Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1957
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

E ORNEY @;ENEKRI,

OPTEXAS

Dr. E. N. Jones, President Opinion No. WW- 334

Texas Technological College

Lubbock, Texas Re::Whether Texas Technologi-

cal College may present

commercial television pro-

grams should the Federal

Communications Commis-

sion grant a television

channel for use by the

Dear Dr. Jones: College.

We quote from your request for an opinion as follows:

"In your opinion No, WW-5 under date of

Januarv 22, 1957, you ruled that:

"Yhe Board of Directors of Texas Tech-

nological College has the authority to

engage in educational television broad-

casting on a non-commercial basis pro-

vided that said Board, in the exercise

of sound discretion, determines that

such activity is reasonably necessary

for the accomplishment of the statutory

purposes of the college and within the

legitimate objects of its creation.'

"Also, the opinion contained the following:

"'Since the question is not raised by

your inquiry, this opinion shall not be

construed as dealing with the authority

of the college to engage in any type of

television broadcasting on a commercial

basis, in whole or in part s , .I

"It has now developed that there is need for

an opinion from you on the question of whether or

not Texas Technological College is empowered under

its charter to present commercl.altelevision pro-

grams should the Federal Communications Comrnis-

sion grant a television channel for use by the

College,

Dr. E. N. Jones, Page 2. (m-334)

"From the tenor of your opinion No. WW-5

and the cases cited therein, it would appear

that the primary purpose of a television chan-

nel for the College must necessarily be educa-

tional in nature. If a television channel

should be maintained by Texas Technological

College and primarily devoted to educational

purposes, would this prevent incidental com-

amming over facilities of the

~~~~~~~$?-"@-

Attorney Qeneral's Opinion WW-5 (1957) recognized

the authority of Texas Technological College to engage in

educational television broadcasting on a non-commercial basis

provided the Board of Directors of the College, in the exer-

cise of sound discretion, determines that such activity is

reasonably necessary for the accomplishment of the statutory

purposes of the College and within the legitimate objects of

itscreation. It was also pointed out in the foregoing opin-

ion that a college or university will ordinarily be accorded

the right to perform acts incidental to its main purpose, al-

though it will be denied the right to perform acts not reason-

ably incidental. The Legislature has seen fit to vest consid-

erable discretion in the governing boards of the various state

institutions of higher learning in determining what activities

come within the statutory purposes of such institutions. The

Board's determination is final except where it is made to appear

that its action constitutes a clear abuse of discretion.

An Attorney General's letter opinion, dated January

27, 1948, addressed to Honorable Frank C. Smith, President of

the Board of Directors of Texas College of Arts and Industries,

upheld the right of that institution to permit the installation

and operation of a broadcasting studio on the College campus.

In marking the limits of such authority, the opinion said:

"Thus, your Board is not authorized to

permit the construction on the campus of a

broadcasting studio to be used primarily for

commercial purposes, with only incidental

benefits to the college. The determination

of whether the proposed installation in ques-

tion meets the statutory requirements hereln-

before set out is a matter within the sound

discretion of your board."

Clearly, no agency of the state, which includes

Texas Technological College, has authority to engage in a

purely commercial undertaking for revenue raising purposes

unless authority therefor exists in the Constitution or statutes

i. _, _

Dr. E. N. Jones, page 3 (WW-334)

of the state. This does not mean, however, that an authorized

undertaking must be absolutely devoid of any commercial aspects,

or that an authorized activity is rendered unauthorized because

it incidentally yields revenue from its normal operations. The

undertaking becomes objectionable only when the production of

revenue becomes more than an incidental part of such undertaking.

Southwestern Broadcast Co. v. Oil Center Broadcast Co., (Civ.App.)

21o-s.w.

The acceptance of commercially sponsored programs

enables the student to acquaint himself with this vital aspect

of the Television Industrv, From a legal standpoint, it would

appear no more objectionable than for the College newspaper

to solicit and accept advertising for its pages. The activity,

in each instance, finds legal justification in the purposes to

be served. When the activity bears no relationship to such

authorized purposes, it becomes unauthorized.

You are accordingly advised that it is our opinion

that should the Federal Communications Commission grant a

television channel for use by Texas Technological College,

that said channel may accept, under state laws, commercially

sponsored programs provided that the Board of Directors of

the College, in the exercise of sound discretion, determine

that such programs have a reasonable relationship to the

authorized purposes of said station and to the statutory pur-

poses of the college.

SUMMARY

Should the Federal Communications

Commission grant a television chan-

nel for use by Texas Technological

College, said channel may accept

under state laws, commercially

sponsored programs, provided the

Board of Directors of the College,

in the exercise of sound discre-

tion, determines that such programs

Dr. E. N. Jones, page 4 (WW-3%)

have a reasonable relationship to the

authorized purposes of said station,

and to the statutory purposes of the

college.

Yours very truly,

WILL WILSON

Attorney General of Texas

:-

Lo.

By ~ < <

Leonard Passmore

LP:zt Assistant

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

Ceo, P. Blackburn, Chairman

J. C. Davis, Jr.

John H. Minton, Jr.

John Reeves

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

By: James N. Ludlum

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.