Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1941
Status
Published
On the bench
Gerald Mann
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

OFFICE OF TNE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ‘I’-

Qourot%llucn AUBnN

A7ummwmmtau

Honorable George H. Shepgard

Comptroller o? Pub110 Aooountr

Austin, Texas

Dear Slrr

OpInIon No. O-3830

Re: Transier 0r funds In Old Age

AssIOtanoe FmdZ-

We are in reoelpt or your recent opinion request

relative to ,the txnsrer of certain funds irc;n the State’ Old

Age Aaslstanoe Fund to the Federal Old Age Assistsnae Fund,

rshlch the State Department of Fublic Welfare has requested

you to nake.

There are berore us twc letters from the Depart-

ment oi Publio Welfare, one dated July 26, 1941, the other

dated August 15, 19&l, from which xe understand the iaots

to be as tallows:

Sine6 July 1, 1936, the Federal and State Govern-

ments have heen oooperating in making payments ior old age

aasistanoe on an equal basis, I. e., the Federal Government

has matched State payments to pensioners dollar iOr dollar.

The-aUnIstration Of the ?edbrrdl Soolal SOOUrlty Act IO

vested In the Soolal Seourlty Board whloh has made various

rules and regulations and Is oharged with the duty oi deter-

mining that the Federal monies are expended or dlsttlbuted

in aooordanoe with the Federal Soolal Seourfty Aot. Eaoh

quarter the Federal Oovernment has forwarded It6 pro rata

part of the penalon money to the State Agenoy, based upon

estlaates, and the State agenoy eaoh month has made the aotual

dIsbursemoMs tc Individuals after determinine their ellulbIlIt~

.aud needs. From time to time the soolal Seo&ty Board Kas

made audits of the payments to various reoiplents, and at pre-

sent audits have been oompleted ooverlng the periods 1936, 1937,

1938, 1939, and 1940.

Honorable Caorga R. Sheppard, page 2

At the completiBn of each audit period the Social

Security Board took exceptions to various payments by the

State agency and presented aartaln schedules ot Vlscal and

allglbllity axoapt ions*. After alaarance material had bean

submitted by the State agency in justlticatlon ot the payments,

and appeal perfected to the Social Security Board, said Board

rlnally disallowed and refused to aoncur In payments made to

certain reclpiente from July 1, 1936, to D?oember 31, 1939, In

tha total arm or $23 662.87. In the latter or July 26, 194l,

mentioned above, It 1s stated that *the amounts heretofore

shown as adjustments have bean Oarefulg checked and this

agency la In agreement with the Sooial Gaourity Board that the

Federal Old Age AaaIstanca Fund should be reimbursed due to

the adjustments as shown ior the various periods In accordance

with the audits submitted by the Federal Auditors.”

The State Department of Fubllo Vialfare has tharatora

requested you to transfer #23,662.87 tron the State Old Age

Assistance ?Ud to the Federal Old~Age Assistance Fund In

setl~fnctlon of this clslm by the Social Security BoaQd. You

request our advice as to whether you are authorized to make

this tranarer.

The Public :‘1alfare Aat,. enacted by the 46th Legla-

lature oreated the “State Departmeht of Fubllc Gelfaran,

which among other things wss organized to administer asalstanaa

to tee needy aged, The duties of t5e Texas Old Age Aaslstanoa

Cammlaslon, together with its funds, ware trenstarred to such

nawlg created Dapartnen5. This act was amended by the WPubllo

walrare Act or 1941*, 17th Leglalqtura, a+ractIve July 2, 194l

md in general continued the same sdalnistratlve arganization

as that provided by the Act of 1939.

Under Section I of the “Fubli& ‘:‘altare Act of 191,1w,

the Ptate Departcent of Public :7elf’are is charged with the

admlniatratlon of the walrara activltlas of the State as pro-

vided therein, and it la provided that II shall WadmInIater

aaaiatanoa to the needy aged.” Seotion 6 oi aaid Aot daalgnataa

the State Department as the State agenoy to oooperata with ths

Federal Government In the administration oi the provision8 of

the Federal Soolal Security Aot, Including the payment of asslstan~

to the needy aged.

t

Honorable George H. Shappa$d, page 3

Saotlona 26 and 27 bt the lot of 19&l read a8

rollowa t

*sea. 26. All asslatanoa payments rovldad for

under the tams oi thla Aot ahall ba pa Bd by vouohara

or warrants drawn by theState Comptroller on the proper

aooounts of a *State Department of Dub110 Welrara Fund*;

ror the purpose of parnittlng the State Comptrollerto

properly draw and Issue auoh vouohars or warrants, the

StateDapartment of Pub110 Welrara shall furnish the Comp-

twollar with a list of or roll oi those entitled to asalat-

anoa iron time to time, together with the amount to whloh

each raolplant la entitled. When auah vowhan or warrants

have barn drawn they shall be delivered to the haoutlva

Director of the State Dapartnent of Fubllo Welfare, who

in turn shall suparvlaa the delivery of same to the parsons

entitled thereto.

aSac. 27. (1) For tha Ruwposes of oarrylng out the

provlalona of this Act, the Old Age Asslatanoa Fund, the

3lind Assistance Fund, and the Children Aaalstanoe Fund,

aa provided for in HoLae Bill No. 8, Aota of tine Forty-

seventh Legislature, Regular Seaaion are hereby made

separate aooounts of the ‘State Department of Publlo

Welfare Fund* as oraated by this aot. Provided, that

all moneys In the saparate aooounts at tia State Dapart-

mentor Pub110 Welfare Bund shall be expanded only for

the purposes of oarrylng out the provlalons of this Act,

and for the purposes for which said separate acoounta

were created or appropriated.

e(2) The State Treasurer 18 hereby daalgnatad

aa the opstodlan of any and all money whloh may be ra-

oelvad by th? State of Texas (whloh the State Dapartmant

of public Welfare la authorized to admlnlater), from any

appr>prlatlons nreda by the Congress U the United States,

ror the purpose of cooperating with the several provlmlons

’ of the Federal Social Security Aot, and all money raoaItad

from any other source; and the State Treasurer la ha?aby

authorized to reoelve auoh money, pay It Into the propar,

fund or the proper aooount of the Caneral Fund of the

State Treasury, provide for the proper ouatody thereof, ~\,

and to make dlsbursaments therefrom upon the order of tha

State Department and upon warrant of the State Comptroller

of Public Aocounta.’ !a,

Honorable Cecrga B. Sheppard, page 4

Tha Padoral money mentioned in 27(Z), quoted above

la deposited with the State TraaaureS by vlrtua or an Rot or

Congress. Sad. &2 U.S.C.A. ( ) O)Ol., 393. The Stats monies

in the=sparata aooouuta designated as the Old Age Aaalatanoa

Fund of the State ~apartmant of Pub110 %aliara Fund era

derived iron tsxea levidd and oolleotad bp tha Stats or

Texas and allooatad to this apaolal fund In the State Treasury

or by appropriation by the Laglalatura iron another fund ln

the treasury. For example, sea House Bill No.8, Aota l,7th

Legislature, Regular Session. We assume the "State Old

Age Aaaoolatlon Fund* snd tha RFederal Old Age Aaaistanoa Fund-,

whloh are not mantlonad In the lagIslatl~a act, are separate

aooounta In the Old Age Aaalatanoa Fund propr, whloh you have

set up to iaollltata the kaaplng Of adequate records and a

proper aooountlng between the Federal and State Governments

In their oontrlbutlona to such fund.

It la stated In the letter of August lgth, aooompany-

Ing the request that the quarterly payments had6 by the Soolal

Saourlty Board are only a tentative basis, are not final

payments to the State, and are aubjeot to review by the Federal

authoritlaa. For the purpose of this oainlon we ~111 eaa&‘oe

the correctness of t?ia atstenent and ~111 aaauze further thati

such runda are deposited in trust *tit& tie State agency to be

distributed as directed by the Sootal Security Board, that the

exceptions of said Board ror the pa8lods audited were well taken,

and that the Federal CoverlLaent has a.vslld claim torrelmburse-

ment . We express no opinion with reference to these matters,

however.

hrtlola VIII, Seotlon 6, of the Texas Constitution

rexda in part as iollowsr

wNo money shall be drqwn rromthe Treasury but In

purauanoe of spaclrlo appropriations made by law; nor

shall any appropriation of money be made #or a longer

term than two years, .l,. .I)

The Board has not requested that you draw a werrant

payable to the Federal -Oovernme.nt and thua wlthdraw this money

from the treasury ln pamant of the olala, but Instead has

requested that the Federal Govarnaaatqa aooount in the Old A&a

Aaalatanoa Fund be oradltad with the ano,-nt of the olalm and

oharged against the State aooount in aatlaiaotlon of such

ola4.m. Any dlf~arsnoa between the above twc situations would

.

Honorable George ?I.’ Sheppard, page 5

srem to be one of form and not of substanoe. Thw whole basis

and purpose of this proposed transfer of funds Is it) <pay or

discharge the olaim amde by the Sooial Seourity Board against

the State, and&though the immediate action may not be one

of withdrawal from the treaeury, that ir neoessarllp its

ultimate result and purpose. In our opinion the payment of

this alaim and withdrawal of money from the treasury 16r that

purpose may not be done by lndlrectlon in the absented appro-

riate legislative authorization. MaCombs v. Dallas County,

v T.C.A.) 136 S. W, (26) 975.0

It is also a well established principle of law in

this jurisdlotlon that a Department, suah aa the State Depart-

ment of Public Welfare, w&lch is a creature of the statute

has only authority &a may be delegated to it by the

Legislature, either expaeesly or by neoesaary impllaatlon.

We find nothing in the PublioWelfare Act of 194l

which would authorize this aotion, but on the contrary it direots

that the State money in the Old Age Assistance Fund be used to

furnish ass!stanoe to old persons who satisfy the requlreaents

provided in: said aot.

The ourrent appropriation to the State Department

of Publla Welfafr, (S.B. No. 423, Aats f,7th Lgg., Regular Session)

Old Age Asslstanoe Division, out of tk Old Age Asslstanoe Fund,

after listing various administrative expendas, provides:

“All lnoomer allooated or transferred to the Old Age

Assistmoe Fund by H. B. NO. 8, Aots of the 47th Legisla-

ture, Regular Session, or other revenue laws, for the pur-

pOS0 of providing and administering old age assistance is

hereby appropriated for eaoh of the fisoal years ending

August 31, 1942, and August 31, 19l,3, tothe State Department

o? Pub110 Welfare for old age assistanoe payments and for

salariee, muipment, supplies. travel malntenanoe. ?nd aon-

tinKent expenses neoesaary in the extenplon of said old&

assistanoo, . . .I (Emphasis Sansa)

In our opinion the above appropriation is not euffioient

to author184 the payment of this claim whioh has aoaumulated

over a period of years since July 1, 1936. oh odly aontezplates

the current payment of old age assistanoe to needy reolpients

and adminlstratire expenses in connection therewith, This oon-

oluslon Is supported by Artlole XX, Seation 2(4) of If. B. MO. 8,

;taayded by 8. B. No. 190, Aota &7th Leg,, Regular Session, whio

:

Honorlblr Goorgr H. Sheppard, Paga 6

"(4) After the above allooatlon and payments

have been made from ruah Olearanoe Fund, there rh8ll

be paId therefrom into the Old-Age Assistanoe Fund on

the first of eaoh month, 8uoh aurn, whlah, taken with

other 8ums paid Into ruah Old-Age A88lstanoe Fund by

virtue of othar law8 still In foroe will equal a total

o? One Million Seven Hundred Fifty *housand ($1,950,000.00)

Dollarr, ad 8U8h 8UlE 18 hereby appropriated for the'U8e

provided by law for 8uoh Old-Age Asri8tanoe Fund. Should

auoh payment8 iaSb thr Old-Age A88irtanoe Fund by virtue

of other lavir exored One Million Saven Hundrrd Fifty

Thou8and ()1,750,000.00) DOllar8, In any one month,

then not more than One Million Sersn Hundred FIity

Thousand (#1,750,0OO.O0) Dollar8 o? 8uoh 8hall be ex-

pended for old-age ar8istanoe In such month, and the

remfalnbrr in exOe88 thereof shallb5.tithheld until the

suooeeding month or months and be taken Into oonsldera-

tion In allooatIng fund8 from the Clearance Fund to the

Old*Age Assistanoe Fund, and. the amonnt paid in from the

Clehrance Fund into the Ol&kge Asslstsnae Fund 8hall

be reduced scoordlcgly to the end that a stationary sum

of Ona “illion Seven Hundred Fifty Thousand ($1,750,000.00)

Dollars per nohth'be avaiiable frcn State Funds for 016

age assistance; provided, however, for the balance of the

figoal veer ending August )1, 194l, the payments into the

ZlO-Age Assistance Fund shall be made In the same manner

as provided above. However age we?t the total paid

fro3 all sources Into the 01 A 'Assistance Fund including

the amount allocated to the 01 Age Assistance Fund from

the Clearanoe Fund on the first day of eaah month as pro-

vided above, does not amount to One Million Seven Hundred

Fifty Thousand ($1,750,000.00) Dollars for each month after

t&e ccfeotive date of this aat, then in that event, the

first revenue oolleoted and which ordinarily would be paid

Into the General Revenue Fund of the State OS Texas after

the fIrat day of eaoh month shall be set aside, allocated,

traneferred, oredited, and appropriated to the Old-Age

Assistanoe Fund to the extent and In rush sums a8 are neces-

sary to provide One Million Seven Hundred FlSty Thousand

($1,750,000.00) Dollar8 Jm thr Old-Age A88istanos Fund

for esoh month with the effeotlve date of thi8 Aot, lnolud-

lng the month o? June, 1941, and through the month of

AUgU8t, 1941. All laws in confllot with this seotlon are

hereby repealed to the extent of suoh oonfliot only.*

.

. .

Honorable George II. Sheppard, pago 7

It 18 our OpiniOn that your Department i8 not

authorized to make the transfer of funds as requested by the

State Department of Publia Welfare. WS do llOt eX 1888 EUly

opinion with reference to the authority of the leg f datum

to make an appropriation or any other question whloh may

arise in oonnectlon with this matter, it being unnecessary

ta do so in answering the que-tlnn presented.

Yours very truly

ATTORJXY G?Z?RAL OF TEXAS

By # Cecil C. Cammaok

Aeeistant

ccc;A!m

Ok G.B.L.

4PmOvED Opinlor Com3l~tee

BY B.W.B. Chairman

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.