Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1958
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

February 3, 1958

Honorable Wm. J. Burke Opinion No. ~~-358

Executive Dlreqtor

State Board of Control Re: Authority of the 36th

Austin, Texas lJ~visloq Association of

the Texqs Vatlopal Guard

to erect a Monument as a

memor$al to the Members

of 'the36th Division'

under the provisions of

Senate Bill 437 of the

55th Legislatureand

House ConcurrentResolution

Dear Mr. Burke: 76 of the 54th Legislature.

You have requested an opinion from this office

concerning the interpretationof House ConcurrentResolution

76 passed by the 54th Legialature,andits present validity

since the passage of Senate Bill 437 passed by the 55th Legis-

lature. House ConcurrentResolution 76, whloh was passed by

the 54th Legislature,provided In part as follows:

"RRSOLVRDby the House of Representativesof

the State of Texas, the Senate concurring,that

the 36th Division Assoaiatlonbe and it Is hereby

authorized to erect on the Capitol grounds in

Austin, a suitable monument as a memorial to the

members of the 36th Division, Texas Natgonal

Guard, who served during World Wara 5 and II, the

monument to be created under the supervisionof

and at a location seleated by the State Board of

Control, without any cost to the State of Texas."

You are concerned with whether or not this resolu-

tion is still in force and effect since the passage of Senate

Bill No. 437 passed by the 55th Legislature,codified as

Article 861b, Vernon's Texas Penal Code, and which Aat reads

in part as follows:

--

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, Page 2 (~~-358).

"Section 1. It shall be unlawful, without

the prior express consent of the Legislature,

for any officer of this state or any employee

thereof or any other person to construct,build,

erect or maintain any building, structure,

memorial, monument, statue, concesslonor any

other structure including creation of parking

areas or the laying of additionalpaving on Zny

of the grounds that surrounded the State Capitol ,,

. . .

" . . .

"Sec. 5. All laws or parts of laws in

conflict herewith are repealed."

Article 861b further provides that It shall be a

misdemeanor for any officer or employee of this State or

other person to violate Section 1 of'the above mentioned

article.

You have propounded to this office the following

questions to be answered:

"(1) Since the authority was granted by

resolution,Is the authority for the erection

of the monument to the 36th Division valid with

the passage of S.B. #437?

"(2) Since the passage of S.B. #k37 which

became effectiveWay 31, 1957, provided for,prior

express consent, should the 36th Division of the

Texas National Guard renew its request before the

LegislatureAndyobtain a new authorization?

"(3) Since it appears that it will be some

time before the 36th Division monument plans are

ready for examinationand the final determination

of the site made, for what approximateperiod is

the authority granted by resolution or other

action of the Legislatureconsidered effective

and/or valid as it relates to the erection of

monuments, etc., on the Capitol grounds?

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, Page 3 W-358).

” 4 Would the Board of Control be in riola-

tion 0$4 he provisions of S.B. ,#37 to permit the

tentative selection of a site on the Capiol

grounds with the speelfic understandingw!th the

36th Division that final approval was not to be

granted for the permanent use of any site selected

until after the approval of plans and specifica-

tions by the Board of Control?'

It,was the purpose of the Legislature,in passing

Senate Bill 437, to prevent haphazard constructionof buildings,

monuments and other edifices on the Capitol grounds without

prior approval of the,Leglslature,in order that the Capitol

grounds might retain their attractiveness.

It is the opinion of this office that Rouse Concur-~

rent Resolution 76, passed by the 54th Legislature,meets the

neoesaary requirementsas set out in Senate Bill 437. In the

situationyou pose, the consent haa already been obtained

from the Legislature. It is olearly the intent of the Legis-

lature that consent of the Legislaturebe the only requirement

necessary before the erection of any typeof structure,and

since the 36th Division has already obtained consent, it would

be foolish to require them to go through the proaedure again.

Further, It is the opinion of thia office that the

resolution passed by the 54th Legislature Is still in force

and effect and that the Board of Control has authority under

that resolution to permit the tentative selection of a site

on the Capitol ground5 by the 36th Division Associationof

the Texas National Guard. The Board of Control, after the

selection of the site, still has the right to approve the

final plans and specificationsof the monument to be erected

by the Association.

SRMMARY

Since the 36th Division Association

of the Texas National Guard has

obtained legislativeconsent to

construct a monument on the Capitol

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, Page 4 (~~-358).

grounds, the requirementset out

in Artiale 861b of Vernon's Texas

Penal Code has been met.

Yours very truly,

WILL WILSON

Attorney General of Texas

- Llnward Shivers

Assistant

LS:Jl

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

Geo. P. Blaakburn, Chairman

Jack Goodman

J. Mark McLaughlin

Ralph R. Rash

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNFiYGENERAL

BY:

W. V. Geppert

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.