Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1952
Status
Published
On the bench
Price Daniel
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

T~E:ATTORNEY GENERAL

OF TEXAS

AUWTIN~I.%-EXAS

PRICEDANIEL

ATTORNEY GENERAL

March 6, 1952

Hon. Larry 0. cox

Executive Director

Board for Texas State

Hospitals and Special schools

Austin, Texas

opinion, Do. v-1416

Re: Legality of making pay-

ments after August 31,

1951, under architect

ma building contracts

0ii0cutea prior to sep-

Dear Mr. Cox: tember 1, 1949.

Your request for an opinion relates to the

,legallty of the issuance of four warrants to pay for

part of the construction costs of a building of the

Terre11 State Hospital* The State Comptroller has

taken the position that he is unable to issue the

warrants because of the prohibition contained in Ar-

ticle 4357, V.C.S., against the payment of claims

which are not presented within two years from the

close of the fiscal year for which the appropriation

was made.

The 50th Legislature appropriated to the

Terre11 State Hospital for the fiscal year 1947-1948,

the sum of ~1,500,000 go be used for replacing “wards

for wings of 0ia Main Building aa Hospltal,~~ ma re-

appropriated for the fiscal year 1948-1949 any unex-

pended balance of this suma The same appropriation

act authorized the acceptance of federal aid for build-

‘Xngs, improvements apd~repairs at the eleemosynary In-

sti.tutionse Acts 90th Leg. 1947, ch. 330 pb 566, at

PP. 585, a3. Pursuant to this authorization an agree-

ment was made whereby federal funds in the amount of

ig;riOt;ere granted for this project, payable in in-

Contracts fo,r the building were let prior

to Septemb& 1, 1949. Installments of the federal

grant have been received from time to time, and the

Comptroller has credited the amount of each installment,

as It Was received, to his Account ~0~ ~-1163 covering

this construction project.

T-!cn. Larr:: 0. Cox, page 2 (v-1416)

On Lugust 31, 1951, r.:hich marked the ex-

piration of two years from the close of the fiscal

year 19)t8-1949, the $1,500,000 appropriated from

the General Revenue Fund of the State and all but

a small balance of the federal funds which had been

received up to that time had been paid out on war-

ran%s of the Comptroller. At that time there re-

mained outstanding the claims of various contractors

for materials and services furnished in the construc-

tion of this building. These unpaid claims form the

basis of your opinion request. You state that the

claimants submitted purchase vouchers to the Board

for Texas State Hospitals and Special Schools (which

has succeeded to the powers and duties of the Board

of Control in respect to the Terre11 State Hospital)

and that the business manager for the Board approved

the vouchers before August 31, 199. However, at

that time the last installment of federal money had

not been received and there was not sufficient money

on hand in the State Treasury for the payment of

these claims, and consequently the Board did not im-

mediately forward the vouchers to the Comptroller.

The final inst-llment of the federal grant was re-

ceived for deposit in the State Treasury on October

11, 1951. Thereupon, the Board forwarded these

claims to the Comptroller for payment, and the Comp-

troller declined to issue the warrants for the rea-

son stated above.

The pertinent provision of Article 4357

reads:

‘I . e 0 No claim shall be paid from

appropriations unless presented to the

Comptroller for payment within two (2)

years from the close of the fiscal year

for which such appropriations were made,

but any claim not presented for payment

within such period may be presented to the

Legislature as other claims for which no

appropriations are available-”

The appropriation acts In both 1949 and

1951, after authorizing the acceptance of federal

grants in substantially the same language as the 1947

act, contain a provision that “any funds received

. 0 . .?rom the United States Government are hereby

appropriated to the purposes for which the grant was

. -

Hon. Larry 0. Cox, page 3 N-1416)

mBa6.** Acts 51rt Leg., R.8, 1949 chb 553, pb 1070,

1083* mu 52na kegP S 1951 oh. 499 p ‘~

?t228: at p! 1297. Thi8 l&&& Is bkaa snouih io

include funds rrcrlve& under previously authorized

agreements , au we52 a8 mmdrr a@eements entered into

;;;;;nt to the authocb8ttor eontainsd in the act

. In this ease, inrtaIlrmts of the federal

grant have bran rocslrrd in suerreading blrnniums and

have bosn credited to the Comptroller’s Account ho.

~-11~63 as they were r~o%veQ.

The grorislon of Article 4357 here Involved

is a limitation rtatute, ad It must be construed In

the light of the object iCnr it6 rMotmedt. The pur-

pose of this provlrica was to lllnlmate a necessity

for the Cowtroller to cm*jr rtale appropriation ac-

counts on his books ia tk l&Nllhbod that there might

be outstanding claimi agatmt Maa. Xt was not de-

signed to affect the pa t of clal*s against ac-

counts which have b-n r fi orrrrmt by reappropriation

or by the receipt of ad&lttomrl funds to be credited

to them. So $.sr as the, ComptrolPerCa acoy\untim$ pro-

cedure is .concexnrd, :thk aplNev&%atlon of the ortion

of’ this baildim aeegmmt, irprarente4 by fedora P grants

dates from ttiii” 3 ,W” of ‘

m&r norlpt for Ueposit In

the State Treasury; ,‘vrdem Mube facts, we are of the

opinion that fbe *f4.rcal.- oar llor which such appro-

priations were made” s he3 d be eenstrued to mean thb

fiscal fear durtig v&lob tko ap#xoPslatod funds became

available for disburwmwt~ DEW al1 the funds now’

.available in Account Ilo* L-11 %3 wore added to that ac-

count within the statutory pWi6d, it Is our opinion

that the c’omptrolleF may pro8sntly issue warrants

against the account 3s pay&at of the claims in ques-

tion.

Claim prem1YC06 to the C0mptrollor

wittcla two y6arr f?om tb closr of the

fiscal year In which, the funds for their

payment become availablr for disburrement

Hon. Larry 0. Cox, page 4 (v-1416)

are noLbarred by the limitation pro-

vision Ian Article 4357, V.C.S.

Yours very truly,

PRICE DANIEL

APPROVED: Attorney General

E. Jacobson

Reviewing Assistant

Charles D. Mathews -Mary K. wall

First Assistant Assistant

MKW:wb

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.