Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1961
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

E ORNEY GENE-

OF TEXAS

AUSTIN ~.TEXAS

FVILL WILSON

AlTORNEYGENERAL

February 20, 1961

Mr. Wm. J. Burke Opinion No. NW-996

Executive Director

State Board of Control Re: Whether Acts Fifty-sixth

Austin, Texas Legislature, Third Called

Session, 1959, Chapter 23,

page 442 prohibits the chang-

ing in the air duct connec-

tions of the air condition-

ing system in the State

Office Building when such

changes are necessary to in-

sure proper functioning of

Dear Mr. Burke: such system.

You have requested an opinion on the following ques-

tion:

"Does Section 40 of Article V, 'General

Provisions' H.B. 4, enacted by the Third

Called Session of the Fifty-sixth Legisla-

ture, In 1959, by the following language

'Building Alterations Prohibited. None of

the funds appropriated in this Act may be

expended for removing walls, partitions or

any other permanent part of the New State

Office Building or the Supreme Court Build-

ing' prohibit a change in air duct connec-

tions supplying fresh air to the air con-

ditioning system of the New State Office

Building when such change is necessary to

insure proper functioning and continuous

satisfactory performance and adequate air

conditioning effect from certain individual

air conditioning units serving the first and

second floors of the said State Office Build-

ing?

"Does Section 40 quoted above prohibit

the installation of the necessary and proper

air duct to supply an adequate and dependably

constant amount of fresh air to the individual

air conditioning units serving the west end of

floors one and two of the State Office Building

Mr. Wm. J. Burke, page 2 (m-996)

to be connected with a new outside air intake

opening constructed through the basement wall

of the State Office Building near the southwest

corner of said building?

"If your answer to the above question is

in the negative, is the Board of Control pro-

hibited from paying the cost of such new duct

installation and necessary correction work from

funds appropriated to the Board of Control from

Budget Item 69 of said H.B. 4 entitled, 'Air

Conditioning Maintenance, including maintenance

contracts, professional fees, materials and

supplies, special tools and plant equipment'?“

The facts on which your question is based are stated

in your request as follows:

"Changes in the air supply ducts and con-

nections are necessary because the large fans

supplying the fresh air for all floors above

the second floor develop a suction on the common

air intake duct (from which the units serving

the first and second floors also are supposed to

obtain their fresh air supply) sufficient to

prevent smaller individual units serving the

said first and second floors and especially

those in the west one-half of the building from

receiving an adequate amount of fresh air to

permit proper functioning, adequate performance

and satisfactory air conditioning; and, further-

more, at times completely overpower the intake

capacity of the smaller units with the result

that air flows are reversed to the extent that

the return air grilles actually discharge hot,

contaminated air under pressure instead of suck-

ing it in for reconditioning through filters and

the cooling units.

"The effect of the above described occur-

rence on offices, conference and meeting rooms is

such that inside temaeratures cannot be controlled

by the thermostats and the air conditioning units.

"The proposed, and most feasible, solution

of the problem is the separation of air intake

. .

Mr. Wm. J. Burke, page 3 (w-996)

connections and/or air sources serving the

large fans and the small air conditioning

units so that the respective small fans and

units may have separate and independent fresh

air intake sources to insure that one cannot

interfere with the satisfactory operation of

the other.

"In order to provide the separate air in-

take to supply fresh air to the units serving

the first and second floors (west end) of the

State Office Building, it becomes necessary to

disconnect the air intake, serving the small

units, from the main large air intake, serving

the main fans that supply air to floors three

to ten, inclusive, install a new fresh air in-

take for the small units (serving floors one and

twos)through the basement wall at the southwest

corner of the State Office Building below ground

level protected by an area-way and appropriate

cover structure. Such installation of the neces-

sary new duct would require an opening to be

cut through the basement wall which would in

effect remove a small portion of a 'permanent

part' of the New State Office Building basement

wall.

"Had the effect of the earlier described com-

mon source main air duct on the smaller units

(serving floors one and two) been anticipated and/or

possible of calculation at the time the duct system

for the air conditioning was designed, there is no

doubt that separate ducts would have been installed

when the building was constructed. The building has

been completed, occupied, and the air conditioning

system has been in operation more than one year, and

It is now apparent that the conditions described above

could become worse resulting in more unsatisfactory

operation and improper and inadequate air cbndition-

lng than we now experience."

Section 7 of Article 678m, Vernon's Civil Statutes, pro-

vides:

"The Commission shall obtain title for the

State and retain control of the real property

.

Mr. Wm. J. Burke, page 4 (W-996)

acquired for sites and of the buildings

located thereon until final construction

is completed and the buildings are occu-

pied by the State agencies to be housed

therein, at which time the management and

control of said buildings shall be trans-

ferred to the Board of Control. Except as

otherwise provided in this Act, the initial

occupants shall be those State agencies

agreed upon by the Commission and the Board

of Control."

In view of the provisions of Section 7 of Article 678m,

it is the duty of the State Board of Control to keep the

State Office Building in proper maintenance and repair. Ther+

fore, it is the responsibility of the ,Board of Control to ex-

pend available funds to maintain the proper functioning of

equipment initially installed by the State Building Commis-

sion in the construction of the State Office Building.

Section 40 of Article V of House Bill 4, Acts of the

Fifty-sixth Le islature, Third Called Session, 1959, Chap-

ter 23, page 482 (General Appropriation Bill) provides at

page 732:

"None of the funds appropriated in this

Act may be expended for removing walls, parti-

tions or any other permanent part of the new

State Office Building or the Supreme Court

Building."

It is our opinion that the foregoing does not prevent

the Board of Control from expending appropriated funds to

provide for the proper functioning of initial equipment in

the State Office Building. This is particularly true under

the facts outlined in our request, since the Legislature

in House Bill 4 in Item 69 (page 517) of the'appropriation

to the Board of Control made~specific appropriation for

air conditioning maintenance.

You are, therefore,,advised that you are authorized to

expend monies appropriated in Item 69 for the purposes out-

lined in your request.

SUMMARY

-------

The State Board of Control is authorized

to spend monies appropriated for air

. .

Mr. Wm. J. Burke, Page 5 (m-996)

conditioning maintenance for making changes

in the air supply ducts and connections neces-

sary to the proper functioning of the air

conditioning equipment installed in the State

Office Building.

Yours very truly,

WILL WILSON

Attorney General of Texas

‘hi&v-&

John Reeves

JR:ms Assistant

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMI!l?l?EE

W. V. Geppert, Chairman

William T. Blackburn

Leon F. Pesek

John C. Steinberger

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

BY: Morgan Nesbitt

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.