Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1954
Status
Published
On the bench
John Ben Shepperd
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

NElZAL

Ron. Ii. A. Beckwlth, Chairman

Board of Water Engineers

302 W. 15th St.

Austin, Texas Opinion No. S-134

Re: Whether the provision for

reverslon of water rights

to the State on dissolution

of a water control and im-

provement district, con-

tained in Article 7880-77b,

V.C.S., is automatic.

Dear Sir:

Your opinion request of March 23, 1954 reflects

the following facts:

In 1931, your Board issued a permit to Al and

Lloyd Parker to appropriate 10,034 acre-feet of water per

annum from the Rio Grande in Cameron County for the pur-

pose of irrigating 5,017 acres of land and to create a

reservoir with a storage capacity of 5,017 acre-feet, the

permit providing that the water was to be diverted into

the reservoir by means of a designated canal. The day

after the permit was issued, the Parkers transferred the

permit and all rights thereunder to Cameron County Water

Control & Improvement District No. 18. Such district,

while still,record owner of the permit, was dissolved on

July 31, 1940 under Article 7880-77b, V.C.S.

Reports were filed in 1930k 1931 ;nd 1932 show-

ing only partial completion of the plant. No further

reports having been received, your Board held a hearing

in 1942 to cancel the permit butdismissed the proceed-

ings when A. F. Parker protested in writing. Parker filed

reports only for 1943 and 1946, each reflecting no use of

the water and admitting the permit had been inactive for

a "number of years." On September 28, 1953, your 3oard

cancelled the permit without notice or hearing. Affida-

vits recently filed reflect that 1,000 acres were irrigated

. .

Hon. H. A. Beckwith - page 2 (No.S-134)

in 1929, 1931 and 1932 and are now being irrigated,

but no reservoir was ever created.

As we interpret your letter, your purpose is to

ascertain the validity of your action cancelling the afore-

said permit, and based on that assumption, we shall answer

your letter accordingly.

Articles 7474, 7519 and 7544, V.C.S., provide for

forfeiture of a permit under circumstances such as above

outlined. The first two statutes: above mentioned contain

provisions requiring notice and hearing.

Article 7880-77b deals with dissolution of water

control and improvement districts and provides that when the

assets of the district have been liquidated and all debts

paid, '. . _ the directors of the district shall enter of

record their final order of dissolution . . . and thereupon

any water rights held from the State shall revert to the

State and may not, in anticipation of dissolution, be as-

signed by the district to be so dissolved."

There is no provision in said statute for notice,

and its terms indicate the reversion is intended~ to be auto-

matic. Indeed, there would seem to be no reason for notice

or hearing. The permit was an asset of the district at the

time of its dissolution. Such districts are arms of the

State government. The directors of the district are "the

managing officers in charge of all the business and affairs

of the district. o . ;" Art. 7880-36, V,C.S.

The entry of the order of dissolution by the Board

of Directors under Art. 7880-77b, V.C.S., was a voluntary

act. The initiative was theirs, not the StateIs. They are

presumed to know the legal consequences of their acts, and

doubtless they did know, since the statute under which they

acted in dissolving the district also provides for the re-

version. It would seem unreasonable to give notice and have

a hearing to protect the permit holder against the plain

statutory consequences of its own voluntary act. The statute

is plain, and even if notice and hearing were had, there is

no authority given to the Board of Water Engineers or to any

other agency to deny the reversion.

We hold, therefore; that the permit automatically

reverted to the State at the time of the dissolution of the

district.

Hon. H. A. Deckwith, page 3 (S-134)

SUMMARY

Upon dissolution of a water control

and improvement district under Article

7880-77b, V.&s., a water permit owned

by said district automatically, without

notice or hearing, reverts to the State.

Yours very truly,

JORRBRN SREPPRRD

Attorney General

J. Arthur Sandlin

APPROVD: Assistant

John Atchison

Land Division

Willis E. Gresham

Reviewer

Robert S. Trotti

~First Assistant

John Ben Shepperd

Attorney General

JAS:bt

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.