Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1949
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Hon. James E. Taylor, Chairman

Senate Finance Committee

51st Legislature

Austin, Texas Opinion No. V-818.

Re: Authority of Board of

Regents of The Univer-

sity of Texas to use

the "Available Univer-

sity Fund" for perma-

nent impr9vements for

the School of Dentist-

ry or the AK.B. Ander-

aon Hospital, both lo-

cated at Houston.

Dear Sir:

We refer to your request for an opinion on

the following question:

"Does the Board of Regents of The Uni-

qersity of Texas have the authority to'use

'any portion of the,.*available University

funds' for the purpose of erecting buildings

or other improvements or for the support and

maintenance of either the School of Dentist-

ry of The University,of Texas or the M, Do

Anderson Hospital for Cancer Research of The

University of Texas, both of which institu-

tions are located in Houston, Harris County,

Texas?"

As early as 1917, when two statutory schools

(West Texas A. & M. College and North Texas Agricultural

College) were proposed, the Attorney General was asked

for an opinion on the constitutionality of their es-

tablishment at places other than Austin or Bryan. The

problem involved the question of whether the Legislature

had the power to establish institutions of higher learn-

ing in anx manner other than as provided in Article VII

of the Texas Constitution. In the opinion written by

Hon. James E. Taylor, Page 2 (V-818.)

Luther Nickels, who later served as a Commissioner to

the Texas Supreme Court, it was held that the Legisla-

ture was authorized under Section 48 of Article III to

establish other colleges and universities and support

then out of the general revenue. It also pointed out

that such statutory universities would not be consti-

tutional branches of The University of Texas within

the meaning of Article VII, Texas Constitution. See

excerpts of opinion copies in V-31 attached hereto.

Again in 1928, the Attorney General was asked

to determine whether the School of Mines and Metallurgy

.was a branch of The University of Texas within the in-

tendment of Article VII, Texas Fonstitution, and if so

whether money could be appropriated out of the general

fund to be used for the erection of buildings at El Paso.

The statutes provided (and still provide) that the

School of Mines *shall be under the management and con-

trol of the Board of Regents of the State University,

and the faoultv of said school shall be aooointed bv the

Board of Regents of The University of Tex& aha

the same is hereby made and constituted a br&h’onhe,

State Universit~‘~or instruation in the arts of mining

0 0 0” Art.~ 2433, V.C.S.

In the opinion written by D. A. Simmons, then

First Assistant Attorney General, and recently President

of the Ameriaan Ear Association, it was held that:

“In our opinion, the School of Mines and

bletallurgy is not a bradbh of The University

of Texas, as the term ‘branch9 is used in the

Constitution of Texas,. The history of the

University as briefly outlined herein, shows

very clearly that the power is not given to

the Legislature to create branches of the

University wherever it might see fit 0 0 0n

Itwas further held that the Legislature had

full authority to establish a School of Mines and Metal-

lurgy at El Pas3 under authority of Article 111,‘Section

48, including ereotion of buildings with general reventie

funds. Excerpts from that opinion (Opinion No. 2731 to

Hon. Adrian Pool dated April-18, 1928) are ,quotea in

v-31.

In Mumme v. Marrs, 120 Tex, 383, 40 S.W. 26 31

(1931), Chief Justice Cureton of the Supreme Court wrote

Hon. James E. Taylor, Page 3 (V-818.)

that Section 5 of Article VII, Texas Constitution, de-

fining the Available School Fund, and declaring that *it

shall be distributed to the several counties according

to their scholastic population," was not a limitation

which prevented the distribution of an appropriation

from the general reventie for school districts in accord-

ance with the Rural Aid Aot. In arriving at such con-

clusian, Chief Justice Cureton said:

*The history of educational legislation

in,this State shows that the provisions of Ar-

tide VII, the educational artiole of the Con-

stitutian, have never been regarded as limita-

tions by implication on the general power of

the Legislature to pass laws upon the subject

of education. This article alsoloses a well-

considered purpose on the part of those who

framed it to bring about the establishment and

maintenance of a'comprehensive system of pub-

lic education, consisting of a general public

free school system and a system of higher edu-

cation. Three institutions of higher learninq

were expressly provided for.... The Legisla-

ture, however, has gone far beyond the crea-

tion of the three institutions of higher learn-

ing specifically required by the organic law,

and has created ten additional institutions of

a similar character without direat oonstitu-

tional grant, beginning with the Sam Hbuston

Normal in Huntsville in 1879 o . o O In found-

ing these ten institutions, beginning.more than

fifty years ago, the Legislature has necessarily

held that the specific grants of power con-

tained in the Constitution to erect and main-

tain The University of Texas O O s were not

limitations on its power to create other

schools of similar purpose, and to maintain

them by appropriations from the General Reve-

nue. This interpretation has never been ques-

tioned. and is consistent with authorities from

other jurisdictions. e O On (UnderSCOring ourS,'l

The three institutions of higher learning ex-

pressly provided for and specifically required by con-

stitutional law, as referred to in Chief Justioe Cure-

tonOs opinion, are the constitutional branches of The

University of Texas: the Main University at Austin, the

Medical Department at Galveston, and the Agricultural

and Mechanical College at Bryan.

Hon. James E. Taylor, Page 4 (V-818.)

It will be noted that the School of Mines and

Metallurgy, a college whioh is designated a "branch" in '

the statutes and which is under the management of The

University,of Texas' Board of Regent's, is listed among

other statutory colleges designated in Section 17 of Ar-

ticle VII of the Texas Constitution. However, neither

the Dental College of The University of Texas at Hous-

ton created in 1943, nor the School of Public Health and

a Preoeptorial Training Center authorized by statute to

be established at,Houston (H.B. No. 821, 50th Leg.,

Acts 1947, effective May 27, 1947; Art. 2603f, V.C.S.)

is designated in the provisions of the College Building

Amendment.

The Md.D. Anderson Hospital for Cancer Rel

search was established under Chapter 548, 47th Legisla-

.ture, R. S., Acts 1941 (Art, 26039, V.C.S.), ada was

plaoed under the management ana control of the Board of

Regents of The University of Texas by this Aot.

The Dental College of The University of Texas,

referred to in your letter as the School of Dentistry:

was preated under Chapter 329, 48th Legislature, R.S.,

Acts 1943 (Art, 2623b-1, V.C.S.). This %nstitution was

placed under the mana.gement and control of the,Boara of

Regents of The University of Texas by this Act, and by

this statute was constituted a branoh of The University

of Texas for instruction in dental education.

Seotion 1O;Article VII of the Constitution of

Texas (1876) provides:

*The Legislature shall as soon as prac-

ticable establish, organize and provide for

the maintenance, support and direction of a

University of the first class, to be located

by a vote of the people of this State, and

styled 'The University of Texas,g for the pro-

motion of literature, and the arts and scien-

ces, inoludi~g an Agricultural and Mechanical

departmen~t," (Emphasis ours.)

Section II of the same Article of the Codti-

tution created what is known as the "Permanent Universi-

ty FunC" in order to enable the Legislature to perform

the duties set forth in the faregoing Sectian 10, and

the income derived from the investment of which fund was

made subject to appropriation by the Legislature to ac-

Hon. James E. Taylor, Page 5 (V-818.)

complish the purpose declared in the foregoing section.

The income derived from the investment of the Permanent

University Fund is known and designated as the “Availa-

ble University Fund .fl

It will. be seen from the foregoing that the

Available University Fund was created for a specific pur-

pose; and csnsequently it is a special fund within the

meaning of Section 7 of Article VIII of the Constitution

of Texas which prohibits the Legislature from in any

manner diverting any special fund from its purpose.

However, it will be noted that the power to

locate geographically the University as such., or any of

its branches (others than A, & M. College, Section 13 of

Artiole VII) was vested in the people of the State by

express provisions of the Constitution, as heretofore

shown, to be exercised by a vote cast at an election

held at a time and in the manner as was authorized by

the Legislature.

Chapter 75, 17th Legislature, R.S., Acts 1881,

established The University of Texas and provided far the

location of the Main University and a Medical Department

thereof, to be determined by a vote of the people at an

eleotian to be held on the first Tuesday of September,

1881. (9 Gammel’s Laws p. 171) This Act expressly pro-

vided that the Medical Branch could be located at a dif-

ferent place than the Main University, and that its lo-

cation should be voted upon separately from the Main Uni-

versity.

The result of this election was in favor of

the establishment of the Medical Department of The Uni-

versity of Texas at Galves’ton and the Main University

to be located at Austin, these places having received

the necessary majority vote as prescribed ,by the stat-

ute,

Since e vote of the people was necessary to

locate the University, the University or any of its can-

stitutional branches or departments may not be relocat-

ed by legislative enactment; but if there does exist a

power to so relocate or change the location of such in-

stitution or any of its branches as authorized ta be

created by the Constitution in order to use any portion

of the Available University Fund for their support and

maintenance, it is vested in the people of the State of

Texas to be exercised by a vote of such people cast at

Ron. James E. Taylor, Page 6 (V-818.)

an election regularly and properly called for such

purpose o

But, as hereinabove determined, the specifio

grant of power contained in the Constitution to erect

and maintain The University of Texas is no limitation

upon the power of the Legislature to create other schools

of similar purpose, and to maintain them by appropria-

tions from the General Revenue Fund of ~the State of Tex-

as and to place the management of such instltutons as

the Legislature may deem expedient under the Board of

Regents of The University of Texas or some other agency.

Mummev. Marrs, supra. And the fact that the Legisla-

ture may have created such institutions and located them

in Houston and oonstituted them branches of The Univer-

sity of Texas would not change their status as statuto-

ry branches as distinguished from constitutional branch-

es. Such a statutory branch of The University of Texas

may be fully supported out of the General Revenue. Con-

versely, its is not eligible to partioipate in the Avail-

able University Fund, such fund being only legally ex-

pendable for the use of the cotistitutional branches.

The fact that the pertinent provisions of Sec-

tion ll+ of Article VII of the Constitution prohiblts the

Legislature from levying any tax or appropriating any

money out of the General Revenue Fund of the State for

the erection of buildings of The University of Texas fur-

ther demonstrates the conclusion expressed that the fram-

ers of the Constitution intended that the Available Uni-

versity Fund should be and remain a special fund for the

purpose of supporting and maintaining The University of

Texas as thereby established, and that sald fund should

not be dissipated by being expended for any other pur-

pose. A. G. Opinions Nos. o-7091, O-551.

We have revlewed.the matter and conclude that

the former opinion of Hon. D. A. Simmons herein referred

to concerning the School of Mines~ of The University of

Texas is correct; and we therefore follow that opinion.

Accordingly, our answer to the submitted question is in

the negative.

The Legislature may make appropriations

from the General Revenue for erection Of

buildings and other permanent improvements at

Hon. James E. Taylor., Pate 7 (V-818.)

the Dental College of The University of Texas

and the M.,D, Anderson~Rospital for Canoer

Researoh, both looated in,Houston, Texas.

Neither igstitution is a constitutional branch

of The University of Texas for which the Per-

manent University Fund was .oreated. A. Go O-

pinion No. 2731 dated April 18, 1928 to Bon,

Adrian Pool. Tex. Const. Art. VII, Sets, 10, I

11, 13, 14, 17,. 18; Tex. Const. Art. VIII,

Sec. 7; Tex, Const. Art. III, Sec.~ 48; Art.

2603e,-26031, 2623b-1, 2592 and 265&a, Sec. 5,

vd.2.s. ; A. G. Opinion No. V-31.

Yours very truly,

ATTORNEY

GENERALOF TEXAS

,ti7p-

CEO:mw Chester E. Ollison

Assistant

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.