Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1960
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

MP. Coke R. Stevenson,Jr. Opinion No. WW-816

Administrator

Texas Liquor Control Board Re: Whether or not Art. 667,

Austin. Texas Section 23;(d) of the Penal

Code permits the tax on

beer to be refunded when

such beer is sold to an

Individualwho has a contract

with a National Military

Establishmentto operate a

concessionwithin the enclosures

Dear Mr. Stevenson: of such establishment?

We quote from your opinion request as follows:

"Article 667, Section 23*(d), of the

Penal Code of Texas, provides, to-wit:

"'It is not Intended that the tax

levied in Section 23 of Article II of

the Texas Liquor Control Act shall be

collected on beer shipped out of this State

for consumptionoutside this State, or

sold aboard ships for ship's supplies, OP

on beer shipped to any installationof the

National Military Establishment,wherein

the State of Texas has ceded police jurls-

diction, for consumptionby military

personnel within said Installation,and the

Board shall provide forms on which Distrib-

utors and Manufacturersmay claim and obtain

exemption from the tax on such beer. If

any Distributoror Manufacturerhas paid the

tax on any beer and thereafter said beer is

shipped out of this State, for consumption

outside this State, OP sold aboard ships for

ship's supplies, OP is shipped Into any

Installationof the,NationalMilitary Estab-

lishment as referred to above, for consumption

by military personnel therein, a claim for

refund may be made at the time and in the

manner prescribed by the Board or Administrator.

So much of any funds derived hereunder as ma

be necessary, not to exceed two per cent (2$3

MP. Coke R. Stevenson, Jr., Page 2 Opinion No. WW-816

thereof, Is hereby appropriatedfor such

purpose. The Board may promulgate rules

and regulationsgenerally for the enforce-

ment of this provision.'

"This Department interpretedthe above

to mean that if the beer Is sold to,

Invoiced to, or shipped to, and paid for

by an installationof the National Military

Establishment,where police jurisdiction

has been ceded by the State, that the State

tax exemption should be allowed. On the other

hand, if this merchandise is shipped to,

invoiced to, OP paid for by a civilian con-

cessionairewho is operating for individual

profit that the State tax exemption should -

not

be allowed.

"The situation in question Is where a

concessionairewho is a civilian and is not

a memeber of any branch of the Armed Services

of the United States has been granted a con-

cession to operate a snack bar in a National

Military Establishmentwhere police jurisdiction

has been ceded by the State, The beer is served

at this snack bar located in a bowling alley.

The bowling alley is located within the area

of the National MlLltapy Establishment. The

concessionagreement provides that the con-

cessionaireshall not sell the products,

services.,and merchandise of the concession

to any person except those authorized to be

present in and utilize the facilitiesof the

bowling alley in accordancewith applicable

military regulationsor directivesnow in

effect,

"In order to answer inquiries concerning

the sale of tax free beer to an individualwho

holds a concession in a National Military

Establishment,we respectfullyrequest your

opinion as to the following questions:

"1o Whether OP not Article 667, 23*(d), of

the Penal Code permits the tax on beer to be

refunded when such beer Is sold to an individual

who has a contract with a Rational Military

Establishmentto operate a concessionwithin

the enclosures of such establfshment?

Mr, Coke R. Stevenson,Jr., Page 3 Opinion No. WW-816

c"

"2. Or, is the criterion for tax exemption

not whether the purchaser of the beer is a

civilian, but, rather, whether or not the

State of Texas has any jurisdictionover the

place where the beer is ultimately sold?

"These questions are not the subject of

any pending litigationand your opinion is

necessary in order that we may properly advise

a concessionaireoperating on a Rational

Military Establisbmentwhere the State of

Texas has ceded police jurisdiction."

A careful examinationof the terms of Art..667, Sec. 2&

(d), Tex.Pen.Code,reveals no basis for your departmental

interpretation. It is not required that the beer be sold to

a military Installation,but only that it be shipped tothe

installationfor consumptiontherein by military personnel.

This proposition is clarified somewhat by reference to the

second sentence of the questioned article, which states, in

part:

"If any Distributor or Manufacturerhas

paid the tax on any beer and thereafter said

beer. D .is shipped && any installation.. .

a claim for refund may be made."

As pointed out by Attorney General's Opinion No. W-354,

three requirementsmust be met before refunds may be made in

cases of this nature:

1. The beer must be shipped Into an installationof the

National Military Establishment;

2. police jurisdictionever the Installationin question

must have been ceded by the State of Texas; and

3. the beer must be intended forconsumption by

military personnel within the Installation.

According to the facts set forth in your letter, all three

requirementshave been met, Accordingly,refund should be made.

SUMMARY

Under the terms of Article 667, Section 234

(d), Tex.Pen.Code,the Texas Liquor Control

Board should make refund of taxes paid on beer

shipped to a civilian concessionairewithin a

Mr. Coke R. Stevenson,Jr., Page 4 Opinion No. WW-816

military installationwherein police

jurisdictionhas been ceded where such beer

is intended for consumptionby military

personnel within the installation.

Yours very truly,

WILL WILSON

Attorney General of Texas

JNP:cm

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE:

W. V. Geppert, Chairman

William T. Blackburn

John Lawrence Hargrove

Robert A. Rowland

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

By: Leonard Passmore

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.