The opinion
,-, ?
.TEEA'ITORNEYGENERAL '
OF ?IYExAs
PRICE DANIEL
ATTORNEYGENERAL
hly 31, 1951
Hon. Walter Oeltjen Opinion No. V-1224
County Attorney
Fayette bounty Re: Continuation of State ad valo-
La Grange, Texas rem tax levies in county in
which tax donations were pre-
viously granted to Flood Con-
trol District which has no
Dear Sir: outstanding obligations,
You have requested the opinion of this office as to
whether the State Automatic Tax Board will cause to be levied an-
nually in the Fayette County Flood Control District the full thirty
cents State ad valorem tax for the year 1951 and thereafter until
the expiration date of the grant of State ad valorem taxes heretofore
made to said district.
The boundaries of the Fayette County Flood Control
District coincide with the boundaries of’Fayette County. H.B. 514,
Acts 50th Leg., 1947, ch. 185, p0 314.
Section l(b) of Senate’ Bill 77, Acts 49th Leg., 1945, ch.
364, p. 654, reads as follows:
“(b) For a period of-ten (10) years, commencing
with September 1, following, the,adoption of this Act
there is hereby donated and granted by the State of
Texas to the Fayette County.Flood Control District
one-half (l/2) of the state’ad v&rem taxes collected
for general revenue purposes upon the property and
from persons in Fayette County, which taxes when col-
lected shall be used by the said county for the purposes
of preventing the continued ‘public calamity caused by
great floods, and to construct improvements to control
flood waters in the said county for the protection of life,
property, soil, forests, and Rublic highways lying with-
in the said county.”
Section l-a of Article ,VIII of the Constitution of the State
of Texas, adopted November 2, 1948,‘provides that from and after
January 1, 195i. no State ad valorem tax will be levied upon any prop-
erty within the State for general revenue purposes. It also author-
izes a new county tax and further provides “that in those counties or
political subdivisions or areas of the State from which tax donations
C
I-Ion. Walter Oeltjen, Page 2 (V-1224)
have heretofore been granted, the State Automatic Tax Board shall
continue to levy the full amount of the State ad valorem tax for the
duration of such dona.tion, or until all legal obligations heretofore
authorized by the law granting such donation or donations shall have
~been fully discharged, whichever shall first occur; provided that if
such donation to any such county or political subdivision is for less
‘than the full amount of State ad valorem taxes so levied, the portion
~of such taxes remaining over and above such donation shall be re-
tained by said county or subdivision.”
Article 7048a. V.C.S., enacted in pursuance to the au-
thortiation of Se&ion l-a, provides enabling machinery for the new
county~ tax. Acts 51st Leg., R.S. 1949, ch. 464, p. 849. Section 10
(a)(l) of Article 7048a reads as follows:
“Beginning in the year 1951 and each year there-
after the State Automatic Tax Board created by Article
7041 of the Revised Civil Statutes of Texas, 1925, shall
cause to be levied annually in each county, political sub-
division or other defined area. the full thirty cents (30$)
State ad valorem tax for general revenue purposes, the
proceeds of which heretofore were donated and granted
by the Legislature to certain counties, political subdivi-
sions or other defined areas for the purpose of carrying
out and performing actions of preventing calamities, im-
proving, protecting and reclaiming certain areas for and
on behalf of the State as more fully declared in each ap-
plicable law or laws making such donation or grant and
said Board shall continue to levy such tax at said rate
,in each such designated area until the bonds or other ob-
ligations of said areas authorized or incurred in connec-
tion with the performance of such action on behalf of the
State shall have been fully paid or discharged or until
the expiration date of such donation or grant as may be
determined from the law or laws making such grant or
donation, whichever shall first occur. ”
In the brief which you submitted for our consideration
in connection with your request, you state that the Fayette County
Flood Control District has never issued any bonds and does not have
any outstanding indebtedness, the flood control program in Fayette
County having been operated on a cash basis since the program was
inaugurated. We quote the following excerpt from your brief:
“In my opinion that clause in the Constitutional
Amendment, hereinbefore mentioned, which states ‘for
the duration of such donation’ and the clause in Article
7048a Sec. 10 (a) (1) which states ‘until the expiration
date of such donation’ would not have been included in
^.
Hon. Walter Oeltjen, Page 3 (V-1224)
the Constitutional Amehdrnent and Statute if the legis-
lature had not intended that such clause should have
some meaning or effect. The Fayette County Flood
Control District which operates on a cash basis would
now be penalized merely because it is operating on a
cash basis and because it did not imm,ediately go into
debt at the commencement of the donation perisd by
issuing,bonds.
“If,this county would have issued bonds and such
bonds were paid off in a given year, then most ce’rtain-
ly the donation would end in the year the bonds are paid
off since in such case the discharge of legal obligations
did ‘first occur.’ However, in our instance where the
Flood Controi District is on a cash basis, it wsald be
impossible for the discharge of legal’obligations to
‘first occur* since there are no legal obligations to be
paid off or to be discharged. Therefore, in my sepinion,
the duration of the donation in our countyy must neces-
sarily be for the fully ten year period.
“There are two conditions set out in the Consti-
tutional Amendment and the Statute, i.e. the expiration
of the donation period or the discharge of the legal ob-
ligations outstanding, either of which will eaase the levy
of the ad valorem tax to terminate. Since ,in ?be :zise
of the Fayette County Flood Control District !he second
condition cannot occur since there are no !egst obliga-
tions to discharge, then it appears that the grant should
continue until the first condition occurs, namri;~ the ex-
piration date of the donation.”
We cannot agree with your conclusion for the following
reasons. The constitutional requirement that the ievy shall con-
tinue “for the duration of such donation, or until all, legal obliga-
tions heretofore authorized by the law granting such donation or
donations shall have been fully discharge&“‘ is broad enough to cover
any contractual agreement or undertaking which hatjl been concluded
by the Fayette County Flood Control District. Such legal obliga-
tions, though paid for at the time from past donations, have, neces-
sarily, been ‘“fully discharged.” A bond issue is only one type of
legal obligation, and we see no reason to limit the meaning of the
phrase “legal obligations” to bond issues. Evidently the Legisla-
ture did not so interpret the phrase, since Section lo(a)(l), previous-
ly quoted, requires the Board to continue to levy the previously do-
nated tax “until the bonds or other obligations of said areas a . D
shall have been fully paid or discharged or until the expiration date
of such donation or grant D ~ s whichever shaP1 first occur.”
Hon. Walter Oeltjen, Page 4 (V- 1224)
Of course, it was not necessary for the Legislature to
embody this provision in Article 704ga because the constitutional
provision for ,the continued levy is a mandatory one; and, going a
step further, had Section l-a omitted this requirement, it would
nevertheless have been read into Section 1-a by reason of the pro-
visions of the State and Federal ,Constitution which prohibit impair-
ing the obligation of contracts. In expressly providing the require-
ment for the continued levy, we think that the framers of the con-
stitutional amendment sought to make clear that although existing
contracts were not affected, it was their desire to cut off all dona-
tions which were not required by law to be continued. In this view
of the matter, Fayette County Flood Control District is no more
penalized by virtue of the fact that it has operated on a “cash basis”
than it would be had it issued bonds which matured in 1950 and were
retired. You recognize the unquestioned termination of a grant in
the latter instance.
You are therefore advised that the State Automatic Tax
Board should no longer levy the State ad valorem tax in Fayette
County.
SUMMARY
Since the Fayette County Flood Control District
has no outstanding indebtedness, it has discharged all
legal obligations authorized by the law granting it a tax
donation from Fayette County. The State Automatic Tax
Board should not continue to’levy the State ad valorem
tax in Fayette County f r the duration of the donation.
Tex. Const., Art. VIII, %e c. l-a.
Yours very truly,
PRICE DANIEL
Attorney General
APPROVED: BY @t&.&&-h”+0 &AZ&
Mrs. MariettaMcGre or Creel
W. V. Geppert Assistant
Taxation Division
Jesse P. Luton, Jr.
Reviewing Assistant
Charles D. Mathews
First Assistant
MMC/mwb