Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1949
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 3.5%

The opinion

August 24, 1949

Honorable Robert S. Calvert

Comptrollerof Public Accounts

Austin, Texas

Dear Sir: opinion NO. V-894

Re: Validity of approptiliit-

tlon of funds In LB.

322, Acts 51st Leg.,

R.S., 1949, to the De-

partment of Education

and other agencies from

the Foundation School

Fund.

'Your reque‘stfor an opinion relates to the

validity of the appropriationto the State Department

of Education and other agericlesfrom the Foundation

School Fund in the General DepartmentalAppropriation

Bill (House Bill 322, 51st Legislature). We quote

the questions submitted:

"1. Is the appropriationof funds

contained in the ffeneralDepartmentalAp-

propriationBill (House Bill 322, slat

Legislature)~tothe State Department of

Education and other agencies from the

Foundation School Fund valid in view of

the provisions of Senate Bill No. 117,

slat Legislature, creating said fund and

the provisions of Senate Bill No. 116,

51st Legislature,providing the manner

in which money shall be expended from

such fund?

“2. If you answer to the above

question is in the negative, is such ap-

propriationvalid a8 an appropriation

from the General Revenue Fund?"

Hon. Robert S. Calvert, Page 2 (V-894)

You state that you know of no 1itigatJon

or departmentalpolicy or rule bearing on the quea-

tions submltted.

Section 1 of S.B. 117, Acts 51st Leg., R.S.,

1949, reads in part:

"... there is hereby appropriated,

-allocated,transferredand credited to

a:speclal fund to be known as the Founda-

tion School Fund such an amount as Is de-

termined by the Foundation School Fund

Budget Commlttee,which is hereby creat-

ed...."

The Foundation School Fund (from the Clear-

ance Fund) and the Foundation School Fund Budget Com-

mlttee,(StateCommissionerof Education, State Auditor

and State Comptrollerof Public Accounts) are created

by said Senate Bill 117 as appears from the portion

thereof quoted above.

Section 1 of said Bill further provides the

purpose for which said funds shall be transferredand

credited to the Foundation School Fund:

"... for the purpose of financing a

Foundation School Program as defined in

the Foundation School Program Act...."

Article X of S.B. 116, Acts slat Leg., R.S.,

1949, (FoundationSchool Program Act) reads in part:

"Warrantsfor all money expended ac-

cording to the provisions of this Act shall

be approved and transmittedto treasurers

of depositoriesof school districts in the

same manner as warrants for State appor-

tionment are now transmitted."

It will be noted that Section 1 of Senate

Bill 117 contains a similar provision:

",.. warrants for all money expend-

ed from the Foundation School Fund shall

be approved by the State Commissionerof

Hon. Robert S. Calvert, Page 3 (V-894)

Education and transmittedby him to the

treasurers of depositoriesof school dls-

tricts to which grants are made in the

same manner as warrants for State appor-

tionment are now transmitted."

We do not construe the provisions of~the

Acts to be a limitation upon the power of the Legls-

lature to make an appropriationfrom the Fund for the

support of administrativefunctions described in the

Gll.merAlkln~laws. The language merely describes the

procedure for payments which are authorized to the

school districts. The same Legislaturemade specific

appropriationsfor administrativepurposes from the

Foundation School Fund. Section 1 of H.B. 322, Acts

51st Leg., R.S., 1949, reads In part:

n... there is hereby appropriated

: for each of the fiscal years of,the bi-

ennium ending August 31, 1951 ...$490.000

to the State Department of Education from

the Foundation School Fund, created by

Senate Bill 117, Acts of the Regular Ses-

sion, 51st Legislature,1949...."

Subsection (34). Section 2 of H.B. 322, Acts

51st Leg., R.S., 1949, reads In part:

"There is hereby specificallyappro-

priated out of any moneys in the General

Revenue Fund not otherwise appropriated,

the amount necessary for each month if on

a monthly basis, or each year If on a year-

ly basis, of the biennium ending August 31,

1951, to pay the full amounts contemplated

and provided by Senate Bill No. 117 ...

should there be Insufficientmoney ... to

carry out in full the purposes and provl-

slona of said Senate Bill No. 117....'

The Intention of the Legislaturein enact-

ing Senate Bills 115, 116 and 117, and House Bill 322

is not entirely clear from the language of the indlvl-

dual Acts and thereforewe belltevethey should be taken

together and examined to arrive at the true meaning.

!Phestatutes relate to the same subject matter, and

may be considered to be in sari materia.

Hon. Robert S. Calvert, Page 4 (V-894)

In 2 Sutherland Statutory Construction (3rd

Rd. 1943) 535, It Is aaid:

"Statutesare consideredto be &

pari materlq --~to pertain to the same

subject mstter -- when they relate to

the same person or thing; or to the same

class of persons or things, or have the

sams purpose or object."

The rule that statutes In narl materia will

be considered together applies with peculiar force'to

Acts passed in the same Session of the Legislature.

39 Tex. Jur, 258, Statutes, Sec. 137, and cases there

cited.

A fundamentalrule to be applied In the con-

struction of a statute Is to-ascertain the legislative

Intent, and when once afvzertalned,it Is the law. See

Anar. Inc. v. Texas Underwriters.et al., 129 S.W.2d

374 (Tex. Clv. App., 1939, error ref.).

The language, *... all money expended ac-

cording to the provisions of this Act shall ...n in

Senate Bill 116, is not exclusive and does not prevent

the Legislaturefrom appropriatingmoney out of the

Fund by another Act at the same Session for admlnistra-

tion of the Foundation School Program. The appropria-

tion In House Bill 322 is therefore harmoniouswith

the provisions of Senate Bill 116. If the Legislature

intended this provision to be the same In both Acts,

the words, "accordingto the provisions of this Act,"

may be supplied in Senate Bill 11 . 2 Sutherland Stat-

utory Construction (3rd Rd., 19431 453; 39 Tex. Jur.

183, Statutes, Sec. 96, and cases there cited. We

think such was the intention of the Legislature.

$here is no necessary conflict between the

language, ... for the purpose of financing a Founda-

tion School Program ... in Senate Bill 117, and the

appropriationbill, and such language Is not a limita-

tion upon the Legislature in allocating funds for or

appropriatingmoney from such Fund for administration

necessary to carry out the purpose of the Fund.

Section 1 of Article I, Senate Bill 116 (the

Foundation School Program Act), reads in part:

Hon. Robert S. Calvert, Page 5 (V-894)

I,

It Is the purpose of this Act

C,.

to guarantee to each child OS school age

in Texas the avallabllltyof a mlnlmum

Foundation School Program for nine (9)

full months of the year. and to establish

the eligibilityrequire&r&s applicable

to Texas public school districts in con-

nection therewith."

Section 2 of Article I, Senate Bill 115,

reads In part:

"The Central Education Agency ahall

exercise, under the Acts of the Leglsla-

ture, general control of the system of

public educationsat the State level...."

This language of the Acts (SIB+ 115, 116,

117 and LB, 322) discloses interdependenceof purpose.

The Foundation School Program cannot become a reality

until activated by administrativeofficers and agencies

provided in Senate Bill 115 "for general control of the

System of Public Education at the State level." There-

fore, funds for salaries of administrativeofficers to

conduct the Program at the State level are as neces-

sary to the Program as are funds for payments to the

school districts.

The program cannot function without admlnis-

tratlve supervisionand the expenditureof funds for

that purpose. Thus, the administrativecost of the Pro-

gram Is In reality a part of the Program Itself. AS

has already been pointed out, the Legislaturehas made

a specific appropriationfor that purpose In House Bill

322.

House Bill 322 does not attempt to amend or

repeal any of the provisions of Senate Bills 115, 116

and 117. These Acts relate to the same general sub-

ject and should be considered together. If being SO

considered.thes can be harmonized and effect given to

hearing; Nell1 v.

sldered,'thereis no repugnancybetween tie prOvlsLons

of these statutes. They may stand together and effect

Hon. Robert S. Calvert, Page 6 (V-894)

may be given to the entire provisions of each In a+

cordance with the establishedrules of construction.

Brown v. Chancellor,61 Tex. 438 (1884).

The Acts name two sources of State funds

for the Foundation School Fund -- transfer from the

Clearance Fund by the Comptroller In an amount de-

termined by the Foundation School Fund Budget Com-

mittee as necessary to finance the Foundation School

Program described in the Foundation School Program Act,

and transfer from the General Revenue Fund should there

be insufficientmoney in the Fund to carry out the pur-

poses expressed in Senate Bill 117.

We think from an examinationof the Acts the

Legislature intended,by the enactment of Senate Bills

115 and 116, to create substantiallynew admlnlstra-

tive machinery for the conduct of the public free school

system of Texas and, by the appropriationin House Bill

322, to pay the cost of such system, including admlnls-

tratlon, from funds allocated to the Foundation School

Fund created by Senate Bill 117. It follows that the

Legislaturemust have intended to authorize the Comp-

troller to transfer money into the Fund to pay adminls-

tratlve expenses since It made an appropriationfor

that purpose from such Fund. To determine the legis-

lative intent to have been otherwisewould render the

legislativeaction Ineffectiveand useless, and it is

not presumed that the Legislature intended to do a use-

less thing. 39 Tex. Jur, 245, Statutes, Sec. 131, and

cases there cited. As pointed out In SouthwesternGas

and Electric Co, v.'State, 190 S W.2d 132 (T

PP.9 1945, affd. 193 S,W.2d 6753, an Intent% E?io

a useless, Ineffectivething should never be ascribed

to the Legislaturein performanceof Its law enacting

functions. There is a presumptionagainst a construc-

tion which would render a statute ineffect~iveor in-

efficient or which would cause grave public in ury or

even inconvenience. Bird v. U.S., 187 U.S. 11$ (1902);

also see U.S. v. Powers, 307 U.S.214 (1939).

The Legislaturehas the duty to 'I*..provide

by law for the compensationof all officers, servants,

agents, and public contractors,not provided for in

this Constitution...," Texas Const. Art. III, Sec. 44.

Therefore if House Bill 322 is a "law" and does not

violate other constitutionalrestrictionsand is not

Hon. Robert S. Calvert, Page 7 (V-894)

contrary to general law, it Is valid and should be

given effect.

There Is a rule of law recognized in ,prevlous

opinions of this department that when by general atat-

ute a fund derived from a particular source %a devoted

to a certain purpose such fund may not be diverted by a

general appropriationbill to other and differentuaes,

Johnson v- Fernuson, 55 S.W.2d 153 (Tex. Civ. App.;

1932, error dlsm.1; Attorney General's Opinions Nos.

O-700 and V-412.

We do not consider the appropriationfrom the

Foundation School Fund for the support and maintenance

of the State Department of Education and other agencies

named as appropriatingmoney to a use different from

that to which It is devoted under the terms of the Gilmer-

Alkln laws. The appropriationIn House Bill 322, it

will be seen, Is not contrary to the Gllmer-Alklnlaws

and Is harmonious with the Constitutionand laws of this

State and does not contravene the rule of law ~(thatan

appropriationbill may not operate~to alter or change

the eneral law) announced in State v. Steele, 57 Tex.

203 718821, and followed in opinions of this department.

Attorney GeneralIs Conference Opinions Nos. 1802, 2787,

2970, 2965 and Attorney General's Opinions'Nos. 1745,

O-700, O-1637, O-2573, and V-412.

We conclude, therefore, that the approprla-

tlon which is the subject of your inquiry is valid as

an appropriationfrom the Foundation School Fund and

authorizesyou to transfer, in addition to the amount

determined and certified by the Foundation School Fund

Budget Committee, to the Foundation School Fund from

the Clearance Fund, or from the General Revenue Fund

should there be insufficientmoney in the Foundation

School Fund, for the purpose of paying salarles,.per

diem of Board Members, office supplies and equipment,

traveling expenses, and other necessary expenses, the

amounts set.forth in House Bill 322, Acts of the 51st

Legislature.

The only part of House Bill 322 now before

us for considerationis that portion of Section 1 ap-

pearing at page 75, Senate and House Journal Supple-

ment, 51st Leg., R.S., dated June 29, 1949, making ap-

propriationsto the State Department of Education and

Hon. Robert S. Calvert, Fage 8 (V-894)

other agencies from the Foundation School Fund for

salaries, per,diem of Board Members, office supplies

and equipment, traveling expenses, and other neces-

sary expenses, and the provisions of Subsection (34)

of Section 2 thereof, appearing at page164, Senate

and House Journal Supplement,51at Leg., R.S., dated

June 29, 1949, as the same relates to the appropria-

tions contained in the Bill to the State Department~of

Education and other agencies for admlrilstratlvepur-

poses from the Foundation School Fund. We express no

opinion on the portions of the Bill not here involved.

SUWMARP

-

The provision in the General Depart-

mental AppropriationBill making speclflc-

appropriationsto the Department of Rduca-

tlon and other agencies from the Foundation

School Fund is In harmony with general law

and the Constitutionof Texas and is a valid

appropriation (construingthe effect of the

provisions In H.B. 322, Acts 5lst Leg., R.S.,

1949, upon S.B. 115, 116 and 117, Acts 51st

Leg., R.S., 1949).

Very truly yours

ATl!ORNEYGENEXALOF TJ3XAS

Bv

-Y

Everett Hutchlnson

Assistant

EH:db

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.