Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1944
Status
Published
On the bench
Grover Sellers
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Hon. Jesse James Opinion No. O-5820

State Treasurer Re: Construction, of S.B, No. 8 of the

hustin, Texas Regular Session, 48th Legislature, amend-

ing Article 4740, R.C.S., and Incidental

Dear MrO James: questions o

Your request for an opinion on the above subject mat-

ter, i,s as follows:

“According to the General and Special Laws of

Texas, 48th Legislature, Regular Session, 1943, Life

Insurance Companfe s - Deposits of Securities, Chapter

s$$ S,B. NO. 8, Page 206, An Qct to amend Article

Revised Civil. Statutes of 192Fa was passed

which reads, fn part, as follows:

“‘The physical delivery of such securities to the

Board of Insurance Cimmissioners shall be sufficient

without being accompanied by a written transfer of any

lien securing themas

Wince this Department holds, as custodian, securi-

tfes for companies under the supervision of the State

Board of Insurance Commissioners, as well as the State

Bankfng Department) we kindly request your opinion on

the followfng questions:

“1 .D Is the above Act retroactive covering a.11 de-

posits made prior %o th.is amendment, or does it app1.y

only to deposits made after the effective date of this

law?

“2 0 Has there been a simi.lar amendment enacted

for Senate Bi.11 No. 165 removing the requirement of

transfers of vendor’s l,ien or mortgage notes on depos-

its made by companies under the supervi,slon of the State

Bmkfng Department? If so9 what is the effective date

of said amendment?

“3 Q Under any condition fn which transfer of 11en

is required by law, does the endorsement written on the

margin of vendor’s lien or mortgage notes ‘without re-

course’ and signed by the company constitute a legal

transfer of lien?”

Hon. Jesse James, page 2 (O-5820)

Article 4740 of the Revised Civil Statutes of 1925

as amended.by S.B. No. 8 of the 48th Legislature at its Regdar

Session, provides:

“Any life insurance company now or which may here-

after be incor:2orated under the laws of this state may

;Is-i;osit with the Board of Insurance Commissioners for

t!;e common bene_“i.t of all the holders of its policies

an annuity bonds, securities of the kinds in which, by

the laws of this state, it is permitted to invest or

loan its ca;sitil, surplus, and/or reserves, equa.1 to

tlr 1c:al reserve on all its outstanding policfss in

force e which securities shall be held by said 9oard of

Insurance Comni.ssioners in trust for the purpl:!se and

objects herein specified. The physical delivery of

such securities to the Board of Insurance Commission-

ers shal,l be sufficient without being accompanied by a

t:ritten transfer of any lien securing them. Any such

company may deposit lawful money of the United States

in lieu of the securities above referred to, or any

portion thereof, and may also for the purposes of

such deposit, convey to said l!oard of Insurance Commis-

sioners in trust the real estate in which any portion

of its said reserve may be lawfully invested. In such

case, the Board of Insurance Commissioners shall hold

the title thereto in trust until other securities in

lieu thereof shall be deposited with it, whereupon it

shall reconvey the same to such company. Said Board

of Insurance Commissioners may cause any such securi-

ties or real estate to be appraised and valued prior

.to their being deposited with, or conveyed to, it 9.n

trust as aforesaid, the rea.sonable expense of such ap-

>raisement or val,uation to be paid by the company. Un-

der the ;:rovi,s-Ins of th.is Article, registered as well

as unregistered United States Government securities may

be deposited.”

It is the general rule that legislative acts speak

proL;)2”tivel.y ind not retrospectively, unless such retrospective

featuae is c!~::.rly maniSest from the language of the Bill. We

find nothing ii1 th;? above-quoted amendment that would take the

case out of the ordinary rule. So that, your first question is

answered that the Act is not retroactive so as to cover all depo-

sits made prior to the effective date of the amendment, but that

it applies on.1.y to deposits made after the effective date of the

law.

We assume that your reference to S.B. No. 165 in your

second question is to S.B. No. 165, Chapter 165 of the 42d Legis-

lature at its regular session in 1931. (Rev.Civ.Stat-Art. 1524a,

Vernon’s Codification) o

Hon. Jesse James, page 3 (O-5820)

This Act does not purport to require transfers (actu-

ally) of the liens securing debts or obligations--sec,ur?.ties--

deposited with any corporate trustee in the manner they-in

pointed out o

There has been no ‘amendment of the Act in thi,s respect.

In this connection, however, we will say thcst 1.t may

have been the departmental practice of the Banking Commissioner

in approving deposits \<ith trustees, under the terms of S.R.

165 to require th;zt where~ liens were ,involved a writtei~ t,?:::~nsi‘er

of the iien, as ;:‘e!.l as the notes or securities themselves,

should be executed. Authority to tiake such requ.iremer:ts is im-

plied from the statute requiring deposits, and such a prac;~Ice

should be followed. See our Opinion 1Yc. O-4535.

A lien upon property 1s such hds no legal existence in

5::: -l?i.$z from the debt or obligation srcured thereby. So that,

mything that would operate to transfer the note or other ,fhstru-

ment evidencing the debt, would operate in law to transfer the

equitable lien securing it. Such e+itable transfer, however,

:!ould not be adeouste to meet the St&es s requirement of deposit,

Yor it would not Lbe subject to regi,stration to protect the hol.d-

ers of such securi.ties agaimt the supervening right of ah inno-

:e,zt purchaser of the mortgaged prosert:.

Yox ?:tllrL :i:;;?r:tion is answered in the negative. The

~~‘yi;j~o:y

cjc::.,;,:;it,upon :I, v$Tn,::.c;;* s lien or mortgage note of the words,

“1.:1 t;ho,-;t recour;:f:“, has mthing t,o do with the cLuestim of the

transf’::r 2 i: ‘.,!.:?n secmsing such note D It merely operates to

~-mid 1i.ibiii.t:~ of th.: endorser as ,a guarantor of payfient, but

1: does n~ot ,,f??ct the completeness of the transfer evid~enced~ by

.the sigmture -, :’ the transferor. Hs :3bove explained, this trans-

fer of ths not;. (as by endorsement) I:tould operate to trunsfe?

the equitable title to the lien, bl:t not the legal. title. For

these reasons, in order to transfer the legal. tit1.e to the lien,

it should be done by a properly executed instrument of writing.

We so heid in Cpini3n No. C-4525, dealing with a similar ques-

tion of securities deposited with the Board of Insurance Comis-

siohers under nrticle 4982 of the Revised Civil Statutes.

What we h:ive said about the registration of liens, how-

ever, refers only tc liens upon land. Chattel mortgage liens,

however, while they may not be registered in the way that liens

upon realty are registered, are nevertheless subject to the stat-

utes regulating chattel mortgages u?on personal property gener-

ally, but with reference to automobiles, specifically, by com-

pliance with the provisions of the Certificate of Title Act.

Hon. Jesse James, page 4 (O-5820)

These suggestions thus volunteered may be of little

or no value in your particular inquiry, however, as the securi-

ties thus deposited, whether with a corporate trustee or with

the State Treasurer, under the most recent amendment of the

Statute (1937) have to be approved by the Banking Commissioner.

The-principles applicable are discussed in Wood v.

Sparks, 59 S.W. (2) 361, 63 S.W. (2) 1109.

In oral explanations of your question No, 3, you have

made it plain that your inquiry concerning the method of trans-

ferring liens securing deposit notes concerned liens securing

deposits made by loan and brokerage companies under Senate Bill

165.

Trusting that what we have said fully answers your in-

quiries, we are

Very truly yours

ATTORNEYGENERALOF TEXAS

/s/ Ocie Speer

BY Ocie Speer, Bssistant

APPROVEDFEB 21, 1944

/s/ Grover Sellers

ATTORNEYGENERALI OF TEXAS

APPROVED: t&INI~AZ'NCOM4TTEE

BY: 8

OS-MR:wb

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.