Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1957
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

THE ATrORNEY GENEWAL

OF TEXAS

Honorable H. C. Plttman, Jr.,

Chairman, Ipdustrlal Accident

Board,

Walton Building,

Austin, Texas Opinion No. WW- 333.

Re: Effect of Section 2 of

House Bill No, 433, Acts

55th Legislature, Regular

Session 1957 (Chapter 397,

page 1186) on authority of

Industrlal Accident Board

to approve compromise set-

Dear Mr. Plttman: tlement agreements.

In your letter of November 8, 1957, you ask:

"Will you give us your opinion as to whether

or not this Board has authorlty to approve a Compro-

mise Settlement Agreement which closes the llablllty

of an Insurance carrier for euture medical and hos-

pital expense under the Workmen's Compensation Act

as amended, I.e. does the word\awardl and the wording

used In the amendment to Section 5 apply to compromise

settlements and take precedence over Section 12, Art-

icle a307v

You further point out that Section 12 of Article 8307,

Revised Civil Statutes, gives the Board authority to approve

compromise settlement agreements under certain conditions, and

that House Blll No. 433, amending Section 5 of Article 8307,

changes the llablllty of Insurance carriers as to medical and

hospital expenses.

Section 2 of House Bill No. 433 reads as follows:

'Sec. 2. Section 5 of Article 8307, Revised

Civil Statutes of Texas, 1925, as amended, Is hereby

amended by adding a new paragraph at the end of said

Section to read as follows:

"lNotwlthstandlngany other provision of thls

law, as amended, no award of the Board, and no judgment

Honorable H. C. Pittman, Jr., Page 2 (W-333).

of the court, havlng jurisdiction of a claim against

the association for the oost or expense of Items of

medical aid, hospital services, nursing, chlropraotlc

,servlces,medicines or prosthetic appliances furnished

to an employee under circumstances creating a llabll-

lty therefor on the part of the association under the

provisions of thle law, shall Include In such award or

judgment any cost or expense of any such Items-

actually furnished to and received by the employee

prior to the date of said award or judgment. The

first such final award or ment rendered on such

claim shall be remlcata of the llablllty of the

association forall such cost or expense which could

have been claimed up to the date of said award or

judgment and of the Issue that the Injury-aid

employee Is subject to the provlslons of this law with

respect to such Items, but shall not be res Judlcata

of the obligation of the association to furnish or pay

for any such Item8 after the date of said award or

judgment, . . .' (Emphasis ours)

The remainder of the paragraph provides for continuing

jurisdiction of the Board over the claim for additional medical

expenses and for appeals to the courts from each successive award

of such medical benefits.

The added paragraph relates only to awards (or denials)

of medical aid and, In our opinion, does not have any.bearlng on

the function of the Board In approving compromise settlement

agreements under Sec~tlon12. The making of awards and th$g;proval

of settlements are two distinct functions of the Board.

Board's approval of a compromise settlement agreement Is not an

award of compensation . . . Neither Is It an order denying compen-

sation." Commercial Casualty Co. v. Hilton, 187 S.W. 2d 1081

(Comm. Am., opinion approved by S. Ct.). The Board Is prohibited

from awarding the workman any money for future medical aid, but

there Is nothlng In the Act which would bar or dlmlnlsh the right

of the parties to enter Into a contract settling their rights and

llabllltles with respect to future medical expenses of the kind

referred to In the amendment. There being no amendment to Sec-

tion 12, and there being no mention elsewhere in the Act of the

role the Board Is to play In the approval or disapproval of com-

promise settlement agreements with respect to future medical aid,

the conclusion seems Inescapable that the Legislature Intended

no change with respect thereto.

The purpose of the amendment to Section 5 was to enable

the workman to obtain unlimited medical treatment. Although his

claim or cause of action Is broken down Into separate periods of

six months each, there Is nothing In the Act to Indicate that

his claim for future medical aid may not be settled by a

Honorable H. C. Plttman, Jr., Page 3 (ww-333).

compromise settlement agreement once and for all. It Is to be

assumed that the Legislature was cognizant of the rules of the

Board which require a showing that maximum recovery has been

reached before It wlll approve compromise settlements,and that

the Legislature contemplated that the Board would discharge Its

responslblllty to protect the +&red workman In this type of

settlement agreement, as It had done under the pre-existing law

where settlement agreements have embraced liability for future '

medical treatment.

Therefore, It Is our opinion that the amendment to

Sec. 5 of Art. 8307 does not alter the authorlty of the Indus-

trial Accident Board under Sec. 12, and the Board has authorl3.y

to approve compromise settlements which close the llabllltv of

an Insurance carrier for future medical and hospital expenses.

SUMMARY

Section 2 of House Bill No. 433, Acts of

Session,

the 55th Legislature, Regular-_. 1957

(Chapter 397, page 1186 at 1192) amending

Section 5 of Article 8307, Revised Civil

Statutes, does not alter the authority tid

duty of the Industrial Accident Board under

Section 12 with respect to the approval of

compromise settlement agreements, and this

authority extends to agreements which terml-

nate the llablllty of the carrier for future

medical and hospital expenses.

Yours very truly,

WILL WILSON

Attorney General of Texas

RRR:mg:pf Mac0 Stewart

APPROVED: Assistant

OPINION COMMITTEE

Geo. P. Blackburn, Chairman

J. C. Davis, Jr.

W. V. Geppert

Leonard Passmore

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

By: James N. Ludlum.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.