Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1959
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

WILL WILSON

A-lTOXCikY ‘3-E-L

March,9, 1959

xr. sto.?eg.x. MimA’,’

Chairman.

Texas State Board ‘ofRegistration

for Public Surveyors

Auet In, Texas

Opinion No. W&6?

.A&: Whether Section 3 (c)

of the Registered Pub-

lic Surveyors Act .of

1955 1s void bec.ause

-It.embraces a subject,

not expressed in the

title, as required by

Wctlon ‘35,Article

III of the Texas Con-

Dear Hr. ‘N&as:, _, stitutlon.

You have requested our opinion on whether .$eot$on 3

‘~,(c).of the Reglsterqd Public Surveyors Act of 1955,~ (A&J,.

54th Legislatura,’Re$uiar Session, 1955,’Chaptk- 328, page

,864,qodlfiqd or Arttale 5282a, V.A.C.S.) is void ‘because

It eatbracesa subject not exprerred .lnthe title as re-

quired by Section 35, Article III of the Teus Constitution.

. :

Th’2title of such Aot ii a$ follows~:

“An Ao$ creating a’State Board of

Re&stration for Public Surveyors; pro-

viding forregistration of pub119 sur-

veyors,;ddrining the taras ‘Registered

Public Surveyor., ’ ‘Public ‘Surveying

~8tid~Publlodurveyor, ’ ‘person,‘~‘,BoBrd,

’

dent8 of Texaq; prescribing ~quallrfoa-

‘tlons for membership on Board; provldlng

method of appointment and prescribing

term 0r orrice,;defining a quorum 0r sald

Board;‘provlding for and preaorlblng oath

Iof offioe iandthe manner of filling

. .

Mr. Staley W. Mims, page 2 (~~-56s).

vacrncles, as well as removal for cause;

prescribing the powers and duties of the

Board; providing for times and places of

meetings of Board; providing for removal

of the.Chairman; authorlzing.':the Board

to adopt rules and regulations; authoriz-

ing employment of Executive Secretary,

restricflng salaries to those comparable

in'other departments of.State; providing

that no ~expenseof the administration of

the.'Actshall .everbe charged against

the Oenerol Fund of the State of Texas;

prescribing the fees to be received by

the Board; outlining qualifications for

riglstratlon under the Act; providing .

for payment of annual registration fee

and penalty for delay; prescribing method

of revocation ,andre'lssuanceof certlfl-

catec> providing penalties for violations;

providing for the dl,spositlonof money .

collected under the Act; providing a

saving pnd severable clause; repealing

laws in conflict; and declaring an emer-

gency. " (Emphasis added)

Section 3 of th2 body of the Act'tiithwhich w.eare

here concerned reads as ~follows: A

"Sec. 3.~ The proiislons'of thls~'

Act shill not apply to any of the follow-

ing:

!'(a)County Surveyor acting In his

official capacity as ,authorlzodbjrlaw.

"(b) Licensed State LaridSurveyor

when actfng.ln his official capacity

as authorized by law.

when "~;~tR~glnsteredProf'esslonal .?%ninear

P 3. I g his profession as auti:orix&d

by law.

'"(dj ofricer of i state, county, city

or othey polit$cal subdivirlon whose offi6lal.

duites.lnolude land atirveyingwhen acting

In his official oapaclty.

Mr. Staley, W. Mims, Page 3 (w-569)

“(e) BQutY, assistant or .empl~oyee

of any .person exempted from'.theprovisions

of thld Act by subsections (a); (b);~and

.I (c) of this Section whitiact&g und,erthe '

direction and supervision of such exempted

person.

"(f) Assistant or employee of*any

Public Surveyor registertd 'underthe

provislons..ofthis Act while aqtlng

under the direct'ionmd supervlq$on'of

such Registered Surve'yor." (RtIphasls

added.)

You aeek to be advtsed iP'\rRegistered Professional

Engineer la~exemptftim thenQUrviey of.suah Act when.he Is

practiolng his profession as authorized by,,~lav,(wheri

her

Is performing engineering duties pur?uan.,to~a Certificate

of Reglstratlon.as provided by Article 32711; Verrioliis

Civil $tatutes):.orwhether such eTamp$lon~contained in _

Seotlon 3(d) of.thd Survbyors'Aot-J.s.'void.. :

In Attorney,'Oe~n,~ral'~s~:~:~n~.on

i?b.-.WW~428.-

{:i9!$i13~

we were of the .oplnlori~tha~,is,& ti*tter..of<,co

bttic.&i&

.Register&J ~ofess16na~ii$ngin,~~rs~+tiL

oxeinp+ ,~P t e.,ct

--a%+T-

her'eunder.conslderatlotiwhln~thl'tigineer'Ydid:'boundary

surveying while praotlc+ng hi6 pooFession.as a'u$hoSrzed'

by law. ft Is still our +plnlon that such is the proper

oon&ructlon of the Aot. However, the questlon.ralsed

were, and'nat ticachedo.rconbidered,In W+&28,~ is whether

the exempt$op as so construed.ls.eff~ct~ire:oy.wh'etner.the

attempted exemption co&raven& the Cofiatitutlonbf~Texas,

and ls,.therefore, void...'

Section 3; of Article III of the Condtittitionof

Texas provi'desi-h.part:

"Nb'blll,~ . '. . shall.;

contain:mwe

'~

than oye‘subjeot, which shall be ,expresped~,

in itn title. Buttif any subj.ectshall'be

embraoed in an ret, which shall not be ex-

pressed lfitAc~$ltle, suah act shall be

~vold only as .to~60muoh thereof, a8 shall

not be so expressed."

Mr. 'Staley W. Mlms, page 4 (WW-$9).

In our opinion, l+ls question Is aontrolled by

Ward Cattle and Posture Company v."CarpenBer (19X8), 109

T 105 200 m 21, wherein th SupruaZiCour'tof

T%zas, ipeaklni through Chief Justlze Phllllppb, said

in part:

. .

"The purpose of the constitutional

provision in respect to the-~tltleof

leglslatlvh acts Is well understood.. It Is

that-by means of thl title, the legislator may

be. peasonably'apprlsed of the,soope of

the bill so that surprl-seatidfraud in

leglblatlon may be prevented. True,

according to previous decisions of this

d'ourt,if the title had only declared

that the urpose of the Act was to amend

Article 7 if35 of the Revi.sedStatutes, it

-wotild have. supported an rot amending the'...'.'

lrtlble so a8 to omit Matagarda.County. :.

But with this title announolng, as It

does,.that the article irarto be~amended :

in a~partloular way, no legislator would

~sonablu have oonoelved that it was to

be amendeh in an6ther.m~ exactly contrary'..

to'that stated. This Is a oa8e lllustrat-

and #&zloe of the constl-

.. (Bnphasls added.):

Alao ace HamIllion v. St. Louis Railroad Company, llj

Tea&i, ‘283 S.W.m, whloh reads lfipart as ,follows:

A caption which declares a

purpose'& &end a statute by adding"

'~theretoa clause creating liability for

Injuries resulting in death when caused j

by.the negligence of corporations, their

agents, or servants cannot be regarded

otherwire than as deceptive in so far"as

the amendment may se,e&to &eclare a~llablll-

ty for deaths ocaaaloned, not by the negll-

d gence of corporations, their agenta-or se*-

vants, but fop dcaths'ocoasloned~by the i

negligence ,of persons, thelr,agents or.',:

servants." +

Mr. Stalejr W. 'Mlms,'page 5 (WW-56~9).

Also see .39 Tex,Jur. 100, :tilch r,eadt%lnpart as

followa:

"Whether + title Is comprehensive

or restricted, ezpressed In-gene~ra&

terms or with,particularity, it must

bC In agreement and conformity, qnd

not at 'variance.,with the,subjeCt pf

the legislation...... '*

,~

"A title Is deceptive, fal.sr'or

misleading if It disguises the tru,e

pufiposeof ~th& act and Imports a sub-,.

ject different from that ~to which the

qct relates. And.whether or not a.:

title &ate8 the gqneral purpose of

the act, It le mlaleadlng 1,fIt states

specific purposea~In such manner aa to.

concea,,1other purposes not stated.

5 ~...' @nphasls.added.) :,~ '.

.Tti

'irnqld i. Lion&d, 114'Te.x.535; $72 S&.'799,-

the Court .s.&id,.~ln;

part:

11 ‘.

~'oa~tlon coniseal&g'the true

.purpose'& ; 'statute,and statl&a+ a&

.together,dlstlnot and foreign purpose, ;

1-knecessarily-deceptive, and cannot be ..

suatalned as complying wlth Sect~lon35

of Article 3 of,'theConstitution;"

In ~Attorney Qeneral'8~Opinion-No. O-5189, (19&j),

In holding that the.statute thereunder consideration was

Invalid, It was said that:

It Is not so written as

to put i ieglslator on notice that one

of thespecific provisions of the Act

(and one ntw.to,$he law of Texas), pro-

hibits the use of a form forr,eoordlng

blntHs..whlchmay Indicate that any such

birth waa.lllegltSmate.U -.

By Sdctlon 3 of 3h.e Aot;,three distinct groups

of persons i.n~

o.fflolalpoaltlons, ,nqne.Iy,,

County Surveyors,

L1censedSkt.e Land.~Surveyore,,and officers of a State,

COUntyI City or other polltlcal~~ubdlvlslon, when acting

Mr. Stale;X.W. mms, page 6 (w-569).

In their offiolal.capaoltles,~are made exempt from the

Act. Those. exemptions, embraced In ~the Ao.t,are apparent-

ly "expre8med in the title." Subsection (c) of Section 3

of the Act undertakes to 'exemptan additional group or

class, namely, a "Registered Professional Engineer when

practicing his profession as authorized by I&w." Obviously,

a profeasloo.~.englneerIs not a person ln'an."offlolal

position" solely by force of being a professional engl:.leer;

and when prrctloinghis profession ,as "authorized by‘law"

he-is not aotlng in an off.lolalcapacity. He Is acting

only In a professlonal.capaoity, even though he may be

lloensed and @Whorlsed to so act by the stututes of this

State. Such professional engineers are not embraced In

the category of !'personsIn official positions" as ex-

pressed In the title of the Act, In our opinion, Nowhere

does the title bf the $Lct intimate or suggest that the

Act shall notapply to a registered engineer when prac-

ticing his ,professlon'

asauthorized by law.

Irxour opinion, the tltJ.e.undertakesto specify

by express language the^"persons" who are exempt from the

provisions of the Act. Such~speciflcatloh as expressed in

the title Is limited to certain persons holding official

positions. Conse'quently the exemptions embraced In

.Scctlon3(a), (b) and (di are in harmony with the title;

but the exemption embraced In Section 3(c) of the Act is

not In harmony with the tltle~and Is not expre~ssedIn the

title.. Therefore, In our oplnlon,~~Section3(c)Iof the,Act

Is void, by force of Section 35, Article III of the Con-

stitution of Texas.

Attorney General's Opinions WW-428 (1958) and

ww-115 11957) are hereby overruled and withdrawn. .:;l

:.. ..

.SuMMARY.

Section 3(o) of the Registered

Publlh Surveyors Act of 1955

(ArtloIe 5282a, v.C.S.) IS

void beoause it attempts to

'exempt Registered ?rofesslonal

Engineers .from the provisions

Of the Act, when such Is not

,MS-.3taley W. Mims, page 7 (W-569).

expressed in the title as

required by Section 35, Article

III of-,theTexas Constitution.

Attorney General's Opinions

Nos. WW-428 (1958) and WW-115.

(1957) .are overruled and

Gi!.hdrati,;

Yours very truly,

WILL WIISON

' AttornCy General of Texas

Tom.1. McF&rllng

Assistant u

TIM:ol,'mfh

.APPRGVEIX.

.OPINION ,COMMITTEE

Geo. P. Blackburn, Chairman'

Marietta Pay@ :,'

J. C. Davis, am.'~

John L. Eaten '.'..

REVIEWED.FORTRE ATT&NEYGENEi&

BY: W. V. ffEPPE?T

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.