Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1947
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

i-398

RICE DANIEL ~'

Ray 5;.1947

'TORNEY

GENERAL

Hods.M; F. Kieke opinionHO. v-1.84 :

County-Attorney

Lee coiinty -. Re: Thi3effect to be ac-

fflddlags,Texas ootidwd0u1-hwp~tlsm

statute where a *alId

contract is executed

withya teacher; and

thwre'is subsequently

elected a.sohool trus-

...tee who Is within the

.prosoribwdde@88 of

rwlatlonshlp.

Dear Sir: .',

You propound to,us the folloW+g quwstl?ns:

"I have.~beforeme for sol&Ion ihe ,qaws-

tiotiof legality ,6fttiwfollowing~s.ltuatlon

arIaIn& out of one of 'O~I'C&UU~XI

school.dls-

trlcts of Lwe CMnty, Teias; It relates.to.the

validity Of 8school teachers two year bon-

tract, and her contract pay-'underheswmploy-

m6nt; Bi%wfly stated? Almwta Robersoa,.a col-

ored teacher holding a degree was employed on

March 12th 1947 to teach the Doak Springs ~

school for the scholasticperiod and sohool

year of 1947 to 1948-l&r contract wailduly

sl&ued &ad ~exwcutwdbg the threw trustees of

said dlstriet to i?lt;Thomas Hodge-0.B. Thom-

as-George Washington- she had~taught in.sald

school for the school.$ear1946 .to1947.

"Th6 trustees were In no manner related

to Altamwta Robwrson the teacher and were law-

fully authorized to &xwoutw thlsootitract,

which happened to b&'a'two year contract; Such

contract was authorized by the Statute which

provides that teachers may be wlectwd'for a

term of two years-on April 5, 1947, in'ac-

cordancw with law requiring elections for

school trustees to be held wwr the State;.~

qne Timothy Robwrson was elected to take the

Hon. M. F. Klekw - Page 2 V-184

plaaw of Qeo. Washington, a trustee who was

defeated for rw-electlonas trustee for said

district;

"TimothyRoberson will assume office on

May 1st 1947~as tru&tww. Timothy Robwrson

Is the uncle of Altamwta Robe&on's husband,

which would make her a relative within the

second degree by affinity to the newly wlect-

ed trustee Timothy Roberson.

"The Board of Trustees have voted to fla

the pay of the teacher at a sum equaling the

maxlmum sum fixed by the State Department of

Education at Austin, this sum now belsg un-

certain until the Legislaturecompletes the

law as to base pay-rizralaid-and per capita.

'As the matter now 3tands under the laws of

Texas, the teachwr.hasa valid contract with

a valid Board of trustees who have elected

hegoir the year just ahead to teach the

pro-

The following questions arw~~

poundwi to you for clarlflcatlon,to-wit;

"QuestionNb. 1

After a valid contract Is made by the

Boar&of Trustees and the teacher, ana dulg~'

signed and executed, does the electorate or

voters have the power to destroy ix lnvall--.,

date a valid contract between the board.and-.

the teacher by electing a relative of within

the prohibited degree as trustee.

"QuestionNo.IL o

Would ttie destructionof such aontract

be a violation of the Constitutionof the

United States and State of Texas, Bspwclally

Article 1 Section 16 which provides 'no bill

of attainder, 8x post facto-law,retroactive

law or ANY LAW IMPAIRING THISOBLIGATION OF

CONTRACTS be made.'

'QuestionNo. 3

The NeDOtiSm law only Inhibits an offl-

cer from lA?POINTING,VOTtiG FOR OR CORFIRM-

IN%' a relative. In thiscase the relative

has done none of these thlngs;

Article 435 p~ovldws 'no officer or

other person Includedwithin the third prw-

ceding article shall approvw~any account

etc.'

Hon.,M F. Kelkw - Page 3 ~ .:~.~,,

,. .i.,,',

.q-184_,..

:; 41.5

!Thwthird arti~lw.refarr6a-to s.pec~lfl-:

callg relates to any officer whd'Vappoints,

votes for or~conflrms*..,~Nowsince the newly

elected trustee did nwithB+of these things,

would :I$be.l&legal f,or$h6 othe~r,..$wo

mem-

bwrs~6f~thw board to approye.the teachwrs~

voucher? ,. ,'

"9kektl,onNo;.'4 .~ .':~

Would not the teach6r be wntltlwa to,~~'~'

the corn nsatlon and contract salary for the

year 19rT-1948for which she was duly eleot-

ed, and enterwd.intoa.contractwith a valid

and wllglblw board of t'rustews."

:.,

Art,iclw432 of our~Pwna1 Code Is commonly

.>.,.

,aowu aa +hw~-"anti-nepotism

statutw.~ It Is as follows:

: j "I&officer of this State.or any offl-

cer'of tinydistrict,-,county,city, precinct,

school district, or other municipal subdi-,

vision of this State, or any officer or mwm-

ber of,any State, alstrl.ct,county, city,

school district, or other municipal board,

or.jixdgw.ofany court)~.orwatwdby or ~undwr .

authority ;o.fSany

'gwnwrar.orspecl+l law of

this State,~or.anymwmbwr~of the Lwglsla-

or vote for or confirm

ture, sball~~inppdlnt,

the appointment to any office, position,

clerkship, employment or duty, of any per-

son related wlthln the second degree by af-

finity or within the third degree by con-

sanguinity to the person so appointing or

so voting, or to any other member of any

such h&rd, the Legislature,or court of'

which such person so appointing or voting,

may be a member, when the salary, fees, or

compwnsatlonof such appointee Is to be paid

for, directly or~inairectly,out of or from

publlc'f%ndSor fees of .offlceof any kind

or character whatgowver."

You are respectfullyadvised that the election

of the school trustee who Is related within the prohlb-

ltea degree to the teacher who had been previously wm-

ployed for the year 1947-1948,,wouldnotoperate retro-

actively to void the contract.

We hand you herewith copy of Opinion No. O-6330

rendered by this department January 25, 1945, which Is ln

Hon. M. F. Kelke - Page 4

line with our holding herein.

The election bf a~trustew to a board of

school trustees,irhoIs related to a teacher

of such school having a valid wXlstlng con-

tract with the board, does not make vald suoh

contract under Artlale 432 of the Peas1 Code.

Yours very truly

ATTORIiEXGRNERALOFTRXAS

BY

Assistant

0S:wb:jt

ATTORNEYGENEXAL

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.