Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1958
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Mr. William A. Harrison Opinion No. ww-362

Commissioner of Insurance

International Life Building Re: "Whether it is necessary to

Austin, Texas increase capital stock deposit

under Article 3.15, Texas In-

surance Code, when the actual

capital stock of a company is

increased by charter amend-

Dear Mr. Harrison: ment, and related questions."

We quote from your letter of December 16, 1957, requesting

the opinion of this department on the above stated question as follows:

"Assume that a company with $100,000 capital exer-

cises its option under Article 3.15, and voluntarily de-

posits with the treasurer securities in the amount of

$100,000, and subsequently the company amends its arti-

cles~of incorporation to increase its capital stock to

$250,000. We respectfully request your opinion as to

whether it is necessary for the company, having once

exercised its option and made the capital deposits called

for in Article 3.15, to make additional deposits with the

State Treasurer under Article 3.15 in an amount to the

increase of its capital.

"Assume that a company has a capital of $250,000 and

voluntarily makes a $250,000 capital deposit with the

State Treasury in accordance with Article 3.15. Subse-

quently, the company reduces its capital to $100,000. We

respectfully request your opinion as to whether the com-

pany could then withdraw from the State Treasury $150,000

of its capital deposit, without submitting in lieu there-

of other securities of a like class, or of an equal amount.

In other words, could the company then maintain only a

capital deposit of $100,000 rather than $250,000?

"In each of our first questions, assume that at the

time of increase or reduction in capital, the company had

outstanding liabilities to its policyholders in this state.

"If your answer to our first question is in the nega-

tive, we respectfully request your opinion as to whether a

company which had originally made a voluntary deposit and

fir.Wil~;iamA. Harrison, page 2 (~~-362)

subsequently increased its deposits at the xquest of thf

State %ard of Insurance, after it had increased its capi-

<al stock, could withdraw the subsequent deposits made at

the request of the Board. In other words, if the Board

erroneously required the company to increase the capital

deposits under Article 3.15, after the company had in-

creased its capital stock, and the company did so without

protest, may the company withdraw from the deposit the

ini-reasesrequired tp be made by the Board? Or must the

compary, having made deposit without protest, maintain t.h-

deposits so long as there is any liability to policyhold-

ers in this State?"

pertinent parts of Article 3.15, Insurance Ccie cf I'--uas,

'Clue

are +a,ie:i.

in part as follows:

"Any 'domestic' company may, at its option, deposit

with the Treasurer of this State, securities in which its

capital stock is invested, or securities equal in amount

to its capital stock, of the class in which the iaw of

this State permits such insurance companies to invest

their capital stock, and may, at its option, withdraw the

same or any part thereof, first having deposited with the

treasurer, in lieu thereof, other securities of like class

and equal amount and value to those withdrawn . . B !;he

deposit herein provided for, when made by any company,

shall thereafter be maintained so iong as said corxpa:ly

shall have outstanding any liability to its polic.yhnMers

in this State . , ."

The language contained in,the first sente:nceof Article 3~15

is initially permissive in nature, and no insurance company is re~;:;ir*-d

i,o&posit t.hesecurities in which its capital stock is i:?,vestedl or

securities equal in amount to its capital stock with t'heStat? Trrasl~~rer

Althcugh the statute is silent on this point, we thi~nkthat, crict!Ihe

iKslrance company has elected to make an initj.aldeposit ::fSer:kiY’i!icS

with the SLate Treasurer, a second option arises when the ccmpa,jr;:u

-:r:-

creases the amount of its capital stock, and under this option ti,-o-!r-

pany inayelect,to deposit with the State Treasurer,'securities i:.-~I~!::"

ii,sincrensed~capital stock is invested or securities equal in arn~~;;;~~t

to its increased capital stock. If the company takes this course of

action, then,,under the terms of this Article, the State Treasu,rerw,c:~~!.d.

e.xe-utea receipt to the company, giving a description of the said s:xrk

or sccuri%ies and stating that the same are held on deposit as the c;~p'.-

tal s;ock investments of such company. However, should the c,om?zany

elect not to deposit securities in which its increased capital stcck

i.sinvested, or securities equal to its increased capital stcck, t,hen

the company would no longer have the right to advertise that the State

Treasurer had on deposit securities as "the capital stock investment

of such company . I .'

or. William A. ~~arrison, page 3 (~-362)

Therefore, in answer to your Question No. 1, we hold that

it is not necessary for a company having once exercised its option and

made the capital deposits called for in Article3.15, to make addition-

al deposits with the State Treasurer under Article 3:15 in an amount

equal to the increase of its capital stock. Howeyer, if such company

does not exercise this option{ then they can no longer advertise that

the State Treasurer has on deposit securities as the capital stock in-

vestments of such company.

Although the initial deposit under the terms of this statute

is permissive in nature exercisable at the option of the company, once

this option is exercised, the company can only withdraw its securities

so deposited in accordance with the withdrawal provisions contained

in this Article. The language of Article 3.15 is clear and unambiguous

and provides for only one method of withdrawal of the securities from

the State Treasurer. BY that method. the comoany may "withdraw the

”

same or any part thereof,'first having deposiied'with the treasurer,

in lieu thereof, qt& securities of like class and equal amount and

value to the@ irithdr&n:" This language clearly indicates that it

was the intentof Wie~Legislature that once a company exercised its

option to deposit securities with the State Treas,urer,that these se-

curities could not be yithdrawn except by substituting in lieu thereof

securities of like class and equal amount. See Attorney'General Opin-

ion No. O-5051 which holds that, "if the life insurance company with-

draws its security, said company must deposit in lieu of the security

withdrawn, other securities equal in value to the security withdrawn."

Further substituting the conclusion that deposits once made

may not be withdrawn is the language in Article 3.15 that "the deposits

herein provided for, when made by a company, shall thereafter be main-

tained

its policyholders in this'state.! Manifestly, the deposits permitted

to be made by insurance comnanies are intended by the terms of the stat-

ute to be made for the benefit of the policyholders of the insuring

company. To permit the company to withdraw deposits once made, particu-

larly in view of the fact that the statute authorizes the company to

advertise that it has made such a deposit, would be nothing less than

statutory authorization to perpetrate fraud upon policyholders. Fur-

ther, Article 3.18 of the Texas Insurance Code which refers to deposits

permitted under Article 3.16 of securities equal to the ampunt,of the

legal reserve of a life insurance company by'express langusg& permits

such deposits to be withdrawn in the event that these, "deposits exceed

the net value of all policies and annuity bonds which it has in force,

less such liens (not exceeding such net value) as the company may hold

against them, t . ." The absence of such language in Article 3.15 with

reference to the deposits made to the extent of cafiitalinvestments,

we think evidences the legislative intent that'such withdrawal privilege

should not be accorded the companies in Connection with deposits made

under ArtiCle 3.15.

Mr. William A. Harrison, page 4 (w-362)

Therefore, in answer to your Question No. 2, an insurance

company, once exercising its option under Article 3.15 cannot withdraw

from the State Treasurer part of its capital deposit simply because

it has by charter amendment reduced the amount of its.capital.

In your third question the facts are such that the-company

originally made a voluntary deposit under the terms of Art~icle3.15

and, subsequently, increased its deposits,at the request of the State

Board of Insurance without protest after it had increased the amount

of its capital stock.' In view of our answer to your first question, .

the action of the State Board of Insurance in requiring that such a

depcsit be made would be erroneous. However, we do not believe that

under the terms of the statute an answerdifferent from that given in

response to your second question would be appropriate.~,'Thefact that

the company!6 voluntary.action may have been to some measure influenced

by an erroneous act on the part of the Board cannot effect the con,sid-

eration that to now permit the withdrawal of the funds would permit

the perpetration of a fraud upon those policyholders who have become

policyholders in reliance of the provisions of the statute.

Therefore, in answer to your third question, an insurance

company having exercised its option under Article 3.15 to tike deposits

to the extent of its capital with the Board cannot withdraw such deposits

or part thereof from the State Treasurer simply because such deposit was

made as the result of an erroneous request onthe part of the State Board

of Insurance.

SUMMARY

A life insurance company once having made an initial

deposit of securities with the State Treasurer in the

amount of its capital pursuant to Article 3..15of the

Texas Insurance Code need not increase,such deposit

each time it increases its capital stock. If the com-

pany does increase its capital stock and does elect

not to make additional deposits in the amount of the

increase of its capital, such company may not continue

to advertise that it has on deposit with the State

Treasurer securities as the capital stock investment

of such company.

A life insurance company once exercising its option

to make a deposit under Article 3.15 cannot withdraw

from the State Treasurer part of its capital deposit

simply because it has decreased the amount of its

capital stock.

A life insurance company increasing the,amount of its

deposit with the State Treasurer under Article 3.15

Mr. William A. Harrison, page 5 (~~-362)

on the erroneous request of the State Board of Ir,-

surance to do so may not withdraw such increased

deposit.

Very truly yours,

WILL WILSON

Richard A. Wells

Assistant

,RAw: .lm

APPROVE3:

OPINION COMMITTEE:

Gee. P. Blackburn, Chairman

John H. Minton, Jr.

Morgan Nesbitt

Wayland C. Rivers,,Jr.

REVIEWED FOR TFIEATTORNEY GENERAL

BY:

W. V. Geppert

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.