Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1941
Status
Published
On the bench
Gerald Mann
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

GERALDC. MANN

HonorableTom 8-y

countyAttornq

Potter county

Amcwillo,Texas

Dear Sir: Opioion Ho. O-3003

Be: Validityof oomtnot between

Potter Countyud George 0. Ehmnborg

capmy, appraia81engiawra.

IIIyour letter of Deoem~r 21, 1940, you requortw opinionls to

whether a certain oontraotmade betweenGeorge 0. EhrenborgCompany,as firs%

party, and the City of Amarillo,the Board of Truatteeaof hurillo Indepemd-

eat S&o01 Didriot, and the Commtasioners' Court of Pottsr~Cowty, TOXAS, as

secondparties,made on Oc'bbm 8, 1940, in a valid and Madiag obligation

88 between Ehrenlmrg and Pottem Camty.

The obligatiomundmrdatha cofiraotrelate to all of the territory

embracedin the boundariesof Lnrillo IadpenemdsptSchoolDistrictin

Potter Couatp and in your letteryou advisethat about 9f$ of the ad valexw~~

taxes oollsotedin Potter Cou#ty co111011

froaathe affechedares. Im the agree-

ment, among other things,first partJris requiredto prepareseotionalmaps,

to f’unish the servicesof expertsin build- tiuatiom methodswho will

msasum aad descritibuildimgsaad improvements upon lots a8d par0018 ia the

territoryinvolved,applyingfaotorsof valuationand deproaiatlonfor eaoh,

based upon the fair market oost of new reporduot%om,rithspeoifiodeprecia-

tion, if any, axpresrredi# oae psroemtagathe oomsidentioa of meohanioal

deterioration, obsolesoenoe, age amd lack of utility,and to tabluateimform-

atlox and data for eaoh building. First party is alao required to furnish

the aervioesof expertsin the valuationof personalpropertyand ',

equipwnt oonnronly used for publicutilitiesand imdistrialplants,and to

make appr&al of all suoh propartgaad equipnemt.

Reoordsof such work are 40 bo made availableto the county amd

first party agreesthat ito erpert;awill furnishinstruotiontothe tax

assessorin the presentusesof the methoda of wluatioaamd oomputationSO

that the systQa installedmay bs continuedaad kept up-to-datein the

future.

paragraph 2 of said ocmtraotreads as follorsr

HonorableTom Seay, page 2 (O-3005)

"The party of the first part agreesto furnishthe serrioesof expert;s in

land valuationmethodsarhotill, with the help of a local board, furnished

at no cost to party of the first part by the partiesof th* seoondprt,

ascertainthe valuationsof eaoh singlestreetto the lots and parcelsof

land frontingthereon. This havingbeen done,the expertswill computethe

valuationof all lots and parcelsaoauratelyand proportionately and truly

aooordingto such unit foot valuations,smd take in consideration depreoi-

ation for bad looation,oreeks,overflow,etc. This surreynot to cover

farm lands."

For suoh servioesthe three partiesof the seoondpart agree to pay

first party the sum of #9,500.00in installments. It is unneoessaryfor us

to set out the contentsof the oonttaotin any more detail than above,singe

-a believethat the quotedprovisionof the contraotrendersit invalid.

There is no oontrcllingdifferencebetweensaid paragraph2 of the

contractin questionand paragraph4 of the oonfraotinvolvedin the case of

Marquartv. Harris County,117 5.W. (2d) 494, by the QelvestonCourt of Civil

hppeals. Frcanthe opinionof the court in that 0880 we quote as follows:

"Wxilethe ConnuissionerslCourt may validlyemploy 'skilledexperts*to value

for taxationpurposesproper* in speoialinstanoes,whereteohniaalequip-

ment is required,sinoethis contra& - by its expressterms-embracesa

valuationof the entire taxablepropertyof Harris ounty,as reflectedby its

tax reoords,it necessarilysupersedesthe pornrers,1utiae,and functionsof

the tax assessorand colleotor,and since those dutiesare devolvedby law

upon him, such an attemptedemployment'bythat body of other personsto, in

the first instance,performsuch duties ;--toad,is an expenditureof publio

funds for an unauthorizedpurpose. . . .

"No extendeddiscussionwillbe indulgedin under this last-statedground.

Sufficeit to say that such am apparentundertaldngof a oommisaionsrsl court

to itself initiallyrevaluethe entiretaxable propertyof a oounty,under

the guise of using the same for its own informationand guidancewhoa sitting

as a Board of Equalizgtion, does not seeanto this oourt to squarewith the

talamcedsystem of relativepourers and duties oonferredupon that body by

our laws, as -parable to the correlativeone8 oonferredupon the OOU~ tax

assessor-oollsotor; . . .

"The authorities oited under ground (5) supra seem to make it quite clear

t&t this oontraotdid evidencean undertakingto in effectusurp the Offi-

cial privilegesand obligationsof the tax assessor-oolleotor, as vouohsafed

inthe statutesthere collated,while uponthe other hand, the differingand

oorrelativaduties of the oonwLssioaers* OOUI% -- *s a Board of Equalieatiom--

are mbraoed within R.S., Articles7206, 7211 and 7212. Bdertbem it would

seen never to have been oontsmplatedthat the Board of Equaliza~:iom should

a& upon whimg otherthan the assessmentsfirst renderedto them %the

tax assessor-collaotor, amd not initiallyupon their ORB motion. . . l"

c -c

-

HonorableTom Seay, page 3 (O-3005)

The fact that the instantcontractis oonfinedto the territory

embracedin the &arillo IndependentSchool Distriotand that farm lands are

excludedfrom its operationmakes no differencein principle.

Inths case of Roper v. Hall, 290 S&f. 289, the Waoo Court of

CivilAppeals sustaineda oontraot made by FreestoneCountyiaith Thomas Y.

Pickottfor the oolleotionand assemblyof informationoonoerningoil r~r~p-ar-

ties and the fMng of values thereo% However,it was pointedout 8s the

basis for that holdingthat those servioesinvolvedan exbraordinaryskill

not possessedby the ordinarytax assessor. The pewor of the county oonnnission-

ers* Courts to make oontraots of the charaoterinvolvedin Ro r v. Rail was

reoognisedin the ldarquart case. But, in our opinionthe serv

-redoe8 req in

paragraph2 of the oontiraot in questionare not of the type dealt with in the

Ro r aa8e. At least as muoh skill and speoialknowledgeis requiredin attaoh-

ng valuationsto farm lands as in valuing a large part of bity properties. To

P-

hold that the servioesprovidedfor in said paragraph2 are expert services

which can be oontraotedfor by a conmissioners* courtwould be to wipe auf the

distinotionrecognizedin Roper v. Hall, and expresslydrawn and followedin

Marquartv. Harris County.

The provisionsof the quoted paragraphof the oontraotforms P

major part of the oomsiderationof the agreement,aad so iaaeparablybound to

other provisionsthereof,that the entire contra& mu& fall regardlessof the

validityof any suoh other parts. MarquartV. &rris County,supra. Hence,

we rest our opinionat this point and answer your puestionfn the negative.

Yoursver~rtruly

ATTORNEYGEXBAL OF 'TEXAS

APPROVED JAN 23, 1941 By /s/Glenn I?.L&i8

/t747mv;;uvper8

Glann R. Lewis

AlTORNEYffENERAL Assistmzt

GRL:EP:62gil APPROVBD

opinionConmlihtee

By xw B

Chairman

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.