Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1947
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

. R-220

233

April If;, 1947

Hon. Henry G. Lehman, Chairman ’

Insurance Committee

House of Representatives

Anstln, Texas opinion No. v-147

Re: Constitutionality of H.B.

665 and 666 relat lve to

group insurance on the

lives of employees of

Dear Sir: state and district schools.

We refer to your inquiry concerning the conztl-

, tutionality of House Bills Nos. 665 and 666, 50th Leg-

islature, aou pending in the Jnzurance Committee of the

. House of Representatives.

Both bills are for the purpose of adding pro-

visions to existing law authorizing school systems, as

employers, to pay all, or a portion, of the premiums on

group insurance policies for the benefit of employees

of such achoolz, with money belonging to such employer

district; or, alternat ivoly,’ such employers are given

the power to make salary deductions from pay warrants

of such employees for such premiums.

Rouse Bill No. 665 includes “The State of

Tbxns and any of Its designated agents ‘or agencies,

with rezponsibil1tg or authority for public education,

such as common and independent school boards, Boards

of Regents of State colleges and universities, the

county school boards, or any other agency of and with-

In the State by which a person may be employed in pub-

lic education, hereinafter referred to as public school

employees”, and also includes insurance for health, ac-

c ident, accidental death, dismemberment and hospital,

surgical and medical expenses for the benefit of em-

ployee a.

No method is provided in either of these bills

by which an administrntive board may determine the per-

centage of the premium which may be paid in mrt by the

school employers and in part by its employees, or how

much of such premium shall be pald by the employees; nor

‘_.zni Hon. Henry 0. Lehman, Page 2, F-147

Is there any provision requiring the consent of the em-

ployees of school employers to deductions from their

salaries to pay premiums on insurance policies. House

Bill No. 666 merely provides that the amount OS inzur-

ante shall be “based upon some plan which will pre-

clude individual select Ion. ” That language is taken

from the law which the bill seeks to amend, but it

creates confusion in an effort to construe the law

which the bill re-enacts.

We are attaching copies of our Opinions Nos.

O-2469, O-2838 and O-3541, which are pertinent to your

inquiry.

In Opinion No. O-2469, Honorable T. 0. ,Walton,

President of A & M College, was advised that premiums

on group insurance policies may not be lawfully paid

with mopey derived from student fees, local funds or

other inst it utlonal f undz under the jurisdiction of

the Board of Directors of that college.

‘

v Opinion No. O-2838 advised Honorable T. M.

Trimble, First Assistant State Superintendent of, Public

Inztruction, that the Board of Trustees of the Fort Worth

Independent School District may not lawfully use local

maintenance funds to pay the employer’s part of a group

life insurance premium for teachers; and also that such

school trustees may not lawfully include such premiums

in teacher’s contracts as part of such teachers’ salar-

lez because such added sums to pay such premiums would

_... not thereby become a part of such salary in fact and

would remain public money.

In Opinion No. O-3541, this department defined

“Available School Funds” and advised Honorable Lon B.

Alzup, Chairman, House Conference Committee, that admln-

iztrative costs of dlvlzionz of the State Department of

Education cannot be paid from the State Available School

Fund. ,

Wi adhere to those opinions.

Both of the bills under consideration contem-

plate the use of public monies to pay premiums on group

insurance policies for the benefit of employees of school

employers. Such money is to be paid by the school em-

ployer directly or is to be withheld as salary deduc- I,

t ions, with or without the consent of such school em-

ployeez.

Hon. Henry G.. Lehman, Page 3, V-147. 235

.

Sections 51, 52’and 53 of Article III of the

Constitution stand as obstacles to the grant of public

money to school employees for such purposes.

The pertinent part of Section 51 reads:

“The Legislature shall have no power to

make any grant or authorize the making of any

grant of public money to any individuals, as-

sociation of individuals, municfipzl or other

corporations whatsoever, , . .

The pertinent part of Section $2 reads:

,,,.. “The Legislature shall have no power to

authorize any county, city, town or other pol-

itical corporation w subdivision of this State

to lend its credit or to grant public money or

a thing of value in aid of, or to any individ-

a ual, ?,szoclation or corporation whatsoever..

. .. .

1 School employees are ‘individuals’ and groups

of them are. “associations of Individuals”.

The pertinent part of Section 53 reads: ..

)I . . . nor pay, nor authorize the pag-

meat of, any claim created against any coun-

ty or municipality of .the State under any

agreement o$ contract, made without author-

ity of law.

In the case of Harllngen Independent School

District vs. C. H. Page & Bro., 48 3. W. 2d 983, Sec-

tlon A of the Commission of Appeals of the State of

Texas, decided that an Independent school district is

“municlpallty” within the conzt it ut icnal provision

“precluding the legislature from paying or authorizing

‘municipalltlez” to pay claims created against “mun-

icipalities” under a contract made without authority

of law.

Section 5 of Article VII of the Conztitut ion

provides that:

II . . . the available school fund shall

be applied annually to the support of the

Hon. Henry 0. Lehman, Page 4, V-147

.

public free schools. And no law shall ever

be enacted appropriating any part of the

permanent or available school {und to any .,

other purpose whatsoever. . .

Article 2837, Vernon’s Civil Statutes, reg-

ulates the use of schoql funds as follows:

“1. The State and county available

funds shall be used exclusively for the pay-

ment of teachers’ and superintendents’ sal-

aries, fees for taking the school census,

and Interest on money borrowed on short time

to pay salaries of teachers and superlnten-

dents, when these salaries become due be-

fore the funds for the current year become

available . . .

“2. Iocal funds from district taxes,

. tuition fees of pupils not entitled. to free

tult ion and other local sources may be used

for purposes enumerated for State and county

funds and for purchasing appliances and sup-

plies, for the purpose of payment of lnsur-

ante premiums, janitors and other employees,

for buying school sites, for buying buildings

and repairing and rent1n.g school houses, and

for other purposes necessary in the conduct

of public schools to be determiied by the

Board of school trustees . . .

The Insurance premiums mentioned In that law,

are ior insurance for the protection of school property

against danage.

We are further of the opinion that deduct ions

may not be made from compensation warrants of employees

for the payment of Insurance premiums, without the con-

sent of such employees, because such deductions would

deprive such employees of their property without due

process of law in violation of Section

- - 19, Article I,

of the Constitution of the state of Texas, and the

Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments of the Constitution of

the United States.

. .._

. r Hon. Henry 0. Lehman, Page 5, V-147

.

SUMMARY

House Bills 665 and 666, 50th Legls-

lat ure , authorizing school of~flclals to

pay premiums on insurance policies with

public money for the benefit of employees,

are void because they would authorize the

making of a grant of public money to ln-

dlviduals and assoc lat ions of individuals

in violation of Art. III, Sects. 51, 52,

53 of the Texas Const ltutlon; and because

they would .authorlze the use of publ,lc

school funds for a purpose other than the

support of the public free schools. Const .

of Tex., Art. VII, Sects. 3, 5.

Yotiiv very truly,

. ATTORUEYGENERALOF TEXA3

’ .

BY

WTU:rb:erc:dr:mrj ATTORNEYGENERAL

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.