Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1958
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

~~HEA~ORNEY GENERAL

OFTEXAS

Honorable William J. Burke Opinion No. W-345

Executive Director

State Board of Control Re: The legal effect of House

Austin, Texas Concurrent Resolution No.

17, of the First Called

Session of the 55th Legls-

lature, 1957, purporting

to direct the Board of,

Control not to accept bids

for oil and by-products

from companies engaged in

the importation of crude

oil into the United States,

Dear Mr. Burke: and related questions.

Your request for an opinion.reads In part as follows:

“I am attaching a copy of House Concurrent Reso-

lution No. 17, introduced by Representatives Latimer,

Lee and Kennard.

“The Resolution directs the Board of Control not

to accept any bids for 011, etc., from firms that Import

crude oil or products into the United States or those

affiliated with such importing firma.

“The Board is also directed to study existing con-

tracts and make every effort to terminate said contracts

with oil Importers if it Is legally possible to do 80.

%l%e Board of Control purchases refined products

for the use of the State and State-owned vehicles. The

availability of adequate service and supply facilities

throughout the State Is directly related to the refining

capacity and distribution organization of the contracting

supplier. It has been found that even some of the ‘major’

011 and refining companies have limited and/or no dli-

trlbutlon of refined products In some portions of the

State. Some of the problems involved In purchasing from

Independent producers are refinery location and dlstri-

butlon facilities for refined products, a satisfactory

method for handling multiple lndeperdent contracts and

credit arrangements between the various contract areas

of the State, refined products of uniform quality and

Honorable William J. Burke, Page 2 (WW-345,

dependability. There are differences to be found In

petroleum products refined by various producers be-

cause of the method of processing and compounding and

the chemicals used therefor. This is particularly

true of lubricating oil and grease.

‘Our questions are as follows:

“(1) In order to be assured of adequate service

for the State's fuel and refined produ::ts needs, under

the Resolution, can we legally obtain and/or force

compliance leading to the Issuance of a certificate

from refiners certifying that the refined products

purchased for consumption by the State are refined

from Texas crude’? Would sue” certificate satisfy

the Intent of the Resolution?

“(2) In the event our examination of existing

contracts with refiners indicates that they are 011

importers but that said refiners are willln to

furnish a certificate such as described In f 1) above,

would the Board of Control be In violation of terms

of the Resolution to continue to purchase from refiners

with whom we now have contracts?

“(3) In the event our Investigation reveals that

the firms with whom we have State contracts are Importers,

and that they are unwilling to execute a certificate stat-

ing the products sold to the State are refined from Texas

crude oil; If we attempted to terminate the contracts as

directed by the Resolution, could they be legally terml-

nated without affording cause of legal actlun against

the State by present contract holders.

“(4) In the event the holders of our present con-

tracts for refined products are affiliated with 011

Importing companies, but refine the products which are

sold to the State of Texas from Texas crude oil and so

certify to that fact, what ,ls our position with reference

to compliance with the Resolution and particularly para-

graph 7; paragraph 87

“(5) In the event present contracts are terminated

and new bids are called for refined products, and upon

call for said bids we find thaL distribution of non-

Importing refiners f products 5.s ‘spotty’ ar,d/or limited

and that State-owned vehicles operating throughout the

State cannot be adequately served b:? the same and/or

other refiner contracts, what course of action Is open

Honorable William J. Burke, Page 3 (W-345)

to us to obtain supplies of fuel and oil products In

those areas where non-importing refiners are not

operating or do not have adequate distribution of their

refined products?

“(6) What form of statement by bidders should

be used?' Is such a statement form now available?

"(7) What authority and/or power of enforcement

does H.C.R. #17 bestow on the Board of Control with

which to effectuate the provisions of the Resolution?

House Concurrent Resolution No. 17 resolves as

follows:

"RESOLVED, By the House of Representatives of

the State of Texas, the Senate concurring, that the

State Board of Control be directed not to accept any

bids for 011, gasoline and/or lubricant needs of the

State of Texas from any person, firm, oartnershlp,

company or corporation which imports any crude 011

or products Into the United States, or bihlch pur-

chases any foreign-produced crude 011 or products, or

from any individual, firm, partnership, company or

corporation which is owned, controlled, or affiliated

by stock ownership, or otherwise, with any importer

as defined herein; and be it further

"RESOLVED, That the Board of Control be directed to

study all contracts now In efPect with any Individual,

firm, partnership, company or corporation which Imports

or Is affiliated with any importer of foreign 011, as

defined herein, and make every effort to terminate

forthwlth such contract or contracts If It is legally

possible to do so; and be it further

"RESOLVED, That bidders on oil, gasoline and/or

lubricant needs of the state be required to file with

the Board of Control a sworn statement attached to their

bids to the effect that they areanot importers of foreign

crude 011 or products, or affiliated with such importers,

as defined herein."

Under the State Purchasing Act of 1957 (Senate Bill

169, Chapter 304, Acts 55th Legislature, Regular Session,

1957, page 739, codified in Vernon's as Article 664-3, Vernon's

Civil Statutes, the Board of Control is required to award

.

- .

Honorable Wllllam J. Burke, Page 4 (W’W-345)

contracts to the bidder submitting the lowest and best bid.

Subdivision (f) of Section 8 provides:

“(f) Award of Contract. The Board shall award

contracts to.the bidder submitting the lowest and

beast bid. In determining who,ls the lowest ,and best

bidder, In addition to price, the Board shall con-

sider:

“(1) The ability, capacity and skill of the

bidder to perform.the contract op.provlde the service

required;

“(2) Whether the bidder can perform the con-

tract or provide the service promptly, or within the

time required, without delay Lr interference;

“(3) The character, responsibility, integrity,

reputation, and experience of the bidder;

“(4) The quality of performance of previous

contracts or servioes;

“(5) The previous and existing compliance by

the bidder with laws relating to the contract or

service;

“(6) The sufficiency of the financial re-

sources and ability of the bidder to perform the

contract or provide the service;

“(7) The quality, availability and~adapt-

ability of the supplies, or contractual services,

to the particular use required;

e ability of the bidder to provide

futurl:(%nLance , repair parts, and service for

the use of the subject of the contract;

e number and scope of conditions at-

tachei(zA t: bid . ” .

Section 30 of Article III of the Constitution of

Texas provides :

“Sec. 30. ND law shall be passed, except by

bill, and’no bill shall be so amended In Its passage

through zither House, as to change its original

purpose.

. .

- -

Honorable William J. Burke, Page 5 (WW-345)

In view of the provisions of Section 30 of Article

III of the Constitution above quoted, a statute can not be

amended by a resolution. Humble 011 & Ref. C_o. _vs ~&ate.

104 S,W. 2d 174 (Tex. CivT A 36). Terrell W ells Swik-

ming Pool vs Rodriguez, 182 S%:?d 823 ( Tex. Civ. A .

1944) Moshelm va Rolilns, 79 S.W. id 672 (Tex. Civ. &.

1935,'error dismissed).

It is our opinion that House Concurrent Resolution

of the First Called Session of the 55th Legislature, 1957,

constitutes an attempt to amend the provisions of SubditSsion

(f) of Section 8 of Chapter 304, Acts 55th Legislature, Reg-

ular Session, 1957 in violation of Section 30 of Article III

of the Constitution of Texas. Therefore, in answer to your

questions, you are advised:

1. The State Board of tiantrol is not authorized

to require the "Issuing of a certificate from refiners

certifying that the refined products purchased <or consump-

tion by the State are refined from Texas crude.

2. The Board of Control is required to continue

the purchase from refiners with whom the State now has con-

tracts in accordance with the terms and conditions of such

contracts and is not authroized to abrogate the obllgatlons

of the State under existing contracts.

3. In answer to the remaining questions you are

advised that the State Board of Control is required to

follow the terms and conditions of the State Purchasing Act

of 1957 In awarding contracts for the purchase of.the State's

fuel and refined product needs.

SUMMARY

The purchase of feul and refined

products for the State is governed by

the provisions of Chapter 304, Acts

55th Legislature, Regular Session, 1957

(State Purchasing Act of 1957). The

provisions of Rouse Concurrent Resolution

No. 17 of the First Called Session of the

55th Legislature, 1957, can not amend,

. .

1,622

Honorable William J. Burke, Page 6 (WW-345)

alter or repeal any of the provisions

of the State Purchasing Act of 1957

in view of the provisions of Section

30 of AFtlcle III of the Conetltutlon

of, Texas.

Very truly yours,,

WILL WILSON

Attorney General of Texas

JR:tllg

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

Geo. Pi. Blackburn, Chairman

John H. Mlnton, Jr.

Marietta Payne

B. H. Tlmmlns, Jr.

Fred Werkinthin

REVIEWEDFOR THE ATTORNEYGENERAL

By: W. V. Geppert

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.