Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1942
Status
Published
On the bench
Gerald Mann
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

GENERA

Honorable Marvin B. Broa, Jr-

Criminal Dietriot Attorney

Fort I%rbh, .Te~s

Attention: Ebn. D+xm Roses opinion &.0-44C2

Dsar Si'rr Rer Ths effect of Seations 39 and 42

of House Bill No. 20, 47th Legia-

latuie. otithe disolosure 'ofrs-

ports made by the Dspartment of

Publio safe* to proseouting of-

ficials.

we ars iu receipt of your letter of February 7, 1942, from which we

quote the folloniag portiona:

"The office.of the Highway Patrol at Fort )Ibrth,acting, they say, und&

direatiou of Coloael Haner Garrison, Dire&or of the Department of PuLilio

Safety, will not-file in this office a copy of.their report as to what

they did or found in510their investigation. I have seen a number of their

reports and they draw a diagram of the soene of the ,aooident,whiah would

be wry helpful, together with their oQrment ~a@ to.what they found out fran

persons other than the aoaused, to the IRst~iot.Attorney~s Office; *hen

complaints are filed for drivJ.ng'amotor Vehicle while intoxicated, fail-

ing to render aid, or murder without maliae. I& fa$, if they do ,not ohoese

to file a wanplaint, their underataudiig is that they'are foxbidden by this

Act to disclose to the proseouting atto.rm@a off$oe anythiug that they-y

know about the prtioular transaotion, ~hep,int'onnatioaO&I&~ to this offibe

that there has been a violation of the la&.

"Our oonstruotion of this Aat is that.they only +hiag,,thatis priVilegeedend

confidential iathe report of the w~m(tde t0 th4 l%&rtment of kulS&O fbfe-

ty, not as to the evidenoe.that &ghiz 6; might iiiit

show a~violation of the

lam.

"I sm sure that Colonel Garrison and his Dspartment.are ,aotingih aerfeotly

good faith; tit I em also equally sure that they ha-fea Disoolioeptioaof

the effeot of House Bill No. 20.

"Will you please advise this offlce at your earliest emmenienoe yotm oon-

struotion of the duties of the Department of Public Safety a6 to notifying

the prosecuting officers of such aooideuts where the offense of drunken

driving, failing to render aid, or murder is involvedf'

Honorable &rvin H. Brown, Jr., page 2 (O-4402)

The ~rovisioniiof House Bill Do. 20.of the 47th Legislature,

(Article 6667b;Revised Civil Statutes) which are involved in+his opin-

ion are Sections 39 and 42. Section 39 reads as follows:

"Aooidents to be reported by persons involvedr -

*Every person involved in an accident resulting in death, injury,

or apparent property damage of l?iQ Dollars ($50) or more where one or

more motor vehicles are involved and vhhois the holder of an opsrator's,

cammeraial operator's, or chauffeur's license, under the provisions of this

Act, shall make a report of suoh accident to the Department of Public Safety

within forty-eight (46) hours. Refusal to make such report shall render

the holder of such license liable to suspension or revocation of such license.

Reports required by this Section shall be deemed privileged communications."

Section 42 provides as follows:

"Accident reports confidential: -

"All required accident reports and supplemental reports ahall be

without prejudice to the individual so repxting and shall be for the con-

fidential us&of the D+artzsent except that the Department,may disclose the

identity of a person involved in an acaident when such identity is not other-

wise knom or v&en such person denieshis presence at such accident. No

such report shall be used as evidenoe in any trial, civil or 'criminal,aris-

ing out of such accident, exaept that the Department shall furnish upon re-

quest of any person who has, or claims to haw, made such a report or upon

demand of any court; a certificate showing that a specified report has or

has not been received by the Dsparbnenb, solely to prove a compliance or

failure to cmsply with the requirementthat such report be made to the De-

partment.'

Ws believe the intention of the Legislature in enacting the above

seotions was to prevent 'enyviolations of the Constitutional inhibitions

against self-incriminations. The Fifth Amendment to the Constitution of the

Unite.dStates and Article 1, Section .lOof the mustitution of Texas, pro-

vide, in substance, that inall criminal prosecutions the accused shall not

bs compelled to give evidence against himself. This rule applies in any

kind of oass inwhioh one is called as a tittnessincluding civil and orim-

,inal oases. See 44 Texas Jurisprudenoe, page 964, et seq., and 12 Texas

Law Review, page 20, et seqi

This privilege is discussed in Wigmore on Rvidenoe,~~Volume8, page

325, et seq., in which it is said:

"The protection, under all clauses, extends to all manner, of proceedings in

which testimony is'to be taken, whether litigous or not, and whether 'sx

pertef or otherwise/ It;therefore applies in all kinds of courts, and all

methods of interrogation before a court, in investigations by a grand jury,

and investigations by a Legislature or a body having legislatwe funotions,

and in investigations by administrative officials."

_ .-

Honorable h&rvin H. Brown, Jr., page"3 (o-4402)

This privilege,is always personal as is discussed in 44 Texas

Jurisprudence, page 966, where it is'saidr

"The privilege of not enswsring the questions on the ground that it vii11

inoriminate him is the privilege of the witness only; only he may assert

the privilege of refusing to testify on that ground."

Privileged ccamsunioationsare always held inviolate, but we do not

believe this rule has ever been carried to the extent of saying that inform-

ation obtained from other sources cannot be divulged by the person obtaining

such facts. Thus in discussing the scope of privileged communications be-

tween attorney and client, Mr. Wigmore in his work on Evidence, Volwae.6, at

page 615, et seq., saysr

"It is therefore not sufficient for the attorney, in invoking the privilege,

to state that the information oeme somehow to him while acting for his cli-

ent, nor'that it came from sane particular third person for the benefit of

the qlient (unless the latter are agents of his client)."

Ik, believe that the intention of the Legislature in establishing

the Department of Public Safety as is setforth in Artiole 4413, Sections 4

and 21 and other ,sectionsthereof, indicates that the department is to &op-

erate witht.he sheriffs and other local peace officers throughout the State

for the purpose of the prevention and discovery of orimes and the apprehen-

sion of criminals and the promotion of public safety. &ticle 4413, Section

4, provides*

"The oommission shall formulate plans and policies for the enforcement of

the criminal laws and of the traffic end safety laws of the State, the pre-

vention of crime, the detection and apprehension of violators of the laws,

and for the education of the citizens of the State in the promotion of

public safety and law observance."

Artiole 4413, Section 21, providesr

*The Director . . . shall formulate and put into effeot plans and means of

cooperating with the sheriffs end local police and peace ofiloers through-

out the State for the Purpose of the prevention and discovery of crimes

and the apprehension of criminals and the promotion of public safety."

Our interpretation of the above articlea and authorities is that

the Deparhnent of Public Safety is not authorized to disclose any informa-

tion contained in reports reoeived from the persons involved in the acci-

dent described in thes statutes, but that they are authorized to notify

the prosecuting officers of all other information relating to oriminal

offenses which they receive from third persons or obtain during the course

of their own investigations.

Rnorable Marvin H. Brown, Jr., ~.i.-.,

Page 4 (o-4402)

1.. :

Your request also relates to the authority of the Department to

furnish proseouting.offiaere with a copy of the report made to it by a

patrolman in instanoes involving offenses of.drunken driving, failure to

stop and render aid, or murder, etc.

Director Garrison advises that'the~Department of Public Safety

does furnish to such officers such fasts as are discolsed by the investi-

gation end that its patrolmen are instruatsd to cooperate with other

officers in this respect, hrt thaf.it is the established policy of the

Departrent not to furnish aomplete copies of such reports for the mason

that they always contain comments by the patrolman making the report

which comments are considered confidential.

I% csn find no legal objection to this established policy of.the

Department.

Yours wry truly

ATTORNEY GEiNERbLOF TRXAS

ay /s/Alfred F. Herb&in

Alfred F. Hebsrlin

~~A~sistant~

APPRWRDAPR 8, 1942

/s/GROVRR SELLERS

FIRST ASSISTART

ATTORNBY GENERkL APPROVED

Opinion Casmittee

By BPlB

ChaWsan

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.