Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1958
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

THEATTORNEY GENERAL

OFTEXAS

AUSTIN ~~.TEXAS

WVIJX. WILSON

ATrouNEY GENxmcAL

.December 9, 1958

Ron. Will.iam A.,Harrison Opinion No. W-533

Commissioner of Insurance

International Life Building Re: Certai~nquestionscon-

Austin 14, Texas cerning reinsurance by

companies subject to the

fire insurance rating

laws relnsuri~ngfire in-

surance policies issued

by companies which are

not subject to such rat-

ing laws.

Dear Sir:

Your amended request for an opinion given. in lieu

of your letter of May 5, 1958, is as follows:

"Most companies writing fire and casualty.insurance

in Texas are subject to the provisions of Sub-chapter C

of,Chapter 5 of the Texas Insurance Code which author-

izes the State Board of Insurance to fix and pr.omulgate

firesinsurance rates. However, reciprocals, Lloyd8 and

county mutual insurance companies need'not conform to

th,efire Insurance rates promulgated by the Board. It

has come to the attention of the Board that a number of

stock and mutual insurance companies which are subject

to the rating laws are reinsuring 100% of the fire in-

surance coverages written by companies which are not sub-

ject to these rating laws. Polici~esof fIre insurance

purportedly are Issued by a Lloyds or reciprocal or

cpuatg mutual (which will hereinafter be referred to as

exempt ,companies)at rates fixed!by such exempt company+ .

without respect to the rates promulgated by tie Board.

At the inception the coverage Is reinsured 100% by the

stock or mutual company which could not otherwise issue

policiesat the rates used in the issuance of such

policies.

"We respectfully request your opinion on certain

questions pertaining to the following facts:

"An exempt company has entered into a reinsurance

contract with,a non-exempt company. Such agreement Is

in substance that the exempt company has agreed to cede

. ’

Hon. William A. Harrsion, page 2 (WW-533)

to the non-exempt company all the ~premiumswritten by

theeexempt company on certain fire insurance coverages

and in turn the non-exempt company has agreed to rein-

sure 100% of the liability of the exempt company. The

only return to the exempt company is a small ced,ing

commission. The non-exempt or reinsuring company has

agreed to bear all of the expenses of servicing the bus-

iness, paying the agent's commissions and has even been

de~legatedthe authority to appoint agents to act for the

exempt,company in connection with the sale of the par-

ticular insurance in question. The non-exempt company

assumes full responsibility to investigate, settle and

defend all claims arising under the policy. The pur-

pose of this arrangement is to permit the non-exempt

company to obtain the business at rates lower than that

which they are permitted to write under the applicable

rates promulgated by the State Board of Insurance. It

IS standard procedure for the policy of the exempt

company to have on its face or by endorsement language

to the effect that the obligations under the policy are

reinsured 100s by the non-exempt company. As a matter

of practice the insured In settlement of,ang loss deals

direotly with the non-exempt reinsuring company. In

many Instances the policyholders are unwilling to ac-

.cept the insurance of the exemptcompany until they have

been furnished absolute evidence that the policy will

be reinsur~ed100% by the pon-exempt company.

"With.respect.to the above,outline fact situation

we,ask .the following questions:

'j!(l)'

Must the rate of premium charged the policy-

holder conform to the standard premium pro-

mulgated by the State Board of Insurance for

the particular risk covered under the provi-

sions of Sub-chapter C of Chapter 5 of the

' Texas Insurance Code of 1951 as amended?

/.

"(2) Id?the non-exempt.'reinsuring' company re-

quired to pay the gross premium.recelpts

tax led& by Article .7064, R-S,, 1925'"

The ,speclfic statutory authority for fixing of rates

of :fire~insurance premiums is contained in Article 5.26 of

" I, 'the.Texas Insurance Code as amended, Acts 1957, 55th Leg.,

p.,1.443;: C'h.497 p Section (h) speCifically exempts from the

operation of.Aptlcle 5.26 "County Mutual Insurance Companies

operating under Chapter 17 of this Code; Underwriters at a

: &loyd's operating under Chapter,18, of this Code; Reciprocals

and inter-insurance exchanges operating under Chapter 19 of

'this Codes". 'Sub-chapter C of Chapter 5 of the'Texas Insurance

Hon. William A. Harrison, page 3 W-533)

Code generally governs the power of the State Board of+ In-

surance to promulgate end fix rates of fire insurance pre-

mlums charged on polrcles of fire fnsurence and allied lines

~issued in the State of Texas.

Article 5.26 as emended In 1957 requires the State

Board of Insurance to promulgate maximum rates of insurance

ror fire risks. Insurance companies subject to the law must

charge the rate8 fixed by the Board unless permission Is

granted by the Board to deviate.

Initially, it 'is our opinion that the Legislature

did not intend .for'the State Board ,of Insurance to promulgate

maximum rates for 'relnsurance" premiums.

'Relnsurence" is a contract whereby one for a con-

sideration agrees to ,indemnlfganother, either In whole or

In pert, against loss or liability, the risk of which the

latter he8 assumed under a separate and distinct contract

a8 Insurer of a third party. 8 Couch Cyclopedia of Insur-

ance Law,.p. 7389, Sec. 2256; 24-D Tex. Jur. 980, Sec. 484.

Of course,,reinsurance is a form of Insurance. How-

ever, we believe the Legislature Fn Sub-chapter C of Chapter

5 of the.Texas Insurance Code has recognized e distinction

between "InsUrlng" and %einsuring". In Article 5.41, Texas

Ins'uranceCode, it .is.provided:

: '"No,'company

shall engage or participate.In the

insuring or reinsuring of.eny property inthis State

against loss or damage by fire ~except In compliance

with the terms end provisions of this law; nor shall

any.such'company knowingly write insurance at any

les8errate thanthe rates herein provided for, . . .'

The,firstcleuse expressly recognizes the distlnction

between-!'j.n&rance"ena 'reinsurance' and then the next clause

deacribea~wha,tl'sprohibited, that is, the company Is prohl;

bited from '!'knowingly

writing insurance at .any lesser rate .

.', . -.~See,alsothe first sentence of Article 5.42 indicat-

ingthe Fntent of the Legislature to only regulate relations

~,betweena.c~ompanyand lts,pollcyholders rather then relations

: .bat.~aen,:co,~pdnle.s..

Again; the following leW3UVM from

.Artlclis (l)t.being Intended that every contract

5.27,..'".....

or policy of.:lnsUrenc,eagainst the hazar~dof fire shell be

issuedin'eccordenee ,with the terms and provls,ionsof this

subchapter; . .; .,':.'is indicative of an intent to'exclude

"In a true contract of relnsurance the,reinsur-

r.einsurance'.

ing company does not iSSUe a 'contract or,policy of lnsur-

ence against the~hezard of fire". The reinsurance contract

Insures 'thepolicy $SSUing company against 1oSS by reason

Hon. William A; Harrison,'page 4 (WW-533)

of having issued contracts or policies of insurance.

Again, this conclusion is reinforced by the language

of the emergency~clause of the original Act permitting the

Board to set maximum rates of fire insurance. Section 31 of

the Act, 1913, p. 195, is as follows:

"The fact that there is now no sufficient law

in this State prohibiting unjust discrimination In the

collection of fire insurance rates as between citizens

of the State; nor protecting citizens in securing rea-

sonable rates, constitutes an emergency . . . . -'

We are not unaware of previous Attorney General

opinions rendered on the same OP similar questions. By

opinion dated June 25, 1924 (Vol. 267, p. 267) the then At-

torney General rendered an opinion to the State Fire Insur-

ance Commission that properly licensed stock fire insurance

companies which undertook to reinsure risks which were ln-

8Ured by companies not subject to the rating law were obliged

to observe the rates for such risks which had been estab-

'lished by the Commission. A year later by opinion dated

August 4, 1925 (Book 274, p. 901) the Attorney General ad-

vised the Fire Insurance Commission that the writing of re-

insurance was not covered by the fire rating law. There is

no discussion in this opinion of.the previous opinion of

June 25, 1924. Then by opinion dated September 29, 1930

(Book 316, p. 903) the Attorney General advised the State

Fire Insurance.Commissioner in effect that reinsurance was

within the rating provisions of the statute.

You have orally.advised me that in spite of these

opinions It has been the consistent departmental interpreta-

tion that reinsurance in general was not subject to the

rates promulgated by the State Board of Insurance and the

predecessor Board of Insurance Commissioners. We do not

believe that the statutes in question are ambiguous, but

rather that they clearly exclude from their terms reinsur-

ante, and the two earlier opinions to the contrary are

clearly in error.

However, your lester suggests transactions which do

,not fall within the usual purview of reinsurance and though

we have held that reinsurance as such does not come within

the provisionsof the fire insurance rate laws, the law does

not prevent an inquiry beyond the form of a transaction into

its true substance. We hold that under the fact situation

given that the transaction in question is not one of rein-

surance insofar as the rating laws are concerned. We further

hold in response to your first question that the so-called

reinsuring company has issued a policy of direct insurance.

.I

Hon. Wllllam A. Harrison, page 5 (W-533)

The premium charged the policy holder must conform to the

.rates which the reinsuring company is permItted to use under

'the provFslons of Sub-chapter C of Chapter 5 of the Insur-

ance Code.

What then 1s the primary testto determine whether

or not a given transaction, regardless of the verbiage used,

comes within the provisions of Sub-chapter C of Chapter 5?

We believe that the statute applies when an Insurance company

enters into a contract to directly Insure the hazards of

fire and its allied lines. In support of this conclusion is

the,language of Article 5.27 previously quoted stating the

intent of the Legislature:

"It being intended that every contract or policy

of Insurance against the hazard of fire shall be is-

sued in accordance with the terms and provislons of

this sub-chapter."

The prlmarg test then as to whether or not the so-called

reinsurance described by your request must conform to the

rating provisions of Chapter C is whether or not under the

terms of such so-called relnsurance contract the original

insured has the right to proceed against the so-called re- ?:~

insuring company if he should suffer a loss from the hazards

of flre.&If the original policghold$r has a right to pro- ',

ce,eddirectly against the 'reinsurer there is.nothtng

which distinguishes the obligation of'the so-called rein-

surer from that which he would undertake should he Issue

directly a pollcg on the risk in question---the "reinsurer"

has contracted,to indemnify against thenhazard of fire.

'We do not intend to hold that every contract which

gives the original policyholder a right to~proceedagalnst

the so-called~ reinsurer must conform to the provisions of

Sub-chapter ,C..

Itisnot unusual for the original insuring company

and,the reinsuring company to arrange conventional reinsurance

1 in.'sucha manner that the relnsurer assumes direct responsl-

bflities to theepolingholder. Here again we look to the

b.. purpose;for wh%ch the Act was passed. As evidenced by the

emergency clause the original fire Insurance rating law was

.:enacted to prevent discrimination between policyholders.

~''That purpose.is served when each policyholder similarly

sltuated,obtalnFng direct coverage from a non-exempt insur-

ance company is able to obtain such coverage at the same

rate of premfum. A polLcgholder who has obtained his policies

of Insurance direct from a non-exempt company Is not dis-

criminated again& as between hImself and another who originally

:,’ . _

Hon. William A. Harrison, page 6 (W-533)

obtains a policy from an exempt,company at a lower rate of

premium and then later, Independent of the original negoti-

'ations, the same non-exempt insurance company assumes all

or part of the liabilltg of the exempt company on that par-

ticular policy. The second policyholder in the purchase

or acquisltlon of his policy obtained no advantage of price

or premium to which~he was not properly entitled. The lat-

ter policyholder bargained for and acquired indemnity in the

exempt company only. But where the'policgholder obtains a

policy from an exempt company which at Its inception con-

talns provisions which allow~him to proceed directly against

the non-exempt company,,he has bargained for and obtained

indemnity from the non-exempt company at a lesser rate than

a policyhblder who obtains a d~irectpolicy from.the non-

exempt company, thereby creating the discrimination Intend-

ed to.be eliminated by the law.

We would point out that the determination whether

the transaction constituted ','reinsurance"

as opposed.to

"direct insurance" Is largely a factual one dependent on

assessment of the intent of the parties. That factual de--

t'erminationls~prlmarilg your responsibility,

,

Your second questlon is whether the reinsuring com-

pany is required to'pay the gross $remium receipts tax levied

by Article 7064.

c

Artkle 7064 exacts a tax on'the gross amount of

'premiums ~received on.certainlines of insurance including

fire Insurance. However,,expressly exempted ,from the pro-

visions ~of Article 7064,are 'premiums received from other

licensed companies for reinsuranc,e?. We are not here con-,

cerned with the substantial qu~estion:ofwhether or not re-

ciprocal exchanges come underthe.terms of Article 7064..

Article 7064 requires the fnsurance company subject thereto

to report-to thenBoard'the;"gross amount of premiums' re-

celved on property which is further defined:.,'~

II . . (t)he gross premium receipts :where"re-

ferredto in thls.'law:shallbe the total gross ~amount .a

of ~premiumsreaeived'onleach,and every kind of insur-

,. ,ance OS risk written, exc,epQpremlums received from

other licensed cdmpan~l&sfor reksurance? :less,return

premiums and dividends 'paIdpolicyholders; but there

,., ; shall be no deductlon for premfums paid for reinsurance."

We. have held~under'the fact situationthat~ the obll-

gation of the so-called reinsurfng company.was ln~fact a di-

re@t obllgationof.the reinsuring company rather than one of

relnsurance. Thus,:we':be'li.eve,

that the exemption in Article

7064 "reinsurance~'?:',would,'

not b.e,applicable.:sunder the fact

situation and with the,,:above,con~lusfons,.the.so-calledceding

., ':

. .

Hon. William A. Harrison, page 7 (W-533)

company would be collecting the premium both for itself and

for the so-called reinsuring company and in this sense the

gross premium on the policy would have been received both

for 'itself and for the so-called reinsuring company. As-

suming that the ceding company was a type of company sub-

ject to the tax under Article 7064, then both the assuming

and ceding company would be jointly and severally liable for

the premium tax under Article 7064. If theceding company

be exempt under the terms of Article 7064 from such a premi-

um tax, then only the so-called reinsuring company would

be liable for the tax.

We reached the above conclusion in view of the fact

that under the circumstances given each of the two companies

involved as,sumes100% of the liab111ty provided in the policy.

The Insured could elect to proceed either against the so-

called ceding company or against the reinsuring company in-

dependently or could proceed against’them jointly in one

swit q Thus, each of the companies has assumed a joint and

sev~eralllabilltg under the terms of the contract. Hence,

each would be jointly and severally liable for the taxes on

the premium.

SUMMARY

Under fact situation given, where fire lnzur-

ante polLcy of a company exempt from fire

Insurance rating law is reinsured 100% by a

company subject to this law:

(1) The premium charged the pollcyholder

must conform to the rates which the relnsur-

lng company is permitted to use under the

rating law.

(2) And both companies are subject to the

premium tax levied by Article 7064 unless

: exempted.

FBW:lm:wc Very truly yours,

APPROVED:

OPINIOR COMMITTEE: '. WILL WILSON

Geo. P. Blackburn, ChaIrman Attorney General of Texas

W.E. Allen

Marietta McGregor Payne By s/Fred B. Werkenthin

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY Fred B. Werkenthin

GENERAL BY: Assistant

W,.V. Geppert

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.