Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1949
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

THEAITORNEYGENERAI.

OFTEXAS

October 10, 1949

Hon. Bascom &iles, Chairman

Veterans' Land Board

General Land Office

Austin, Texas Opinion No. V-930

Re: Investment of Permanent

School Fund in bonds is-

sued by Veterans' Land

Bo&rd and necessity of

advertisementfor compe-

Dear Sir: titive bidding.

You have requested an opinion on the following

questions,which are quoted from your letter:

"1. It is noted that under Article 2669

the State Botid of Education is authorized

to Invest the Permanent Public Free School

Funds of the State in bonds of 'the State of

Texas.' The Board has been acting on the

assumption that the bonds will be State bonds

having in mind the declarationsin the pro-

vis~ionof the Constitutionand in the Act

that they are obl&gatlonsof the State of

Texas. Are ~theproposed bonds eligible for

investmentas bonds of the State of Texas?

"2. If the bonds are eligible for such

investmentand acceptable to the State Board

of Education can a sale be made to the State

Board of Education without compliance with

the requirementsof Sections 6 and 7 of Sen-

ate Bill 1Bo.29 requiring publicationof

notice and request for competitivebids?

"3. In issuing the proposed bonds the

Board will reserve an option of redemption

prior to rmturity. The bonds will bear an

interest rate less than 23s per annum. Will

the provisions of Article 2675excepting the

State bonds render inapplicablethe restric-

tions contained in kticle 2671that bonds

Hon. Bascom Gilea, page 2 (V-930)

purchased for the Permanent Public Free

School Fund shall bear interest at not

less than 23% per annum?"

The bonds to which you refer are those provided

for In Section 49-b, Article III of the Constitutionof

Texas, which section was adopted on November 7, 1946, and

in the enabling act, Senate Bill No. 29, Acts of the

Fifty-firstLegislature. Your first question is manifest-

ly answered by the constitutionalprovision itself. It

is specificallyprovided therein that bonds issued there-

under "shall be executed by said Board as an obligation

of the State of Texas." These bonds would, therefore,be

eligible investmentsunder Article 2669, V.C.S., which

provides that the State Board of Education is authorized

and empowered~toinvest the permanent public free school

funds of the State "In bonds of the United States, ~the

State of Texas . . ."

However, It is our opinion that compliancemust

be had with the requirementsof Sections 6 and 7 of Senate

Bill No. 29 with respect to the publicationof notice ,and

request for competitivebids even though the bonds ulti-

mately may be purchased for the benefit of the Permanent

School Fund. In Sections 6 and 7, it is provided:

"Sec. 6. When the Board shall have

authorized the issuance of a series of said

bonds and shall have determined to call for

bids therefor, it shall be the duty of the

Board to rxlblishat least one (1) time not

less than twenty (20) days before the date of

said sale an appropriatenotice thereof. Such

publicationshall be made in a daily news-

paper . . .

"Sec. 7. None of said bonds shall be

sold for less than their face value with ac-

crued interest from date, and all of such

bonds shall be sold after competitivebiddlnq

to the highest and best bidder, except in

those cases where the administratorsof the

state's funds iven priority exercise, with-

in fifteen (15ejdays after notice thereof,

their right of priority to take such bonds

at the highest nrlce bid bv another . . ."

(Emphasisadded)

: .

Hon. Bascom Glles, Page 3 (V-930)

Section 6 makes it the duty of the Board to

publish the notice of sale. Section 7 provides that all

such bonds shall be sold after competitivebidding and

then to the highest and best bidder except where the

administratorsof the state's funds exercise their right

of priority. Such right of priority can be exercised

only to purchase the bonds "at the highest price bid by

another." It is obvious that the quoted phrase could

refer only to a bid submitted after proper notice had

been given. It is our opinion that the statute contem-

plates that the Veterans' Land Board issue the bonds on

the best possible terms regardless of whether they are

purchasedby administratorsas investmentsfor state's

funds or whether they are purchased by private invest-

ors. We have been advised that the Board subsequentto

the date of your letter of request determined to publish

notice of sale and request for competitivebids and that

the same has now been published. It is our opinion that

the Board in this determinationhas complied both with

the letter and the spirit of the law.

Your third question presents more difficult

problems. Article 2675 provides in part:

"The provisions of the six preceding

articles shall extend to any bonds or se-

curities other than the bonds of the State

or of the United States . . ."

Article 2671, which Is one of the "six preced-

ing articles," outlines the conditions upon which bonds

may be purchased by the Board of Education. It provides

in part:

,t. . . No bonds, obligations,or pledges

shall be so purchased that bear less than two

and one-half (23%) per cent interest. No

bonds, obligations,or pledges cxcent those of

the United States, the State of Texas. and the

University of Texas, shall be so purchased when

the indebtednessof the county, city, precinct,

or district issuing same, inclusive of those

offered, shall exceed seven (7%) per cent of

the a:sessed value of the real estate therein

. . . (Emphasisadded)

It is noted that the exception provision appli-

es only to the seven (79%) limitation,and that no excep-

tion Is provided with respect to the 23% limitation. The

. ‘..

Hon. Bascom Giles, page 4 (V-930)

clear inference is, therefore, that the 2s limitation

would apply to all bonds purchased.

,BothArticles 2671 and 2675 were originally

enacted as part of Chapter 124, Acts of the Twenty-

ninth Legislature in 1905. They appear as Sections,

4 and 9, respectively. Although Article 2671 has been

amended numerous times since its original enactment,

Article 2675 has not been changed. Moreover, the ex-

ception, "except those of the United States, the State

of Texas, and the University of Texas," in Article 2671

did not appear In the original act and was not added

thereto until the enactment in 1929 of Chapter 278, Acts

of the Forty-firstLegislature. If neither the limita-

tion as to interest rate nor the 7% valuation limitation

applied to bonds of the State of Texas by virtue of the

provisions of Article 2675',then it could be argued that

the reason why the 7s assessed valuation exceptionswas

added to Article 2671 was to make the interestrate

limitationapplicable to all bonds purchased by the

Board of Education. The 1929 act, being sub,sequent in

time of passage to the 1905 act, would govern.

However, we have concluded in any event that

the Constitutionalamendment Itself and the enabling act

make these bonds eligible Investmentsfor the Permanent

School Fund. The Constitutionalamendment provides that

the bonds shall bear Interest at a rate not to exceed

three (3%)per cent per annum. It also provides that in

"the sale of any such bonds, preferentialright of pur-

chase shall be given to the administratorsof the various

teacher retirement funds, the Permanent UniversityFunds,

and the PermanentFree School Funds." See also Section 5

of Senate Bill No, 29, which contains a similar provision.

You will note that the only~limitationas to

interest rate specified in the Constitutionis the maxi-

nmm tbree (3%)per cent, and that no limitation is placed

on a minimum rate. You will also note that the preferen-

tial right is given to the administratorsof the named

funds In the sale of any such bonds. This preferential

right of purchase is granted by the ConstitutionItself,

and is independentof any other constitutionalor statu-

tory grant. It is our opinion that the preferential

right attaches to any bonds issued under this constltu-

tional or statutory grant at the interest rate specified

in the "highest price bid by another," regardless of the

fact that such rate may be less than 24%. As a practi-

cal consideration,It may be added that during the past

: . .

Hon. Bascom GileS, page 5 (V-930)

several years millions of dollars of bonds have been is-

sued that bear less than 24% interest. We think that it

clearly was within the contemplationof the Legislature

in providing for the submission of Section 49-b of Artl-

cle III and of the qualified voters in adopting the same

that the bonds could bear less than 23% interest, and in

most probabilitieswould. The preferentialright attach-

es to the sale of any such bonds, and it is our opinion

that this provision makes them eligible as investments

for the Permanent School Fund. If there Is any conflict

between Article 2671 and Section 49-b, then, of course,

the Constitutionwould govern in this regard.

SUMMARY ',

Bonds issued by the Veterans' Land Board

under the authority of Section 49-b, Article

III, Constitutionof Texas, and 'itsenabling

act (S. B. 29, Acts 51st Leg., 1949) are obli-

gations of the State of Texas, and are eligible

investmentsfor the Permanent School Fund even

though such,bondsmay bear less than 23%.

The Veterans* Land Board in the sale of any

bonds must comply with the requirements of Sec-

tions 6 and 7 of Senate Bill No. 29 requiring

publicationof notice of sale and request for

competitivebids. Such.bonds may be purchased

by the Board of Sducation for the benefit of

the Permanent School Fund only after such pub-

lication and only if the Board of Education

properly exercises its right of priority to

purchase the bonds at the highest price bid by

another.

Very truly yours,

ATTORNEY GRRERAL George W. Sparks

Assistant

GWS-s

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.