Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1958
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

H[E,~XTORNEY GENERAL

OFTEXAS

Honorable Wm. J. Burke Opinion No. WW-499

Executive Director

State Board of Control Re: Authority of the State

Austin, Texas Board of Control to

modify and alter the

permanent entrances ln-

Dear Mr. Burke: to the Capitol grounds.

You have requested an opinion conaernlng your auth-

ority to change the design of the drive entrances and exits

of the Capitol grounds located addacent to the corner of Con-

gress Avenue and Eleventh Street. Attached to your request

is a map or plat showing the proposed change In the driveways

providing for the entrance and exit of traffic into and out

of the Capitol grounds.

The proposed change contemplates a widening of that

part of the driveways providing for the entrance and exit

located adjacent to the corner of Congress Avenue and

Eleventh Street in the City of Austin, and eliminating the

ninety degree turns existing at the present time. You state

that the purpose of this proposed change is as follows:

"The fact that a serious bottleneck

exists at the 11th Street &nation with

the west drive of the Capitol creates a

necessity for consideration of changes

in design of the outlet. The change in

design would move (slightly to the west)

the ornamental stone column ad,jacent to

the drive outlet and would necessitate

the removal of approximately 4' of the

iron fence In order to straighten out the

offset In the west Capitol Drive; the

ornamental column would be replaced on

its foundation and the fence reconnected.

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, page 2 (WW-499).

We merely propose to eliminate the off-

sets In the west driveway and to provide

for freer access to 11th Street. A similar

change would be required on the east drive

in the moving of the ornamental column

(slightly to the east), shortening of the

fence, and its subsequent reconnection to

the ornamental column. Each of the changes

proposed will involve a slight change in

the radius of the curbs bordering 11th

Street.

"The changes proposed would eliminate

the existing blockade of sidewalks on both

the west and eastdrives. AA lnspectloA

.of the area will reveal that the sidewalk

terminates near the fence, that IA order

to obtain access to the street it is

necessary for pedestrians witbiA',the

Capitol grounds and on the sidewalk to step

out into the drive in order to get around

the end of the fence and the ornamental

column. Our proposal would provide a

sidewalk connection with the curb area

without the existent danger that is iAhereAt

in the present situation. We believe that

we should correct difficulties relating

to pedestrian and vehicalar movements wlth-

in the Capitol grounds; the correction

will improve the external appearanae of the

grounds, particularly on the 11th Street

side."

Your specific questions are:

"1 . If the ObllgatiOA to maintain, repair,

supervlse, etc., iAClUdes the grounds

and driveways, does the Board of

Control have authority to modify

the entrance to the Capitol drives

to conform with proposed design iA-

dlcated on the attached print?

"2 * Does Article 86lB of the Penal Code

prohibit such modification of the

entrance ways under the terminology

,of Sections 1 and 6?

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, page 3 (WW-499)

"3. Does Article 861B of the Penal Code

abrogate any of the authority, ex-

pressed or implied, conve ed by

Articles 667 and 670 (VCS~?

"4. Does the Board of Control now have

full authority to proceed to make

the modifications of the drives in

the event such should be necessary?"

Section 1 of Senate Bill 437, Acts of the 55th

Legislature, Regular Session, 1957, Chapter 313, page 758,

codified in Vernon's as Article 861b, Vernon's Penal Code,

provides:

"It shall be unlawful, without the prior

express consent of the Legislature, for any

officer of this state or any employee thereof

or any other person to construct, build, erect

or maintain any building, structure, memorial,

monument, statute, concession or any other

structure including creation of parking areas

or the laying of additional paving on any of

the grounds that surrounded the State Capitol

on January 1, 1955, and which grounds were then

bounded by Eleventh, Brazes, Thirteenth and

Colorado Streets, In the City of Austin, Texas,

whether such land lay inside OP outside the

fence enclosing part of the grounds3 provided,

however, that paved access and underground

utility installations may be constructed and

m provided further, that the pro-

visions of this Act shall not apply to the

Supreme Court Building, according to the ap-

proved plans dated October 29, 1956, nor to

the State Office Building, according to the

approved plans dated November, 1956.”

Sections 2 and 3 provide for the penaltieS for Viola-

tion of the provisions of Section 1 of the Act.

Section 1 of Article II of the Constitution of Texas,

provides as follows:

"Section 1. The powers of the Govern-

ment of the State of Texas shall be divided

into three distinct departments, each of which

shall be confided to a separate body of magis-

tracy, to wit: Those which are Legislative to

one; those which are Executive to another, and

those which are Judicial to another; and no

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, page 4 (w-499 1

person, or collection of,persons, being of

one of these departments, shall exercise any

power properly attached to either of the

others, except in the instances herein ex-

pressly permitted." (Rmphasis added)

In view of the prohibition contained in Section 1

of Article II of the Constitution above quoted, it Is

necessary that we first determine whether the provisions

of Article 861b of Vernon's Penal Code is an attempt to

exercise managerial functions (an exalusive power of the

Executive Department of Government) as'dlstinguished from

a law making function (an exclusive power of the Legls-

latlve Department of Government).

It is noted that in enacting the provisions of

Article 861b, the Legislature did not attempt to state

how any particular building or structure would be erected

or maintained; rather the Legislature was providing by law

the limits of power to construct, build, erect or maintain

certain buildings. Therefore, it is our conclusion that

Article 861b of Vernon's Penal Code constitutes an exercise

of Legislative function rather than an Executive function

of government and in this respect is constitutional because

it is not an attempt by the Legislature to Itself "exercise"

an executive power. We need not discuss the phrase "with-

out the prior express consent of the Legislature".

The State Board of Control Is a statutory board,

created by Title 20 of the Revised Civil Statutes of Texas

of 1925, as amended, and, therefore, exercise only statutory

powers. Therefore, we are not confronted with the question

of whether the provisions of Article 861b attempts to limit

the exercise of powers granted by the Constitution of Texas

to officers and boards created by the Constitution and we

express no opinion thereon,

The proposed change contemplated in your request

will require the laying of additional paving on the Capitol

grounds as defined by Article 861b, Vernon's Penal Code.

Furthermore, it will require the removal and reinstalla-

tion of an existing structure (ornamental granit columns)

on the Capitol grounds. Therefore, such proposed change is

in direct contravention to the express provisions of Arti-

cle 861b. Since the proposed change is providing for

paved access to the Capitol grounds, the only remaining

question is whether such proposed change will fall within

the proviso above quoted.

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, page 5 (w-499 1

It is our opinion that the proviso will not negate

the express prohibition of laying additional paving on the

Capitol grounds, for when a statute expresses a purpose,

and afterwards an Inconsistent particular Is expressed,

the latter is to be regarded as an exception to the former,

and both are permitted to stand. 39 Tex. Jur., Statutes,

Section 101, page 191.

In our opinion the proposed than e will contravene

the provisions of Section 1 of Artiale iii

61b. Therefore,

in answer to your specific questions you are advised:

1. The State Board of Control does not have the

authority to modify the entrance to the Capitol drives

to conform with the proposed design indicated by the at-

tached map or plat to your request.

2. Article 86lb, Vernon's Penal Code, prohibits

such modification of the entrance way.

3. Article 667, Vernon's Civil Statutes, provld-

ing that the Board of Control shall have charge and aon-

trol of the halls, chambers and committee rooms of the

State Capitol Building, and Article 670, authorizing the

Board of Control to prepare plans and specifications for

the improvements and repairs of public buildings or pro-

perty of the State and to supervise the construction of

said work, have no application to the facts presented in

your request.

4. The Board of Control does not have full

authority to proceed to make modifications of the drives

involved in your request.

This opinion is not to be construedas passing

upon the validity of the Penal provisions contained in

Sections 2 and 3 of Article 861b, Vernon's Penal Code.

SUMMARY

The State Board of Control is

prohibited by the provisions

of Section 1 of Article 861b of

Honorable Wm. J. Burke, page 6 (w-499 1

Vernon's Penal Code from making

any modlfTcotlonof the drives

Into or from the Capitol grounds

whiah will call for the laying of

additional paverent.

Yours very truly,

WILL WILSON

Attorney General of Texas

JR:zt Asellstant

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

Geo. P. Blackburn, Chairman

Leonard Passmore

Jack Goodman

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY OENERAL

r BY:

W. V. Geppeti

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.