honorable Zelter Murahim

County Attorney

Heakell County

Harkell, Teus

Dear Sir:

whlah reedr in part a

to my roqueat

eonneotion I

toe0 Of a Rural High

Weinert Rural High

igh Sohool l;tatrlot,frol~

Dlstriot to Yeinert to euP-

ng faoilftier rm available

liehing the Pleasant View Com-

at by election or otherwise?

Y?he further questian then ari8ee in the

preeent wme whsthsr said Board of Trusteee a?

the \VeineXtRural High Sahool District have the

authority upon renorel of said building or Prior

thsfeto, it they have the power to remove in the

Hon. Walter Murohleon, Page 2

flret place wlthout abolition or cOnsolid?tlon

Of the elementary diatrist, to tear down said

elem4ntary school building end use the materiala

Or t0 attach it as an integral part to another

bulldlng or bulldlnge?"

In OUT CplnlOn NO. 0-2493 we ruled that undv the

provision8 of Article 2922f, Revlaed Civil Statut48, 19215,

an elementmy school dlstriot wl thin e rurel hi& school

district may be diaoontlnued by the rurel hi@ s0hoOl dl&i-

triOt trU&8ee and consolldatsd with EXXJ~&Q? di&trict athin

the rural hi& eohool district for elemntary purposes with-

out tha neo4aaity of holding;an elrctfon v&en the eohool

within the elementary district falls to hat4 an average dally

ettendan04 the preceding year of at least EO pupils. We

further ruled that after auoh dlacontlnuanc4 by the local

board and consolidation of th4 district with another by ths

county eohool board it would bs wlthln the authority grants6

the local bcerd of truetaas to remove the build1 in th4

el4a4ntary dlstriot to aupplem4nt the housing fao "plitler at

the dlrtrlct ae consolidated. In view of dlrrioultier which

might aria4 upon the complete dlrsolutlon of the rural hl$h

school dlatrlot, we s~gcsted, ea a matter of pr404utlon,

the rural high sohool board should make some provlslon to

protect and preserve any property rl&ta which th4 origina

slementary diatriot might have.

It hea been eug&eated thet the board of tN6t406

of a rural high sohool district has the authority to do the

acts get out in the additional queatlans, based Upon an

inferen drawn from ths court's qualltlo4tlon ln Chastaln

v. Maul&in (T. C. A. 193O) 32 3. ?V. (ad) 235, quoted in

mrO~$ion No. 0-2483. The.lfmguage referred to read8 as

"The point 1s made in appsllees brief t&t the

bulldlng l~eybe returned or a new on4 Qr4Ot4d When-

eves the necessity ariaee. The trusteea of the

groupea dietriot hav4 ths manageement4nd control

of the building in question, and we do Ilothold

that they 4r4 without atuthor$tyunder proP4r 4af4-

guards for its return or r4plaoezu4ntto reBove it

temporarily to the Groavenor dietriot. That quw4-

tlon, however, la not prorented by ths pleadinga

or proof befOr uao The 0684 es mado by the rrcord

:r

Ron. Welter Marohlaon, Pago 8

preaente on17 the question or the power or th4

Groammr tN8tOO8 to convert the 80hool building

Of the Panther Creek d1m.w (Underaoorlng oura)

In the Ch4atain Case the oourt wea careful to point

Out ?&fit80 10% 88 the TariOwa dementsry dlatriota within

the grouped rural high achool dirtriot malntelned their

a8P~ratO IbRtity, the property en4 funds of the various

diatrlota should be maintained and not diverted from on4

dlatrlot to Mother or to the grouped district, Tb+ OoOt

dlreotly held:

"Th4 trustee8 of the group46 distriot

were l.nveat4dwith tbs pomr and cherged

with the duty of canduoting aohools and of

admlnIstarlng all 80hool roperty end fund8

Of all the Uiatrlot8 with 'p

n the bound8riea of the

conaolldatad diatriota. But they did not have

tha right to divert property aa funds or one

~dlatrictGo another, or to the grouped dietriot.

This la oleerlg the holding in the KoPheil 4eae.

It ra0w8 th4t they did not h4va tb4 power t0

remove the aohool bulldfng of the P4nth.r Creek

diatrlot to the Groavamr blatriot, a8 that

would have b44n a dlv4rsion or the proparty

from it8 proper purpom and objeot. The only

wn8Olid8tlOn arraoted by the grouping was

thet of the fund8 031laoted fran taxation ior

gen4ral m4lnt4lnanoa. The ownerehlp of auoh

4ohool buildings of the several diatriota

rsmain4e the property of thoae dlstrlota end

00uie not b4 eiv48t4e or lmpairee by the

trusteea or ths grouped district. Viebelieve

ana 80 hole that in attempting to rermrveth4

school bullding the trustees wore about to

perform a wholly umuthcrieeh eat."

The tN&bae of B rurel hi${haohocl diatriot, it la

true have control and manegaarontof the 84hool8 4nd building8

in t& various eiatrlcta making UP the gmup, aad umm tb&

general pomp*, the court reoogniseh that olroumat~noa~ W+t

arlee wherein itnould be within their pOwOr t0 “temPOrar1~Y”

remov4 8 building or other .prOpOrty from an 4Xi8tiW elm-

tary dietriot. However, to extend the inf4r4noe drawn iron

this dictum 80 as to author144 th4 b06re to do th4t *id I4

augge8ted by the 4ddltloral quwtions Would be ‘practical~ly to

nullify th direct holding Of the court.

Hon. Wiltrr ASurchiron,?age 1

We here %xamined the r%oords b%rore the oourt in

that 088% ~4 the t%Cte now b%iora ue %re practiaelly the

sama a8 those whloh the omrt oharectorize4 am 8 oonrsrelon

of'the %ohool building of the Panther Cr%ek district.

with the bame ~%liflo%tlOn% reoognized by the

oouvt in Chmstaln v. tiauldln,aupr% each of the foregoing

questlone are anawered in the negatlrr.

You-6 rory truly

ATTORHK!fOENERAL OF TEXAS

ccc:rw

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.