Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1957
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

TREA~~~ORNEY GENERAL

OFTEXAS

gag 16, 1957.

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, Opinion No. WW-134

Executive Director,

State Boardsof Control, Re: Does the Board of Con-

Austin, Texas. trol have authority to

waive performance under

a construction contract

awarded on bids when the

contractor later claims

that he did not include

certain items in his bid

which were shown on the

drawings made a part of

Dear Mr. Burke: the bid invitation?

You have requested our opinion on the following

question:

"Does the Board of Control have authority

to waive performance under a construction

contract awarded on bids when the contractor

later claims that he did not include certain

items in his bid which were shown on the

drawings made a part of the bid invitation?"

In reply to our request for additional information,

you have stated:

"Bids were originally received for this pro-

ject on June 9, 1955 and were rejected due to

the fact that they exceeded the appropriation.

The window schedule on Sheet 506-3 of drawings

in Group 5, Division A calls for Venetian blinds

in certain windows of Building 506. Venetian

blinds were not indicated in any other part of

the plans and specifications. However, in the

second paragraph under Art. 9 of the General

Conditions of the Specifications is the following

statement, 'Unless otherwise specified, all

materials shall be new and both workmanship and

materials shall be of good quality. The Contract-

or shall, if required, furnish satisfactory evi-

dence as to the kind and quality of materials.'

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, page 2 ww-134

"Bids were received on the revised plans

and specifications on July 14, 1955, and the

contract was awarded to 9. 0. & C. D. Yar-

brough Construction Co. The plans and speci-

fications relating to the Venetian blinds were

not changed in any way in the revised set.

"If the plans and specifications concerning

Venetian blinds were changed, they were changed

by the Architects prior to the original advertise-

ment for bids and issuance of the plans and speci-

fications to bidders."

Under agreement dated August 16, 1955, 9. 0. and C.D.

Yarbrough Construction Co. has agreed to provide all the

materials and perform all of the work as shown by the draw-

ings and described in the specifications prepared by Fehr

and Granger, and Niggli and Gustafson, associated Architects,

and under the agreement the drawings and specifications pre-

pared by such Architects are made a part of the contract for

all purposes.

In the drawings of Group V, Division A, Sheet 3, the

window schedule contained therein requires that Venetian

blinds shall be affixed to the windows of Building No. 506.

In the written specifications there are no specific details

written concerning these Venetian blinds. However, in the

second paragraph of Article 9, of the General Conditions of

the specifications, the following statement is found:

"Unless otherwise speciffed, all materials

shall be of good quality. The Contractor shall,

if required, furnish satisfactory zvldence as to

the kind and quality of materials.

Since the Contractor has agreed to install Venetian

blinds to the windows of Building 506 by agreeing to perform

all of the work and furnish all materials called for in the

drawings and since this was a condition upon which all bld-

derswere required to bid, it Is our opinion that the Board of

Control does not have the authority to waive the performance

of this condition of the contract, and that the Contractor

is required to install Venetian blinds in accordance with the

provisions of the General Conditions above quoted.

The above answer to your question is not to be con-

strued as preventing the Board of Control from entering a

change order for removing the Venetian blfnds from the con-

tract, provided appropriate credits are given by the Con-

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, wk3e 3 WV-134

tractor, pursuant to the specifications.

SUMMARY

The Board of Control does not have

authority to waive performance under

a construction contract awarded on

bids, when the contractor later claims

that he did not include certain items

in his bid, which were s~hownon the

drawings made a part of the bid

invitations.

Yours very truly,

WILL WIISON

Attorney General

JR:pf:rh

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

H. Grady Chandler,

Chairman

L. P. Lollar

J. L. Smith

Grundg Williams

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

By: Geo. P. Blackburn

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.