Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1945
Status
Published
On the bench
Grover Sellers
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS

AUSTIN

GROVER SELLERS

*_:

ATIORNEI Gs?al?AL

Ymfarhbie Ernest Cuba

county nttorn6y, Ll Paw county

Yl Yaw, Texan

Opiaioa sao. o-bebo

lie: AMe88wnt of 8har68

of ,acrtloarl

bank abook.

luoh ohwe am requfred to br

b y th e8hareholdere lt tlmlr *

,and toll falne.*

net 6apitfAl6Q86t8 to WZ'iV6 at th6 V&b8 beok Of tb Ihbal-08."

WQ alated in 6 Tex. Jur. 340:

*It fk proper for tbw awewor or the board

to eoaeider a11 eAeaumt8 whlab trnd to aompow or

8UgWnt'ti~ VkiUS Of th0 ItOOk in the h~t1ia8Or the

lndlvldual rtookbolder, that is to ray, t&s capital.

QUX-&Q, tmdiilded pWrlf8 and 611 other perlonal

and mm1 property owned by the bank as a eorporation.'t

gonorable Arnest Culnn, page 2

It ie insoonneotion with thir method that your problem

aris88r The inatitutlon in question has included nn item o?

$265.376.23 as "Other Liabilitiesv in Its "'Reportof Conditions

at the Close or Buelnew on Lhmember 30, 19U.w In another

stateursntof oonditlon mailed to It8 depositors however, this

item 18 inoluded within an aggregate figure of 4629,827.92, which

is entitled, "Heservetv:Interest, Taxes, Contingenoies end Cther

Liabilitie8.v The asse8sor is oontending that SuOh fund8 being

vBe8ervea* are Oapltal fUnd8 in the hand8 ~0r the bank nnd should

Ohwdore be oonsidered as auginenting the value of'the stook, The

other oontentlon pursued by the bank 18 that the (225,976.2S por-

tion Of tha #629,827.92 8hould not be treated a8 oapital fUnd8,

but a8 aliabilitfe8* for the rearon that the )265,376.23 Item

ie made up 0r "renerve8m ror paynbsnt0r 8peOisl 80000ntsi nsmely,

to pay intere8t on saving8 aooount8, oltr taxer, payroll ~texer,

lntere8t on Oertirioater of depoalt, Federal DepoosltInmranoe

Companyaa8essments, surety bonds, and old age a88i8tanoe taxem;

and thut eaoh month there la plaoed in these aaoounts an amount

that ha8 aoorued in there different iem8.

Your problem then lnvolveo the proper interpretation of

a ballkingin8titUtiOn's rin6n0isl 8tetement as on aid in erriring

nt thenttue value 0r it8 ahares. Neither will the Court8 disturb

sn n88008ment fairly arrived at wr say this drpartment assume

the role or sn interpreter 0r rlaanoial statirtio8. Value or

looal bank etook, lika Value oi real estate, I8 arrived at by

eoneideratioa of raots more eu8geptible of determination by loos1

experta, those iamlliar with the Looal ploture and oapable of giv-

ing proper weight to all availabl*,evidenae. The Legislature ha8

thus vested sole discretion in Q:~~luationand equalization of values

of property aubjeat to taxation in the local aasetwaor and board of

equelieation~. ~hie department is justiried in offering advioe,

however, where the railure to ooasider a given faot or the improper

consideration given a raot may amount to arbitrary action or the

abuse or dlsoretlon.

ue therefore advise you thnt reaognleed aooounting praatloe

distinguishes surplus reserves suoh ae for additions, antioip:jted

losses, bond sinking fmds, and the like from w-oalled “reserves”

set up for contra asset aooounte, euah as accrued liabilities.

while aaorued liability “reSerVe0” repreaent runds held by the

bank not immediately payable, by their very nature as accrued

t

liabilities or debts, little, if any, oonsideration oould be aooorded

euoh runas am elements tending to oompose or augment

, the value 0r

th, stook in tiie/ h,mds ot the stoakholder. hw0~8, ir the

raats are found 'to 'be am stated by the bank, the assessor and county

oom;nieslonerelcourts should give appropriate ooneideration to the

raot that the $283.376.23 portion of the so-called "reserve' fund

represents definite accrued liabll1ties rather than capital funda,

eurplue or undivided prorita. The assessor or the board of epualize-

tion may, of oourse, In ereroising their expert administrative Judg-

ment, oonalude that 813amount la escee8 0r that neoessary to meet

these liabilitiaa haa been eet aside. Any 8uoh exoese should, of

oourse, be treated am eurplu8 or undivided prOrit8.

It le beliaved that the rationalization suggested in

thi8 opinion will serve to distinguish it ito3 o-pinionHo~~tJ072

to which you Invited the attcmntlon or this departnmnt,.

opinion lnvo3ved a fund set up ror oontingencle8 r#brrr than

eoorued llabilitiee and the holding wa8 that such fund ~618

‘one of the feotors to be taken into ooneideration bl the

board of eQuell%atlon in fixing the value of the stook inr tax

purpoOee.w

The principles met forth in thi8 opinion should answer

the supplemental question presented in the fifth paragraph of

your letter of September 28th. In the event they do not, how-

ever, kindly met rorth tts r80t8 upon whioh~~#&!hi&&tlon i8

based, a8 you have done the main question pzerrenS+d,and thi8

opinion will be eupplemsnted aooordingly.

Yours very truly

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.