Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1958
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 3.5%

The opinion

Honorable Price Daniel Opinion No. WW-530

Governor, State of Texas

Capitol Station Ee: AppoYntment by ,Governor

Austin, Texas to fill vacancy in the

office of Dkstrict Judge

Dear Governor Daniel:

You request an opinion In answer to the following

questions:

"1. Can Judge Joe Brown enter upon the d'utiesof

his office without appolntment by the Governor, prior ~to

January 1, 1958?

"2. Is the Governor ,authorizedto appoint Judge

Brown to fill out the unexpired term of Judge ,John C,

HOYO, under the following circumstances:

"On August 31, 19,57, the same Judge Joe Brown was .ap-

pointed by the Governor to this newly created 150th Dl~etTlet

court. His nomination was submitted to the Senate in Oct.

17, 1957, and he was not confirmed. Thereafter the Governor

appolnted John C. Hoyo to fill the office. Judge Hoyo dLd

not seek election to the full term. Joe Brown was the only

candidate for the place and he was nominated In the Demo-

cratic Primary and elected November 4."

Your letter further glve.sthe information that Judge

Hoyo has become deceased, and that by reason of his death,

there is now no Incumbent of said 0ffic.e,ofDistri.ctJud~ge.

Our answer to yuur First Question 18 that Judge Brown

cannot, by virtue .ofhis election, snter upon the duties of

the office to which he was elected, prior t,oJanuary 1, 1959.

The Election Code, Art.,1.08, is as foll.ows:

"From and after the effective date hereof

the terms of office of all elective State

and District Offlcera of th'eState of,Texas,

excepting aovernor, Lieutenant Governor,

Honorable Price Daniel, page 2 (WW-530)

members of the Senate, and members of the

House of Representatives, shall begin on

the first day of January next following the

General Eleotlon at which sold respective

State and dlst~at~,offlaer~ were~elected."

(emphasis ours).

And In the case of Rxparte Sanders1 147 Tex. 248, 215 S.W. 26

325 (1948), The Sufieme'Court f T exas held, among,other

things, that,a person eleoted go the,offltieof dietriot judge,.;.

In the November generalseleotlon could not by virtue of his ~ .I:

said electlop, asewne ;me dutiesof that office until the

first of the suoeeedlne January,

We argthus oompelled, both by the applicable.statute

and by the decision of the Supreme Court, to answer the

question in the negative.

The answer to the,seoond questlon'is that the ffovernor

of Texas, is not authorized to appoint Judge'Joe Brown to

serve the .remalnlngportion of the term of office to which he

was previously appointbd and which appointment was rejected

by the Senate of Texar. This la forbidden by the Constitution

of Texas, Article 4, Sebtion"l2, whloh provides as ,follons:

"All vacancies in State or distrlot offices,

,except members of the Legislature..shall be

filled unless otherwise provided by law, by

@ppoiritmentof the Governor, whlch'appolntment,

if made during Its seaslon shall be with the

advice and lon,eetitof two-thirds of the Senate

present, the!said appointee, or some other person

to fill sucn vaoancy, shall be nominated to the

Senate during the first ten days of Its session.

If rejected, said office shall immediately be-

come vacant, and the 'Governor shall, without

delay, make further nominations, until a con-

firmation takes place. But should there be

no ~confirmationduring the session of the Senate,

to fill the vaoanoy until the next session of the

Senate or uritllthe regular election to said office,

should sooner oaaur. ,:Appointments to vaoancles

In offices eleotlve by the people shall only oon-

tinue until the -first general election thereafter."

(Bnphasls ours).

In that clause of the quoted Const&tutlonitXArtiaD~

rhSch cays, "the (Dovernortill not TRERIwFTEfLappotint~uy-

lpIzronzo ff.l.lsWa~~~ who hu been rejected,$F t+

mte:: t,- wo* tm~ ear" a?pri

"M"i -. w#q w-

ant. Mr..Black,.In l@e a*hortta$Fve *; m;c+X

F@urth Edftfon, glves"the &Xlow%ng as w Ie&W

of "thsraaftir"r

"After the time last mentioned;.after th&t

after that timer'aftei?ward~subsequestig;.

ChenaMorth. Faople v* st. LalGLe+p.(kT3.B;

CO., 3w Ill. sdli&lJb:,H.l&z17; lisilmuttav..

~tle@U38nty & sm c&..rl65 lrpp.Dv,

1 4; Imale v. stat6,

573, Iis1lK~K?i,.,lJ4%,

147 *+. Cr. IL 384, 130 LW. 2d gie5,. gci?T*."

m 8&e sts+hm di8fS.n8s

"euch~"e8 ms+nfn@

"Of t&t Bfnd, Igving partl.cuLarquality or ,'

charaofer speciEted. In re Brock, 312 Ft, sbz,

166 L 785~~ 7%T, Imtlcol with, lnaingtryma

6mnt M what hrrrbeenmentioned.. &I re

m.tar3es W!lIl,1114W&K?. 213,*.25% F..Yd!,.7%

AUka, altilar, of the like kind; V~~h'

mneents the objectr~an,already ps&Q8uZsr%&E

Xr~tQaslauhfch arc W mentSoned, W fk &

dasarQttlve and relrhfve word, referrIng,to

the Lrurtentcaeri-ant..Strawberry Wll Land

Corparrtlon v. Starbu&, 124,Va..73, 97 SAL

362,. 366; &3OmQ cx reL lEEllp v., l!&lSc.

sem.u8 ccallml8Rsan,. Iyl kpp.~ mr,m%a,, rnfj7F

B,Y..S,' 703,, mi.*"

The above set 0u-tArtlale of the C@nstZtution Tf p&%X..

IX muat be conatiruedto mean what it says* a& to s+g~w&H it

means. It eaya and meana~t&at when the Oovernor apg.&.nti

some personsto ill1 e va.cancyin the t~ez?m

of'en offZ@xvsnd~

the,appointee ie refused aonflrnation @ chc SenaW,. tiaa

Qavernor cannot again *poZmt the rej+cWd a4ppa&nt~ tDz rtlll

at&d temn a~?’any w- Mtts~I~

simlms

The EcmorabLe Jae Bruwn cannot by virtue SS

his election to,the office at the last

gene- election enter upon the duties of

his office prior to &nuary 1, 19fi9c The .

Honorable Joe EWwwn -ot be appoSnt~edW

,Pfllthe vaarnay nmw ex&8t-

the @avermar tfii

Honorable Price Daniel, page 4 (WW-530)

ing in the office to which he was elected,

his previous appointment by the Governor to

such office for the present term having been

refused confirmation by the Senate of Texas.

Youra

As,s?stantAttorney General

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

Riley Eugene Fletcher, Chairman

Marietta McGregor Payne

Cecil Cammack

Morgan Nesbltt

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL:

By: W. V. Geppert

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.