Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1951
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Hon. H. A. Beckwith, Chairman

Board of Water Engineers

302 West Fifteenth Street

Austin, Texas Opinion No. V-1307

Re: Purposes for which the

appropriation to the In-

terstate Compact Commis-

Bion may be used during

the biennium ending Au-

gust 31, 1953.

Dear Sir:

You have requested an opinion of this office re-

lating to the purposes for which expenditures may be made

from the appropriation to the Interstate Compact Commission

in the general anoronriation bill for the biennium ending

August 31, 1953.--I-i.@. 426, Acts 52nd Leg., R. S. 1951, ch.

499, p. 1228, at p. 1374.

The various statutes pertaining to the Interstate

Compact Commission and related agencies will be summarized

in chronological order so that your specific questions can

be placed in the proper perspective.

The Le lslature created the Interstate Compact

Commission In 19&9, and authorized the Governor to appoint

an Interstate Compact Commissioner 'to negotiate an agree-

ment with each of the affected States respecting the use,

control and disposition of'the waters of the Canadian, Red

and Sabine Rivers and their tributaries" and to tlmakethe

necessary investigations and procure the necessary data

for the proper performance of his duties, and may, with

the approval of the Governor, employ such clerical, legal,

engineering and other assistance as may be necessary in

the performance of such duties." H.B. 594, Acts 51st Leg.,

R.S. 1949, ch. 380, p. 716 (Art. 7466g, V.C.S.) The stat-

ute and emergency clause make clear that the Commissioner's

duties were the negotiation of agreements and the investi-

gating and procuring or data necessary to the negotiations

concerning the above-named rivers. This statute also car-

ried with it an appropriation for the remainder of'the bi-

ennium ending August 31, 1951.

Hon. H. A. Beckwith, page 2 (V-13073

The Interstate Compact Commissioner successfully

negotiated an agreement with New Mexico and Oklahoma re-

lating to the Canadian River. The Legislature adopted the

agreement, efPective,May 10, 1951, and charged the State

Board of'Water Engineers with the administration of the

H.B. 63 Acts 52nd Leg., R.S. 1951, ch. 153, p.

%tp:%. 7466h, ;.c.S.).

By an act effective June 15, 19.51,the Legisla-

ture amended House Bill 63, sunra, taking from the Board

of Water Engineers the administration of the Compact in

the following language:

"Section 1. That Section 2 of House Bill

No. 63, Acts or the Fifty-second Legislature,

1951, be amended to read as follows:

"'Sec. 2. The Governor shall appoint a

suitable person as Commissioner for the State

of Texas to serve as a member of the 'Canadian

River Commission' as contemplated by Section

(a) of Article IX of the Canadian River Com-

pact set forth in Section 1 of Said House Bill

NO. 63. The Commissioner so appointed Shall

have the powers and discharge the duties pre-

scribed by the terms of said Compact. He shall

be allowed his actual expenses In the discharge

of his duties under said Compact, and shall

have authority to meet and confer with the

other members of the Canadian River Commission

at Such points within or without the State of

Texas as the Commission may see fit. The sum

of One Thousand Dollars ($1,000) is hereby ap-

propriated to the "Canadian River Revolving

Fund" as the prorata obligation of the State

of Texas to such iund as provided for in Section

(b) of Article IX of said Compact. The sum here-

in appropriated shall be made available on Sep-

tember 1, 1951, out or any funds in the State

Treasury not otherwise appropriated and shall be

paid out of the Treasury on warrant of the Comp-

troller upon sworn account of the Commissioner.'"

H.B. 805, Acts 52nd Leg., R.S. 1951, ch. 446, p.‘

803 (Art. 7466b, V.C.S.)

By an Act effective June 21, 1951, the Legisla-

ture authorized the Sablne River Authority, which had been

established in 1949, LH.B. 467, Acts 51st Leg., R.S. 1949,

Hon. H. A. Beckwlth, page 3 (V-1307)

ch. 110, p. 193 (Art. 8191; V.C.S.l/ to negotiate a com-

pact regarding the distribution and use or all waters of

the Sabine 'Riverwatershed as follows:

"Section 1. The Sabine River Authority,

when designated by the Governor of the State

of TeXaB pursuant to Article X of the Consti-

tution, Shall have the power and authority to

negotiate with ~the duIy authorized representa-

tives of the State of Louisiana and the duly

authorized representatives of the Federal Gov-

ernment for a compact regarding the diBtribu-

tlon and use of all waters of the Sabine River

Watershed, and shall represent the State of

Texas through a majority of Its Board of Di-

rectors, and any and all negotiations neces-

sary to secure.such a compact between the

State of Texas and the State of Louisiana.

"Sec. 2. Any agreement which may be en-

tered into between the Sabine River Authority'

on behalf of the State or Texas and the Com-

pact Commission of other affected States and

the representative of the government of the

United States respecting the waters of the Sa-

bine River shall have no binding eff'ectupon

the State of TeXaB or its legal representation

until the same shall have been ratified by the

Legislature of this State and approved by the

Governor.

"Sec. 3. There is hereby appropriated to

the Sabine River Authority the sum or Four Thou-

Band, Six Hundred and Seven Dollars ($4,607)

for the purpose of carrying out the provisions

of this Act." H.B. 413, Act8 52nd Leg., 1951,

ch. 482, p. 857.

Cn September 4, 1951, the Governor, pursuant to

Section 1, au ra designated the Sabine River Authority as

hi8 represen

+ ative In negotiating a Sabine River compact.

The general appropriation bill for the biennium

ending August 31, 1953, ha8 the FolloWing appropriation:

Hon. H. A. Beckwith, page 4 (V-1307)

"INTERSTATE COMPACT COMMISSION

Subject to the provisions appearing at the end

of this Article, there is hereby appropriated

out of the General Revenue Fund to the Inter-

state Compact Commission for each of the fiscal

years of the biennium ending August 31, 1953,

the SWIIof Ten Thousand Dollar8 ($13,000) for

the payment of salaries and other necessary

expenses for said Commission. Said appropria-

tion shall be expended under the direction and

supervision of the State Board of Water Hngi-

neers. Properties and facilities owned by the

Interstate Compact Commission shall be made

available to the State Board of W$ter Engineers

for the purposes of this Section. H.B. 426,

Acts 52nd Leg., 1951, ch. 499, p. 1228 at p.

1374.

In the light of the above statutes and approprla-

tions, ou have asked the following questions with regard

to the T 10,000 appropriation in the general appropriation

bill for the Interstate Compact Commission:

(1) Is the Canadian River Commissioner to be

paid out of the $10,000 appropriation?

(2) Must the $10,000 be apportioned equally among

the Canadian, Red, and Sabine Rivers, or may it be apportion-

ed as the Board of Water Engineers deems necessary?

(3) May any of the $10,000 be allocated for ex-

penses of investigating and procuring data for, and in ne-

gotiating, a Sabine River Compact?

(4) May any of the $10,000 be expended on the ne-

gotiation of a Red River Compact?

The answers to all of the above questions lie In

a determination of the authority remaining in the Interstate

Compact Commissioner in the light of the general statutes

set out which were passed subsequent to the statute creating

the Interstate Compact Commissioner. The $10,000 appropri-

ation iS made for the Interstate Compact COmmiBBiOn, and it

is elementary that the money may be spent only for actlvi-

ties which that orrice is authorized to carry on during the

present biennium.

.

Hon. H. A. Beckwith, page 5 ,(V-1307)

It’,18 clear that all payments and allOWaZXe8 to

the Canadian River Commissioner must be paid from the ap-

propriationmade In House Bill 805, m.’ The emergency

clause of that Act Indicates that one of its primary pur-

poses was to provide funds “to oay the actual expenses of

the Commissioner in the performance of the duties of his

office. ’ The authority of the Interstate Compact Commis-

sion was limited to the necessary investigating and pro-

curing of data leading up to, and the negotiation of, com-

pacts for the Red, Sab~ine,and Canadian Rivers. The ne-

gotiations relating to the Canadian River have been com-

pleted, and the compact Is now in effect. Therefore, under

the terms of the statute setting up the Interstate Compact

Commlealon, the authority it had as to the Canadian River

is at ari end.

The general statute authorizing the Sabine River

Authority to negotiate a compact relating to that river is

in partial conflict with the earlier statute whlch,set up

the Interstate Compact Commission and invested it with au-

thority to negotiate a compact for the Sablne River. The

latter statute gives to the Board of Directors of the Sa-

bine River Authority the pouera to carry on “an and all ne-

otiations necessary to secure such a compact etweenxe-

hexas and the State of Louisiana.” gphasia add-

ed.) However, the duty and authority “to make the necessary

investigations and procure the necessary data” for the ne-

gotiation of a Sabine River Compact was not removed from

the Interstate CompactCommIssIoner or repealed by the lat-

ter act. It appears that the Legislature intended that

this type of work be continued out of funds appropriated

for the Interstate Compact Commission in order to assist

the Sabine River Authority in its negotiations.

In view of the above, the appropriation to the-’

Interstate Compact Commission may be expended for the sal-

aries and expenses of the Commission in investigating and

procuring data for, and the negotiating of, a Red River

Compact, and for investigating and procuring data relating

to the negotiation of a Sabine River Compact. There 18 no

requirement as to division of the appropriated funds be-

tween the rivers mentioned, this being a matter necessar-

ily controlled by the needs in each instance.

SUMMARY

The Canadian River Compact Commissioner should

be paid his expenses and allowances from the appro-

priation contained in H.B. 805, ncts 52nd Leg.,1951,

Hon. H. A. Beckwith,,page 6 (V-1307)

ch. 446,. p. 803 (Art. 7466by V.C,S.) rather than

from the appropriation for the Interstate Compact

Commission contained in the general appropriation

bill, H.B. 426, ,ACtB52nd Leg.,,1951.

The latter appropriation may be ~expended for

investigating and procuring data for, and the ne-

gotiation of, a Red River ,Compact; and in lnvesti-

gating and procuring data,for the use of the Sa-

in negotiating a Sabine River

bine River ,Authori.ty~,

Compact.

APPROVED: Yours very truly,

Jesse P. Luton, Jr. PRICE DANIEL

Reviewing ASSiStant Attorney General

Everett Hutchlnson

&eCUtiVe ASBiBtSnt

Charles D. Mathews

First ASSiStant

~EWT:et

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.