Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1960
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

THEA'ITORNEY GENERAL

OF TEXAS

W’ILJi WILSON

ATIXBRNEY GENERAL

November 30, 1960

Honorable Penn J. Jackson, Opinion No. WW-967

Chairman

State Board of Insurance Re: Authority to permit Excess

International Life Building Automobile Insurance Rates

Austin 14, Texas

Dear Sir:

Your request asks whether the promulgation of certain proposed

rules applicable to motor vehicle or automobile insurance rates would

violate the law in certain respects. In summary, these proposed rules

would allow, with the permission of the insured, the sale of such insur-

ance at a rate in excess of that fixed by your now existing rules where

such an insured was unable to obtain insurance at the regular rates,

his application having been rejected by three insurance companies.

Under the proposed rules, an excess rate, agreed to by the insured,

would be “suggested I’by the insurance company to be approved by the

Board.

The objections that are raised to such proposed rules are briefly

that:

1) the proposed rules would be an illegal delegation of the

Board’s power to classify risks;

2) the proposed rules would be an illegal delegation of the

Board’s power to fix rates;

3) the proposed rules would violate Art. 5. 01 requiring the

Board to classify motor vehicles according to the risk and usage made

the reef: and

4) that the proposed rules would violate Art. 5..09, Insurance

Code, forbidding discrimination in the matter of prem$nn charges as

between insureds having a like hazard.

The authority of the Board to fix and promulgate automobile insur-

ance premium rates is found in Subchapter A of Chapter 5 of the Texas

Hon. Penn J. Jackson, page 2 (WW-967)

Insurance Code and in particular Art. 5. 01 which provides in part:

“The Board shall have the sole and exclusive

power ~‘andauthority, and it shall be its duty to deter-

mine, fix, prescribe, and promulgate just, reasonable

and adequate rates of premiums to be charged and

collected by all insurers writing any form of insur-

ance on motor vehicles in this State, including fleet

or other rating plans designed to discourage losses

from fire and theft and similar hazards and any rat-

ing plans designed to encourage the prevention of acci-

dents. In promulgating any such rating plans the Board

shall give due consideration to the peculiar hazards and

experience of individual risks, past and prospective,

within and outside the State and to all other relevant

factors, within &nd outside the State. The Board shall

have the authorjty also to alter or amend any and all of

such rates of premiums so fixed and determined and

adopted by it, and to raise or lower the same or any

part thereof, ”

It may be observed that broadly speaking two principal processes

are involved in rate fixing. Initially, the Board must “classify” the

different risks according to their circumstance and secondly, promul-

gate rates and schedules to apply to the risks within the different classi-

fications. The Board is, of course, vested with discretion in determin-

ing the myriad factors that are to be considered in this process.

Under the plan as presented it appears that the final rate applica-

ble to a risk coming within the proposed rule would be one assessed upon

the circumstances peculiar to the individual risk rather than upon stan-

dards of general application much in the fashion of “judgment rating. ”

In our opinion the automobile rating laws contemplate that to “determine,

fix, prescribe, and promulgate” automobile insurance rates requires

the Board to fix standards of general application by which a rate may be

determined, rather than simply approving rates for an individual risk,

In our view the proposed rules then are beyond the scope of the Board’s

authority. We call special attention to Art. 5.09 in this respect, which

forbids discrimination as to rates between insureds “having a like hazard. ”

While it may be arguable that two risks otherwise similarly situated ,are

not of “like hazard” where one of the two has been turned down by three

insurance companies, no provision is made within the proposed rules for

Hon. Penn J. Jackson, page 3 (WW-967)

the application of a rating plan or system to determine the final rate

of premium for risk coming within the proposed rules. * The very

spirit of the proposed rules in this respect conflicts with Art. 5. 09.

We think the force and effect of the proposed rules is to segregate

risks to the end that no rates are promulgated by the Board for the

risks - rather, the parties agree upon the rate and then seek Board

approval. This result runs contrary to the intention of the Legislature

embodied in the automobile rating law that rates be uniform.

SUMMARY

The State Board of Insurance is not authorized to

promulgate rules permitting the writing of automo-

bile insurance at excess rates even though the risk has

been rejected three times by insurance companies.

Very truly yours,

WILL WILSON

Attorney General of Texas

BY

Fred B. Werkenthin

Assistant Attorney General

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE:

W. V. Geppert, Chairman

Martha Joe Stroud

,Howard Mays

Martin DeStefano

Bob Rowland

REVIEWEDFORTHEATTORNEYGENERAL

BY: Leonard Passmore

* For example, if two automobile risks came within the rule, each is to be

separately rated even though they may be identical in every respect. In

this aspect the proposed rule differs from Rule 81 of the Casualty Automo-

bile Manual referred to in your request. While Rule 81 permits individual

rating of risks, it does so only where the risk is individually unique.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.