Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1949
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Hon. L. A. Woods Opinion wo. V-872-

.~,

State Superintendent

Department of Education Re: Procedure to annexpor-

Au&n, Texas tion op spciilg Lake-

Par+ Distriot to'Texar-

kana I.S.D.,'Feconsi+

eringAttotiey General

opinion Ho. o-3823

~DearSir: dated August 7, &9&l. t

You have referred this office to Attorney Gen-

era1 Opinion Woo,O-3823 rendered by a prior administra-

tion and holding that ,TexarkanaIndependent School-Dis-

trict may annex any part or the whole of a contiguous

common distriot (Spring Lake Park Comaon District) by

complying with the prooedure.set outsin its ape&al law;

designated as Section l-a in.Chkpter'.~9,.Se~~~~ll.no. /

297 .'SpecialLaws of the *39th Legislature, 1st C-S.,

1926. ‘L .,

.^

Seotion l-a provides as +ollows:

"Whenever a zaajorityof the lnhabi-

taiits;.,qualified

to-vote fop metibersof the

Legfslature~of any t&ritobyadjbiiiin& the

limits of the TexarkanaIndependbnt Sohool

Dlstriot, shall desire such tez%itory to be

added to and become a part of mid indepen-

dent school district, and a majority of such,

qualified voters sign a petition to that ef-

Sect, any three of such qualified voters may

file with the board of trustees of said inde-

pendent school distriat the said petition,

making affidavit of the facts set forth in

said petition, fully describing by metes and

bounds the territory proposed to be annexed,

and showing Its location with reference to

the existing territory of the Texarkana In-

dependent School District; provided, that

said territory proposed to be added must be

contiguous to one line of said independent

school district. And upon filing of said

petition, affidavits and descriptions, with

- .

Hon, L, A, Woods, page 2 (V-872)

the president of the board of trustees,

it shall be his duty to submit the ssme

to the board, and, if upon investigation

by the board it is found that the propos-

ed addition is necessary and practicable,

the said board of trustees, by resolution

duly entered upouits minutes, may .receive

such proposed territory as an addition to,

end as becoming a part of the colp~orate

limits of the said Texsrkana Independent

School District;. After the passage fnd

adoption of such resolution, the terri-

tory so.received shall be a part of the

Texarkana 'IndependentSchool District;

and the.inhabit$nts thereof shall thence-

forth be entitled to all the,~~rightsand

privileges as other citizens and inhabi-

tants of,the said indeoendent schooldis-

trict: The 'wlioie.or'*& uortion‘& anY

cont.ixuouscommon school district.vwhether

bondedor not'.mav bemexed'to the-Texar- ' '.'

kana:Independent.Sohool Districtin the '

manner herein oresdribed. o .." (FderG-~,,' ~' _~'

scoring ours.~) .r ' *::

,.:;

In Opiuion No, 0-38~23,evident1 no:consider&

tion was givento

. Section"2 of Artidle 27ci' e snd Section

1 of Article,.27@f, V,C.S., enacted by the-'&l& Legisla-

ture, 1st C+.; Abts-192q0 ~Yourequestthatwe review

that opinion-in the light of such statutesgnd-@vise

whether its'holdin&is'correct.

.

~'T'

Thb 'two'1929 Aots, shove referred to; ~are~-how

in effectand must be coristruedtogether, CountySchool"

Trustees .of Orawe County v,~Dist;'Trustees~~bf~Piairie

View CoSoDo,'~137 Te$,a~c

125, /153 SOW&d 434 1,:('194.1]f.:Board

of School Trustees of You& ;;&y v. Bullock C.S,ms

S,W,2d 530 (Texa Coma;-App.1 ! ./

)P ..~

c Without repeatin all of the terms &the above

.designated sectionsof thy iii

1929 Acts,'provi.sionis-made

therelnthat 'in each coui+ty,of.thisState the:county-

board of trustees &iall.havg the authority, when duly pe-

titioned.& provided in said Acts, to deta&'from; and

annex to, any:.schooldistriqt'territory contigu6us to the

common boundary line of the two dis~tricts;provided the

board of trusteesof the district &which the'annexa-

tion is to.be,~made,:~approves-,by

m$jority vote,theproposed

transfer:ofterritory; 'Thei:Adtsprescribe further'proce-

Hon. L, A. Vioods;page .-3 '(v-872)

:

‘ ~'dure,if:more than tenpercent of the district is in-

.volved,-and speoific,ally-providethat "no schooS dis-

trict shall b&reduced $6'ep area .of.less ~tharinine

square mi1es.v .. .

.~ ,, _.

,The-repealingclause of the 1929 Acts, Chap-

ter ‘47; Section 3+ reads in part as follows,:

,..

"All lawtiand parts af laws, Gtirieral

arid~S~ecial,'in'o~nfli,ct

h&reijithare'here-

by repealedi . .v'~. _ .'

a repeal of

to; or in~olisistentwith, ,

L.

discuss whet&r

themin (providing for automat&z ei;

of city oontrolled.sohool districts

was repealed by the 1929 .A&% above

it has been held InCit of Beau;

.:'mont'Ind. School Dist. v. Broadus; 182 &W. --5mKz.

2d 0

;~.,Civ. App: 19l$+;error ref.).t&t article 2804 haspnot

been-repealed, e&pressly.nor,by

'1929 Abts, for the.reasonthat&

.o~f-the,,.

laws relating to

: ~:distr%cts,andothersehool-,districts.in the county shows

a manifest intention ,on%he~part of the-law-making body

to provide-for two separate'classSfications of districts,

nsmel~, a district locatdd~withina inuAicipal.ity,over

~“

.. which.the qitg has ass)uu@ control; andadistrlct over

which a City has no control. Opinion'~-3823 properly

,:,holda'that~Artiole 2806 is'notapplidable to Texarkana

Independ~t~~School'b~kittict.

"The ~egisl&X've historycoiicerning the TeXar-

: kana Independent'SohoolDistrictshows'that it is not a

munioipaIIy controlled sohodl district. '-Itis.an inde-

pendent scihool~distriatcreated~~bgBpecial'law;divorc-

city cdjitrolin 1920. Chap. 31, S.B. 9, Acts

Legislature, 3rd C.S., 1920, as.amended'by-Chap-;-.

297;~SDec. Laws of 39th Leg., 1st C.S., 1926;

A.G. :OpinionNo. 0-3823;.V-650. We find no like ,legis-

lative history which would operate~to save from the re-

pealing &feats of ths 1929 Acts, school district.8like

Texarkanacreated bye special law and which do not fall

within the classification of.a municipally controlled

school digtr1c.t.

- .

Han, L, A. Woods, page 4 (V-872).

It is our opinion, therefore, that to the ex-~

tent that the annexation provisions found in Section lo+

of S.B. 297 (the s ecial law applicable to the Texarw

Independent SchoolP are repugnrat to, or inconsistent

with, the Acts .of 1929 (Section 2 of Article 27&e md

Section 1 of Article 27&f) they have been repealed by

the Section 3 of the.1929 Acts, above quoted.

Section l-a of S.B.-297 provides that the pe-

titlon for annexation of'contiguous territory to the

district~.shallbe filed with the board of trustees of

the Texarkana district, ,,andthat such.board by resolu-

tion may receive such territory. The subsequent 1929'

Acts provide that such a petition for detachment and an-

nexation of territory to a contiguous district shallbe

submitted with the county board of trustees, and (the

. other procedure of the Acts being complied with) the

county board may pass an order transferring said terri-~

tory. Construing the Acts of 1929 together, asthey must

be Qen common and independent districts are involved,

they contain the express prohibition that "no school

-‘districtshall be~reduced to.an area of lessthan nine

square miles.". Thus,.the,oounty school board has au-

.thority~&der~Section 1~of Article 27wf, and Section.2

of Artiole 27428 to detach snd'annex portions of~,school 5

districts in accordance with the procedure ,thereof,but

_,,they ~wouldhave no authority~thereunder to annex or de-

,i~

tach an entire ac,tiveschool'distri6t..Weiriert I.S.D. v.

Ellis, $? S.W.2d 374 (Tex;~'Civ.Ap& 1932) * &g&nbothsm

v. County School Trustees,.220 S.W.2d,213. ITsx. C,iv.App.

/I :

1949).

Clearly, therefore, the authority~grsnted~:Coun-

.ty School boards,and~the procedure prescribed in the1925

Acts herein considered confli&~$with and supersedes the

authority granted Texarkana board of trusteesand the

procedure prescribed in Section l-a of Senate Bill 297,~~

insofar as the power and procedure for,annexatlon of a

part orportion of .the contiguous common school district

may be involved, Tothis extent, Sectiqn l-a is repeal-

ed by @he subsequent 1929 Acts.

.Thes~e1929 Acts~,however, d6 not oonflict.with

i the authority granted the Texarksna board.in~s'uohSectiti

1-a stopannex'the whole of splycontiguous con+n'district

<underthe procedure and in the manner therein prescribed.

The Springlake Park district not being dormant so as to.

be subject to the provisions of Article 27&&e& V.C.S.;,

.A or Article VIII of S.B. 116, slst'Legislature, those

laws could not beapplicable to conflict with the author-

ity granted the Texarkana Board in Section l-a to annex

j

I

i

659

,Hon* L. A. Woods, page 5 (V-872)

the whole of that contiguous common school district.

Article 2806, authorizing oonsolidation of school dis-

tricts by an election prooedure therein provided, does

not contain a repealing clause. Article 2806.-t be-

ing repugnant to the provisions of Section Al-a,it is

merely cumulative.

Accordingly, Opinion po. O-3823, dated August

7, X9,!&is fnodifiedby the holding of this opinion; To

the extent, also, that A. G. Opinion.V-650 follows and

relies on the holding in Opinioh

, o-3823, it is modified

-by this opinion.

The authority granted the board of trus-

-.&es of Texarkana Independent District'~and

the procedure prescribed in Section l-a of'

S.B. 297,~Special Laws of ,39th Legislature,

1st called sessipq, 1926, to ,annexa portion

of a contiguous oommon school'distriot, be-

iln&nflict with Section 2 of Article /

r;&e and Section 1 of Article 27&f (Acts

"'of 19 ); have'beeqlrepealed by-Sectioni3,

GhaP* AcQtB.1929. Atlnexatiozl of a por-

tion of contiguouS Springlake'~Pz&kCommon

Sohool.Distri+ ho~~T~+kanaDistrict may

be aocomplished-'tbroughthe county board of

trustees ina-ccordanoe with and subject to

the.-provisio&iofSection 2 oP~A~ti@l6 27.&e

.&dSection l~.ofArticle 2'(&f;V.C%3. .AtV

tomiey;General Gpin+ons-100s.. 9-3823 and Vi-

650 hire-~aocoi.di~ly~~modif~~d’~~ere)lgI, - ;.':i,:.-i.

', : .'.

:. ~y;,;,.ve& tmk&

ATTpRNEY GENERAL

Chester E. Ollison

GEO:bh:gr:mw Assistant

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.