Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1951
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

November 30, 1951

Hon. C. H. Cavness Opinion No. V-1361

State Auditor

Austin, Texas Re: Several questions concerning

the disposition of soil conser-

vation district funds under

House Bill 97, Acts 5lst Leg.,

R.S. 1949, and House Bill 190,

Dear Sir: Acts 52nd Leg., R.S. 1951.

The first of the questions which you have submitted

for our consideration reads as follows:

“1. Should the total amount to be repaid the

State General Revenue Fund by each District as pro-

vided in Section 5, House Bill No. 190, 52nd Legisla-

ture, be construed to be the total sum of money paid

to the District as provided for in both House Bill No.

97 of the 51st Legislature, R.S., and House Bill 190

of the 52nd Legislature, or will it be the unexpended

sum reappropriated to the District only by House Bill

No. 190 of the 52nd Legislature, R.S.?”

In connection with this question, you submit the fol-

lowing:

“In regard to question No. 1, herein, the State

Soil Conservation Board has advised the various State

Soil Conservation Districts’ Boards of Supervisors

that the total amount each District will be required to

repay will be the amount of the unexpended balance at

August 31st, 1951, that is reappropriated by the provi-

sions of House Bill No. 190.

“On page 2 of your Opinion No. V-l 197 addressed

to Governor Allan Shivers, you have stated in part:

a ‘It is our opinion that House Bill No. 190, if it

becomes law, would be valid; that the provisions there-

of are in pari materia with the provisions of House Bill

No. 97; and that both Acts should be construed together

to make a harmonious whole.‘

Hon. C. H. Cavness, Page 2 (V-1361)

“In our audits of the various districts’ accounts

and records, we have found a considerable variation

between the Districts’ unexpended balances that will

result in a relatively small amount being repaid by

some Districts, whereas other Districts will be re-

quired to repay a considerable portion or all of the

money they have received from the State, if they pay

only the amount appropriated to them by House Bill

No. 190. On the other hand, if Section 5 of House Bill

No. 190 applies to the amount appropriated by both

House Bill No. 97, 51st Legislature, and House Bill

No. 190,‘52nd Legislature, all Districts would be re-

quircd to ultimately repay the total amount that has

been appropriated to them.”

Sections 1 and 2 of House Bill 190, Acts 52nd Leg.,

R.S. 1951, ch. 497, p. 1206, read as follows:,

“Section 1. The unexpended balances of all sums

appropriated to and granted the several soil conserva-

tion districts of Texas for the fiscal year ending Au-

gust 31, 1950, and for the fiscal year ending August 31,

1951, are hereby reappropriated and granted to such

soil conservation districts. A soil conservation dis-

trict shall be eligible to receive grants for each period

of the biennium after it has been duly organized and a

Certificate of Organization for the district has been

approved and signed by the Secretary of State. All

grants to soil conservation districts shall be made by

the State Soil Conservation Board based on the Board’s

determination of equity and need of the district apply-

ing for the grant.

“Sec. 2. Approval of all grants of assistance to

soil conservation districts as provided in this Act

shall be certified to the State Comptroller of Public

Accounts by the State Soil Conservation Board. Such

certification or approval by the State Soil Conserva-

tion Board, presented to the Comptroller, shall be suf-

ficient authority for the Comptroller to issue his war-

rants against any appropriation made for grants to soil

conservation districts and shall be also sufficient au-

thority for the State Treasurer to honor payment of

such warrants.

* ..

. . .

Section 5 of House Bill 190 reads, in part, as follows:

Hon. C. H. Cavness, Page 3 (V-1361)

. .: .’ It ,is further provided that each district

receiving funds under this Act shall pay five per cent

(5%) of any sums received as,rental payments on

equipment or machinery under lease to the State Treas-

ury for deposit in the General Fund, until the funds re-

ceived~by’a district under this Act shall have been re-

paid in full.”

From your statement in connection with your first

question, it is obvious that the State Soil Conservation Board in-

terprets Section 1 of House Bill 190 as reappropriating the unex-

pended balances of State appropriated funds previously allocated

to individual soil conservation districts directly to the districts

having such unexpended balances on hand at the end of the past

biennium. We are in accord with this interpretation. However,

such unexpended balance may or may not be the total amount which

a district will be called upon to repay under Section 5. There re-

mained in the State Treasury at the end of the past biennium an

unexpended balance ‘of the appropriation previously made to the

several soil conservation districts by House Bill 97, Acts 51st

Leg;, R.S. 1949, ch; 540, p. 1000. This unexpended balance was

likewise reappropriated and granted by House Bill 190 for alloca-

tion during the biennium to the various districts by the State Board

as provided in Sections 1 and 2 above quoted. Such grants when

received by the districts will unquestionably be funds received “un-

der this Act” and must necessarily be included in ascertaining the

total to be repaid under Section 5.

We do not think that State appropriated funds received

by individual districts under the provisions of House Bill 97 but

expended prior to the end of the past biennium should be included

in determining the amount to be repaid under Section 5. Gnly funds

received “under this Act” are required to be repaid. Funds ex-

pended prior to the end of the last biennium did not constitute any

part of the “unexpended balances” which were reappropriated by

House Bill 190. In addition to the excerpt which you quote from

Opinion V-1197 (1951), we call your attention to these additional

portions of Opinion V-1197:

“The caption of House Bill No. 190 states that

it is ‘an Act amending House ,Bill No. 97, Acts of the

Fifty-first Legislature, Regular Session, 1949. . . .’

~The body of the bill does not state that it is amending

said House Bill, and in reality does not do so except

by necessary implication and then only as to certain

provisions of House Bill No. 97, Acts 51st Leg., R.S.

1949, ch. 540, p. 1000, that are in conflict with the

provisions of House Bill No. 190, Acts 52nd Leg., R.S.

1951.

.

Hon. C. H. Cavness, Page 4 (V-1361)

“It is our opinion that there is no fatal conflict

between the caption and the body of House Bill 190.

We have carefully examined the caption of House Bill

No. 190 in connection with the body of the bill and have

concluded that the Act constitutes a complete bill with-

in itself and that the caption is sufficiently broad to

cover the various provisions contained in the body of

the bill. The portion of the caption of House Bill No.

190 which states that it is amending House Bill No. 97

should be rejected as surplusage. 1 Sutherland on

Statutory Construction (3rd Ed. 1943) 328.”

.’

_ Viewing House Bill 190 as a complete bill within it-

self rather than as an amendatory act, we do not think that funds

received ‘under this Act” can be properly construed to embrace

the sums received and expended under the provisions of House

Bill 97, a prior and entirely different act of the Legislature. It

is true that some districts will, as pointed out by you, be required

to repay a greater proportion of the State funds which they have.

received than will others. Nevertheless, under our interpretation

of Section 5, the requirement for repayment operates prospective-

ly only, rather than retroactively. Its fairness lies in the fact

that it is imposed with .full notice; its practicality, in the fact that,

being foreseen, it may be provided for.

<

Our answer to your first question precludes consid-

eration of your second, which is predicated on the assumption that

Section 5 of House Bill 190 requires repayment by districts of all

funds received under House Bill 97 and House Bill 190.

Your third question reads as follows:

“If a District at August 31st. 1953, has on hand :

any part of the sums appropriated by House Bill No.

190 of the 52nd Legislature, will such unexpended bal-

ance be required to be refunded to the General Reve-

nue Fund at that time? ”

In replying to your first question, we pointed out that

the unexpended balances of funds which had been allocated to dis-

tricts under House Bill 97 were included in the reappropriation

made by House Bill 190 of “the unexpended balances of all sums

appropriated to and granted the several soil conservation districts

of Texas for the fiscal year ending August 31, 1950, and for the

fiscal year ending August 31, 1951 . . .” Both these unexpended

balances and all other funds which may be granted to the individ-

ual districts as provided by House Bill 190 remain a part of the

appropriation made by House Bill 190 unless and until they are

properly expended. However, such funds as are not expended at

t

,

Hon. C. H. Cavness, Page 5 (V-1361)

the end of the cu~rrent biennium will revert to the General Revenue

Fund. This is so for the reason that under Section 6 of Article

VIII of the Constitution of Texas no appropriation may be made for

a longer term than two years. Therefore, at the end of the two-

year period the appropriation becomes ineffective; and any bal-

ance remaining therein must necessarily lapse. Att’y Gen. Ops.

2941 (1940) and V-316 (1947).

We next quote your fourth question and remarks in

connection therewith:

“*ill the five per cent (5%) of any sums received

as -cental payments on equipment or machinery, as pro-

vided in Section 5 of House Bill No. 190, 52nd Legisla-

ture, apply to District-owned equipment operated by the

District as well as to such equipment leased out to the

landowners?

“With reference to question No. 4, we have found

that some equipment will be operated by employees of

the District and the landowner charged an agreed sum,

whereas other equipment will be operated by the land-

owner who will pay rental for the use of it.

“From a practical standpoint, if the salaries or

wages paid ,the District employees~ during the perform-

ance of the work were deducted from the total charges

for it, the resulting balance would correspond approxi-

mately to the rental charges made for that type of equip-

ment operated by the landowner.”

Section 5 of House Bill 190 reads as follows:

“To carry out the purposes of the soi~l conserva-

tion district program as is provided in the State Soil

Conservation Law, supervisors may acquire by lease

or purchase machinery and equipment and operate such

machinery or equipment or may furnish same under

lease or rental agreement at prices being currently

charged for such services; provided, however, that the

charge in any particular project shall never be less

than the actual cost to the particular district for rea-

sonable rental, labor, maintenance, depreciation and

replacement of equipment. It is further provided that

each district receiving funds under this Act shall pay

five per cent (5%) of any sums received as rental pay-

ments on equipment or machinery under lease to the

State Treasury for deposit in the General Fund, until

c the funds received

have been repaid

by a district

in full.”

under this Act shall

. . .I

Hon. C. H. Cavness, Page 6 (V-1361)

This section clearly contemplates two types of opera-

tions. In some instances the district will operate the machinery

and equipment, procuring the labor necessary for such operations,

and in other cases the machinery or equipment will be leased or

rented to individual landowners who will operate the equipment

themselves or otherwise supply the necessary labor for such op-

erations. It is true that if the salaries or wages paid employees

or laborers secured by the district for performing the operations

were deducted from the total job charge for a project, the balance

might be compared to a rental charge for the equipment. How-.

ever, in such cases the agreement between the landowner and the

district would ‘constitute a contract for the entire job or project.

The consideration or price paid by the landowner would not, in

either legal or common parlance, be termed a rental payment.

Since the Legislature has expressly limited the sums from which

five per cent is to be taken to “sums received as rental payments

on machinery or equipment under lease,” we are of the opinion

that five per cent should not be deducted from sums received for

operations conducted by the district.

SUMMARY

The total amount required to be paid to the Gen-

eral Revenue Fund under Section 5, House Bill 190,

Acts 52nd Leg., R.S. 1951, ch. 497, p. 1206, is the a-

mount of the soil conservation district’s unexpended

balance of State appropriated funds which was on hand

at the end of the past biennium, plus the amount of any

additional State funds which may be granted the dis-

trict during the current biennium by virtue of House

Bill 190. Any unexpended balance of sums appropri-

ated and granted to a district under House Bill 190

will revert to the General Revenue Fund August 3 1,

1953. Tex. Const. Art. VIII, Sec. 6. The requirement

that five per cent of sums received as rental payments

on equipment or machinery under lease shall be paid

to the State Treasury does not apply to sums paid to

districts by the landowner for projects conducted by

the district.

APPROVED: Yours very truly,

W. V. Geppert PRICE DANIEL

Taxation Division Attorney General

Everett Hutchinson

Executive Assistant %Vh.d&%%~ ti

Mrs. Marietta MC regor Creel

Charles D. Mathews Assistant

First Assistant

MMC/mwb

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.