Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1951
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

E f%TTOKNEY GENERAL

OF TEXAS

PRICE DANIEL

ATTORXEY CE:NEBAI.

October 10, 1951

Hon. George B. Butler, Chairman

Board of Insurance Commissioners

Austin, Texas Opinion No. V-1313

Re: Procedure for reporting

the percentage of United

States Bonds held by an

out-of-State life insur-

ance company under Ar-

Dear Mr. Butler: title 4769, V.C.S.

Your letter requesting our opinion in reference to the

above-captioned matter reads in part as follows:

“Please see Article 4769 enacted by H.B. 471 of

the 51st Legislature, and particularly the following pro-

vision of Section 1:

” ‘Each such insurance organization shall also re-

port to the Board of Insurance Commissioners on or

before the first day of March of each year the amount

that it had invested on the 31st day of December, pre-

ceding, in Texas securities as defined by Article 4766

of the Revised Civil Statutes of Texas, 1925, as amend-

ed, and the amount that it had invested on said date in

similar securities in the State in which it had its high-

est percentage of admitted assets invested, and in corn-

puting the amount of such investments it shall include

as a part thereof that percentage of its investments in

bonds of the United States of America that its reserves

on policies of insurance issued on the lives of persons

residing or domiciled in Texas ark= of its total reserves

on all policies outstanding, but in no event shall it in-

clude any amount of such bonds in excess of the amount

thereof reported by said company as Texas securities

in its Texas tax return covering the year 1946.’

“Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, Fort

Wayne, Indiana, is an out-of-State life insurance corn-

pany licensed in Texas. For the purpose of this request

for opinion, we can assume that the company’s reserves

for policies issued on the lives of persons residing or

domiciled in Indiana are considerably in excess of its

Hon. George B. Butler, Page 2 (V-1313)

reserves on policies issued on the lives of persons

residing or domiciled in Texas. When the Company

filed its tax return for the year 1950, it reported the

same figure for its Government Bonds in the column

reflecting its Texas securities that it did in the col-

umn setting out its similar securities in the State of

Indiana.

61

. . .

“There is some difference of viewpoint in the

Department as to the effect of the changes made in the

quoted portion of Article 4769 as against the corre-

sponding provision in Article 4769-a before its repeal.

“Will you please advise me whether Article 4769

permits out-of-State life insurance companies admitted

in Texas to report as ‘similar securities in the state

in which it had its highest percentage of admitted as-

sets invested’ that percentage of its investments in the

Bonds of the United States that its Texas reserves are

of its total reserves, or should such a company report

as similar securities that percentage of its investment

in United States Bonds that its reserves on policies is-

sued on the lives of persons residing or domiciled in

the state in which the company had the highest percent-

age of its admitted assets invested are to the company’s

total reserves on all of its outstanding policies? ”

Article 4769, V.C.S., prior to its amendment in 1949

(House Bill 471, Acts Slst Leg., R.S. 1949, ch. 619, p. 1362), pro-

vided a method of reporting the percentage of United States Bonds

held by out-of-State insurance companies as follows:

“Each such insurance organization shall also re-

port to the Board of Insurance Commissioners on or

before the first day of March of each year the amount

that it had invested on the 31st day of December, pre-

ceding, in Texas securities as defined by Article 4766

of the Revised Civil Statutes of Texas, 1925, as amend-

ed, and the amount that it had invested on said date in

similar securities in the state in which it had its high-

est percentage of admitted assets invested, and in com-

puting the amount of such investments in such other

state it shall include as a part thereof that percentage

of its investments in bonds of the United States of Amer-

ica purchased between December 8, 1941, and the ter-

mination of the war in which the United States is now

engaged that its reserves on policies of insurance is-

sued on the lives of persons residing or domiciled in

Hon. George 8. Butler, Page 3 (V-1313)

such state are of its total reserves on all policies out-

standing. ” (Emphasis added.)

The 51st Legislature amended Article 4769 by House

Bill 471 (Acts 51st Leg., R.S. 1949, ch. 619, p. 1362) so as to change

the method of computing the securities in the state in which out-of-

State insurance companies had their highest percentage of admitted

assets invested. Such amended act, with certain omissions deemed

immaterial, is as follows:

“Each such insurance organization shall also re-

port . * * the amount that it had invested . . . in Texas

securities . . , and the amount that it had invested on

said date in similar securities in the State in which it

had its highest percentage of admitted assets invested,

and in computing the amount of such investments it

shall include as a part thereof that percentage of its

investments in bonds of the United States of America

that its reserves on policies of insurance issued on

the lives of persons residing or domiciled in Texas

are of its total reserves on all policies outstanding,

II

. . .

The language used in this amendment is plain and un-

ambiguous, and therefore is not susceptible of construction.

You are therefore advised that an out-of-State life in-

surance company in its annual report to the Board of Insurance

Commissioners should show the amount that it had invested on the

31st day of December, preceding, in securities, similar to Texas

securities, in the state in which it had its highest percentage of ad-

mitted assets invested; and such insurance company in computing

the amount of such investments should include as a part thereof

that percentage of its investments in bonds of the United States of

America that its reserves on policies of insurance issued on the

lives of persons residing or domiciled in Texas are of its total re-

serves on all policies outstanding. However, in making such report

it should not include any amount of such bonds in excess of the a-

mount thereof reported by said company as Texas securities in its

Texas tax return covering the year 1946, as provided in House Bill

471, Acts 51st Leg., R.S. 1949, ch. 619, p. 1362.

SUMMARY

An out-of-State life insurance company in its

annual report to the Board of Insurance Commission-

ers should show the amount that it had invested on the

31st day of December, preceding, in securities simi-

lar to Texas securities, in the state in which it had

Hon. George 8. Butler, Page 4 (V-13 13)

its highest percentage of admitted assets invested;

and the insurance company in computing the amount

of these investments should include as a part thereof

that percentage of its investments in bonds of the

United States of America which its reserves on poli-

cies of insurance issued on the lives of persons re-

siding or domiciled in Texas are of its total reserves

on all policies outstanding. However, in making this

report it should not include any amount of such bonds

in excess of the amount reported by said company as

Texas securities in its Texas tax return covering the

year 1946, as provided in House Bill 471, Acts 51st

Leg., R.S. 1949, ch. 619, p. 1362.

Yours very truly,

PRICE DANIEL

Attorney General

APPROVED:

W. V. Geppert

Jesse P. Luton. Jr. Assistant

Reviewing Assistant

Everett Hutchinson

Executive Assistant

Charles D. Mathews

First Assistant

WVG/mwb

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.