Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1947
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

R-157

TTORNEY GENERAL

TEXAS

Au~-~N~~,-~'ExAs

PRICE DANIEL

ATTORNEYGENERAL

April 8, 1947

Honorable E. D. Camiade Opinion No. V-133

Executive Secretary

Texas State Parks Board Re: Whether the undivided

Austin, Texas one-half interest of

Bexar County in and to

0 the Mission San Jose

may be transferred,

and the authority of

the Texas State Parks

Board to acaept such

interest as a park

site.

Bear Mr. Camiade:

Your request for an opinion of this Depart-

ment is substantially as follows:

1. *Is the County of Bexar, Texas,

autherizd to transfer all of' its right,

title and inte~rest to the 'Plaza of Mis-

sien Sin Jose', and 60 feet along the

nerti~ slae of said yiaaion Plaza (Pyron

Rod), ta(;ether with the walls adjoining

the Plaza?"

2. *Is the Texas State Parks Board

authorized to acoept such transfer of ln-

tere8t?"

Pursuant to an agreed judgplent entered in

tke 48th JmU.cial Distr&ct Court of~Bexal County, Texas,

on the 8th day of November; 1937, in Cause I?o. B-85355,

'stylM A, .J:Drossoerts vsa San Antonfo Conservation So-

ciety, et al, an unai.vfaea one-half interest in and to

the *Plaza of Mission San Jose" vested in A. J.Drosaaertd,

Roman Catholic Archbiship of San Antonio, and the County

of Bexar, Texas, subject, however, to certain designated.

“covenants running with the land”. Pyron Road was de&i-

cated to road and highway purposes and title vested in

Bexar County, Texas.

Subsequently,,in oontortity with an agreement

between the County of Bexar,and the Texas State Papks

-. .

Hon. E. D. Camiade - Page 2 (V-133)

Board, the Texas State Parks Board) Alvin J a Wirtz, Act-

ing Seoretary of the Interior, and the Archbishop OS

San Antonio, on the 8th day of May, 1941, exeoutea an

agreement designating the Mission San Jose as a nation-

al historic site. The Archbishop agreed to hold andpre-

serve in perpetuity the historic Mission San Jose ohurch

building and appurtenanoess and the Texas State Parks

Board agreed to hold and preserve in perpetuity all his-

toric buildings, struotures ana appurtenancea*

Article 6068 of Vernon’s Civil Statutes pro-

vides as follows:

“The said Board shall solicit dona-

tions to the State of tracts of lad,

large or small, to be used by the State

for the purpose of public parks and/er

recreational areaa, and said Board is

hereby authorized to accept in behalf er

the State the title to any such traot or

tracts of land D or, where the site pro-

posed is not deemed suitable for a State

Park by the State Parks Boaras to reject

or refuse title so that it ahall not vest

in the State, or .if title to a site has

beoome vested in the State for ?ark pur-

poses and the site is deemed unsuitable

for a State Park by the State Parks Board,

whether the United States of America has

undertaken the &evelopment 6P any site in

which title to 8-e is now veete& in the

State for park purposes8 the Board is here-

by authorized and empowered to transfer

title to another State Department or insti-

tution wishing the land, or where the land

has been denate& by a city or ceunty or

other donor* to traaef’er title to auoh

city or oounty er other donor where they

wish the site returned to them, or where

the United Utatrrr of America ha8 untiertak-

en the derelepmeat of any site in which

title to snme is new vested in the State

ror park purpoaen to transfer title to

the Unite& States of America, or where

the deed to the atate Parks Board contains

a reverslo& clause providing that title

shall revert to the donor when not used

for park purpoae8, to declare that the perk

is unsuitable for State Park purposes ana

Hon. E, D, Camfade - Page 3 (v-133)

that title has reverted to the grant-

ors; provided that in all instances

where the Board acts under the auth-

ority of this statute, it must do so

by a two-thirds (2/3) vote of the

members of the Board, and. providing

that the Chairman of the Board shall

sign all instruments authorized un-

der this Act."

Inasmuch as the Mission San Jose has beans

designated as a national historic site, it is believed

that the County of Bexar would be authorized to trans-

fer its undivided one-half interest in and to said ais-

sion to the Texas State Parks Board to be~maintaimed as

a site pursuant to the agreement, subject, however, to

the liaitations and covenants imposed.

In accordance with the usual

rules of contract law, it is well

settled that joint tenants and ten-

ants in common can deal with strang-

ers just as freely as owners of prop-

erty held individually, The several

co-owners aoting together can bind

themselves and the common property

by their contracts, and each of them

oan bind himself and his individual

W&est therein. (14 Am, Jur., po

One tenant in common cannot dedicate any

part of the land without the assent of its ao-tenant:

(Cheaowth Bras, vs* Magnolia Petroleum Company, et al,

129 S. W. (26) 4461. The agreement reveals an expres-

sion 011 the part of all parties that the Mission be

designated as aa historical site,

Therefore, in answer to your first question,

it is the opinion of this Department that Bexar County

may transier its undivided one-half interest in and to

the Plaza of Mis8lon Sah Jose, together with the wlls

adjoining the Plaza, to the Texas State Parks Boar&, to

be maintained as an historical site; inasmuch as title

vested in such county by an agreed judgment, followed

by an agreement OS dedication.

Since Pyron Road has been dedicated for road'

and highway purposes, title vested in the State OS Texas.

Hon. E. D. Camiade - Page 4 (V-133)

Counties being

- legal subdivisions of the State, county

roads are State property, and the title is held for

the benefit of the State. (21 Tex. Jur, 625) There-

fore, it is the opinion of this Department that, so

long as Pyron Road is used for the purposes for which

dedicated, the title will remain in the State,

Your second quo&ion requires a construction

of the above quoted statute. An examination of the orig-

inal Act of the Legislature (Acts 1939, 49th Leg., R,S.,

S. B., 298) reveals that the caption of such Act relates

to “land titles and interests”. The word Winterestsn in

such caption would seem to negative the fact that a fee

simple title was intended to be conveyed in all cases.

It would appear from the reading of the original Act that

the Legislature intended that the Parks Board may receive

whatenr interest a aonor of’ land had at the time of such

tranrier tc’the Boara. If such be true, the Parks Board

would be authorized to do those things nsdrrrrry to ac-

complish the purpoms intended by the Le islature. If a

statute I8 eusceptible of construetim, sft di0ula be so

construed a8 to a*oamplish itrs purposes, (Lowenetein,

et al, vs. watts, et al, 137 3. w. 26 2)

The State Parks Board is not an independent

oorperation or Institution operated fcr financial gain,

but an agency of the State charged with the responsibil-

ity of acquiring and maintaining a system of publicparks

far the bansiit of the people generally, for the benevo-

lent purpose of promoting health, happiness and general

welfare of citizene. (3tata ve Brannmn, et ux. 111 S.W.

(2d1.347,) A8 suoh agency, it Is bsl,ieVed that Article

4068, sups, rhould be liberally oonstrued to accomplierh

the purpase intended by the Legislature, Moreover, the

upress authority given to the Board to accept or refuse

title indicates an intention of the Legielature to com-

Jt to the Board the discretion of accepting or rejecting

any traat of land or title whatsoever offered,~ If, after

aebeptamaes such tract of land Is not auitable,~the Board

is luthcrlzo& to reconvey the dame to the donor,

Therefore, in answer to your second question,

it is the epinion of this Department that the FwkrBoanl

would be authorized to aocept the undivided one-hal? in-

terest now vested in the County of Bexar, Texas, in and

te the Plaza ef Mission San Jose,

Hon. E. Il. Camiade - Page 5 ('iT-133)

SUMMARY

subject to the limitations imposed

by agreement, Bexar County nay transfer

and the Texas State Parks Board may ac-

cept in behalf of the State, title to an

undivided one-half interest in and to a

tract of lana referred to as the "Plaza

of Mission San Jose".

Yours very truly

ATTORNEY

GENERALOF TEXAS

Burnell Weldrep

BW:djm:wb Assistant

APPKOPEDAPRIL 8, 1947

ATTORNEY

GENERALOF i'EX&3

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.