Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1944
Status
Published
On the bench
Grover Sellers
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Honorable T. M. Trimble

first Assistant

State Superintendent of Public Instruction

Austin, Texas

Dear Sir: gpeinion No. O-6259

: Whether holdover school

trustee is authorized to

vote in selecting his

successor and related

matter.

Your request for opinion upon matters related to you by the

Superintendent of Public Schools of Pairfield, Texas, has

been received and carefully considered. ive quote from the

Superintendent's letter to'you as follows:.

"I would like for you to get the Attorney General's ruling on

the following two questions: If a trustee is duly elected

by popular vote and refuses to-qualify the outgoing trustee

holds over until his successor is duly qualified, does this

holdover trustee have the power to vote in selecting his

successor or does he hold over until the next annual election

in April? What difference will a half-uncle make, if a

person Is half-niece by marriage or affinity? In this case,

the trustee is a half-uncle-by marriage. He sis.the president

of the School Board and has to sign the pay checks. This

person would be disqualified if they were a full niece by

affinity but I do not know what difference this would make

In the case of this teacher."

We assume that your question relates to an independent school

district and will consider it on that basis.

Article 2777, Vernon's Annotated Texas Civil Statutes,

applicable to independent school districts, reads as follows:

"The seven candidates receiving the largest number of votes

at the first election, and the three or four candidates re-

ceiving the largest number of votes at all subsequent elections,

shall be entitled to serve as trustees hereunder. Those elected

at the first election shall determine by lot the term for woich

they are to serve. The four members drawing the numbers one,

-_. .

Hon. T. M. Trimble - Page 2, o-6259

two, three and four shall serve for one year, and the three

members drawing the numbers five, six and seven shall serve

two years, or until the second of April theresfter, and until

the.ir successors are elected and qualified; and regularly

thereafter on the first Saturday in April of each year, four

trustees and three trustees, alternately, shall be elected for

a term of two years, to succeed the trustees whose term shall

at that time expire. The membars of the board remainlna after

a vacancy shall fill the same for the unexpired term. Id.”

(Underscorihg ours).

Article 16, Section 17, Constitution of Texas, provides:

“All officers within this state shall continue to perform the

duties of their offices until their successors shall be duly

qualified.”

Although it has been held that under the above quoted constl-

tutional provision an officer who holds over until his successor

is dul qualified, Is a de jure officer. (Cowan v. Capps,

278 s. j: . 283; state v. Jordan, 28’S.ri. (2) 921) It has been

held that the failure to ‘elect a successor constitutes a

“vacancy” in said office within th,“,;;;nlvng of a statute pro-

vidin for filling of a vacancy. . Wornell, 65 S.W.

(2) 320. Undoubted1 y we think the same rule would apply where

a trustee WE9 elected but failed to qualify within the time

allowed by law.

The holdover trustee’s term of office has already expired -

he is merely holding,over until his successor duly qualifies.

The failure of the person elected to qualify within the time

allowed by law constitutes a “vrcancy” (for appointive purposes)

in the office of trustee. Although the holdover trustee is a

de jure officer capable of transacting business pending the

time his successor is appointed and qualifted, it is our

opinion that he would not be considered “a member of the board

remaining after a vacancy ” for the purpose of appointing his

successor, de call particular attention to the language quoted

above from Article 2777. It does not provide that the “board

of trustees” shall fill such v acancy but that “the members

of the board remaining” shall fill the vacancy. We are supsorted

in this holding by authorities cited’in’Opinlon No. o-761 of

this department, a copy of which Is enclosed herewith. The hold-

over trustee will hold over until his successor ClUSlifiSS.

Answering your second question, it Is our opinion that the

relationship between the trustee and teacher (half-uncle and

half-niece, respectively, by affinity) comes within the degree

(second degree) prohibited by our anti-nepotism laws. See

Hon. T. M. Trlmble - Page .3, o-6259

authorities cited in Opinion No. 0-3016 of this department,

a copy of which is enclosed herewith.

Yours very truly

ATTORNEYGENERALOF TEXAS

s/ Wm. J. E'annkg

Wm. J. Fanning

Assistant

WJF:BT/cg

A?lROVELl hlAY 5, 1945

s/ Grover Sellers

ATTORNEYGENERALOF TEXAS

Approved Opinion Committee

By BWB, Chairman

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.