Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1947
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

R-179

THEATTORNEYGENERAL

OFTEXAS

Marah 22, 1947

Hon. Bert Ford

Texas Liquor Control Board

Austin, Texas opinion No. v-100

Re : VaLldlty of order passed

by the Commlssloners * Court

of Byrleso,~ County with

rbfsrsnce to tb4 sale of

alcoholic kverages and

Denr MrIr.Ford: relat4d quest ions.

Your latt,er of Febtiuarj 25 Is, set out in full

b%iow :

Vour valued opimioa

1s respectfully

reqtieete’d with referem to the Oertaln

quQstlons propoquled bblov with i?ef4rence

to the fact sltu&tionti heFsln related:

“Harked ISxhlbit~ On4 1s a cop7 of $n

order .passed by t,he Oonmirriolrer4 Court of

Burlesoa~Coutitj,~Texas, under date of March

11, 1946,~ vith referenoe to the iale of al-

coholic beverag6 in Burl44oa County.

“Under data of March 26, 1946, Steve

D. Navles, P. 0. Box 181, Bryan, Texas, exe-

cuted an orgglnal applisation for a package

store permit to be located on the south side

of Highway 21, five hundr4d (500) yarda west

of the Braaos Rlvsr Bridge, about twelve miles

from Caldwell In Burl4son County, Texas. This

appllcat Ion, accompanied by a proper bond and

the aecessary fees,, was filed ftith the Texas

Liquor Control Board on April 10, 1946. Short-

ly after April 11, 1946, th, abov4 aentloned

copy of the Co1amiseion4er~s ,$ourt order was

filed with the Taxa Liquoa Control Board.

“On or about Apr¶i 19, 1946, Mr. Steve

D. Nav14s, accompanied by his attorneys, Law

Henderson of Brgan and Ohant Sanderford of

Austin, appeared in my offlee and requested

r .

Hon, Bert Ford, Page 2, V-100

some action on his application Sor a pack-

age store permit e The application was ap-

proved by County Judge Hays Bowers of Bur-

leson County, Texas, and found to be in

regular order D

“Prior to the appearance of Mr. Navles

and his attorneys, I had been Informed that

a building had been moved on the property

across the road from the location Mr, Navies

desired to use for his permit and that said

building was being converted Into a church.

A hearing was had and evidence offered to

show that there was no church In existence

at this location at this time. As Admin-

istrator for the Board I found that there

was no church in existence within three hun-

dred (300) feet of the Iocat ion for which

Mr. Nevles sought a Piquor store permit; and

on April 19, 1946, I ordered the permit is-

sued and same was issued,

“In compliance with the provisions of

the Texas Liquor Control Act, under date of

July 18, 1946, Steve D, Navies executed the

proper application for renewal of the permit

above mentioned and same, accompanied by the

proper See i was Piled with the Board on July

29, 1946, The renewal permit was issued

September 1, 1946, and automatically expires

August 3~1, 1947e No protest against the re-

newal of the original permit was ever filed

with this office until long after the r4n4w-

al permit was issued..

“Yesterday I received a letter dated

February 18, I947, signed by H. ,D, Dennis,

Pastor of the Wl,lIlams Xemorial Church, which

church Pastor WlPllams says is vlthln one hun-

dred forty-four ( 144) feet of the S rant door

of the Navles Package Store in question. Pas-

tor Dennis is demanding a hearing on the mat-

ter.

“I am also in receipt of a letter dated

February 1.6, 1947, from Sheriff Cleve Bates,

Burleson County., T4xas, which letter caare.ln-’

to my hands yesterday stating that, the L. IS.

Williams Memorial Baptist Church is located

Hon. Bert Ford, Page 3, V-100

directly adross the highway from the Mavles

Package Store 0

“At my request the attorneys for the

Williams Memorial Church had e. survey mad& of

distance between the said church and the

Navies Liquor Store, and I attach the plat,

which was mad4 and certified to by Bennle

F. Sebesta, County Surveyor of Aurleson

County, Texas, I had requested the attor-

neys for the Memorial Baptist Church to

have the englnssr making this survey show

all roads Intersecting with State Highway

No. 21, but he apparently overlooked doing

this o Since th~ls plot Is drawn to scale,

It can be ass-d that there is not any

other road Intersecting with 3tate Highway

Noo. 21 within 300 feet of the Memorial Bap-

tist Church or the Navies Liquor Store,

‘In cases heretofore arising where a

church has been built vlthln 00 feet of a

packa 4 store according to t ;f e measurements

specl B;led, after a permit has been issued,

it has been b4ea the policy of this depart-

ment to notify the permittee that the permit

would not be renewed unless a new location

had been Sound before the expiration of same

for the reason, that the Administrator has

been unable to find arry autho:rity In the

law authorizing eancellatioa. The Adminls-

trator has also been unable to find any

authority for making a refund for the un-

used portion of the perml~t Se4 even II the

permit v4r4 surrendered for voD.uitarg can-

cellat ion,

“The only instances where similar fact

sltuat ions have arisen have bden in lncorpor-

ated cities and towns having an ordinance

prohibiting a license or permit within 300 feet

of a church. So far as the Administrator

knave, the Commissioner’s Court in Burleson

County Is the only one that has undertaken to

pass an order prohibiting sales in rural areas

where a church is located vlthln 300 feet of

a premise authorized to sell alcoholic bever-

ages o

. .

Hon, Bert Ford, Pa&e 4, V-100

%lhlle the order of the Commissloner”s

Court of Burleson County does not exactly

foqlow Section 25(a) of the printed Texas

Liquor Control Act with reference to mea-

surements9 I think it is fair to assume that

the attached order was passed by said Court

uadqr.the authority provided in said Section

25

“The specific questions which I desire

to have answered by the Attorney General are

a% follows 2

“‘P 0 Is the order passe~d by the Commls-

slonerOs Court of Burleson County, Texas, un-

der date of March 11, 1946, a valid order?

“2, If the order is valid, then has

County Surveyor Bennie F. Sebesta of Burle-

son County, Texas, made the measurements in

the proper manner, or should the measurements

be along the property lines of the street

fronts and from front door to front door and

in direct line across intersections where

they may occur? (See Section 25 (a) 1.

“30 If it fs determined that the ordin-

ance isvalid and also determined that the

measurements have been properly made, then

Is it the duty of the Administrator, assum;

ing that the Wllllams Memorial Church Is now

a bona fide church, to cancel the package

store permit of Steve D, Mavles?

‘“4 0 If ft is held that it is the duty

of the Administrator to cancel the Havlese

permit 8 then what section of the Act Is to

be used in notifying Mr. Mavles that a hear-

ing Is to be had for the purpose of cancel-

ling his permit provided it is determined

that his location is within 300 feet of a

bona fide cbureh?

“5o If the permit is cancelled under

these circumstances, then would Steve D.

Mavles be entitled to a refund of his permit

fee from the date of the cancellation to Aug-

ust 31, 1947, which is the date saw auto-

matically expires? ”

HOKI,Bert Ford, Page 5, V--1C;ci

Article 6k6-25aof Vernon’s Penal Code, which

ia also Section 25a of Art1cS.e 1 of the Texas Liquor

Control Act, is as follows:

“The Commissioners’ Court of any county

in the territory thereof outside incorporated

cities and towns and the governing authorities

of any city OP town wlthln the corporate. limits

of any such city or town may prohibit the sale

of alcoholic beverages by any dealer where the

place of business of any such dealer is wl.thi~n

three hundred (300)feet of any church, public

school or public hospital, the measurements to

be along the property lines of the street fronts

and from front door to front door and in dif;ect

line ac~ross intersections where they occur,

That such delegation by the Iegls1ature is

valid appears we19 settled, We quote from 30 Am, Jur.

435,436,

‘A state, in the exercise of its police

power, may enact a valLd law forbidding the

sale of lntoxlcatlng liquor 1.n a partleular

locality, such as a law prohibiting sales

within specified distances of churches and

schools, as well as other buildings, lnstltu-

tions, and grounds, public and private 0 Sim-

ilar power may l?fl e_zcgsr,c_j- ,spkG muriiclpfZ~

ties and counti.egO , i r

“The Leglslatura ma2 by pt’atut.e, and

municipalities and counties, dua G&r>,

x by orditrancepr~bitthee~~tthllBhrnent

,-- -.--.--

pi licensing of saloons wits$ spe_cifled

distances of churches. fl TEmphsuis added,)

The first question for determlnat,ion is the

validity of the order of the Commissionerss Court of bur-

leson County dated March 11, rg46* The order of the

Commissioners) Court contains the fol.lowing language

with regard to method of measurements:

Sl 0 D the mileage to be made from tha

front door of the property li.ne and from prop-

erty line to front door 0 ”

.,

Hen, &rt Ford, Page 6, V-100

Article 666-2fja, supra, grants the authority

to counties and cities to prohibit the sale of alcoholic

beverages where the place of business is within three

hundred feet of certain establishments and then In the

latter part of the article provides for ,the means of

measuring this distanced

11

” 0 0 D the measurements to be along

the property Pines of the street fronts and

from front door to front door and In direct

line across intersections where they occur’.’

The language used In the Co5r&sslonersP Court

order to set forth the method of measurement Is obscure

and ambiguous u However 3 it may be assumed that the Com-

mlssloners~ Court meant to follow the method ,of measure-

ment set forth by the Legislature. We quote from 20

Co Jo 3, 802:

“‘As a county Is a quasi corporation s 0

0 0 3 and a governmental agency of the State,

D 0 0 with no Independent sovereignty, It

possesses only such powers as are expresslv

or implledly conferred upon it by eoastitu-

tlonal provisions or leglslatlve enactments,

Powers not eonferred are just as plainly

prohibited as though expressly forbidden;

and, when

-- a power Is conferred --- be exer-

to

elsed in a particuPar manner, there is an

imnliedr~strietion _upon the exercise of

that power in excess of tlib m, or In a

manner different from that &-

BEmphasls added, B- -

As to the eonstruetlon to be placed on coun-

ty orders, we quote from 20 C, J, S,, 871:

“Since it Is not to be expected that the

orders and ordinances of a county board will

be drawn with that degree of preciseness and

skill which characterizes acts adopted by

higher PeglsPatlve bodies, they should, ex-

cept for penal ordinances, be construed llb-

erally, and so as to give effe$ to the clear

Intention of the county board.

And again in 20 C, J, %-, 870, we find this

statement:

Hon. Bert Ford, Page 7’> V-100

“A county order o~dlwaance must comply

with the formal requl.sites, prescribed by

statute. However, where the subject matter

of the order or ordinance 1s within the jurl

isdiction of the board, substantial compll-

ante Is sufficient, and the order 01’ ordlua-

ante will not be declared Invalid for mere

informalities or irregularit les, or because

of the presence of unnecessary recitals

therein, whether such recl.tels are correct

or incorrect D”

We believe that a comparison of the language

used in the statute and the language used~ i,n the county ,

order wlth reference to method of measurement shows an

attempt on the part of the county to adopt the statu-

tory language, and in view of the liberal construction

to be given county orders, we are of the opinion that

the Commissioners’ Court order 1s a valid one, and that

the method of measurement intended by the Commisslonersg

Court is the method set forth in Article 666-25a, suppa,

The next question tc be resolved 1s whether

or not the measurement as shown on the plat 1s the cor-

rect method. The church Is located on the west sl.de

of Texas Highway No, 21 and the liquor store on the

east side of said highway and north of the church. The

county surveyor has measured from the liorth door of the

church diagonally and in a noT-th easterly directioo to

the west door of the liquor store, In other words, his

measurement consists of a straight line joi.nlag the

two doors, tend is, therefore, a measurement of the clos-

est distance between the two doortr, This distance IS

144 feet, Your question is whether this 1s the correct

method or whether the measurement should be “along the

property lines of the street fronts and from front door

to front door and in direct line across Intersections

where they occur. ”

The cases of Hallum v, Texas Liquor Control

Board, 166 3. W, (26) 175 and St ubbs v L Texas Liquor

Control Board, 166 3, W, (26) 178, deal with the proper

method of measurement under Arti.cle 666-256, supra. Al-

though in both of these cases an intersection was in-

volved, we believe the language will be helpful In the

quest Ion before us, In these eases, the court decided

that the distance between opposite eorne,rs of inter-

sections was properly measured diagonally rather thuu

across street lines D

lion, Rert Ford, Page a, V-100

We believe that in order to accord with the

rule prescribed by Art, 666-25a, the measurement should

be as follows: Beginning at the front door of the L. B

Williams Memorial Baptist Church in an easterly dlrec-

tion to the property line of the highway front; thence

at right angles north along said line to a point direc-

tly opposite the front door of the liquor store; thence

east in a direct line to the front door of Ravles Liquor

Store 0

Since au intersection does lot occur between

these establlshnmnts, It was not the legislative Intent

to require measurement to the nearest Fntersectlon and

then back to the establishment where the intersection

does uot separate the church from the package store.

The following language in the Rallum case, cited above,

leads us to this conclusionn

“In reaching the front door af the church

from the front door of amellant’s &ace of busi-

ness, and vice versa* ue~~ssarllg, & lntersec-

tion of these streets would be emcouatered.”

-hasIs adde’d,~

It would therefore seem to follow that if in

walking from front door to fro&t dear an intersection

would not uecesearlly be eucoautewed then the measure-

meut would be made from front door to front door along

the property lines and across the street in direct line.

Streagth is added to this proposl.tlon by the

Stubbs case, cited above, in which the Dallas Court of

Civil Appeals stated:

‘“Obviously, it was the intention of the

Legfslature to prohibit a place for the sale

of liquor within 300 feet of a church, deter-

miued by any permlssable masuremnt under the

rule prescribed for that purpose 0 0 0 0 In

applying the prohibition against sales near

churches, great llberallty is exercised, aad

the rule of construation usual19 adopted is

said

-- to f=or the relinloua iaotitutloas Kd

not the traffizrs

-- in liouor, 0 D 0 D y -

An excelleat annotation on the mode of mea-

surement of such distanees appears in 96 A, L, R,, 778.

In that annotation, the following language appears:

Hon. Bert Ford, Page 9, V-100

“The proposition appears to be estab-

lished as a rule of Law that, except as may

& otherwise specificaXYy provided, the dls-

tance contemplated by a statute or regula-

t ion pro, hlbltlng the granting of a license

for the sale of intoxicating liquors, or

traffic therein, within a certain distance

of a named lnstltutlon or place (e. g,,

church, D D e ), must be measured In a

straight line ~ rather than in some other man-

ner, such as by the ~aually traveled route

or the street lines,” gkmphas is added 0)

It is our opinion that the computation of the

distance in the manner already set forth Is the correct

method of measurement i

The third question is whether or not it is

your duty to cancel the package store permit of Steve

D, Navies, assuming the WllliarmMemorlal Church to be

a bona fide church, Art lcle 666-12, Vernon ss Penal

Code, provides as follows:

“The Board or Administrator may cancel

or may suspend for any period of time not

exceeding sixty (60) days, after notice and

hearing, any such permit granted If it Is

found that any of the following fs true:

“(1) * That the permittee has at any

time been convicted for the vlo:latlon of any

provision of this Act,

““(2) * That the perml,ttee has violated

any provision of this Act or any rule or

regulation of the Board at any time 0

“(31 D That the permittee has made any

false or misleading represeatatlon or state-

ment in his application,

“(4) D That the permittee is Indebted

to the state for any taxes, fees, or penal-

ties imposed by this Act or by any rule or

regulation of the Board-

‘7 5) D That the permittee is not of

good moral character, or that his reputa-

tion for being a peaceable and law-abiding

Hon0 Bert Ford, Page 10, V-100

citizen fn the comtnunfty where he resfdes is bad,

“(6) e That the place or manner in whfch per-

mfttee conducts hfs business is of such a nature

which, based on the general welfare, health, peaces

morale i and safety of the people and on the public

sense of decency, warrants the cancellation or sus-

pension of the permit.

“(7) D That the permittee fs not maintaining an

acceptable bond 0

“(8), That the permittee maintains a noisy,

lewd, disord~erly,. or insanitary establishment or

has been supplying impure or otherwise deleterious

beverages 0

“(9) 0 That the permfttee is insolvent or fn-

competent D or physically unable to carry on the

management of his establishment.

“(10) * That the permittee fs in the habit of

using liquor to excess,

“(11) 0 That either the permittee, his agents9

servants s or employees have misrepresented to a

customer or the public any liquor sold by hfm,

“(12) 3 Where the word PpermftteeV fs used fn

(1)s (2), (3), (5)s (6)s and (lo), of this Section

ft shall also mean and include each member of a

partnership or association and each officer and the

owner or owners of the majority of the corporate

stock of a corporation,”

Under the “Expressi Unfuswrules the Board or

Admfnfstrator may cancel or suspend a permit only if some

subsection of Section 12 9 supra p has b’een violated. We

quote 39 Tex,, Jur, s 188, 189:

“The maxim Expressfo Unfus est exclusio alter-

lus (the expression of one thing is exclusive of an-

other) is said to be a logical, sensible and sound

rule of construction; and it has been frequently ap-

plied in the construction of statutes as well as fn

the interpretation of other documents. The maxim

signifies that the express mention or enumeration

of one person, thfng, consequence or class is tan-

tamount to an express exclusion of all others, And

Han, Bert Ford, Page 11, V-100

when it is applicable, affirmative words imply a

negatirr of what is net affirmed, negative words

imply an affirmetivr of what is net negatived; and

a provision limlting a thing to be done in a par-

ticular form or menner implies that it shall not be

done otherwisr.n

After a careful reading of Section 12, supra,

and a ooasideration of all of the facts presents4 in yeur

letter, it is the opinion of this Depmrtwnt that you de

not hsve authority tr cancel the prokage store permit cl

Steve D, Navles under any of the subsoctiens of Artidle

666-12, Vernon's Penel Code,

Having answered your first question in the af-

firmative and your second and third questions in the neg-

ative, a consideration of questions 4 and 5 is unnecessary. _

SUMMARY

(1) The order passed by the Commissioners!

Court of Burlesen County prohibiting the sale

of intoxicating beverages within 300 feet of a

church is valid. The measurement of the 300

feet from package store to church must be along

the property lines ef the street frents and

from front door to front door as provided in

'Art, 666-25a, Vernoass Penal Code,

(2) Where church is built within 300 feet

of package store after permit has been issued

and permit is renewed without any proteat being

filed, Administrator is not authorized to cancel

permit under Art. 666-12, Vernon79 Penal Code,

Very truly yours,

APPROVEDMAR. 24, 1947 ATTORNEYGENERALOF TEXAS

A&& By@-

Clarence Y. Mills

Assistant

CMII:rt:mrj

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.